ŷ

Cecily's Reviews > The Truth About Owls

The Truth About Owls by Amal El-Mohtar
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
1199525
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: short-stories-and-novellas, bildungsroman, ya, magical-realism, race-people-of-colour

Owls have eyes that match the skies they hunt through. Amber-eyed owls hunt at dawn or dusk; golden-eyed owls hunt during the day; black-eyed owls hunt at night.


Image: Owls (.)

This is a poignant bildungsroman about a Lebanese girl, living in Scotland. Her first encounter with an owl is scratched deep in her memories: horror, fear, and guilt. Nevertheless, she develops an affinity for a captive owl, and thence the Welsh myth of , �a beautiful woman, made of flowers, who was turned into an owl�.

Straightforward realism?

"—sometimes—I feel like I'm just a collection of bits of things that someone brought together at random and called girl, and then Anisa, and then�" she shrugs. "Whatever."

You can read this prosaically, picking up facts about owls along the way. Anisa experienced bombing in Lebanon, bullying in Scotland, and sudden surges of anger in both. She finds peace and fascination at the Scottish Owl Centre. The story touches on identity (heritage, difference, assimilation, racism, and feminism) and growing up, but ever so lightly. It’s not an issue-based story; they’re just facets of Anisa’s life. The ending is perfect, and not quite what I expected.

Magical realism

The far better approach is to infer a sprinkling of the magic/alternative reality that is more explicit in the brilliant novel El-Mohtar co-wrote with Max Gladstone, This Is How You Lose the Time War (see my review HERE), and her short story, Pockets (see my review HERE).

Anisa is drawn to a specific owl whose eyes match her own, and who is named after the mythical .

The heart-shaped face is alien and eerie and beautiful and like when you can see the moon while the sun is setting, and that there should be a single word for the color of the wings that's like the sheen of a pearl but not the pearl itself.�


Image: “Blodeuwedd � oak, broom and meadowsweet� by Jenny Dolfen (.)

It drives Anisa to teach herself Welsh, so she can read the myth in its original language:
She likes that there is a language that looks like English but sounds like Arabic; she likes that there is no one teaching it to her, or commenting on her accent, or asking her how to speak it for their amusement.

But the connection goes beyond mere curiosity, fondness, and empathy. There is something mysterious, powerful, and transformative between Blodeuwedd and Anisa. You might even call it magical. I do.


Image: More owls (.)

Owls in culture

I’ve enjoyed owls in children’s books (Old Brown in The Tale of Squirrel Nutkin, Wol in The House at Pooh Corner, the Owl Babies, and Hedwig in Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone). Twenty years ago, we took our small child to an owl sanctuary much like the one in the story. Other than that, I’ve not really thought about them.

Then, a few months ago, I sought solace from pandemic, politics, and other stresses on Instagram. I am a passive presence, curating a feed of nothing but beauty (no politics, family, or friends). I follow artists, galleries, museums, heritage organisations, national parks and forests, art/nature photography, glassblowers, Chinese architecture, and� owls. The owls have been the most unexpected and varied delight.

And then I read this story, and learnt a little of the mythology, symbolism, and superstitions around owls (see ). They’re often associated with fear and bad luck! I suppose that’s because they’re predators, mostly hunt at night, and they can rotate their heads 270 degrees, revealing or hiding their big eyes. But I’m a fan. Of owls and El-Mohtar.

Read it on Strange Horizons

You can read or listen to this story (11 pages or 37 minutes): .
It was written in 2014, five years before This Is How You Lose the Time War.

I class this as YA, suitable for children as young as ten or eleven, but it is also an enjoyable quick read for adults.

See also

For a very different take on humans and owls, see Claire Oshetsky's brilliant, raw, and disturbing novel, Chouette, which I reviewed HERE.
88 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Truth About Owls.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

October 8, 2020 – Shelved
October 8, 2020 – Shelved as: to-read
October 8, 2020 – Shelved as: short-stories-and-novellas
October 12, 2020 – Started Reading
October 12, 2020 – Finished Reading
October 15, 2020 – Shelved as: bildungsroman
October 15, 2020 – Shelved as: ya
October 15, 2020 – Shelved as: magical-realism
October 15, 2020 – Shelved as: race-people-of-colour

Comments Showing 1-29 of 29 (29 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Apatt (new)

Apatt Beautiful review (and pics) Mrs! I read everything prosaically, not knowing any other way. Still, poignant but only 3* eh? Needs more poignancy. At least it's not owlful eh?


Cecily Apatt wrote: "Beautiful review (and pics) Mrs! I read everything prosaically, not knowing any other way. Still, poignant but only 3* eh? Needs more poignancy. At least it's not owlful eh?"

Thanks, but you read sci-fi, so you're used to shades of unreality!

The 3* are my enjoyment, now. If I were a young teen, I'd probably give it 4*.


message 3: by Apatt (new)

Apatt Then I would like to rate this book at 4* as proof of my continuing youth. As for shades of unreality, check out the complete works of The Beeb's Jonathan Head.


message 4: by Cecily (last edited Oct 16, 2020 12:51AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Cecily Apatt wrote: "Then I would like to rate this book at 4* as proof of my continuing youth....."

LOL. But I don't feel that youthful. However, as I just gave Johnny the Clockmaker 4*, largely because of my nostalgic love for it as a child and then a parent, you're right. 4* this will be.

Apatt wrote: "... As for shades of unreality, check out the complete works of The Beeb's Jonathan Head."

I have. I'm wary. I'm sorry.


message 5: by Laysee (new)

Laysee Coming of age story, displacement, identity, mythology about owls - that is a lot to pack into 11 pages. It is amazing! Great review, Cecily. I enjoyed the owl pictures, too. I think owls are cute.


message 6: by Cecily (last edited Oct 16, 2020 08:55AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Cecily Laysee wrote: "Coming of age story, displacement, identity, mythology about owls - that is a lot to pack into 11 pages. It is amazing! Great review..."

If you read it, I think you'd quite enjoy it, and it wouldn't take long, but I wouldn't actively suggest it to you, as it is primarily a YA story imo. (I read it because I loved her novel so much.)

Laysee wrote: "... I think owls are cute."

Lots of beautiful ones on Instagram, including short videos... 😉


message 7: by Alfred (new)

Alfred Haplo Owl-standing review. Also, I loved your idea of curating beauty!


message 8: by Cecily (last edited Oct 16, 2020 02:39PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Cecily Alfred wrote: "Owl-standing review..."

First Apatt's "not owlful" and now your "owl-standing". LOL
So here's an owl standing. It was the first one I bookmarked on Instagram:



Alfred wrote: "... I loved your idea of curating beauty!"

I highly recommend it. You can be anonymous, passive, and just see the sorts of things that soothe you. I find glassblowing videos delightful, too.


message 9: by Alfred (last edited Oct 16, 2020 06:52PM) (new)

Alfred Haplo Owwwl*... That's a beautiful picture!

(Sorry, that's a very poor attempt to mean Awww .... It's Apatt's fault for starting it!)

Glassblowing is mesmerizing. Did you visit Chihuly Gardens a while back (I seem to recall you posting a review, or something?).

Mostly, these days, I rely on my laptop's daily background changes of natural landscapes for my escape into beauty.


Cecily Alfred wrote: "... Glassblowing is mesmerizing. Did you visit Chihuly Gardens a while back (I seem to recall you posting a review, or something?)...."

I'm fortunate to have done a days' glassblowing, several times, at different studios, so when I watch videos, it also rekindles those memories. One of the things I like about doing it is that although my creations never turned out quite as I expected, they were still lovely in a quirky way. That wouldn't be true of painting, for example.

Chihuly, yes, I adore his work. I knew of it from a huge chandelier at the entrance of the V&A museum in London, so when we went to Seattle three years ago, Chihuly Gardens was top of my list. I posted a couple of pics in this "review" (well remembered): /review/show....

Since then, I've seen a big exhibition scattered around the huge Kew Gardens in London, both daytime, and at night. Night was best of all.


message 11: by Caroline (new)

Caroline This sounds a very moving read....

It sounds too as though you follow some wonderfully soothing things on line. I am also intrigued by owls. Particularly after reading Wesley the Owl, and seeing a large number of beautiful owl photographs on flickr. Like you I very much liked the children's book Owl Babies.


Cecily Caroline wrote: "This sounds a very moving read....
It sounds too as though you follow some wonderfully soothing things..."


I'm not sure "moving" is quite the word I'd choose, but it takes a lot to move me! But it is sweet, without being sentimental and cloying, and thought-provoking.

Now, I think I should go and find some owls and maybe a little glass-blowing...


message 13: by Vartika (new)

Vartika Sounds lovely, Cecily. Owl be reading this soon ;)


message 14: by Carmen (new)

Carmen Great review.


Cecily Vartika wrote: "Sounds lovely, Cecily. Owl be reading this soon ;)"

I hope you enjoy it. It won't take long.

Carmen wrote: "Great review."

Thanks, Carmen.


message 16: by Andrew (new)

Andrew H Very interesting. The same mythical framework as Garner's The Owl Service. A fine analysis, Thank you.


Cecily Andrew wrote: "Very interesting. The same mythical framework as Garner's The Owl Service. A fine analysis, Thank you."

I've not read The Owl Service, but I'm glad you enjoyed my review, and if you're tempted to read the story, just click the link: it won't take long.


message 18: by JimZ (new)

JimZ Wow,,,,I wonder what other creatures can rotate their heads like that...270 degrees! What a hoot!


Cecily JimZ wrote: "Wow,,,,I wonder what other creatures can rotate their heads like that...270 degrees!..."

Just owls, I think.

Lots of short videos online; here's one:

JimZ wrote: "... What a hoot!"

LOL. Or, if channelling AA Milne, WOL.


message 20: by Lori (new)

Lori Thanks for the link!


Cecily Lori wrote: "Thanks for the link!"

Happy to help. Enjoy the story.


message 22: by Amanda (last edited Dec 28, 2020 02:31PM) (new) - rated it 2 stars

Amanda NEVER MANDY Gorgeous review.


Cecily Amanda wrote: "Gorgeous review."

Thanks, Amanda, and I'm sorry it wasn't the right story at the right time for you.


Amanda NEVER MANDY Cecily wrote: "Amanda wrote: "Gorgeous review."

Thanks, Amanda, and I'm sorry it wasn't the right story at the right time for you."


Reading it led to your review so it was well worth the time. I see some of you sparkling in those owl eyes. ;) (I love reviews that show bits of the person writing them.)


Cecily Amanda wrote: "Reading it led to your review so it was well worth the time. I see some of you sparkling in those owl eyes. ;) (I love reviews that show bits of the person writing them.)"

What a sweet thing to say. Thank you. Over the years, my reviews have become more personal and that's helped deepened understanding and friendships.


Derrick Cecily, I like your perspective on this which is completely different from mine. I guess you got more from it than I did. I haven't dived more into her work but I think Pockets is by far the best.


Cecily Derrick wrote: "Cecily, I like your perspective on this which is completely different from mine. I guess you got more from it than I did. I haven't dived more into her work but I think Pockets is by far the best."

Very different - and that's fine, and even interesting. Pockets was good, but Time War is in a different league, imo.


Laura Janeiro Thanks for reading. Both the original story and your review. Both were moving. Tenderness is now in my mood for the day
P.S. and, by the links
=)


Cecily Laura wrote: "Thanks for reading. Both the original story and your review. Both were moving. Tenderness is now in my mood for the day..."

Thank you, Laura. I trust the tenderness of your mood is of the positive kind.


back to top