Jeffrey Keeten's Reviews > Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy
Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy (George Smiley, #5; Karla Trilogy, #1)
by
by

"The suspicious black car did not follow me home. How am I supposed to maintain this level of paranoia with this level of incompetence?" Tweet from jkeeten's defunct Twitter account.
"I don't smoke but I always travel w/ a Zippo lighter in case I have to light a beautiful woman's cigarette or the wick of a Molotov cocktail." Another tweet from jkeeten's defunct Twitter account.
The British Secret Service, resembling a corporation that has suffered sagging profits, has reshuffled key players, ousted others, and in the process forced George Smiley into retirement. Smiley, in his twilight years, could have easily decided to take up gardening or researching an interesting point of history, but he has wife problems. Ann has left him, leaving him to cover her missing presence with little lies and subterfuge. Given his past he is quite good at it. He is somewhat surprised to discover how much he misses her given the problems she continues to create for him. He has spent a lifetime controlling his emotions, but she is quite good at making him suffer.
"Putting on the hall light, he stooped and peered through his post. One "account rendered" from his tailor for a suit he had not ordered but that he suspected was one of those presently adorning Ann's lover; one bill from a garage in Henley for her petrol (what, pray, were they doing in Henley); one letter from the bank regarding a local cashing facility in favour of the Lady Ann Smiley at a branch of the Midland Bank of Immingham.
And what the devil, he demanded of this document are they doing in Immingham?Who ever had a love affair in Immingham, for goodness' sake? Where was Immingham?"
He is of course angry. What person wants to see the results of their spouses affair through a series of bills or in today's world credit card receipts? Smiley talks tough.
"And if Ann wanted to return--well, he would show her the door."
But when he is honest with himself.
"Or not show her the door, according to--well, how much she wanted to return."
With almost a sigh of relief, Smiley is summoned to interrogate an agent that has stumbled upon bit of intelligence hinting at the existence of a deep cover mole in the service (so much for retirement). This begins a cat and mouse game showing Smiley at his best sifting through incomplete files, weighing the validity of whispers, and chasing a ghost agent back into the Circus. Smiley is some what of an enigma to work with. One of his loyal followers Peter Guillam gives us some insight.
"He spoke as if you followed his reasoning, as if you were inside his mind all the time."
Smiley is really fighting a war on two fronts with his enemies within the service and with the subterfuge of the Karla organization. All players would like Smiley off the board.
This novel is almost as complex as a Russian novel. There are a lot of names to assimilate early, don't despair, they start to sort themselves out as the plot advances. There is a lot of spy jargon. Babysitters, coat trailing, honey-pot, housekeepers, janitors, lamplighters, lotus eaters, mailfist jobs, pavement artists, reptile fund, scalphunters, shoemakers, and wranglers to name a few. You will come away feeling like you have a working knowledge of what it would really be like to be a spy. John Le Carre is the grand master of spy craft in my opinion, and there simply isn't a better example of his skillful plotting than this book.
Read the book then watch the movie and if you want more watch the mini-series. If you are like me it might take all three just to feel like you have found every gem, and every clue that Le Carre so liberally sprinkled through this historical work of fiction. There are two more books in the Karla series...The Honourable Schoolboy and Smiley's People. I for one plan to follow Smiley every step of the way.
If you wish to see more of my most recent book and movie reviews, visit
I also have a Facebook blogger page at:
"I don't smoke but I always travel w/ a Zippo lighter in case I have to light a beautiful woman's cigarette or the wick of a Molotov cocktail." Another tweet from jkeeten's defunct Twitter account.
The British Secret Service, resembling a corporation that has suffered sagging profits, has reshuffled key players, ousted others, and in the process forced George Smiley into retirement. Smiley, in his twilight years, could have easily decided to take up gardening or researching an interesting point of history, but he has wife problems. Ann has left him, leaving him to cover her missing presence with little lies and subterfuge. Given his past he is quite good at it. He is somewhat surprised to discover how much he misses her given the problems she continues to create for him. He has spent a lifetime controlling his emotions, but she is quite good at making him suffer.
"Putting on the hall light, he stooped and peered through his post. One "account rendered" from his tailor for a suit he had not ordered but that he suspected was one of those presently adorning Ann's lover; one bill from a garage in Henley for her petrol (what, pray, were they doing in Henley); one letter from the bank regarding a local cashing facility in favour of the Lady Ann Smiley at a branch of the Midland Bank of Immingham.
And what the devil, he demanded of this document are they doing in Immingham?Who ever had a love affair in Immingham, for goodness' sake? Where was Immingham?"
He is of course angry. What person wants to see the results of their spouses affair through a series of bills or in today's world credit card receipts? Smiley talks tough.
"And if Ann wanted to return--well, he would show her the door."
But when he is honest with himself.
"Or not show her the door, according to--well, how much she wanted to return."
With almost a sigh of relief, Smiley is summoned to interrogate an agent that has stumbled upon bit of intelligence hinting at the existence of a deep cover mole in the service (so much for retirement). This begins a cat and mouse game showing Smiley at his best sifting through incomplete files, weighing the validity of whispers, and chasing a ghost agent back into the Circus. Smiley is some what of an enigma to work with. One of his loyal followers Peter Guillam gives us some insight.
"He spoke as if you followed his reasoning, as if you were inside his mind all the time."
Smiley is really fighting a war on two fronts with his enemies within the service and with the subterfuge of the Karla organization. All players would like Smiley off the board.
This novel is almost as complex as a Russian novel. There are a lot of names to assimilate early, don't despair, they start to sort themselves out as the plot advances. There is a lot of spy jargon. Babysitters, coat trailing, honey-pot, housekeepers, janitors, lamplighters, lotus eaters, mailfist jobs, pavement artists, reptile fund, scalphunters, shoemakers, and wranglers to name a few. You will come away feeling like you have a working knowledge of what it would really be like to be a spy. John Le Carre is the grand master of spy craft in my opinion, and there simply isn't a better example of his skillful plotting than this book.
Read the book then watch the movie and if you want more watch the mini-series. If you are like me it might take all three just to feel like you have found every gem, and every clue that Le Carre so liberally sprinkled through this historical work of fiction. There are two more books in the Karla series...The Honourable Schoolboy and Smiley's People. I for one plan to follow Smiley every step of the way.
If you wish to see more of my most recent book and movie reviews, visit
I also have a Facebook blogger page at:
Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read
Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
July 3, 2012
–
Started Reading
July 3, 2012
– Shelved
July 6, 2012
–
Finished Reading
August 29, 2014
– Shelved as:
spies-espionage
June 29, 2016
– Shelved as:
book-to-film
Comments Showing 1-50 of 72 (72 new)
message 1:
by
Jason
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Jul 06, 2012 09:28AM

reply
|
flag

I knew it would be good, but was pleasantly surprised at the complexity of the plot. I really had to pay attention. Have you read the other two books in the series?


That is good to hear. I'll be reading it next.


Read Declare, loved it. It turned out to be one of my favorites, certainly of the last year. Very good.

Yeah I loved that book, but alas read it before goodreads.

I wonder if a lexicon for the Smiley-specific spy jargon exists somewhere out there. Probably so. I'll look later.


I wonder if a lexicon for the Smiley-specific spy jargon exists somewhere out there. Probably so. I'll look later."
Thanks Steve.
Wikipedia did a great job of collecting the jargon. I would definitely suggest keeping it handy while you are reading the book.

I usually can read with the television on or some music playing in the background, but with this book that was impossible. Driving safely and listening as carefully as you need to for this book could prove frustrating. I might try the audio (in a few months) since I've read the book.
Even reading the book I felt some frustrating that I wasn't grasping all the threads. This is an important book and I really didn't want to fail because I couldn't pay attention well enough. I had to stop and take a walk out on the deck every so often to clear the cobwebs.

Also watch the Alec Guinness series before watching the Gary Oldman movie.

Thanks Tfitoby that book would be helpful.



In my review I decided that the tone and atmosphere are what makes this book what it is and Le Carre is probably right in those terms but I like my adaptations to try to stay true to the content. I think the movie left too much out, I ended up explaining things to my wife as she hadn't read the book.

I haven't watched the movie yet, but my impression from what I've read and what you are saying is they are almost relying on the fact that you've read the book. I loved the series, but my wife felt that it dragged. I'm hoping she'll like the movie version better, but maybe I'm just exchanging one problem for another.

Those were Leahs exact words.
At lest you know that by getting your wife to read the book it's exactly as intended and really very good too.

Shannon I think I'm averaging somewhere around 30 likes per review. My highest is In Cold Blood http://www.goodreads.com/review/show/.... With the number of really terrific reviewers on goodreads I'm humbled with the support that my friends are giving me. I think you will find that many, many more people are reading your reviews, but they don't comment or hit the like button so they are ghosts. We could use a page view counter that would give us an idea of how many people at least look at our reviews.

I need to move the movie up my netflix queue and watch it. I shoehorned the book between the series and the movie. If I had it to do again I would of course read the book first, always a best policy.

Those were Leahs exact words.
At lest you know that by getting your wife to read the book it's exactly as intend..."
Have you convinced your wife to read the book?

I did not care for the movie, BTW.

Have you read the book?

The book is rich in detail and truly a classic of cold war literature. With the discussion on this thread I've come to the conclusion that I will like the movie a lot better having read the book. I wouldn't judge the book by the movie.

Eventually i will read The Spy Who Came in from the Cold (movie being very very good especially on criterion dvd) which many people consider his masterpiece.
Great review Jeffrey. I did what you said. I read the book first. But I was so lost. I just missed what was going on. Maybe I read too fast, but I got lost in the labyrinth. That was back in '96. When Netlix was created, one of the first things I rented was the Alec Guiness miniseries. I said, wow, so that's what happened. I really did not get it until the miniseries that I watched 4 years ago. Then this new movie came out, and I had forgotten a lot of details from the miniseries, which I had only seen once. So it was all new again. I immediately watched the movie just to make sure I got it. Then I found my old mass market with Guiness on the cover and moved it to my bedroom bookcase, which means I will re-read soon. Seriously, IMHO, only the strongest and most intrepid of readers should read before watching. This is one of those rare circumstances where I think a reader might benefit from watching the movie first--then reading the book--then watching the miniseries. That's my advice. Great review.
I agree with message 27 about The Spy Who Came in From the Cold. It is a masterpiece and I read it before watching the Burton movie, and I understood the book when I read it. :)

You've probably got a good point there Steve, there's a little bit of work involved in the reading of this so it can't be for everyone to just jump in to without prior warning.

The more information I get from all my great goodreads friends the more I'm scratching my head to figure out what order I should suggest people should read/watch this story. All the points are valid. It really shows how complex the plotting is for this book. I guess my best advice is if anyone struggles with the book or the movie or the mini-series do not give up. Try one of the other choices available.

I haven't seen it yet Riku, but Tfitoby has so hopefully he will see this and comment.

There is! It's great!

There is! It's great!"
Yes it is. Oldman so deserved his oscar nod. But the more leisurely mini-series with Alec Guinness is a lot easier to follow.
Excellent review-craft, JK. If you are planning on following Smiley you might want to break out your slightly soiled trench coat and maybe a pair of opera glasses.


A lot of people bought the book when the movie came out. Those copies should be showing up in used bookstores now. You can pick up a used copy on your favorite site :-)Amazon for $4.00 including shipping.


Nope. JK read it before you; he's just floating his review now, a year later.

I'm sure there are a hundred books you've read before me Jonathan. :-)

I amassed this rather large following so quickly on Twitter and felt this weird pressure to feed the beast every day that I finally had to just close it. My brain was being compressed down into 140 character bits. Writing reviews for GR is much more fulfilling. I did enjoy resurrecting a couple of my favorite tweets for this review.

This book has been on my TBR list for far too long. Now it's on my BOLO list!


Harry: You have a "sweet spot?" And you weren't "titillated?" What the hell are you reading???
But I wonder though, if a book makes you work that hard to keep track of things, whether that's good story telling? I agree; I wonder myself and think I fall on the side of 'not' such good storytelling. I don't need it spelled out but it doesn't need to be so buried that I have to work that hard to keep track.
Speaking generally here, of course, because I haven't read this book.

For me reading is just like when I used to chase women. Sometimes you have a hard week and your tired and you want that girl that won't give you too much resistance. She's just glad you asked her. Then there are weeks were you are feeling great, maybe closer to eight feet tall, and you decide to take on that girl with the pearls. You know she is going to be much more work. Her summit is lined with pitfalls and minefields, but you know once you get where you want to be it will be worth it.
In other words sometimes I want my story spoon fed to me and sometimes I want a bit of a brain crunch that requires more from me than just being a passive reader.
Of course nothing more annoying than buying the flowers, taking the girl with the pearls to a movie, taking her out to eat, and your left on the doorstep with a peck on the cheek. I do expect the writer of the more complex book to give me more than a peck on the cheek at the end.
The TV series is the same title as the book.

I try damn hard to titillate Harry with each and every review I write. As far as the sweet spot if Harry is calling balls and strikes than there is one hopping mad pitcher on the mound. haha Harry knows what he likes.
Unless you really like spy craft this may not be the best book series for you Cathy. I'm queuing up the second book in the Karla Trilogy soon and that might give me a better idea if I should recommend you jumping in the pool with LeCarre.