ŷ

Nataliya's Reviews > Rosewater

Rosewater by Tade Thompson
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
3672777
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: 2020-reads

The main reason I use ŷ is the beauty of finding new great books because of the book friends that I made here. This is exactly how I came across Rosewater which somehow never even registered on my book radar. So thanks, friends - carol and Samuel! This was quite good.
“I am not curious. I want to leave. This thing I do is not beautiful. It is filth.�
Set in the near future (2043-2066) in Nigeria, it shows us a world not much different from the one of our present, with the rough hard edges and unpleasantness and criminality and money worship and poverty and intolerances and prejudices - but with one very important difference: the aliens, of the space kind. Back in 2012, a giant alien lifeform, colloquially known as “Wormwood� landed in London and is now moving through Earth’s crust, not even the first of its kind, and strange things have happened, and America has “gone dark�, and in Nigeria a giant alien biodome has eventually popped up in 2055, occasionally radiating apparently healing rays (also capable of raising zombified dead at times and cause grotesque transformations in some), and an entire city has sprouted around the dome - the eponymous Rosewater (named so sarcastically, because the open sewage in its early days smelled anything but).


“We have more experience than any Western country in dealing with first contact. What do you think we experienced when your people carved up Africa at the Berlin Conference? You arrived with a different intelligence, a different civilisation, and you raped us. But we’re still here.�
The story is unfolding in three separate timelines, told in blunt, non-nonsense voice of Kaaro, a former thief and now a press-ganged agent of a secret arm of the government secret police because of his valuable and rare gift:
“This is my job. My real job. I read minds for the government.�
Kaaro and few other like him can connect to the xenosphere - a psychic link to what appears to be the world’s stored consciousness, and this gift is a direct consequence of the aliens and their “soft� invasion. Somehow certain people - the “sensitives� - can form links with the alien fungus-like organisms (“xԴǴڴǰ�) that make up the xenosphere. And apparently the sensitives are dying - or maybe being killed off. Bad news for Kaaro.
“What we call the xenosphere is larger than we think. What we use is the tiny periphery that connects us and the people in our immediate environment. You’ve heard of how photosynthesis involves quantum physics? This lattice of xenoforms connects throughout Earth’s atmosphere, but not just at the present time. It is in the past and the future, and in alternate versions of our planet. It is an easy place to get lost in.�
I have to say - I loved Kaaro and his narration. Cynical and blunt, no-nonsense, no-frills voice coming from a person who is clearly not a hero, but not an archetypical antihero either. Kaaro has no illusions about the world; he’s middle-aged and has been around the metaphorical block a few times. He’s focused on pragmatical and practical survival and egoism over idealism, and suffers from apathy from which he gets shaken up despite his wishes. He does his best to remain as detached as possible, with self-interest, self-preservation and personal gain being the driving force behind many of his decisions and actions. He is lonely, although often by choice, and bitter and probably could use a few therapy sessions. He can be crass and at times a bit sexist and rude and indifferent - but also at other times compassionate and brave and, although he’d deny it - pragmatically idealistic (although not for long). He’s a bit of a diamond in the rough - quite a bit of rough. Yeah, he’s kind of an asshole - but a compelling one.
As his dossier states:

“When suitably motivated, Kaaro can be a valuable asset. That said, he is sexist, materialistic, greedy, insolent and amoral. When he was young, he stole regularly even though his parents were not struggling financially. He is not violent and does not tolerate the threat of violence well. To recruit him we used a combination of these factors, offering his freelance rate of pay as well as exposing him to extreme violence done to others.�

The alternating timelines are structured to provide just enough revelations about this world to keep me glued to the page and my imagination rolling. It’s really the journey of discovering the world, building the coherent picture out of puzzle pieces and context and time jumps - and the worldbuilding is nicely paced. Rosewater and the other corners of this world that we see are vivid in my mind, and the character of the place is well-captured - rough, hard-edged, cruel, brutal, and often unforgiving, and not as far removed from our present as one would hope. The worldbuilding is creative yet firmly grounded, and therefore quite enjoyable. There’s no shortage of profanity and unpleasantness and bodily acts and fluids - but it never ventures from gritty to prurient, and for that I’m thankful. And the great thing about the time jumps is that we get to see the changes in Kaaro’s outlook and personality after time and the world have their way with him - the changes that are very interesting when placed side by side. Despite his best efforts, he’s certainly not static, and I enjoyed seeing the glimpses of growth, both positive and negative.
“This is a psychofield, a thoughtspace, essentially unstable. While most people conceptualise thinking as this straightforward linear thing, I see ideas spreading out into alternatives before one is selected. In this place every notion can potentially become reality.�

The premise of the story, the constant connection through the xenosphere, raises interesting questions in our increasingly more and more connected - at least on a superficial level - world. The unavoidability of alien-propagated connections opposed to the deliberate disconnection of parts of the world, and the ability of the government through those like Kaaro to literally look inside your mind - it’s all can lead to quite a wealth of ponderings and parallels to the current world, of course.

And of course, the culmination of the events by the end of this book sets interesting stakes for the rest of the trilogy, and I am quite curious to see where it all goes. Although it can still be read as an open-ended standalone, I suppose, as Kaaro’s questions do get somewhat answered, although those answers do lead to more questions.
“The idea of a singular hero and a manifest destiny just makes us all lazy. There is no destiny. There is choice, there is action, and any other narrative perpetuates a myth that someone else out there will fix our problems with a magic sword and a blessing from the gods.�

It’s clever, complex and entertaining, and was a welcome change from a few lackluster books I’ve read recently.

Solid 4+ stars.
143 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Rosewater.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

October 23, 2020 – Started Reading
October 23, 2020 – Shelved
October 24, 2020 –
26.0%
October 25, 2020 –
50.0% "I am thoroughly hooked by this story. Let’s see if I can finish it tonight if I really try."
October 25, 2020 –
70.0% "Love it so far!"
October 26, 2020 –
99.0%
October 26, 2020 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-20 of 20 (20 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Di (new)

Di Maitland I've heard such good things about this. Sounds like I should give it a go after all.


Nataliya I liked it quite a bit. I’m very curious to see where this trilogy goes. I’m getting my thoughts together for eventual review, but it certainly was fresh and interesting.


message 3: by nastya (new)

nastya and now it’s on my radar


message 4: by Di (new)

Di Maitland And solllldddd. Your review reminds me a little of Semiosis.


message 5: by Pooja (new) - added it

Pooja  Jha Wow!! I want to jump into this soon now:)


carol. A beautiful summary and analysis, all woven together. I couldn't think how to tell my reaction without filling my review with spoilers, so I didn't even try, but this is the other review I wish I would have written! :) I'll just refer people who want to know what it was like her :D


Left Coast Justin Yeah, he’s kind of an asshole - but a compelling one.

Something to aspire to. Nice review! Especially regarding the origins of the term 'Rosewater'


Nataliya nastyako wrote: "and now it’s on my radar"

Yes!!!


Nataliya Di wrote: "And solllldddd. Your review reminds me a little of Semiosis."

Yessss!!!!
I haven’t read Semiosis yet, but it certainly sounds interesting. I’m curious to see what you think of Rosewater.


Nataliya Pooja wrote: "Wow!! I want to jump into this soon now:)"

Do it! It’s good and different. I’m surprised it didn’t get a Hugo or a Nebula nod.


message 11: by Di (new)

Di Maitland Recommend Semiosis (though it’s also quite scary/horrifying). I won’t be able to get to this for a while but it’s definitely on my list now.


message 12: by Nataliya (last edited Oct 31, 2020 09:43AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Nataliya Left Coast Justin wrote: "Yeah, he’s kind of an asshole - but a compelling one.

Something to aspire to. Nice review! Especially regarding the origins of the term 'Rosewater'"


Well, if one must be an asshole, you might as well strive to be the best one out there.

As for the town name - I’m going to add the quote, straight from the proverbial horse’s mouth (or other orifice, I suppose):

“From the start. I mean from the start. So, Kaaro, what was it like?�
“Pretty feculent.�
“What do you mean?� asks Layi.
“He means it was shitty,� says Aminat.
“Yes, I know what the word means, but I think he means it literally.�
“I do. The predominant smell was of shit.�



Nataliya carol. wrote: "A beautiful summary and analysis, all woven together. I couldn't think how to tell my reaction without filling my review with spoilers, so I didn't even try, but this is the other review I wish I w..."

Thanks, carol! I am very happy that I come across this book, so world of thanks to you and Samuel! How exactly did this not get the Hugo or Nebula nods? It certainly merited more recognition.


message 14: by Tom LA (new)

Tom LA Agree about ŷ!!


Nataliya Tom LA wrote: "Agree about ŷ!!"

😁 I really can’t remember how I used to find great reads before this site. I mean, I did a fair share of library shelves browsing and an occasional bookstore browsing, but it was such hit and miss. I found so many of my favorite writers and books through this site, and it’s quite amazing. I just realized I’ve been on here for an entire decade.


message 16: by Vartika (new) - added it

Vartika This sounds like a fantastic book. So glad your wonderful review showed up on my timeline :)


message 17: by carol. (last edited Nov 01, 2020 08:20AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

carol. Nataliya wrote: "How exactly did this not get the Hugo or Nebula nods? It certainly merited more recognition."

I don't know, because I certainly agree. Name recognition? You'd think Locus would have given it a nod. There's not even that many reviews, and they drop significantly for the subsequent books.


Nataliya Vartika wrote: "This sounds like a fantastic book. So glad your wonderful review showed up on my timeline :)"

It’s a really good story. I’m very glad that I came across it.


Nataliya carol. wrote: "Nataliya wrote: "How exactly did this not get the Hugo or Nebula nods? It certainly merited more recognition."

I don't know, because I certainly agree. Name recognition? You'd think Locus would ha..."


Yeah, it’s strange that it got snubbed across the board, even when it came to nominations. And it does seem less known that similar books released at the same time. It just seemed to stay under the radar - I certainly had no idea about it until now.


message 20: by Phil (new) - rated it 4 stars

Phil Great review Nataliya! I really enjoyed this one, and only stuck with it due to your and Carol's review (I found it hard to get into at first). And yeah, much better than the typical books being nominated for Hugos and such!


back to top