Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Piyangie's Reviews > War and Peace

War and Peace by Leo Tolstoy
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
48056505
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: russian-lit, in-my-library

This Tolstoyan masterpiece is one of the best-written books on War and its effect on people's lives. The War is the Napoleonic war where Russia was invaded by a strong French army conquering Moscow, and the subsequent defeat and flight of the conquering army. Although some of the previous battles such as Austerlitz have been included, the story's "War" was mainly centered on the 1812 Napoleonic campaign. The Peace is somewhat ambiguous but can be surmised as the everyday life of the upper-class Russian nobles and the effect of war on them. Tolstoy interlaces both these parts well and brings to the readers a memorable story.

If one sections out the story, one finds three distinctive yet interconnected parts: the war, the peace, and Tolstoy's musings. The war occupies most of the book and dominates the story. Tolstoy with his brilliant writing brings out the brutal side of the war in detail. The atrocities committed by both sides of the army - Russian and the French, the callous and cold-hearted actions of the two opposing camps against one another forgetting that they are, after all, human brothers, and the absolute butchery that takes place in the name of fame and glory are spilled from Tolstoy's pen without any scruple. It was hard to stomach it all, knowing that somewhere in history, those deeds were actually committed. However, Tolstoy is determined to show the moments of humanity, in between battles, when the men of war are relaxed and can think for themselves rather than following the commanding orders. It seems that he wanted to counter the hellish side of the war by showing that the men preserved humanity to some extent without totally turning themselves into monsters in the heat of the action.

When the parts of the war are taken out the rest of it occupies the lives of the upper-class Russian nobles. Their ambitions, hopes, and dreams, and their love, loyalty, and betrayal are all portrayed in a fascinating bundle. The Rostovs - Natasha and Nikolai, the Bolknoskys - Andrei and Marya, and the Bezukhovs - Pierre (mostly) and Helene run the show while few other interesting characters - Dolokhov, Denisov, Vasily, and the villain Anatole Kuragin brings up the rear. This is a work of countless characters both historical and fiction, but it still can be narrowed down to a considerably small number for the purposes of the story. The inter-relationship between Natasha, Andrei, and Pierre is instrumental in exposing the themes of love, loyalty, tolerance, and the need to forgive. With sensitivity and a clear mind as to true human nature, Tolstoy has voiced efficiently on his favourite themes. However, I had trouble connecting with the characters. Although I didn't dislike them, I couldn't embrace them with my whole heart either. They were distant and a little cold, and at times, inconsistent. The only steady character was Andrei (to me at least) and his role doesn't run through to the end.

Finally, Tolstoy's musings fill in the gaps wherever a gap can be found. And it is quite often, I assure you. :) As in all Tolstoy literature, the meaning of life runs as an undercurrent here too. It is quite relevant given that death is an expected consequence of War. Some of his thoughts are quite interesting, although he can be exceedingly preachy. His thoughts also run on the deterministic nature of history and a detailed analysis as to the causes that determined the historical events are presented in the form of a second Epilogue! E. M. Forster has once said that Epilogues are for Tolstoy. If you read this complete Epilogue of War and Peace, you'll understand what he meant. :)

I'm really happy to have read this masterpiece of Tolstoy. It was by no means an easy read, but I made it in a little more than two months. The credit goes entirely to Tolstoy's writing. It is simply breathtaking. Tolstoy is a great master of creative compositions, yet, in my view, War and Peace is the best literary product of Tolstoy when it comes to writing.
152 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read War and Peace.
Sign In »

Quotes Piyangie Liked

Leo Tolstoy
“The strongest of all warriors are these two â€� Time and Patience.”
Leo Tolstoy, War and Peace


Reading Progress

December 1, 2020 – Shelved
December 1, 2020 – Shelved as: to-read
December 1, 2020 – Shelved as: russian-lit
December 5, 2020 – Shelved as: in-my-library
July 10, 2021 – Started Reading
July 12, 2021 –
page 66
4.72%
July 14, 2021 –
page 116
8.29%
July 18, 2021 –
page 213
15.23%
July 24, 2021 –
page 273
19.51%
July 27, 2021 –
page 317
22.66%
July 30, 2021 –
page 374
26.73%
August 3, 2021 –
page 453
32.38%
August 7, 2021 –
page 533
38.1%
August 10, 2021 –
page 588
42.03%
August 13, 2021 –
page 667
47.68%
August 16, 2021 –
page 756
54.04%
August 18, 2021 –
page 819
58.54%
August 21, 2021 –
page 911
65.12%
August 25, 2021 –
page 1037
74.12%
August 31, 2021 –
page 1096
78.34%
September 3, 2021 –
page 1146
81.92%
September 7, 2021 –
page 1196
85.49%
September 10, 2021 –
page 1259
89.99%
September 12, 2021 –
page 1317
94.14%
September 15, 2021 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-17 of 17 (17 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Tiffany (new)

Tiffany Great job with reading and finishing this book! How did you manage to remain focused? I think that is my main problem right now with trying to tackle this book. :/


Piyangie Thank you, Tiffany. I kind of read it on a slow schedule, like 4-5 chapters a day. I was determined to read that amount every day. There were days that the story was really compelling that I read more than the set number of chapters. There were also times that I took breaks in between the books as I was exhausted. :) The buddy read helped me to keep focused since I wanted to be near their reading mark. :)

It's not an easy book to read, so the best thing is not to pressure yourself and take it very very slow, perhaps a chapter a day since they are short ones. I know a group that reads books one chapter a day. I think it's an interesting concept. There is no pressure of reading that way.


Lucija Looking forward to reading your review!


Piyangie Lucija wrote: "Looking forward to reading your review!"

Thanks, Lucija. Just posted it. :)


QNPoohBear The writing is quite beautiful in part. Andrei's thoughts and Pierre's attempts to find meaning in his life. I both enjoyed and rolled my eyes at the soap opera plot that ran through the middle of the story though.


Piyangie QNPoohBear wrote: "The writing is quite beautiful in part. Andrei's thoughts and Pierre's attempts to find meaning in his life. I both enjoyed and rolled my eyes at the soap opera plot that ran through the middle of ..."

I liked his writing very much, and quite agree with you as to the plot. :)


Melcat I still have flashbacks of the never ending ramblings on war history... very nice review Piyangie ! and welcome to the "I-conquered-war-and-peace-club" ahha


Piyangie Melcat � wrote: "I still have flashbacks of the never ending ramblings on war history... very nice review Piyangie ! and welcome to the "I-conquered-war-and-peace-club" ahha"

Thank you, Melcat. Happy to be part of the club. It was forever on my TBR, so the feeling that I've finally done it is quite something. :)


Lady Clementina ffinch-ffarowmore Great job finishing this Piyangie. No easy feat as you said; I don't honestly remember much of the book (I tackled this as a commute book at one point of time and it took me 3 months I think) but i did feel sympathy for Andrei and pierre grew on me as well. The social aspects of the novel had me thinking of present day parallels--spoilt rich kids and all


Piyangie Lady Clementina wrote: "Great job finishing this Piyangie. No easy feat as you said; I don't honestly remember much of the book (I tackled this as a commute book at one point of time and it took me 3 months I think) but i..."

Thanks, Mallika. Yes, it's no easy feat and I'm glad I've accomplished it. I liked Andrei very much. Although I disliked him initially, he grew on me. Pierre, I couldn't quite fathom. In any case, I couldn't much connect with many of them.


message 11: by Tiffany (new)

Tiffany Piyangie wrote: "Thank you, Tiffany. I kind of read it on a slow schedule, like 4-5 chapters a day. I was determined to read that amount every day. There were days that the story was really compelling that I read m..."

I find that getting through this book is a chore to read, but I am not going to give up on it. I think it's because I can't remain focused on it and Tolstoy makes my brain hurt. I feel that sometimes a single chapter feels like I am reading a thousand pages. It's also very possible that I am just not in the mood for such a book right now and maybe my lack of enjoyment comes from that as well.

I've been such a mood reader these days. So whenever I am not in the mood for something, I just can't read a book, much less actually enjoy what I am reading.


Piyangie Totally understand, Tiffany. I'm a mood reader too. I recently finished The Moon is Down by Steinbeck and feels absolutely wretched that I find it difficult to start on another book.


message 13: by Mark (last edited Sep 24, 2021 10:07AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Mark André Cool review, Piyangie! So glad you had fun. I agree completely: Tolstoy is one of the true Titans of world literature. I liked the recounting of the famous battle at Borodino, and Napoleon’s refusal to release the Guard: knowing already, maybe, that he would need their protection during the inevitable retreat later on. - )


Piyangie Thank you, Mark. Yes, the battle of Borodino, the beginning that vicariously marked the downfall of Napoleon. Had a hard time of reading through those so detailed battle passages. And it is there Andrei (my favourite character) was fatally wounded. I remember both the incidents as if I read it yesterday. Funny how you can remember so much detail about such a massive piece.


message 15: by Mark (last edited Sep 25, 2021 02:18PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Mark André Piyangie wrote: "Thank you, Mark. Yes, the battle of Borodino, the beginning that vicariously marked the downfall of Napoleon. Had a hard time of reading through those so detailed battle passages. And it is there A..."

Your welcome, Piyangie. Yes. Quite vivid writing. Meant to be remembered. - )


Piyangie "Meant to be remembered." Well and truly said, Mark! :)


message 17: by Mark (new) - rated it 5 stars

Mark André Piyangie wrote: ""Meant to be remembered." Well and truly said, Mark! :)"
Thank you, Piyangie! You are most kind. - ))


back to top