Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Dmitri's Reviews > Going Clear: Scientology, Hollywood, and the Prison of Belief

Going Clear by Lawrence Wright
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
73216705
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: north-america, religion, cults

"If it's not true for you, it isn't true." - L. Ron Hubbard

**

Lawrence Wright became a Pulitzer Prize winning author for his 2006 'Looming Tower' about Al-Qaeda, before this 2013 book was begun. Many interviews were done and much was researched here as well. Previously he wrote about the Amish and studied the Jonestown Massacre. He was a journalist for Rolling Stone and later the New Yorker for forty years. My interests in Scientology are comparitive religion, history and politics. The Taiping, FDLS, ISIS and millenarian groups hold a similar fascination. Founder of Scientology L. Ron Hubbard created a disturbing synthesis of science fiction, religion and psychiatry. Perhaps psychosis and paranoia were integral to his flights of fantasy.

Born in 1911, Hubbard had a successful science fiction career in 1930's pulp magazines. He was a good friend of Robert A. Heinlein, and an associate of Isaac Asimov and L. Sprague de Camp. In WWII he had a brief but checkered Navy stint. By his account he sunk several enemy ships, was wounded but lived to tell the tale. Navy records don't support his claims, and he was repeatedly relieved of his command. In 1946 he was connected with a magic cult based on Aleister Crowley's beliefs. He wrote 'Dianetics' in 1950 and is rated as a most published author ever. During 1967-75 he lived on a fleet of ships sailing the oceans. He died in 1986 in seclusion on the run from the government.

'Dianetics: Modern Science of Mental Health' first appeared in 'Astounding Science Fiction'. It was an early self-help book devised as an alternative to psychiatry's use of drugs, electric shocks and lobotomies. Hubbard drew from his prior knowledge of hypnosis. People traumatized by early crises could be relieved by 'auditing' past problems, later with the use of an 'E-meter' similar to a lie detector. Sublimated memories uncovered during sessions evolved into prenatal and reincarnation revelations. Once 'clear' an initiate could aspire to ascending spiritual levels and even paranormal powers. Hubbard went on to define gradiations in seekers progress to attainment of knowledge.

The pseudo-science of 'Dianetics' led to a neo-religion. His copyright lost in bankruptcy Hubbard founded Scientology in 1954. In his belief system a 'thetan' is an immortal alien being who inhabits people's bodies at birth. Between lives thetans go to Mars and receive 'forgetter implants'. 75 million years ago an evil overlord conspired with IRS agents and psychiatrists to freeze thetans and fly them to earth on DC-8 jets. They were implanted with images of God, Heaven, the Devil and Hell in 3D movie theaters. Earth had been civilized many times, but always blew itself up under the influence of alien souls. Scientology could save humanity from them and achieve spiritual progress.

In the 1960's IRS audits, FDA seizure of E-meters, and charges of fraud drew Hubbard abroad. Hounded by global governments he took to the sea. Founding a paramilitary navy he was shunned at ports as undesirable. Allegations of mistreatment arose and a persecution complex took hold. The 1973 Operation Snow White was an espionage effort where thousands of Scientologists infilitrated government agencies to expunge files and subvert investigations. A new base in Florida was established in 1975 and Hubbard came ashore. Chased by the IRS and FBI he went into hiding and directed the Church from afar. Buying a ranch in California he lived his last years in a converted school bus.

David Miscavige is depicted as a violent sociopath raised in the fold who seized power after Hubbard's death In 1986. He groomed celebrity advocates who had been long sought after, Tom Cruise, John Travolta and others. Miscavige carried the Church message with missionary zeal. Punishment for minor infractions was routine and severe since the Sea Org days and became worse. FBI raids found people locked up, denied food and forced to work for free. Attempts to leave were met with coercion and harassment. Many members were born in the Church or had joined at an early age. With few skills and outside contacts they were docile and compliant. Human trafficking cases were begun but abandoned.

In 1967 the Church lost tax exemption when the IRS claimed Scientology was a commercial enterprise offering fixed fee services. In litigation theological experts argued the church was similar to other creeds. Articles of faith such as virgin conception, magical flight, resurrection and exorcism were features of all doctrines. New religions were always faced with discrimination. Adherents were often subjected to poverty and asceticism. In 1993 the IRS, under a barrage of lawsuits for 26 years, ruled Scientology should be not be required to pay taxes under 1st Amendment protections. In 2009 the incoming Obama administration made revocation of the tax exemption a top policy goal, based on an open internet poll. So far the thetans are still among us.
48 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Going Clear.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Started Reading
December 2, 2020 – Shelved
December 2, 2020 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-21 of 21 (21 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Aurelia (new)

Aurelia A fascinating topic Dmitri! It is always amusing to think about our traditional religions, through the lens of these modern religions! It gives a new dimension to Religion as something deeply human!


message 2: by Bob (new)

Bob Newman Yes, very interesting. Though most religions have non-logical or magical parts in their make up, few of them are so commercial and so lacking in love. I'm not sure I'd call Scientology a religion, but it is at least a cult. And what is the difference? Yeah, well, a few books in that question!!
The Little King---There is only one true religion!
Local churl---Then, how come there are so many churches?
The Little King---The cults have to go someplace.

I wonder if you ever heard of a flying saucer cult in Australia. I think it was back in the 1930s. A local Sydney stadium filled to capacity with people who expected the flying saucers to land on a certain day. They didn't land. But many people continued to follow the cult anyway. Some parallel with people who predict they will win elections and then don't win, but still claim they did.


Dmitri Aurelia wrote: "A fascinating topic Dmitri! It is always amusing to think about our traditional religions, through the lens of these modern religions! It gives a new dimension to Religion as something deeply human!"

Thanks, Aurelia! Religion is a fascinating human trait. Many practice faith and find answers to their questions, while others use it for control. It created great art and architecture, as well as war and repression.


message 4: by Dmitri (last edited Jul 21, 2022 09:02AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dmitri Bob wrote: "Yes, very interesting. Though most religions have non-logical or magical parts in their make up, few of them are so commercial and so lacking in love. I'm not sure I'd call Scientology a religion, ..."

Thanks for your comments Bob! I have to agree Scientology is a dismal example of manipulating people's money and faith, on par with selling fake university degrees and subverting democracy.

I’ve heard of the flying saucer arrival. Didn't they move up the date?


message 5: by Bob (new)

Bob Newman Mm, I don't remember. I read about it back in the late 70s, I think. But the idea of the chapter (in a book about cults) was that despite the failure of the prophecy, people kept on believing.


message 6: by Dmitri (last edited Aug 16, 2021 04:05PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dmitri Bob wrote: "Mm, I don't remember. I read about it back in the late 70s, I think. But the idea of the chapter (in a book about cults) was that despite the failure of the prophecy, people kept on believing."

Hi Bob, Sorry to reply six months later. I was thinking of Heaven's Gate. This article doesn't tell it well, but they waited for aliens to arrive and take the believers away.




message 7: by Michael (new)

Michael Perkins Book about how failed prophecies only increase fidelity to the cause.

/review/show...


Dmitri Michael wrote: "Book about how failed prophecies only increase fidelity to the cause.

/review/show..."

Thanks Michael! I followed your link and read an excellent review by BlackOxford. The underlying book looks very interesting too.


message 9: by Michael (new)

Michael Perkins His review has great insights. I've shared it with many GR connections.


message 10: by Darya Silman (new)

Darya Silman And people believe this??? They must be in despair


message 11: by Dmitri (last edited May 30, 2022 07:43AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dmitri Darya wrote: "And people believe this??? They must be in despair"

It reminds me that fiction is more compelling than fact.


message 12: by Jessaka (new)

Jessaka I often like to read religious books that expose Certain types of religion Your review is very good


Dmitri Jessaka wrote: "I often like to read religious books that expose Certain types of religion Your review is very good"

Thanks Jessaka. As Bob commented above, it’s somewhat closer to a cult than a real religion. But I guess one person’s religion is another’s person’s cult.


message 14: by Jessaka (new)

Jessaka I think they are all colts


Dmitri Jessaka wrote: "I think they are all cults"
Amen.


message 16: by Pam (new)

Pam Power hungry people


message 17: by Linda (new)

Linda Fascinating review. I didn't realize crazy this cult is.


message 18: by Daren (new)

Daren I enjoyed re-reading this review Dmitri. Such bizarre tales adopted into a belief structure. Could only have come from a science fiction writer though, right? Makes you wonder if other science fiction writers never really kicked on enough into their own cults!


Dmitri Linda wrote: "Fascinating review. I didn't realize crazy this cult is."

Thanks Linda, I couldn’t do it justice but I tried.


message 20: by Dmitri (last edited Jul 21, 2022 02:39PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dmitri Daren wrote: "I enjoyed re-reading this review Dmitri. Such bizarre tales adopted into a belief structure. Could only have come from a science fiction writer though, right? Makes you wonder if other science fict..."

Thanks for re-reading it Daren. I think you’d have to be a really creative science fiction writer and a certifiable megalomaniac to approach this level of of achievement.


Dmitri Pam wrote: "Power hungry people"

I thinks it boils down to that Pam. And if power is your hunger what better way to achieve it than be a prophet of something or other.


back to top