Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Petra in Tokyo's Reviews > Marry Him: The Case for Settling for Mr. Good Enough

Marry Him by Lori Gottlieb
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
1237196
Update Aug. 2022 This is where I am now. Not marriage, but living together I think. My bf whom I am only 75% happy with wants me to come and live in the US and says he can facilitate that. We get on great, we share being artists and writers, but.... he is not exciting and our sex life rates on a GR scale 1.5, rounded down. But I'm not getting any younger. All my relationships last a year, year and a half, and maybe I should settle for Mr. Good Enough and find happiness in what we share together.
__________

I read one more chapter after DNF'ing the book. It was on a dating coach and percentages and realising that you (the woman over 35) are not only 'not all that', you are 'not very much at all'. The author is 5'2" and wants a man of 5'10"+ and the coach says why not move your limit down to 5'5" but she feels she couldn't possibly date a man that short. Only 15% of men are over 6' and 80% of women want one. She says her age range is 35 to 48. Then she doesn't like men say this, ask for that, have a motorbike or like audiobooks. So the coach eventually works out that she has only a 5% chance of meeting someone who meets all her requirements.

Factor in her religious requirements (they have to be the same religion as her with the same level of observance) and it turned out to be 0.1%. That is one man in ten thousand. Would she, for that man, should she meet him, fit his bill?

She was 41, a bad age for an older man who wants biological children, she's 41, men prefer women under 35 no matter what age they are, she has a child, men do not like single women with children. She's got OCD with placement of her items - they can't be touched, is indecisive about everything, can't cook, gets stressed out and explodes really easily (she admits to all of these) and so on.

Where does that leave me? I am full of off-putting flaws. (view spoiler)
__________________

The whole book is terribly distressing because it is mistitled. The true title should be "Women are past their sell-by date as future mothers at 35: how to settle for a man who is divorced and already has children and pays alimony and whom you only have a few things in common, but at least he's willing to commit." If I had read that I wouldn't have got the book, I don't want to read about how I long missed my chance and now as far as men are concerned, I'm just invisible, undesirable, not worth bothering about.

She's talking about how dating agencies, matchmakers and the like say that a woman of 38 wanting a goodlooking man with a good job, tall and all his hair is going to have to downsize, because she's not the prize to attract an A+ man anymore. What a load of tosh. I'm on the verge of dnf'ing this book. I've dnf'd this book. Thank you, Malia your review made up my mind.

Speeddating at 41 The author pays a lot of money to go to an upscale speeddating evening. There are 10 women between early and late forties. There are only 6 men most in their 50s and 60s. The organisers said that men want younger women so they lie about their age and if they didn't let them in they would go out of business. So an expensive and wasted evening for all concerned, except the organisers.

Me at 48, husbands and my personality faults (view spoiler)

"The Husband Store A new store has opened. A huband store! There’s a sign at the entrance: You may visit the husband store only once. There are six floors, and the value of the products increase on each successive floor. The shopper can choose any item from a particular floor, or go up to shop on the next floor, but she cannot go back down except to exit the building.

So, a woman goes into the store. On the first floor the sign on the door reads:
Floor I—Men Who Have Good Jobs. “That’s nice,� she thinks, “but I want more.� So she continues upward, where the sign reads:
Floor 2—Men Who Have Good Jobs And Love Kids. She’s intrigued, but continues to the third floor, where the sign reads:
Floor 3—Men Who Have Good Jobs, Love Kids, And Are Extremely Handsome.“Wow,� she thinks, but feels compelled to keep going.
Floor 4—Men Who Have Good Jobs, Love Kids, Are Extremely Handsome, And Help Equally With The Housework. “It can’t get better than this!� she exclaims. But then a voice inside her asks, “Or can it?� She goes up and reads the sign.
Floor 5—Men Who Have Good Jobs, Love Kids, Are Extremely Handsome, Help Equally With The Housework, And Have A Great Sense Of Humor. Having found what she’s looking for, she’s tempted to stay, but something propels her to the sixth floor, where the sign reads:
Floor 6—You Are Visitor 42,2i5,602 To This Floor. There Are No Men On This Floor. This Floor Only Exists To Prove That Women Are Impossible To Please. Thank You For Shopping At The Husband Store.

To avoid gender bias charges, the store’s owner opened a Wife Store right across the street.
The first floor has wives who Love Sex.
The second floor has wives who Love Sex and Are Kind.
The third floor has wives who Love Sex, Are Kind, and Like Sports.
The fourth, fifth, and sixth floors have never been visited." (The beginning of the book).

That woman is me to a T. I never used to be like that. My first husband was my teenage sweetheart and we were both artists and loved music and writing and books and wanted to escape Wales for London. We ended up as platonic friends. My second husband was a government official, a handsome man, in the top political family of the island. He loved writing, fishing and sex (in reverse order). (view spoiler) I started to go to Florida and it was like men everywhere and coffee, lunch and dinner dates and I didn't have to settle.

All I did was be flattered and have fun and when I could have made a good relationship, could have settled for Mr Good Enough and we could have grown together as friends and partners, I stupidly didn't. The knight in gold armour on the proud white horse is Prince Charming, the Shrek version.

I need to change. The borders opened on 1st Dec. We've been locked down since March. I'm leaving after Christmas and I have three men to see and I have to stop this shit. I want to be in love, I want to be loved. I want a partner to hold hands with when we go out walking. Relationships are not jigsaws with ever piece fitting perfectly. I know this but cannot act like it. I know it is more important to be with a nice kind man with whom I get along and we laugh a lot and have sex a lot and travel independently every now and again.

This is not for anyone to read, but it's ok to do so. It's really written to remind myself where I am, the mistakes I've made. Because I'm determined to move forward. And hope that this book can help. (view spoiler)
251 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Marry Him.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

December 3, 2020 – Started Reading
December 3, 2020 – Shelved
December 3, 2020 – Shelved as: to-read
December 6, 2020 – Shelved as: 2020-100-reviews
December 6, 2020 – Shelved as: 2020-read
December 6, 2020 – Shelved as: books-i-really-loathed
December 6, 2020 – Shelved as: getting-a-bit-personal-here
December 6, 2020 – Shelved as: reviewed
December 6, 2020 – Shelved as: popculture-anthropology
December 6, 2020 – Finished Reading
May 30, 2022 – Shelved as: dnf-or-never-read
December 8, 2022 – Shelved as: rewritten-reviews

Comments Showing 1-50 of 65 (65 new)


message 1: by nastya (new)

nastya wow loved this. good luck!


Petra in Tokyo nastyako wrote: "wow loved this. good luck!"

Thank you. I hope it works. This year has been so lonely. For lots of people.


Cynda is preoccupied with RL You might be one to something Petra. Many people are lonely and maybe many will marry post-covid days. Good head start maybe. . . .


message 4: by Alien (new)

Alien Bookreader Quite interesting. I guess it depends on how high the standards are. I've met people who feel that they've settled because there was no use waiting for the perfect person (not just women, men too who said they gave up on finding the "perfect woman"). Their marriages seem strained. Maybe all marriages at some point get strained.

I recently met a man (single guy) who said he's rather have a difficult relationship than no relationship at all. I think he's completely naive. The worst case scenario of being alone is what- being lonely? Worst case scenario of a bad relationship - mental or physical abuse, bad mental health, health issues from the chronic stress? I've seen it first hand in my own family (both men and women in my family being victims of explosive partners).

Ideally when you find someone you really like, you can simply enjoy being with them without thinking of what's missing. But I would be cautious with the idea of settling for someone who is not really a match.

Being single is not the worst thing in the world. I don't see why people fear it so much.


Adina (notifications back, log out, clear cache) Good luck in finding the right person. However, it seems your search gave you some exciting experiences. Some not so nice, I agree but you do not seem to get bored. Except for this year, I am sorry it made you feel so bad. I keep saying that specialists do not take into account the psychological damage of lockdowns.


message 6: by Fran (new)

Fran Excellent review, Petra. The old thoughts of marrying Mr. Good Enough and "learning to love him" went out the window with the merry housewife preparing the perfect dinner for her working husband. Seek and you shall find adventure and fulfillment....you go girl!


Petra in Tokyo Alien wrote: "The worst case scenario of being alone is what- being lonely? ..."

The worst case is going to be different for everyone. Intellectually, being alone is fine. Physically, no hugs, no sex, no one to walk with holding their hand, is among the worst to me. I live in a rainforest on a tiny island in the middle of nowhere at all. I ache for physical company.


message 8: by Caroline (new)

Caroline Great review, and I hope you find someone on floor 5 ....


Petra in Tokyo Caroline wrote: " I hope you find someone on floor 5 ...."

Thank you. The book is deteriorating. It's now saying repeatedly that once past 35 you are past your sell-by date and men don't want you as a potential mother for their children. In fact men under the age of 50 don't want you. So maybe they won't even let me in the store.


message 10: by Caroline (new)

Caroline :O(


message 11: by Paul (new)

Paul Secor Go to the Husband Store. Go to floor 2, 3, or 4. Pick one out and be happy with who you're with. Forget about all of the glitz and glamour. Enjoy life and be happy.


message 12: by Petra in Tokyo (last edited Dec 04, 2020 09:34PM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Petra in Tokyo Paul wrote: "Go to the Husband Store. Go to floor 2, 3, or 4. Pick one out and be happy with who you're with. Forget about all of the glitz and glamour. Enjoy life and be happy."

Ironically, the only two 'qualities' in the Husband Store I really like (and am working with some success on letting go) is handsome and has a good sense of humour. Kids are grown. I couldn't care less what job he does, I'm not looking to be supported, housework, well there's always the weekly treasure. I just want some to have fun with who wants thinks most things are are better with a partner, better shared.


Cynda is preoccupied with RL Eros is a wily character. You never know when he might show up. . .


Petra in Tokyo Cynda wrote: "Eros is a wily character. You never know when he might show up. . ."

I think he's too busy gate crashing parties elsewhere, or else we don't move in the same circles.


message 15: by Alien (new)

Alien Bookreader Petra-X wrote: "Alien wrote: "The worst case scenario of being alone is what- being lonely?."

Yes, actually after writing my comment I also thought about how the surrounding culture will influence the experience of being single. Some cultures have more community, social events, openness to strangers (my experience living in Asia). In other cultures seen people stick to small social circles and are more wary of strangers (my experience living in Europe).


Petra in Tokyo Alien wrote: "actually after writing my comment I also thought about how the surrounding culture will influence the experience of being single...."

Being in a bad relationship is soul-destroying. Being in a not-so-good relationship where there are a lot of things you like is doable Here the society is very small. The total population is only of a small town anyway and is divided into several distinct groups who don't mix, ever. I don't fit into any of them, not one of them likes me, so I sit in my little rainforest home and dream of holding hands with someone and walking the streets of a big city.


message 17: by Negin (new)

Negin Petra, your review was wonderful, as always.
Most importantly, I hope so much that you find the best person for you - the one where both of you can be happy and content, at least most of the time. Life is sometimes very wonderful and sometimes very difficult, but most of the time it's just neutral. Remember during the difficult times that it will not last forever, that things will eventually shift. I keep telling myself that these days, I'm talking about covid and how much this year stinks. It won't last forever.


Petra in Tokyo Negin wrote: "I hope so much that you find the best person for you - the one where both of you can be happy and content, at least most of the time...."

Thank you. So do I, I am so despondent stuck on this rock. Beaufiul surroundings and a perfect climate are for doing things in with a partner, they don't substitute for having one.


message 19: by Kathleen (new) - added it

Kathleen I loved Lori Gottlieb’s Maybe You Should Talk to Someone. It’s too bad about this one!


message 20: by Alien (new)

Alien Bookreader Petra-X wrote: "Alien wrote: "actually after writing my comment I also thought about how the surrounding culture will influence the experience of being single...."

Being in a bad relationship is soul-destroying. ..."


Yes sounds quite isolating.


message 21: by Licha (new)

Licha Very interesting review. I love the different floors story. Good luck in your search.


Petra in Tokyo Licha wrote: "Very interesting review. I love the different floors story. Good luck in your search."

That sucked me into the story.


message 23: by Licha (new)

Licha I'm still trying to figure out what floor I'd like to get off on. Lol.


Petra in Tokyo Licha wrote: "I'm still trying to figure out what floor I'd like to get off on. Lol."

The one where there are a lot of men eager to meet you, no matter what the sales force tell you!


message 25: by Théo d'Or (new)

Théo d'Or OMG, this is The Case for Settling for Mrs Petra Good Enough.
I guess you wanted to write a book into a book. I think it worked out for you.


Petra in Tokyo I primarily write reviews because I like to write. I also write blogs in my reviews because I need to write. I did put it in spoilers and explain it was for me. Sometimes it kind of pours out of me.


message 27: by Théo d'Or (new)

Théo d'Or Can't wait for a trilogy :))


Petra in Tokyo Théodore wrote: "Can't wait for a trilogy :))"

Sarcasm! I used to have a blog, Theo, I closed it down because I got trolls, hackers and a stalker. Sometimes I need to just write, and I am only a virtual presence, I'm not "real" to anyone here, except a few people who know me IRL.


message 29: by Théo d'Or (new)

Théo d'Or Sarcasm ?! Not at all, Petra. I really wish that.


message 30: by Théo d'Or (new)

Théo d'Or What's your IRL ?🙂


Petra in Tokyo IRL = In real life


message 32: by Théo d'Or (new)

Théo d'Or Aa..Otherwise " The Phantom of the Opera ", right ?


Petra in Tokyo Théodore wrote: "Aa..Otherwise " The Phantom of the Opera ", right ?"

Not sure what you mean.


message 34: by Morgan (new)

Morgan Hummm - Made me think of "Looking for Mr. Goodbar"
Very cool review even if you didn't much care for the book.


Petra in Tokyo Morgan wrote: "Hummm - Made me think of "Looking for Mr. Goodbar" Very cool review even if you didn't much care for the book."

Thank you, I'm glad my love life is more cool written than lived. I would have liked the book better if it didn't continually remind me that I'm not just past my sell by date as a woman but actually should have been chucked out along with the mouldy stuff in the fridge.


message 36: by Kevin (new)

Kevin Ansbro You hit the nail on the head when you wrote "Relationships are not jigsaws with every piece fitting perfectly." - hence the reason why opposites often attract.
I would hazard a guess that your soul-baring anecdotes are far more interesting than this book, Petra. Superb review!


Petra in Tokyo Kevin wrote: " would hazard a guess that your soul-baring anecdotes are far more interesting than this book, Petra. Superb review!..."

It's easy to do that when no one much knows me. I'm just Petra - X!


message 38: by Debbie (new)

Debbie Petra, I could read your bloggy reviews all day. I just wish you felt better. You have a lot of self-awareness, and you are so damn smart! Bad luck to be stranded and to get COVID. Things have to get better for everyone in 2021! What happens to the husband store if there’s an earthquake? Do all the men get jumbled up and end up on the wrong floors, indistinguishable? Maybe there needs to be a shake up of desirable traits. Hope you find a hand-holder.


message 39: by Carmen (new)

Carmen Great review! I wish you luck and happiness.


Tamar...playing hooky for a few hours today you are hilarious! my saint of a husband is looking better and better.


Petra in Tokyo Debbie wrote: "What happens to the husband store if there’s an earthquake? Do all the men get jumbled up and end up on the wrong floors..."

Then they have a fire sale, and they all go cheap :-)


message 42: by Debbie (new)

Debbie Petra-X wrote: "Debbie wrote: "What happens to the husband store if there’s an earthquake? Do all the men get jumbled up and end up on the wrong floors..."

Then they have a fire sale, and they all go cheap :-)"


LMAO!


message 43: by Cecily (new)

Cecily Facts, jokes, heartbreak, hope.., this has it all. Fingers crossed for you.


message 44: by Joe (new)

Joe Krakovsky I know this is serious stuff but I had a good laugh at your 'sell by date' because we religiously mark our groceries with expiration dates before putting them on our shelves. And I don't think you are "invisible, undesirable, not worth bothering about." I think you are pretty, smart, and not one to put up with any of Shit. Happy hunting. (I hope you get an orange vest for Christmas.)


Petra in Tokyo Cecily wrote: "Facts, jokes, heartbreak, hope.., this has it all. Fingers crossed for you."

Thank you. Things are looking up... if I can get off the island and no one 'cancels' me.


Petra in Tokyo Joe - orange vest? Don't get it, pls explain.


message 47: by Liam O'Leary (new)

Liam O'Leary Probably the most personal review on GoodReads, we're all rooting for your Petra, writing this all down will probably help you figure things out. Being your son's age I highly doubt I'm probably out of my depth here, but I do wonder whether being a "three strikes" person works well with a realistic idea of "the one" for anybody. I also think the problem with the stores analogy is that men on the fifth floor are worse at what men on the first floor do. And maybe a jack-of-all-trades will either be too blunted to be good enough at anything, or too focused to be with anyone or anything for too long. Also, who would enter a store of purchasable men without a height or muscle section, especially when the corresponding wife store requires their products love sex on every floor? To me, the combination of stores doesn't add up! I believe the third floor of the wife store might have e-sports instead, and that some depraved men did once reach the sixth floor of the wife store... only to find unicorns. Good luck, Petra!


Petra in Tokyo Liam wrote: "Probably the most personal review on GoodReads, we're all rooting for your Petra.."

No, I've bled all over GR when I was ghosted by GR bff Sheila for no known reason, and last year when the racing car driver dumped me. You just missed all those. Sometimes I blog, sometimes I review. I think it's because GR has such a great community on it and anyway only a few people on my list actually know me in person.


Petra in Tokyo Liam wrote: "I do wonder whether being a "three strikes" person works well with a realistic idea of "the one" for anybody...."

I'm not a 3 strikes person, but these two men were. You can tell by the way they talk of other relationships. You can see they start off all idealistic and the woman is trying to please them, but then she says or does something that really doesn't go along with what they want. Strike one. And so it goes, on the third one, you get dumped. The husband store was in the book, I just quoted it.


Petra in Tokyo Liam wrote: "Being your son's age I highly doubt I'm probably ou..."

As far age goes, that awful cliche 'you are as old as you feel' is actually true. Also maturity is not a level that rises, it is a wave, it is variable. You can be very mature and wise in some areas and 16 in others. You'll find out.


« previous 1
back to top