Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Fionnuala's Reviews > Snow

Snow by John Banville
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
5498525
's review

bookshelves: johnbanville, review-just-for-my-own-records
Read 2 times. Last read December 9, 2020 to December 11, 2020.

For me, the most interesting, indeed surprising thing about this book was that John Banville put his own name to it and not the pseudonym Benjamin Black which he's used in the past for his noir novels. I enjoyed those books initially but I eventually grew tired of the repetition of themes so I wouldn't have picked this up if I'd known it was more of the same. Admittedly, he's created a new and very different detective figure in this one, but the two principal characters from his noir series pop up here again so it's definitely out of the same stable. In any case the themes are identical: 1950s Ireland, and in particular the way society was dominated by the Catholic Church. In this story he focuses on clerical child abuse, ripping into it fiercely and presenting it as if viewed through his trademark whiskey glass. The main difference between this book and the Black series, apart from the author's name on the cover is that the story is not told from the point of view of a member of the majority Catholic population but through the eyes of one of the small minority of Protestants in the country at that time. There's also the fact that although whiskey glasses are mentioned a lot, the main character doesn't actually enjoy drinking it.
43 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Snow.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
December 9, 2020 – Started Reading
December 11, 2020 – Finished Reading
December 19, 2020 – Shelved

Comments Showing 1-18 of 18 (18 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Théo d'Or (new)

Théo d'Or Which would be the meaning of the title ?
It seems a bit poetic, though.


message 2: by Laura (new)

Laura I suppose once readers know Black is John Banville there is little point in continuing the separation. I think writers with pseudonyms want to separate their identities - in other words their novels create a certain image and style - from which they like to depart - so once the cover is blown ...


message 3: by Fionnuala (new) - added it

Fionnuala Théodore wrote: "Which would be the meaning of the title ?
It seems a bit poetic, though."


Thanks for reminding me of something I meant to say about the title, Théodore. The story, which involves a dead man, happens over a few snowy days leading up to Christmas. The main character, Detective Strafford, makes a comment about the snow to his boss in which he makes a veiled reference to the last lines of James Joyce's famous story, 'The Dead'. But his Police Chief boss doesn't get the reference.
'Is it now snowing down there, like it is here?�
‘Yes, Chief. Snow is general all over Ireland.�
‘Is it?�
‘It’s a quotation–never mind.�



message 4: by Fionnuala (new) - added it

Fionnuala Laura wrote: "I suppose once readers know Black is John Banville there is little point in continuing the separation. I think writers with pseudonyms want to separate their identities - in other words their novel create a certain image and style..."

Yes, Laura, it was clear that Banville wanted a separate identity when he created the Benjamin Black series, and I liked that there was that separation between his detective novels and his more literary fiction. But as you say, it served little purpose any more. My version of this book didn't have the series subtitle by the way—that's a definite giveaway.


message 5: by Paul (new)

Paul I've never read Banville, Fionnuala. What's his non-noir fiction like? The Dead, on the other hand; I know exactly how good that is. Ah, Michael Furey...


message 6: by Fionnuala (new) - added it

Fionnuala Banville's non-noir is maybe worth a try, Paul. I used to read everything of his I came across but not so much in recent years. The Sea remains in my mind as a high point.
If you're into Irish writers, his Time Pieces: A Dublin Memoir is enjoyable—a mixture of geography and literary history written in an easy style.
His style and themes can be very elaborate too, as in Ancient Light or The Infinities.
One book I definitely don't recommend is his Mrs Osmond which is a rewrite of The Portrait of a Lady. He alienated me with that book.


message 7: by Vesna (new)

Vesna Fionnuala wrote: "One book I definitely don't recommend is his Mrs Osmond which is a rewrite of The Portrait of a Lady. He alienated me with that book."

OMG, I'm so glad I am carefully reading the comments besides your always interesting reviews, Fionnuala. I was just about to order his Mrs. Osmond as a followup to my reading of The Portrait of a Lady that I plan for the early next year!


message 8: by Eva (last edited Dec 21, 2020 09:55AM) (new)

Eva I've read in an interview that one day, he thought "why hide, there's no reason to be ashamed of these" which is why he now uses his real name for everything.


message 9: by Fionnuala (new) - added it

Fionnuala Ah, ok. Thanks for telling me they, Eva.


message 10: by Fionnuala (new) - added it

Fionnuala Vesna wrote: "OMG, I'm so glad I am carefully reading the comments besides your always interesting reviews, Fionnuala. I was just about to order his Mrs. Osmond as a followup to my reading of The Portrait of a Lady that I plan for the early next year!"

Now I regret being so damning of that book, Vesna. Perhaps you will like it. Banville does a great job of imitating HJ's style.


message 11: by Vesna (new)

Vesna Fionnuala wrote: "Now I regret being so damning of that book, Vesna. Perhaps you will like it. Banville does a great job of imitating HJ's style."

Oh, I see. I'll then definitely keep him in mind, Fionnuala. Still have to see how I feel about HJ's style, it will be my first James.


Danielle McClellan Thanks for your review, Fionnuala. I just finished the book and although I loved the wintery chill of the setting, the overall plot fell flat for me.


message 13: by Fionnuala (new) - added it

Fionnuala I know what you mean regarding the plot, Danielle. It was too easy to figure out. I felt the book could have done without the interlude in the middle where we got the first person account from the main villain. Even if we hadn't figured out the puzzle before then, that gives it all away. Plus the hypocrisy of the villain's voice was really hard to take � though I know Banville caught it fairly accurately.


message 14: by Sue (new) - rated it 4 stars

Sue Thanks for this insight. Fionnuala. I haven't read any of the Benjamin Black noir novels yet.


message 15: by Fionnuala (new) - added it

Fionnuala You're coming to his detective stories with fresh eyes, Sue, and that's great. Enjoy them.


Left Coast Justin I didn't like this one at all. It might have been daring if it had been published twenty years earlier, but what was up with such a bloodless protagonist?


message 17: by Fionnuala (new) - added it

Fionnuala I completely agree, Justin. Old and stale, all of it.


Jennifer Welsh I was also disappointed in this one, Fionnuala, and had expected less of a thriller from Banville. I've still never read another by him. I agree with Justin, too–the topic was so Been there, Done that, but for the Protestant - Catholic relationship


back to top