Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

switterbug (Betsey)'s Reviews > Cloud Atlas

Cloud Atlas by David Mitchell
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
2843912
's review

it was amazing

After finally dusting off this book from my shelf, which sat for eight years untouched, I devoured it like an irresistible drug. The spirits of the literature gods, dead and alive, have convened with Mitchell, and Mitchell has embraced the half-seen and the unseen, the lives and half-lives, and the mystical, boundless forces that turn a book into a world, a narrative into a universe. There's as much meaning outside the pages, and between words and passages, as there is in the explicit text--a potent cosmos of orbiting ideas. Mitchell has punched a hole in the sky with this book.

That “everyone is connected� is not an original theme of literature. It has been done as prosaically as Coelho or as lofty as Nabokov. Mitchell’s book of six nested stories is a furious and radiant masterpiece of formal structure and polyphonic elasticity, with the universal theme of connection—between generations, geographies, and centuries; people of vastly different ethnicities, cultures, even fabricated clones!

From the South Seas of the mid-19th century to the post-apocalyptic future on Hawaii’s islands, Mitchell explores the link between people as much as a thousand years apart in time and an incalculable amount of distance. Our undertakings, our destructions, our sorrow, our humanity, and our imperfections reach across the millennia. What communicates our exertions is our recording of things said and done. “Sunt lacrimae rerum,� writes the protagonist of the second story. The world is a world of tears, and the burdens of mortality touch the heart.

The six novellas that comprise the novel are written in ascending and descending order. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 5, 4, 3, 2, 1. There are great tonal shifts between stories, yet the parts equal the whole. As the narrator of the second novella says about his composition, Cloud Atlas Sextet, for six overlapping soloists (piano, clarinet, cello, flute, violin, and cello), they are “each in its own language of key, scale, and color.� There is much to say about music and the structure of this novel.

And, in each story is a character with a comet-shaped birthmark, inferring incarnations of the same soul. The first five titles end in “Half-Lives� (which makes sense because they are only half a story) and the narratives end in a cliffhanger, usually an interrupted sentence or moment. The descending order (or latter half of each novella) pick up the Half Lives where they left off in the ascending stories.

Story #1 is written Melville style, about a notary, Adam Ewing, on a ship in the South Seas, who is facing an ugly truth about people and their predatory nature. In story #2, Belgium, 1931, a scheming, disinherited opportunist, Robert Frorbisher, procures a job as an amanuensis to an ailing, syphilitic composer. His narrative is told via letters to his lover, Rufus Sixsmith, Waugh-style. He finds the interrupted journals of Ewing at the composer's house. In the third tale, set in mid-70's California, Luisa Rey, a journalist investigating nefarious activity at a nuclear power plant, is after some sensitive information from physicist Rufus Sixsmith. Luisa also acquires some of the letters that Sixsmith received from Frobisher. Her story has a distinctly Grisham/Chandler style.

Story 4 is about a British publisher, Timothy Cavendish, who has a manuscript of the Luisa Rey story, but ends up imprisoned in a nursing home, trying to escape. Very Amis-y in narrative and characters. In the fifth story, Mievillie-ish, set into Korea’s future, the country is ruled by a totalitarian government, or “Corpocracy;� they clone “fabricants� who function without human sentience. When one fabricant, somni 451, develops human consciousness, her life becomes endangered. This is an era where words like starbucks and disney aren’t proper nouns anymore. Somni is charmed by an archived disney from the 21st century called The Ghastly Ordeal of Timothy Cavendish.

The central story, #6, is whole, and the hardest to read (linguistically), where Somni is revered as a kind of enigmatic god-spirit. It takes place in a post-apocalyptic world far, far into the future, where humans have reversed to a primitive or Iron Age state. The language is a sort of Twain-esque Pidgin. It takes a while for the dialect and colloquy to make sense, but the effort is worth the reward.

Six places, six times, six vocabularies--in one choate, mind-twisting tale. It is a riddle, wrapped in a mystery, inside an enigma (as Churchill would say), and obscured by clouds (as Pink Floyd would sing). There's always treacherous forces coming to annihilate us, manmade and cowardly; there are also moral, stouthearted, everyday flawed heroes with fugitive wings and incorruptible souls. We endure, and we endure, and we endure. We touch one another. Occasionally, we punch a hole in the sky.
35 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Cloud Atlas.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Started Reading
July 23, 2012 – Finished Reading
July 26, 2012 – Shelved
July 31, 2012 –
page 509
100.0% "5 star review pending. Where are 10 stars when you really need them? "Fantastic on steroids to the 20th power.""

Comments Showing 1-26 of 26 (26 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Rock (new)

Rock Conner Thanks, Betsey, You're a jewel.


switterbug (Betsey) Aww...thank you, Rock!


B0nnie Wonderful review Betsey. I love Cloud Atlas. You let it sit for eight years, and I never heard of it until rather recently. Boo hoo! Have you seen the trailer? I'm so looking forward to the movie...but I know it will not be nearly as good as the book.


message 4: by switterbug (Betsey) (last edited Aug 17, 2012 06:19AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

switterbug (Betsey) Yeah, the trailer is exquisite. That was finally the provocation to dust off my copy! (No, movies are rarely as good as books, but I will see this one, for sure!)


BooksnFreshair (Poornima Apte) Fine review of a fine book!


switterbug (Betsey) Thanks, P! I realized that I accidentally wrote "Books are rarely as good as movies." Had to change that! Anyone who knows me would crack up at my typo.


s.penkevich Great review, love the Pink Floyd reference at the end too.


B0nnie switterbug (Betsey) wrote: "Yeah, the trailer is exquisite. That was finally the provocation to dust off my copy! (No, movies are rarely as good as books, but I will see this one, for sure!)"

Ha, yeah. But there are a few - Paths of Glory by Humphrey Cobb is a very good book - but the movie is pure genius. And of course there are some trashy books that I won't admit to...


switterbug (Betsey) LOL! Well, I DID love BRIDGES OF MADISON COUNTY movie, but I couldn't get past page 3 of the book without vomiting. ATONEMENT was a very good adaptation of book-to-movie. I like it when I am surprised by a good adaptation. Rare, though. I can't wait to see Keira Knightly in ANNA KARENINA!!! I so loved that book!


message 10: by Mark (new) - rated it 4 stars

Mark Another fan of the Bridges of Madison County movie...yeah! Great screenwriting job on that film. I have also had my copy of Cloud Atlas sitting on my shelf for about as long. In fact, it's an advance copy. I really should pull it off the shelf in anticipation of the movie.


Maggi I have never been that tempted, for whatever reason, to read this book, even though others I know have loved it. After reading this review I know I need to give it a try. "Punched a hole in the sky!" Nice!


message 12: by Lewis (new) - added it

Lewis Weinstein BETSEY ... Do you write? If not, perhaps you should consider it. Your review is exquisite ... LEW


switterbug (Betsey) Lew--I have been a closet writer on and off my whole life. But I am very lazy, and when the choice between reading and writing is at hand, I always choose reading! Thank you for your very kind comment.


message 14: by Judi (new) - added it

Judi Now I need to dust off my copy!


message 15: by Heather (new) - added it

Heather Simply beautiful review!!!


Your Excellency You've found one of my top 5 books - one of the few that I've read more than once. Such a tour de force, on so many levels. I still marvel at the intertwining of the 6 stories.
BTW, you got me on the use of the word 'choate.' I wasn't sure about that one; then I found this article on it in the NYT:

[sigh] I guess I'll allow that one...
8-)=


switterbug (Betsey) Wonderful article, Your Excellency. Actually, I had a feeling it wasn't a real word when I used it--I tend to be a bit of a word snob myself, but it just seemed so...right! I mean, in this case. I knew it wasn't in the dictionary, even! Well, if I think of a better word, one that FEELS right, I may change it. Some wrong words feel right. LOL


message 19: by Jan (new) - rated it 4 stars

Jan I loved this book unreservedly.


message 21: by [deleted user] (new)

I second Lewis's comment, Betsey. Not sure I'll ever read Cloud Atlas, but I happily immersed myself in your beautifully written review of it! (That first paragraph is fantastic!)


switterbug (Betsey) Thank you, Ashley!


message 23: by Ian (last edited Oct 28, 2013 03:13PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ian "Marvin" Graye Oh my god, Betsey, how did I miss this review? My sincerest apologies. You have such delicate and subtle insights into the charms of this book. I had to read the book twice to really appreciate it, but even then you've detected many things that I missed.

BTW, I also love the reference to "Obscured by Clouds".

This has sent me off investigating the film for which Pink Floyd provided the soundtrack, "La Vallée", the wiki synopsis of which is:

"Viviane (Ogier), the wife of the French consul in Melbourne, joins a group of explorers in search of a mysterious hidden valley in the bush of New Guinea, where she hopes to find the feathers of an extremely rare exotic bird. Along the way through the dense jungles of Papua New Guinea and on the peak of Mount Gilowe, she and the small group of explorers make contact with the Mapuga tribe, one of the most isolated groups of human beings on earth, who inspire them to explore their own humanity, unfettered by their own subjective ideas of "civilization". The search becomes a search for a paradise said to exist within a valley marked as "obscured by cloud" on the only map of the area available dated as surveyed in 1969."

I think I first saw the film in an all night cinethon in the mid-70's.

I can't think of an appropriate antonym for "obscured" to express the extent to which "Cloud Atlas" might be the opposite of "obscured by clouds" and about the discovery of humanity in all its diversity, but starting with ourselves.


switterbug (Betsey) Thank you, Ian! And that is just beautiful. I must look for "La Vallée" soon! Other than *unambiguously clear,* I don't know what what would be a good antonym, either. But that was a moving Wiki synopsis. And I never understood people who dislike Cloud Atlas, either, and complain that it is boring or unreadable! Is humanity unreadable?


message 25: by Ian (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ian "Marvin" Graye switterbug (Betsey) wrote: "I never understood people who dislike Cloud Atlas, either, and complain that it is boring or unreadable!"

Or worse...


Larissa Loved your review, and after having this book set aside for almost 1! year I have decided to read it. I don't know if it's a bad thing reading a review whilst reading the book. I guess I want to know how it ends. Thank you for the review :)


back to top