Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Morgan's Reviews > Ficciones

Ficciones by Jorge Luis Borges
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
1656680
's review

it was ok

Ok, I'd tried to read Labyrinths years ago and found it dry and dull. I thought that perhaps I just wasn't in the proper state of mind, or perhaps wasn't well read enough to get it. I'd also come off of a Calvino kick, so Borges felt boring. Fast forward to me thinking that I really should commit to Borges and give him a real chance.

I have to say that hard a hard time with this book. I only really like one story The Babylonian Lottery. The Circular Ruins, The Library of Babel, The Garden of Forking Paths and The Secret Miracle being alright and scant few others like An Examination of Herbert Quain and The End only fair.

Most of the time I feel like I'm stuck as some shitty academic after-party listening to the drunken rambling of a self-indulgent lit professor trying to make himself believe that he is the smartest guy in the room. I get the references, but most of this just isn't that interesting. It all comes across as clinical, with a tone of little Jack Horner self satisfaction staring at his thumb saying "What a good boy am I."

Let me write you a Borges story:

I could write a longer story dear reader, but instead I will keep to laconic prose. I met Arkadiusz Juhász when he threw a crust of bread at my head and laughed in that way that he does. At the time, I was simultaneously reading De Natura Deorum, Hasidic Kabbalah, and Discours de Métaphysique. [Fill page one with nonsense that isn't all that important to the story, feels otherworldly, and serves only to offset and confuse the reader]. At dinner Arkadiusz Juhász described the labyrinth in his mind. He had an experience the likes of which you will never have. Jews are mysterious. He solved a puzzle that he created for himself and figured out that he is Shakespeare and everyone wrote Henry V for it has always existed. There is a long history of naming a thing, but in reality everything is the same. Arkadiusz Juhász felt disjointed from the world and wandered and time passed with little result. Perhaps he was in a sanitarium with black circling walls. Arkadiusz Juhász has written a collection of essays to describe the effect of his travels. Here is the list: Darkest Jungles 1898; The Diminishing Return 1900; Checkers and the Vanishing Point 1904; The Breadbox 1904; The Unhappy Happenstance 1906 (unfinished); Ur Nuts 1907; Life in a Ziggurat 1909 (never actually written); The Aching Feather 1910; Critical Analysis of Being Spanish 1912 (writen in Portugese and German). [Describe some of these essays]. Arkadiusz Juhász confessed to me that he was really a war criminal. But, I later found out that he may not have been. Arkadiusz Juhász died of a brain hemorrhage in 1951.
120 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Ficciones.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

July 28, 2012 – Started Reading
July 28, 2012 – Shelved
August 3, 2012 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-26 of 26 (26 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Scott (new)

Scott Firestone Exxxxcellent....


Luis Fernando There's a special place in hell for people like you.


Morgan I hope so.


message 4: by Jack (new)

Jack This is my favorite review of any product/service that I have ever read.


message 5: by John (new)

John I hope your special place in Hell is next to mine.


Terry Fantastic. Hope you got an advance


Karla Angélica I don't think Borges ever wrote any nonsense. He knew what he was doing. The fact that you don't understand him should't be material for you to minimize his great contribution to Literature. Borges is just not for you.


Negri I have to admit I smiled at your parody, but then I felt a bit sad. If this is all you ever got out of Borges, it's a sad thing to be you. Oh well...


Luis Best review I've read so far. So spot on.


William What an awful life it is to live when one cannot appreciate J. Louie Borges. I fell for you mate, and in your memory I will love Ficciones twice as much.
And what is it with reviewers on Good Reads and saying that the writer is "trying to make himself believe that he is the smartest guy in the room" or some similar attack on the writer's self-expression and intentions?
Are people on this website incapable of not enjoying something without having to find someone to blame or insult over it? Can you not like a writer without assuming that he's pretentious? I see this kind of thing every where on this website, and sometimes I even see people insult the those who LIKED the book that the insulter didn't like, which is even more perplexing.
Is it narcissism?


message 11: by PJ (new) - added it

PJ Great review


message 12: by Bill (new)

Bill Shubert I've got to agree. I tried to read Borges also, and while there were cool ideas, the prose around them was so tedious that in the end I would usually give up before finishing any one story. When I made myself go through to the end, it never felt worthwhile.


message 13: by Sean (new) - rated it 2 stars

Sean I've read instruction manuals for vacuums that were less clinical than Borges.


Aylinn Did you ever considered that the topics you deem boring may be of interest to others and no one is obliged to write books just on topics that you find interesting, because you are not the center of the world?


Morgan Ha! Last I checked the whole point of a review is to talk about how something made the reviewer feel. Dismissing being the subject of the experience is totally unrealistic. Unless I am listing catalog numbers and credits, talking about the book from my point of view is obviously going to end up being subjective. Borges would have understood.


Aylinn Yeah, and your review tells me nothing beyond that. 'I find it boring, pretentious and clinical' you provide almost no arguments to back it up, so readers end up learning more about you than the book. The only one argument you make is that things are unnecessarily confusing, but you complain that a guy who is known to have loved the methapohr of labirynth (a thing which by definition is something complicated, confusing, has dead ends, etc.) does not make things straightforward, really? To me it seems like you missed the point.


Morgan I get the point, I just don’t enjoy the delivery. Give me Calvino any day.


Boethia As much as I loved Borges' writing and his stories overall, and I definitely think there's so much more to his work than an intellectual onanism and lengthy fictional bibliographies, your Borges-inspired story is spot on. I'm kind of surprised so many people seem to be genuinely offended. Come on, people. No one is untouchable. Borges claimed Jesus and Judas might be the same person, I think he could handle a good parody.


Roselin Estephanía Finally! Oh man, I'm like three stories away from finishing this book and to me, reading it, feels like a lottery: starting every story hoping to enjoy it. So far I've liked three, the others were so... annoying. I mean there are lots of interesting paragraphs here and there, but for the most part, at the end, I just think "what for?". I'll probably try reading another book from him in the future, to see is it's this one I don't like, or if it's overall everything he writes.

I'm not saying he's a bad writer, or that this is a bad book, and I get feeling it a little personal when someone dislikes something you really like, but... saying that it's "sad" that people like us don't "get it" it's so patronizing, why so salty? There are so many books and so many authors to enjoy. No, my world is not over just because Ficciones was a pain in the ass to read.


message 20: by Greg (new) - rated it 2 stars

Greg But what happened to the central element of your story, the crust?


UpdatedSpring Your story at the end is terrifyingly accurate.


Stefan Bendik So I’m not alone. I thought I was missing something but obviously this is not for everybody.


message 23: by Ciro (new) - added it

Ciro I love the book but this review is priceless.


Carlos Gandiaga Props to you. Great review, I also feel this way. Love the haters comments. Maybe I'll try to reread one day, but what a pain it's been this time.


Melina Ramirez So hilarious and accurate


message 26: by Mark (new) - rated it 1 star

Mark Let’s keep it real. It was like reading a scientific journal composed a bloviating professor who hasn’t been laid in 10 years. I DNF’d. I gave it plenty of chances. It’s one of those books where people think they’re oh so intelligent for finishing. They didn’t understand 85% of it. Fact not Ficciones.


back to top