Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Teresa's Reviews > Pew

Pew by Catherine Lacey
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
541416
's review

really liked it

Throughout this work, the titular character chooses not to speak, for the most part, and I agree with that decision: what is there to say to what’s said to them. Silence is inimical to many people and the people of the town, not surprisingly, fill the void with their worries, their hopes, their prejudices, and their own stories. In having a main character not speak, there’s the danger of making that character flat, but Pew’s thoughts are rich and worthy of contemplation.

I didn’t fully appreciate this novel until, at Cecily’s recommendation, I read Ursula Le Guin’s “The Ones Who Walk Away From Omelas,� which I did immediately after finishing Pew. (The story’s only four pages long and can be found online.) Not only is the name of the neighboring county of the novel an anagram of Omelas, the story’s concluding paragraph is used as an epigraph for Pew. The novel holds at least three references (one, a direct quote spoken by a minor character) taken straight from the story. I now understand Pew’s thoughts about and connection to the “fields� (as in grass), something I’d found perplexing.

I then wondered if the novel stands on its own without one knowing the Le Guin story, but that’s a different debate, I suppose. Any lack of previous comprehension is my own failing and perhaps you’ll understand it better than I did without reading the Le Guin afterward. It was rewarding to do so, though, and bumped my satisfaction up a star. Now that I have that fuller understanding, I won’t explain it here: it’s best you come to it on your own. Thank you, Cecily. And thank you to my dear friend Cathrine, who gifted me this: I likely wouldn't have read it otherwise.
31 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Pew.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Started Reading
January 23, 2021 – Finished Reading
January 24, 2021 – Shelved

Comments Showing 1-4 of 4 (4 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

E.J. Aha. I'm going to read The Ones Who Walk Away From Omelas. Without knowing anything about the Ursula Le Guin story, I read Pew and thought it was excellent. Very curious to see how the additional insight will influence my appreciation. Thanks for the recommendation.


Cecily I'm so glad you enjoyed this little enigma. As you point out, having a main character who doesn't speak but who isn't flat it quite an achievement.

To what extent this story stands on its own if one doesn't follow up with Omelas is an interesting question and one I guess we'll never know for ourselves. (I already knew it, and reread it after reading this.)


Teresa E.J. wrote: "Without knowing anything about the Ursula Le Guin story, I read Pew and thought it was excellent. Very curious to see how the additional i..."

Good to know, E.J. I know there are plenty like you. :)


Teresa Cecily wrote: "To what extent this story stands on its own if one doesn't follow up with Omelas is an interesting question and one I guess we'll never know for ourselves. (I already knew it, and reread it after reading this.)."

For me, upon finishing Pew, I felt a 'lack.' After reading 'Omelas', I felt that lack filled. If I'd taken even more time to reflect without reading the Le Guin, I might've have filled that hole anyway, but that, as you say, I'll never know.


back to top