ŷ

Barbara's Reviews > One Hundred Years of Solitude

One Hundred Years of Solitude by Gabriel García Márquez
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
27456036
's review

liked it

Can you appreciate a book and dislike it at the same time? This book reminded me of Lincoln at the Bardo, although certainly not in content. Both are written by obviously brilliant writers. Both are inventive, creative. Both stretch the conventional boundaries of the novel (something only great writers try, and something I appreciate in any art form). Both are amazing, and yet, I didn't love either book. Sometimes originality works and sometimes it doesn't, at least for some.

I understood what Marquez was saying: war is senseless, events, like names, repeat throughout history, families are complicated, political parties are all guilty of the same things, the past often blends with the present, progress often has unwanted results, capitalism can be corrupt and on and on. These are all important aspects in the history of Colombia during the 100 year period 1820-1920. I also think the author intentionally wanted the characters to be blurry, for after all, weren't they the same characters through the generations? Only the matriarch was a player with depth. I need to feel something for characters, not necessarily compassion or love, just something.

100 Years of Solitude might have been palatable if I had known the history of Colombia during that time period. But even so, it was repetitious, yawn producing. I often groaned as I picked it back up. It was like being in a fevered dream, bizarre events with moments of clarity.

Am I glad I read it? Yes. Did I enjoy parts, especially the humorous parts? Yes. I'm actually fonder of it the farther I get away from the drudgery of reading it. Did I enjoy the experience? No. I am just thankful Marquez didn't write 200 Years of Solitude!
100 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read One Hundred Years of Solitude.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

February 10, 2021 – Started Reading
February 10, 2021 – Shelved
February 21, 2021 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-34 of 34 (34 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by [deleted user] (new)

What a great opening question my friend! I loved your review, Barbara ;o)


Richard (on hiatus) I think it’s very possible to admire a novel but not really enjoy it. I’ve had this on my kindle for ages and it stares at me accusingly from time to time. I will read it one day but I’m guessing my reaction will be the same as yours :)


Lucy Great review Barbara! I had begun to read “Love in a time of cholera� by the same author and could not finish it- maybe I’ll try this one instead :)


Jennifer Welsh Yes! And, I had a similar experience to you on this one. Great review!


Beata Fine review, Barbara :)) I have a sentiment for this novel and I'm glad you liked it a little :))


Barbara J.K. wrote: "What a great opening question my friend! I loved your review, Barbara ;o)"
Thanks so much J.K. I have had that experience with other books not mentioned in this review. You can't love them all!


Barbara Richard wrote: "I think it’s very possible to admire a novel but not really enjoy it. I’ve had this on my kindle for ages and it stares at me accusingly from time to time. I will read it one day but I’m guessing m..."
I hope I haven't discouraged you from reading the book. I am apparently in the minority. It is always an uncomfortable feeling to not love a highly acclaimed book. Thanks for your comment, Richard.


Barbara Lucy wrote: "Great review Barbara! I had begun to read “Love in a time of cholera� by the same author and could not finish it- maybe I’ll try this one instead :)"

Thanks so much, Lucy. I read Love in the Time years ago and remember nothing about it. If you do read 100 Years, I would suggest reading about that time period in Colombia. I'm glad I didn't totally discourage you.


Barbara Jennifer wrote: "Yes! And, I had a similar experience to you on this one. Great review!"

Thanks for commenting, Jennifer. It is always comforting to know others have had the same reading experience. No one in my book club loved it.


Barbara Beata wrote: "Fine review, Barbara :)) I have a sentiment for this novel and I'm glad you liked it a little :))"

Perhaps I'll reread it someday and have a more positive experience. You and I usually have similar reactions to our reads, not that there is anything wrong with a difference of opinion among friends. Thank you for your comment, Beata.


Matthew Ted A fair and honest review of my favourite book of all time, Barbara. Even I can admit that 200 Years of Solitude would have been overkill.


Barbara Matthew wrote: "A fair and honest review of my favourite book of all time, Barbara. Even I can admit that 200 Years of Solitude would have been overkill."

Thanks so much for your comment, Matthew.


message 13: by Candi (new) - added it

Candi Your last sentence made me smile, Barbara. I've been hesitant to try Marquez. I think I'm afraid something will go over my head! One of these days I'm just going to have to take the plunge though. Marvelous review!


Left Coast Justin Nice ending line on your review. I've never read this, and it doesn't sound like I need to rush right out and correct that.


Barbara Candi wrote: "Your last sentence made me smile, Barbara. I've been hesitant to try Marquez. I think I'm afraid something will go over my head! One of these days I'm just going to have to take the plunge though. ..."

I hope you enjoy it if you do get to it. Thanks for your kind words, Candi.


Barbara Left Coast Justin wrote: "Nice ending line on your review. I've never read this, and it doesn't sound like I need to rush right out and correct that."

No Justin, no need to get to this one, but you may enjoy it more than I did. I appreciate your comment.


message 17: by Julie (new)

Julie Terrific review, Barbara! Sorry you didn't enjoy it more! 💖


Susan Chapek Perfect review, esp the first sentence.


Barbara Julie wrote: "Terrific review, Barbara! Sorry you didn't enjoy it more! 💖"

Thanks, Julie. I wanted to like it more, but it just didn't work for me.


Barbara Susan wrote: "Perfect review, esp the first sentence."

Thanks so much, Susan. I am finding additional books that are examples of my first sentence.


Linda Hart Honest review. I too am glad it wasn't 200 years....


Debbie W. Your final paragraph of your review is hilarious! I appreciate that you are more generous with your stars than I was!


Barbara Linda wrote: "Honest review. I too am glad it wasn't 200 years...."

Thanks for commenting, Linda. There is a certain guilt or embarrassment in not being awed by such an award winning book. I do tend to take professional reviews with a grain of salt.


Barbara Debbie wrote: "Your final paragraph of your review is hilarious! I appreciate that you are more generous with your stars than I was!"

I'm glad you had a chuckle, Debbie. There were parts of the book I would have rated only 1 star, but there were parts that were 4 - my 3 rating was an average.


Kimber Silver Your last line gave me a giggle, Barbara!
I'm sorry to read that you didn't enjoy this book. Your review is marvelous! Thank you for sharing. :-)


Barbara Kimber wrote: "Your last line gave me a giggle, Barbara!
I'm sorry to read that you didn't enjoy this book. Your review is marvelous! Thank you for sharing. :-)"


I am glad I was able to give you a chuckle, Kimber. Thanks so much for your kind words. I always enjoy hearing from you.


message 27: by Lisa (new)

Lisa It's been some time since I read this book and I remember pushing myself to finish it. I so appreciate the first paragraph of your review. And the reminder that books speak to us all differently.


Barbara Lisa wrote: "It's been some time since I read this book and I remember pushing myself to finish it. I so appreciate the first paragraph of your review. And the reminder that books speak to us all differently."

Thanks so much for commenting, Lisa.


Lesle Wonderful insight on this one Barbara!
I love your last quote:

"I am just thankful Marquez didn't write 200 Years of Solitude!"


Barbara Lesle wrote: "Wonderful insight on this one Barbara!
I love your last quote:

"I am just thankful Marquez didn't write 200 Years of Solitude!""


Thanks so much, Lesle. I am sorry it took me so long to see your much appreciated comment.


Kevin Ansbro I chuckled loudly at your brilliantly funny closing line, Barbara! 😂

I also appreciated your honest, even-handed review. Great job!


message 32: by Mark (new)

Mark For comparative purposes try Isabel Allende’s House of Spirits - I enjoyed it more.


Barbara Kevin wrote: "I chuckled loudly at your brilliantly funny closing line, Barbara! 😂

I also appreciated your honest, even-handed review. Great job!"


I really wanted to love it, but I had to admit it wasn't a favorite. I'm happy to know my review gave you a chuckle, Kevin. Thanks for stopping by.


Barbara Mark wrote: "For comparative purposes try Isabel Allende’s House of Spirits - I enjoyed it more."

I do love Allende. House of Spirits has been on my list. Thanks for the recommendation, Mark.


back to top