Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Manny's Reviews > Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy

Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy by John Le Carré
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
1713956
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: strongly-recommended
Read 3 times. Last read January 1, 1984.

I'm one of many people who think that Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy is the greatest espionage novel of all time. Let's take the obvious things first. Unlike most examples of this genre, it's extremely well-written. Also, having worked in espionage himself, le Carré is able to get the atmosphere right. It feels 100% authentic, and you see that spying is like most other jobs. The greater part of it is routine and office intrigues, though every now and then something unexpected and dramatic happens.

So, even if there were nothing more to it, I'd still say that this book was very good. What makes it great is that the author isn't content with giving you a realistic account of what it's like to be a spy. He's gone much further than that, and written a book that's not just about espionage, which most people never come into contact with, but about betrayal, which we see all the time.

The thing about betrayal is that you're generally aware that it's happening before you know how, or why, or who. Things used to be good, and now they're not, and you know that even if you do figure out what's happened you'll never be able to put it right. At best, you'll be able to cut your losses, and move on. In TTSS, the main character, George Smiley, is being betrayed in two different ways. First, it's gradually become clear that there is a mole in his department. It can only be someone at the very highest level. One of his most trusted colleagues, someone he has worked with for years, and shared things with, and treated as a friend, is actually working for the Russians. They have it narrowed down to four people. He has to find out which one it is, and do what's necessary. And, at the same time, he's also realized that his wife is sleeping around. He can't really prove anything, and they never talk about it. But he knows that too.

I can imagine any number of clumsy, over-obvious ways to link up these threads. Le Carré does it with a very light touch. You see these two things happening, and every now and then there is an echo of correspondence. He wants you to be a spy too, and put together the little bits of evidence until you reach a conclusion. It's a book that completely transcends the genre, and shows how a writer who has enough talent can achieve stunning results in any medium. Strongly recommended to anyone who's ever been betrayed, or themselves betrayed a person they're close to. Which, unfortunately, is most of us.
378 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
Finished Reading
Started Reading
January 1, 1984 – Finished Reading
November 26, 2008 – Shelved
December 5, 2008 – Shelved as: strongly-recommended

Comments Showing 1-31 of 31 (31 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Manny Thank you!

I also had to read it two or three times. And I agree, I'm glad I don't work in espionage!


message 2: by Robert (last edited May 17, 2009 08:52AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Robert ***MILD SPOILER ALERT***

This is a book in which almost nothing happens. There's a theft and a murder and very few other dramatic incidents - the rest is Smiley walking/driving about and conversing with various people - mainly listening. It would make a fantastic stage play. It really should be boring rubbish.

Somehow it is instead a tense thriller about people who are paranoid but often not paranoid enough, living isolated, fearful lives and suffering for it, yet trying to serve their country; there can't be any other motivation since the money is no compensation and the job never lets you go.

Really, who'd be a spook or a spy?


Manny Really, who'd be a spook or a spy?

In one of the later Anthony Powell books, a character asks why you'd want to be a double agent. From memory, the answer was "It's like the thrill of spitting on someone from a great height".



Robert I think I'll stick to science, then!


Manny Ah well, in science you can always review papers. If you feel the urge to spit safely.



Robert Can't say I do, really.


Robert A friend of mine once advised me that "Reviewers aren't really anonymous." She also suggested, "Don't piss anyone off," as an important rule to abide by if you are a scientist.


message 8: by Eric_W (new)

Eric_W Terrific review, Many. You nailed it.


message 9: by Bram (new)

Bram Awesome review Manny. I don't think I've ever read an espionage novel, so I might have to make this my first.


Manny Thanks guys! If you're only going to read one espionage novel, make it this one. And if you like it, you might want also want to read the third volume in the trilogy, Smiley's People .

The second volume isn't nearly as good as the first and third (I wonder why this is so commonly the case?), and you can safely skip it.


Robert Darn, the second one is already on my shelf, waiting for me to read it!


message 12: by Lisa (new) - added it

Lisa Vegan Espionage is definitely not my genre but you made this one sound enticing Manny.


Manny It's not my genre either, but most of these rules have exceptions...


Robert This is not typical of the genre, really; it's not a conventional thriller based on pace and incident. This could be why people enjoy it without liking most other spy novels.


message 15: by Lisa (new) - added it

Lisa Vegan It's not my genre either, but most of these rules have exceptions...

Very true. Plus, I have very eclectic taste in books anyway.


Moira This book is fantastic. It and Heart of the Matter might be my two favourite spy novels.


Manny I saw the new one and thought it was okay. I have heard that the original BBC series is better...


message 18: by W (new) - rated it 1 star

W A I found it poorly written. Example: he would throw out a name but not say who it was for several paragraphs. There were few,if any, memorable scenes or characters. I read Dickens� Bleak House at same time. No comparison! TTSS is not the kind of book that I see any merit to. BOORING!!!


Manny W wrote: "There were few,if any, memorable scenes or characters."

Ah come on. What about (view spoiler)? Or (view spoiler)?

I read Dickens� Bleak House at same time. No comparison!

You're just trying to tease some academic into writing "Jarndyce and Jarndyce and Cambridge Circus: Parallel Futilities", aren't you?


message 20: by [deleted user] (new)

Manny wrote; "You're just trying to tease some academic into writing "Jarndyce and Jarndyce and Cambridge Circus: Parallel Futilities", aren't you?"

Personally, I'd settle for another "Jarndyce Vs. Jarndyce" alone.


Left Coast Justin Excellent review sir! I think you really nailed the appeal of this book and others by Le Carre.


Manny Thank you Justin!


Marta Great review. I was trying to put my finger on the essence of the book, and I felt it, but I did not see the right word until I read your review.

Betrayal. Yes, that’s what it’s all about. Thanks.


message 24: by SLB (new) - rated it 4 stars

SLB Lovely review.


message 25: by John (new) - rated it 5 stars

John Manny, so nice to run across you all this time later. Wonderful review. So many others have wonderful reviews of this book and series. The middle book in the series? Would it be The Honorable Schoolboy? I liked it even more than TTSS. More action. Reading along and all of a sudden one it's up to there eyeballs in exploding petroleum or living in a boot over the gunwales. He's such a believable author.


Vineet Jain Manny, thanks for giving it a good review. It is because of your review I read the book. Actually, I listened the audio book on audible which is generally not how I consume my books. But, oh damn, was it good? You bet. I’ve become fan of smiley; and would definitely read smiley’s people next.
Thanks again!
Cheers!


Manny Thank you Vineet, that's really nice to hear!


Spike nice review. Yes, I know of betrayal all too well....you captured it here!


Sergio What a great review Sir. Solid, informed and substantiated . Thank you


message 30: by [deleted user] (new)

That "every now and then something dramatic happens" can be only once in decades, or never at all in a whole career -- most likely.


Robert Walker I've just re-read TTSS for the third or fourth time. There is always something new, inferred or lightly mentioned by Le Carre which carries more weight than first realised.
Of course this sadly missed novelist writes of spies and many people think of him just in that regard. But for me he chronicles the human condition and makes us face the fears most of us hold - betrayal, distrust, deceit, lies, the multiple personalities within us all.
The layers of betrayal recounted in this really great novel are extraordinary - Haydon and Ann, Haydon and Prideaux, Haydon and...
It also in a way catalogues the decline of Britain during the Cold War period as did Philby's treachery. Betrayal amongst a class you would have thought beyond such things.
I always thought that was best captured in the all seeing but unreadable face of Smiley as portrayed in the unrivalled BBC drama of the late 1970s.


back to top