Gabrielle's Reviews > Roadside Picnic
Roadside Picnic
by
by

Gabrielle's review
bookshelves: sci-fi, russian-soviet, sf-masterworks, speculative-fiction, own-a-copy, read-in-2021, reviewed
Aug 12, 2021
bookshelves: sci-fi, russian-soviet, sf-masterworks, speculative-fiction, own-a-copy, read-in-2021, reviewed
4 and a half stars for my first, but certainly not my last, foray into Soviet science fiction, and the work of the Strugatsky brothers!
Thirty years before the beginning of this story, aliens landed on six different locations of our little planet, but they didn’t stay long. The areas where they touched down, now knowns as Zones, are both fascinating and dangerous: unexplained phenomenon make it very hazardous for humans to go to, but the artifacts the aliens left behind make it inevitable that a few will try to get their grubby hands on it, even if they have no idea what the artifacts do. As one might expect, there is official scientific research done on those objects, but also a flourishing black market � which is where Red comes on. Red works at one of the facilities dedicated to the story of a particular Zone, located in what I believe to be Canada, though it is never located with any precision. He goes in and out of the Zone, brings back artefacts for scientists to play with, but also some that end up sold to some sinister individuals, who’s ultimate agenda we are not privy to. Red’s work is dangerous in so many ways: the Zone’s terrain is a constantly shifting and hallucinatory landscape, strange lights appear and vanish, and despite careful decontamination, the effects of being exposed to whatever is in there changes him, affects and transforms his child� After getting caught one final time, he decides to give up this treacherous work, but it’s not that easy to walk away.
I adore the idea that we, as a civilization, we’re just not interesting enough for aliens to hang about any longer than it took them to empty out their trash and bounce. It’s a nice raspberry blown in the face of humans� self-importance � and tendency to litter. It also paints a not-too-shiny portrait of another nasty human tendency: to try and turn every piece of garbage we can get our hands on into something we can sell, no matter how dangerous that might be, both for us and for the person who ends up with the aforementioned garbage. I also love when science-fiction mentions aliens but then they are not really an active part of the story!
Even without trying to read any sub-text from this novel, it remains an absolutely amazing, dark and weird piece of science-fiction history that holds up as an excellent and very readable novel to this day. There are strong parallels to be drawn with Jeff VanderMeer’s “Southern Reach� trilogy (/review/show...), and I wonder if he is a fan of the Strugatsky brothers after reading this � because just like his infamous trilogy, this is a novel that lends itself to removing and examining its layers. My edition includes an afterword by Boris Strugastky, describing the rather convoluted process they had to go through to see this book published (committees, censors, boards, etc�): this makes it hard not to read into the griminess of the world of “Roadside Picnic� as a commentary on a dull and bleak world, where one worked very hard for ultimately very little. The transformation of the children by whatever the parents are exposed to in the Zone also feels like a strange metaphor about how an unfamiliar world can turn even the people closest to you into something you don’t quite recognize. I also couldn’t help but smile at the idea that in the mind of the scientists working at the Institute, the suits running the whole thing have no idea what they are doing and aren’t doing any work of value� I know Red is not really a sympathetic character: by his own description, he is kind of a bottom-feeder, but I saw someone who’s options for survival are very limited by the time and place where he happens to be. In order to live a life that feels decent and fulfilling, he has no choice but to go around the system � but will get crushed by whichever path he chooses.
Thank you Nataliya, for encouraging me to bump this one up on top of the reading pile! It exceeded my expectations in every way, and I look forward to reading more by the Strugatskys!
Thirty years before the beginning of this story, aliens landed on six different locations of our little planet, but they didn’t stay long. The areas where they touched down, now knowns as Zones, are both fascinating and dangerous: unexplained phenomenon make it very hazardous for humans to go to, but the artifacts the aliens left behind make it inevitable that a few will try to get their grubby hands on it, even if they have no idea what the artifacts do. As one might expect, there is official scientific research done on those objects, but also a flourishing black market � which is where Red comes on. Red works at one of the facilities dedicated to the story of a particular Zone, located in what I believe to be Canada, though it is never located with any precision. He goes in and out of the Zone, brings back artefacts for scientists to play with, but also some that end up sold to some sinister individuals, who’s ultimate agenda we are not privy to. Red’s work is dangerous in so many ways: the Zone’s terrain is a constantly shifting and hallucinatory landscape, strange lights appear and vanish, and despite careful decontamination, the effects of being exposed to whatever is in there changes him, affects and transforms his child� After getting caught one final time, he decides to give up this treacherous work, but it’s not that easy to walk away.
I adore the idea that we, as a civilization, we’re just not interesting enough for aliens to hang about any longer than it took them to empty out their trash and bounce. It’s a nice raspberry blown in the face of humans� self-importance � and tendency to litter. It also paints a not-too-shiny portrait of another nasty human tendency: to try and turn every piece of garbage we can get our hands on into something we can sell, no matter how dangerous that might be, both for us and for the person who ends up with the aforementioned garbage. I also love when science-fiction mentions aliens but then they are not really an active part of the story!
Even without trying to read any sub-text from this novel, it remains an absolutely amazing, dark and weird piece of science-fiction history that holds up as an excellent and very readable novel to this day. There are strong parallels to be drawn with Jeff VanderMeer’s “Southern Reach� trilogy (/review/show...), and I wonder if he is a fan of the Strugatsky brothers after reading this � because just like his infamous trilogy, this is a novel that lends itself to removing and examining its layers. My edition includes an afterword by Boris Strugastky, describing the rather convoluted process they had to go through to see this book published (committees, censors, boards, etc�): this makes it hard not to read into the griminess of the world of “Roadside Picnic� as a commentary on a dull and bleak world, where one worked very hard for ultimately very little. The transformation of the children by whatever the parents are exposed to in the Zone also feels like a strange metaphor about how an unfamiliar world can turn even the people closest to you into something you don’t quite recognize. I also couldn’t help but smile at the idea that in the mind of the scientists working at the Institute, the suits running the whole thing have no idea what they are doing and aren’t doing any work of value� I know Red is not really a sympathetic character: by his own description, he is kind of a bottom-feeder, but I saw someone who’s options for survival are very limited by the time and place where he happens to be. In order to live a life that feels decent and fulfilling, he has no choice but to go around the system � but will get crushed by whichever path he chooses.
Thank you Nataliya, for encouraging me to bump this one up on top of the reading pile! It exceeded my expectations in every way, and I look forward to reading more by the Strugatskys!
Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read
Roadside Picnic.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
March 7, 2021
– Shelved
March 7, 2021
– Shelved as:
to-read
March 7, 2021
– Shelved as:
sci-fi
March 7, 2021
– Shelved as:
russian-soviet
March 7, 2021
– Shelved as:
speculative-fiction
March 7, 2021
– Shelved as:
sf-masterworks
August 10, 2021
–
Started Reading
August 10, 2021
– Shelved as:
own-a-copy
August 10, 2021
– Shelved as:
read-in-2021
August 11, 2021
–
Finished Reading
August 12, 2021
– Shelved as:
reviewed
Comments Showing 1-4 of 4 (4 new)
date
newest »


Likewise, I thought that Iain M. Banks' novel "Inversions", seemed a lot like the Strugatsky Br..."
Thank you, Ian! I have two more Strugatsky brothers books on my shelf, but not that one... though I am sure I'll get to it eventually!
A little friendly advice: if you have a choice between different translations of brothers' works, go for Olena Bormashenko. They seems to be the best.

Thanks, Evgeny! My edition of "Roadside Picnic" was a Bormashenko translation, I think the other books of theirs I have are translated by Andrew Bromfield.
Likewise, I thought that Iain M. Banks' novel "Inversions", seemed a lot like the Strugatsky Bros' "Hard to be a God".