ŷ

Cheryl's Reviews > Slouching Towards Bethlehem

Slouching Towards Bethlehem by Joan Didion
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
11255849
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: literary-essays, non-fiction, mesmerizing

"To have that sense of one's intrinsic worth which constitutes self-respect is potentially to have everything: the ability to discriminate, to love and to remain indifferent. To lack it is to be locked within oneself, paradoxically incapable of either love or indifference."

Somehow, I usually read Didion on a blue night, when it's so bright outside that I open my curtains to search for the moon; instead, what greets me is a pale hue of blue sky. When I read Blue Nights, I had a similar experience. These are the kind of nights that reminds a reader of what she is, of what she is not: "We flatter ourselves by thinking this compulsion to please others an attractive trait: a gist for imaginative empathy, evidence of our willingness to give." Oh how I would love to teach Didion's "On Self-Respect," if only to garner the provocative perspective of a generation not yet born when she experienced and wrote this collection.

People debate the essay form often; some think it is simply nonfiction, some are not even sure about the distinction between nonfiction, narrative nonfiction, memoir, and the personal essay. The art of nonfiction is intrinsically disconcerting and perhaps intentional in its derived eclecticism. Still, it is beautiful. Thank goodness we have modern essayists like Leslie Jamison to remind us of the form, an essayist who in my opinion, resembles Didion in style and concept. Any debate of the essay as an art form, should be silenced by Didion's slouching. Why did I take so long to read this, I asked myself as I palmed my forehead, for I drooled through each page, not even noticing when it was time to clear my desk for office hours with students.

These essays illuminate the America of the 1960s that will never exist again, and yet it is the America of today - the odd juxtaposition confuses, I know. Didion has managed to illustrate a landscape of hurt and pain, of music and money, of politics, drugs, rehabilitation, and gain. This is New York, this is California, this is a slouch towards Bethlehem. I was moved by her memoirs Blue Nights and The Year of Magical Thinking; however, with this book, I was inspired by not only the stories and the essay form, but also by the art of the craft of narrative nonfiction in some of her pieces, this art that places a writer within the center of observation, and yet silences her persona.
The impulse to write things down is a peculiarly compulsive one, inexplicable to those who do not share it, useful only accidentally, only secondarily, in the way that any compulsion tries to justify itself.

Didion was a compulsive notetaker and eavesdropper. Because of this, we get stories about: the Los Angeles Santa Ana, a party in Beverly Hills, a story of Sacramento, a "hallucinatory" view of New York, a riff "on morality," a behind-the-scenes look at a Center for the Study of Democratic Institutions, an intense look at acid, alcohol, promiscuity, and all of the hurt that evolves with flashing. Some things we see, we know we'll never see again.

I loved reading "Goodbye to All That," Didion's meditation on New York City, a place she loved and loathed, the city wherein she lost herself. Yet my favorite essay was "Where the Kissing Never Stops," an essay which allowed me to view myself, to think about those intrinsic values placed aside for work; after all, isn't this the beauty of the personal essay, that it teaches us something about ourselves? I found oneness with Joan Beaz, the artist, humanitarian, renegade, and recluse; the woman whose life Didion explores in this piece. Perhaps this is one of those essay collections that leaves each of us with something of ourselves:
The roles assigned to her are various, but variations on a single theme. She is the Madonna of the disaffected. She is the pawn of the protest movement. She is the unhappy analysand. She is the singer who would not train her voice, the rebel who drives the Jaguar too fast, the Rima who hides with the birds and the deer. Above all, she is the girl who 'feels' things, who has hung on to the freshness and pain of adolescence, the girl ever wounded, ever young.
93 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Slouching Towards Bethlehem.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

August 9, 2012 – Shelved
January 19, 2016 – Started Reading
January 19, 2016 –
page 37
14.45% "Here is where the hot wind blows and the old ways do not seem relevant, where the divorce rate is double the national average and where one person in every thirty-eight lives in a trailer. Here is the last stop for all those who come from somewhere else, for all those who drifted away from the cold and the past and the old ways."
January 22, 2016 –
page 150
58.59% ""I think we are well advised to keep on nodding terms with the people we used to be, whether we find them attractive company or not. Otherwise they turn up unannounced and surprise us, come hammering on the mind's door at 4 a.m. of a bad night and demand to know who deserted them, who betrayed them, who is going to make amends.""
January 23, 2016 –
page 256
100.0% "That the ethic of conscience is intrinsically insidious seems scarcely a revelatory point, but it is one raised with increasing infrequency; even those who do raise it tend to segue with troubling readiness into the quite contradictory position that the ethic of conscience is dangerous when it is 'wrong,' and admirable when it is 'right.'"
January 24, 2016 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-32 of 32 (32 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Julie A stunning review, Cheryl. I was just thinking today that I haven't "seen" you in such a long while. And then here you are, with your beautiful phrases. Thank you.


message 2: by Joe (new) - rated it 2 stars

Joe I loved Plays It as It Lays and would venture into Didion's essays if I thought I could add anything more eloquent than you have, Cheryl. I enjoy how you summarized the stops in her journey succinctly and worked in your personal experiences to your review.


Cheryl Julie wrote: "A stunning review, Cheryl. I was just thinking today that I haven't "seen" you in such a long while. And then here you are, with your beautiful phrases. Thank you."

Hi Julie! Thanks for reading and leaving such an uplifting comment. I've missed your beautiful, invigorating reviews! I'm thinking the new GR feed-issue has something to do with it, but I'm glad you stopped by.


Cheryl Joe wrote: "I loved Plays It as It Lays and would venture into Didion's essays if I thought I could add anything more eloquent than you have, Cheryl. I enjoy how you summarized the stops in her journey succinc..."

I enjoyed reading your fascinating review of "Play It" Joe! I'm hesitant to try her fiction, just like you're hesitant to try her essays - ha! Your witty and passionate reviews will work for any author, just as your comments work for me. Thanks for reading and being so encouraging.


message 5: by Ted (new) - added it

Ted Your review inspires me to push this book into a "read sooner rather than later, or not at all" imaginary pile, Cheryl. You make it sound like such a worthwhile read!


message 6: by Seemita (new)

Seemita Cheryl, I smiled as I read your opening paragraph; a certain sense of deja vu trickled through me and then, I wasn't surprised since it was you who was talking (and reading) again about me (and yourself). And while reading through your review, I paused at various places but took a relatively longer halt at this:

'...this art that places a writer within the center of observation, and yet silences her persona.'

I have often felt myself torn between words and silence; how and when can one feel akin to the former and then, completely at ease with the latter. When people speak about being introvert or extrovert, what do they really mean? Aren't we all oscillating between these two fantastic banks, each having enough to provide us warmth and retrospective light? Aren't they sort of inseparable? Ah! Look at me, rambling on your thread! Sorry for hijacking your thread with my loud thoughts but every time you post, dear Cheryl, you send so many perceptive darts my way that it gets nigh impossible to dodge them! Oh, it helps that I love them! :) Gorgeous review, as per usual.


message 7: by Dolors (new)

Dolors Cheryl, there is a quiet wisdom in your writing that never fails to engage. Reading this review urges me not only to read Didion (and other essayists) but also to finally take the definite step towards my resolution to read more nonfiction, even more after your fascinating remarks on the genre and its particular implications for essays. A truly wonderful review, which made me jealous of the students that pass by your office to seek your counsel! ;P


message 8: by Fionnuala (new)

Fionnuala Great words here, both your own and Didion's, Cheryl.
I loved this quote:
'The impulse to write things down is a peculiarly compulsive one, inexplicable to those who do not share it, useful only accidentally, only secondarily, in the way that any compulsion tries to justify itself."
Was thinking something along those lines recently but could never put it like she does.
Like you, I loved Blue Nights and The Year of M T plus From where I Stand - but I haven't read this collection though the title -a great line- is so familiar. Thank you for the gentle push that will definitely make me get to it...
(This review actually showed up in my feed unlike your other recent ones so that's something!)


Helle This is a terrific review , Cheryl! Only the other day I read an article about Joan Didion being the new face (as of 2015) of the fashion house Céline, which I thought was pretty well done for a woman of eighty. I've had my eye on her for a while but had, predictably, considered The Year of Magical Thinking. Now I wonder if maybe it should be this one instead. Thanks for your thoughts on the essay genre - yes, yes, yes!


Cheryl Ted wrote: "Your review inspires me to push this book into a "read sooner rather than later, or not at all" imaginary pile, Cheryl. You make it sound like such a worthwhile read!"

Ha, I love your titled pile, Ted. Please tell me it is actually a shelf you named on GR - ingenious! And thank you for stopping by with a smile. It's always a pleasure to hear from you.


Cheryl Seemita wrote: "Aren't we all oscillating between these two fantastic banks, each having enough to provide us warmth and retrospective light? Aren't they sort of inseparable?...

Simi, seriously, we must be on the same energy wavelength or something because I was just thinking about this point a couple of nights ago, after watching "The Lost Honour of Christopher Jefferies" on Netflix. Jeffries was an academic and recluse, supposedly so introverted that he was eccentric in his dealing with others - admittedly, he did have a few social bolts missing. However, you hear about this introversion centered around the academic world a lot, and yet, there are some who stand before lecture rooms of eighty students weekly. Back to your ponder: makes you wonder doesn't it? We once discussed a study done, and the measure is supposed to center around what we need to recharge: solitude, or people? This is where the answer abides, I think (which reminds me, I'm scheduled to read Quiet: The Power of Introverts in a World That Can't Stop Talking soon).

By the way, you can ramble and "hijack" my thread as often as you like because I love those thought-provoking instances you create with each comment you leave and I appreciate your beautiful response.


Cheryl Dolors wrote: "Cheryl, there is a quiet wisdom in your writing that never fails to engage. Reading this review urges me not only to read Didion (and other essayists) but also to finally take the definite step tow..."

Dolors, each word you write brings with it fluid resonance. Thank you kindly for such an affecting response. I know that the genre will be in good hands via your reviews. Nonfiction or memoir should be seen as the art forms they truly are, for with each brush of the true paint brush, we get more effective portraits of the world (especially since when writing fiction, some don't try to understand global landscapes or characters much, thereby presenting to the world a skewed view of certain locales).


Cheryl Fionnuala wrote: "I loved this quote:
'The impulse to write things down is a peculiarly compulsive one, inexplicable to those who do not share it, useful only ..."


Beautiful quote right? I thought the same thing, that it's nearly impossible to put the feeling to words the way that she did. Which one is From Where I Stand? Do you mean Where I Was From? I'm considering reading The White Album next, but I'm still not sure. And yay to the review finally showing up in your feed, Fio, because I certainly love reading your thoughtful responses! Thanks for some Didion conversation, and I'm glad we both read and enjoyed those memoirs. (view spoiler)


Cheryl Dylan wrote: "Cheryl...love reading you"

I don't even think there are words left for your succinctly robust response, Dylan :) Thanks so much for the kind words.


Cheryl Helle wrote: "This is a terrific review , Cheryl! Only the other day I read an article about Joan Didion being the new face (as of 2015) of the fashion house Céline, which I thought was pretty well done for a wo..."

Oh what an honor for her. When you consider her writing trajectory, and of the plays and screenwriting and books she's still involved with, it's all so inspirational that she just keeps doing these amazing things. She's the celebrity writer most writers still dream of becoming. Helle, thanks so much for the beautiful words. Where to start: it depends on what you want. If you're looking for a full narrative thread, go with a memoir, and then choose, based on themes. YOMT is about loss and death and coping, so consider this. If you want short glimpses of place, people, and time, go with one of her essay collections. Reading her does come with quite a lot of options, so you can't go wrong :)


message 16: by Fionnuala (new)

Fionnuala Cheryl wrote: "...Do you mean..."

Yes! I did mean Where I Was From - I was relying on my memory to recall the title, but you know what, my memory isn't so bad because I have Didion's book shelved along with other books about Place, and I just went and checked, her book is right beside a book called From Where We Stand so I was rembering exactly where Didion's book is on my shelves, seeing it in my minds eye - only I was one book out...


Cheryl Fionnuala wrote: "Cheryl wrote: "...Do you mean..."

Yes! I did mean Where I Was From - I was relying on my memory to recall the title, but you know what, my memory isn't so bad because I have Didion's bo..."


Hmm, now you do have me interested in Where I Was From...


message 18: by Deanna (new)

Deanna I really enjoyed your review, Cheryl :)


message 19: by Samadrita (new) - added it

Samadrita Reading you is always a pleasure, Cheryl. I'll make room for Didion in my tbr this year for sure.


Cheryl @Deanna - Thanks for reading, Deanna :)
@Samadrita - Ditto here, Sam. And I'm glad to hear this :) Thanks for stopping by.


message 21: by Lynne (new) - added it

Lynne King What a splendid title Cheryl and I love your style of writing...


Cheryl Lynne wrote: "What a splendid title Cheryl and I love your style of writing..."

What a humbling compliment, Lynne. Thank you!


message 23: by Margaret (new)

Margaret So long since I've read Didion essays, how wonderful it is that it's this beautiful review of yours bringing me back. I love the image of you palming your forehead and drooling through Didion's pages, not even noticing that your office hours were about to begin. Lost in words again.


Cheryl Margaret wrote: "So long since I've read Didion essays, how wonderful it is that it's this beautiful review of yours bringing me back. I love the image of you palming your forehead and drooling through Didion's pag..."

She's definitely one of my favorite essayists, Margaret. Do you still have your copy handy? Time to dust if off and revisit :)


message 25: by Margaret (new)

Margaret Cheryl, I do indeed have my old copy, a 1968 Delta trade paperback listing for $1.95. Not too much dust, and I've checked the three essays you mentioned by name and will start there. I'll get back to you when I've read those three.


message 26: by Ted (new) - added it

Ted Tonight it's two bookmarks for the price of one, Cheryl. But I still haven't read the book, darn it.

(view spoiler)


message 27: by Cheryl (last edited Oct 16, 2016 05:24AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Cheryl Ted wrote: "Tonight it's two bookmarks for the price of one, Cheryl. But I still haven't read the book, darn it.

You've reminded me that I need to grab this collection and reread the part about Joan Beaz. Thanks for finding something in this review that sparked your bookmarking attention, Ted!
(view spoiler)


Vipassana I'm haphazardly reading this collection now and your review captures my feelings perfectly!


Steven Godin Great review Cheryl!


Cheryl Thanks, Steven!

Vipassana - sorry I missed your lovely comment. I’m glad you enjoyed this collection also.


message 31: by Shankar (new) - added it

Shankar Wonderful!! Your approach to describing the theme of the book was very inventive. It sets the tone for the “Slouch� in all of us. Which is I guess the message from the author. I will read this book for sure. Even if just to understand “our compulsion to please others as an attractive trait�. Thank you


Cheryl Hi, Shankar. Thank you! I’m sure you’ll have some great takeaways after you read it.


back to top