ŷ

Lisa's Reviews > Mudbound

Mudbound by Hillary Jordan
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
103664948
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: 2024, historical-fiction, debut

Hilary Jordan's Mudbound is an outstanding debut novel.

The basic plotline - Henry McAllan moves his wife, Laura, and their 2 daughters from the city to a rural rundown farm with none of the modern conveniences, including indoor plumbing. To add to this change, Henry's father, the deeply racist and selfish Pappy moves in with them. The Jacksons, a black sharecropping tenant family on the farm, have their own mule and are better off than many southern blacks. Setting off a cascading chain of events, Jamie, Henry's much younger brother, and Ronsel, Hap and Florence Jackson's oldest son, return from the war. Jamie is haunted by his experiences flying bomber plane missions over Germany. Rosel, a sergeant who commanded his small tank crew, became involved with a white German woman and relished that his skin color made little difference in war-torn Europe. He struggles with the attitudes of southern whites upon his return.

Jordan makes a bold choice to tell her tale chronologically from multiple points of view. By doing so, I get to know each character and get a more complete picture of the story. The drawback is that I am left wanting a little more of each of these characters. Pappy, the villain of the piece, does not get a chapter. I get very few glimpses into his backstory and how he comes to be who he is at this time. Jordan's characters are multi-dimensional and relatable except for Pappy.

Set in 1940's Mississippi, Jordan brings her setting to life. Once she moves the story to the delta region I can hear the rains and feel the sucking mud. She explores the varying levels of racism from deep hatred in Pappy to a mild feeling of superiority in Laura to the seeming indifference of skin color in the Austrian-born doctor. She shows me the haunting consequences of this hate and asks me to take a deep look into my own heart and examine my intolerances.

I find this setting and these characters a strong contrast to the characters on Wendell Berry's Port Williams farms. (I recently read Hannah Coulter.) Berry's stories are about community and coming together. Jordan's story is one of strife and differences and division. What these characters share is what Jordan dubs "land sickness," a love of the land so deep that it is part of them.

So what is now on my mind? I have a few people of varying skin tones in my life who migrated north. They never felt completely at home, even in the mid-Atlantic. They returned south to the positives they missed while searching for pockets of people who shared their values. Feeling more in their skins in some ways, they bristle at intolerant attitudes, and work toward social justice in their small ways. One of the questions this read has stirred in me is the definition of home and how to live in an imperfect world. How complicit am I in retaining that world? What ability do I have to effect change? And what am I willing to do?

Publication 2008
50 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Mudbound.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

April 16, 2021 – Shelved as: to-read
April 16, 2021 – Shelved
April 27, 2024 – Started Reading
April 27, 2024 – Shelved as: 2024
April 27, 2024 – Shelved as: historical-fiction
April 29, 2024 – Shelved as: debut
April 29, 2024 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-49 of 49 (49 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Albert (new)

Albert Wonderful review! Lisa.


Lisa Albert wrote: "Wonderful review! Lisa."

Thank you, Albert. I'd say Jordan accomplished what she set out to do with this novel.


message 3: by Barbara (new) - added it

Barbara You ask tough questions, Lisa, but they are ones we should all ask. I fine review.


Lisa Barbara wrote: "You ask tough questions, Lisa, but they are ones we should all ask. I fine review."

Barbara, even tougher than the questions is coming up with some answers.


message 5: by Laysee (new)

Laysee What a poignant review! Lisa, this sounds like a truly impressive work for its ability to elicit the searching questions it did for you and fellow readers.


message 6: by K (new) - rated it 5 stars

K Such a thoughtful review, Lisa. I read this when I only rated, not reviewed, books here on GR. I loved it when I read it and even shelved it on my "Favorites" shelf. I often wonder if I'd feel the same way about books if I were to read them again years later. Your review makes me want to revisit this novel.


Antoinette Excellent review, Lisa. I remember really loving this book. They made a movie of this - if I remember it was quite good.


Sujoya - theoverbookedbibliophile Outstanding review, Lisa!


message 9: by Fionnuala (new)

Fionnuala That's a good title too, isn't it, Lisa? The primordial mud. We're still struggling to get out of it.


message 10: by Diane (new)

Diane Barnes I loved this book and remember being powerfully affected by it after reading. Antoinette is right, the movie is excellent too.


message 11: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Laysee wrote: "What a poignant review! Lisa, this sounds like a truly impressive work for its ability to elicit the searching questions it did for you and fellow readers."

Thank you, Laysee. Jordan deftly tackles a challenging topic with this novel.


message 12: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa K wrote: "Such a thoughtful review, Lisa. I read this when I only rated, not reviewed, books here on GR. I loved it when I read it and even shelved it on my "Favorites" shelf. I often wonder if I'd feel the ..."

I understand that thought, K. My reviews have gotten more reflective over time, and I hope they will bring me back to the essence of each book as I re-read them.


message 13: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Antoinette wrote: "Excellent review, Lisa. I remember really loving this book. They made a movie of this - if I remember it was quite good."

Thank you, Antoinette. I'm not much of a watcher, so I'm not sure I'll see the movie; and I have heard a lot of good things about it.

This book--definitely worth my time.


message 14: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Sujoya(theoverbookedbibliophile)- Lots of catching wrote: "Outstanding review, Lisa!"

Thank you, Sujoya. It's an outstanding book.


message 15: by Lisa (last edited Apr 30, 2024 04:13AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Fionnuala wrote: "That's a good title too, isn't it, Lisa? The primordial mud. We're still struggling to get out of it."

Fionnuala, it certainly is. Somedays, I can really feel it sucking the boots right off my feet. Jordan used the metaphor astutely in the novel. Do you think we'll ever get out of the mud?


message 16: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Diane wrote: "I loved this book and remember being powerfully affected by it after reading. Antoinette is right, the movie is excellent too."

Diane, this is a strong book that truly gets to the reader. I hope the impact is long lasting and generates some thought and a little action on the part of the reader.


message 17: by Mark (new)

Mark  Porton Great review Lisa, as usual - sounds like there is a heck of a lot of stuff going on in this book! You've asked some cracking questions in closing - it sounds like you had a buddy read with yourself! Well - regarding the definition of Home - I find that one really difficult, having moved around a lot. It certainly isn't where I live now, Cairns - I'd probably say beautiful old Adelaide in South Australia. How about you?

Oh BTW - do you know this is your 500th review? Congratulations my friend 🎆🎈🎊🎉🎁


message 18: by Barbara K (new)

Barbara K Beautiful review, Lisa. It is interesting how a work of fiction can stimulate inward reflection so much more than reading the news.


Candi An excellent, thoughtful review, Lisa. I remember this novel packing quite the punch, and the questions you've asked are indeed difficult to answer. Let's keep asking ourselves. Then perhaps we will get closer to some answers.


message 20: by Fionnuala (new)

Fionnuala Lisa wrote: "Jordan used the metaphor astutely in the novel. Do you think we'll ever get out of the mud?.."

I'm reading essays by a sixteenth century writer at the moment, and he in turn is reading and commenting on writers from centuries before, and the short answer to your question, the mud is just as omnipresent today as it seemed to have been back then.


message 21: by Violeta (new)

Violeta You present yourself and your readers with some tough challenges especially when you ask for intolerance examination and how to live in an imperfect world. I tend to agree with Fionnuala’s opinion above, the mud is ever present, it’s only its substance that changes. You’ve written a powerful review that stirs the standing waters of our conscience, Lisa. Perhaps that is one answer to your many questions in your closing paragraph.


Carol An oldie but one that certainly deserves being mentioned again.
I'm certain your fine review will draw others to this superior book.


message 23: by Canadian Jen (new) - added it

Canadian Jen I'm not sure why I haven't read this one yet! It's been on my list forever. A compelling review, Lisa!


message 24: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Mark wrote: "Great review Lisa, as usual - sounds like there is a heck of a lot of stuff going on in this book! You've asked some cracking questions in closing - it sounds like you had a buddy read with yoursel..."

Thank you, Mark. I've never thought of it that way before, and I think in most cases our reads are buddy reads with ourselves. 😊
I need reads like this one as reminders strewn in my path so I don't get bogged down in the minutiae of life and forget what is important and remind myself to act accordingly.

And thanks also for keeping track. I had no idea this was my 500th review.


message 25: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Barbara K. wrote: "Beautiful review, Lisa. It is interesting how a work of fiction can stimulate inward reflection so much more than reading the news."

Sad to say, many of us have become callous news watchers; we are just so overwhelmed with all of the bad stuff. Fiction gives me a more in depth look at situations and gives me the opportunity to dive in, as I think it does for many readers.


message 26: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Fionnuala and Violeta,
I appreciate your astute comments. I am not sure if it is a good thing or a bad thing that the substrate changes. That the mud is omnipresent I have no doubt. I am glad that Jordan, and many other authors, are out there stirring up the muck. I'll be optimistic and hope that just a small layer of it will get skimmed off.


message 27: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Candi wrote: "An excellent, thoughtful review, Lisa. I remember this novel packing quite the punch, and the questions you've asked are indeed difficult to answer. Let's keep asking ourselves. Then perhaps we wil..."

Candi, I agree that keeping the questions in mind is the first step. I know for me it is helpful to have frequent reminders which is part of why I am drawn to books with social justice themes.


message 28: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Carol wrote: "An oldie but one that certainly deserves being mentioned again.
I'm certain your fine review will draw others to this superior book."


Thank you, Carol. I hope so!


message 29: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Canadian Jen wrote: "I'm not sure why I haven't read this one yet! It's been on my list forever. A compelling review, Lisa!"

Thanks Jen. I'm happy to provide a nudge!


Angela M Love your thoughts on this , Lisa. Great review.


message 31: by Lisa (last edited May 02, 2024 04:30AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Angela M wrote: "Love your thoughts on this , Lisa. Great review."

Thanks Angela. It was a great read.


message 32: by Fran (new)

Fran Hawthorne Lisa, thank you for sharing your personal experiences in this beautiful review. (And on a literary note: I think you point out an important and common problem with books told from multiple POVs -- inevitably, someone doesn't get enough ink.)


message 33: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Fran wrote: "Lisa, thank you for sharing your personal experiences in this beautiful review. (And on a literary note: I think you point out an important and common problem with books told from multiple POVs -- ..."

Despite the drawback, Jordan made excellent use of the multiple POV here, Fran. I liked how each piece added to the picture I was forming.


message 34: by Fran (new)

Fran Hawthorne Yes, t and that's' the great part about multiple POV. (Multiple POV is also incredibly difficult to write well, to create multiple voices and personalities that are clearly different.)


message 35: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Fran wrote: "Yes, t and that's' the great part about multiple POV. (Multiple POV is also incredibly difficult to write well, to create multiple voices and personalities that are clearly different.)"

So I'll take that to be a compliment for Jordan's writing. 😊


message 36: by Lori (new) - added it

Lori  Keeton I missed this review somehow, but glad to have found it. It’s a book on my TBR and one I need to find time for. Thanks for your thoughtfulness, as always, Lisa.


message 37: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Lori wrote: "I missed this review somehow, but glad to have found it. It’s a book on my TBR and one I need to find time for. Thanks for your thoughtfulness, as always, Lisa."

Thank you, Lori. I think you will appreciate Jordan's themes and writing here. I look forward to your thoughts when you read this novel.


message 38: by Jonathan (new) - added it

Jonathan K (Max Outlier) Never saw the film but am a fan of debut novels which can be hit or miss..sounds interesting so I'll give it a shot


message 39: by Julie (new) - added it

Julie G I like that this story is set in MS. Having done 2 different "read across America" projects, I can tell you that it's not an easy state to find a lot of reading options. I wonder if the author is from there?


message 40: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Jonathan wrote: "Never saw the film but am a fan of debut novels which can be hit or miss..sounds interesting so I'll give it a shot"

Jonathan, IMO this is a very good debut. If/when you do read it, please come back and let me know.


message 41: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Julie wrote: "I like that this story is set in MS. Having done 2 different "read across America" projects, I can tell you that it's not an easy state to find a lot of reading options. I wonder if the author is f..."

Julie, I read up a little on Jordan after reading this one. According to her website, "She grew up in Dallas, TX and Muskogee, OK and currently lives in Brooklyn, NY, along with half the writers in America."


message 42: by James (last edited Jun 05, 2024 05:25PM) (new)

James Fascinating to read your thoughts here and see where this overlaps with some of the themes in Appropriate.

Not at all surprised by your impressions of Pappy, as he's the least developed character in the film adaptation as well.

The movie is excellent, by the way, and I'd be curious to know what, if anything, changed as the result of a novel written by a white woman being adapted and filtered through the perspectives of a Black lesbian director (Dee Rees) and racially diverse cast.


message 43: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa James wrote: "Fascinating to read your thoughts here and see where this overlaps with some of the themes in Appropriate.

Not at all surprised by your impressions of Pappy, as he's the least developed character..."


Well this one is more blatantly racist than Appropriate and lacks the humor which threads through the play. You do have me intrigued about the movie now. Perhaps I will be motivated to watch it if it is currently streaming.


message 44: by James (new)

James It was one of the earliest Netflix Original Productions if I'm not mistaken, and it's currently streaming on Netflix.


message 45: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa James wrote: "It was one of the earliest Netflix Original Productions if I'm not mistaken, and it's currently streaming on Netflix."

Okay, you've convinced me. If it's raining tomorrow I'll be mudbound in Maryland while the McAllan family is Mudbound in Mississippi.


message 46: by Mark (new)

Mark  Porton Lisa wrote: "Mark wrote: "Great review Lisa, as usual - sounds like there is a heck of a lot of stuff going on in this book! You've asked some cracking questions in closing - it sounds like you had a buddy read..."

Some call it stalking Lisa, but I call it observant. Just like I know you've just taken your 8,354th step today moving towards the kettle just then.


message 47: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Mark wrote: "Some call it stalking Lisa, but I call it observant. Just like I know you've just taken your 8,354th step today moving towards the kettle just then."

🤣🤣🤣


message 48: by Linda (new) - added it

Linda Excellent review. This book is sitting on my shelves waiting to be read, I need to move it up!


message 49: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Linda wrote: "Excellent review. This book is sitting on my shelves waiting to be read, I need to move it up!"

Linda, there is a lot to be gleaned here. I'll look forward to your thoughts.


back to top