ŷ

Gaurav's Reviews > Gooseberries

Gooseberries by Anton Chekhov
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
8148922
's review

really liked it

*edited on 23.05.2021

Happiness doesn’t exist, we don’t need any such thing. If life has any meaning or purpose, you won’t find it in happiness, but in something more rational, in something greater. Doing good!


What is happiness? Human beings� quest for happiness in life is often narrow-minded as they see happiness as the ultimate pursuit in life. Does it mean that unhappiness is not or should be part of life? Aren't both different aspects of the same emotion? And what does being happy mean? Does it correlate with success? What is a success then, how do we define it? And whose happiness we are talking about? What does it essentially mean? We need to further explore that is it materialistic in nature or metaphysical, don’t both of them represent our myopic vision. Another key point to be addressed is whether this happiness is selfish or altruistic, whether we need to bother about the society as a whole; and what about the social injustice or various other vagaries present in our society. We need to assess the essence of happiness when we have varied anomalies in our society. Let’s go deeper, to the core of ‘happiness�, the meaning we impart of our lives, the truth we seek in our lives to define it, how much it matters when we talk about happiness; the petty achievements we acquire over the course of our lives, do they really matter, if they don’t then why do we worry so much about them.



link:

Gooseberries is one of the stories written in the last phase of Anton Chekov’s life, the artistic abilities of people often seem to be waned, gradually after touching prime of their prowess but that’s not the case with Chekov, he produced in masterpieces-both in prose and drama- in this phase of his life, perhaps that’s why he is regarded as one of the best short fiction authors, as relevant today as he was then- a timeless beauty. We see that there is an interesting overlapping of modernism and the creative outburst of Anton Chekov in the last phase of his life. During that period, impressionism was gaining popularity in both art and literature, though later it was quickly surpassed by Expressionism and other post-impressionist trends.


It represents a unique feature of its kind, as it is essentially a story within a story, the narrator- Ivan Ivanych, the vet and Burkin, a teacher at a high school took shelter at Alyokhin’s as they get soaked from top to bottom in the divine water pouring from the overcast sky. Ivanych is invited by the group to tell the story which has been impending for some time, the anticipation of the story is so much that not only Burkin and Alyokhin but also the ladies (young and old), and the officers, who were looking down calmly and solemnly from their gilt frames on the walls, are also waiting eagerly, fixing their eyes on Ivanych. The story is about Ivan Ivanych, who is disgusted by the silliness of his brother, Nikolay Ivanych, for he considers the minuscule, materialistic acquisitions in life as happiness, he seems to be blind to the universal human quest for eventual contentment.

Ivanych goes on preaching that people should look for meaning in their lives rather than gratifying themselves with petty things in life. He makes allusion to Tolstoy’s famous story-‘How much land a man need?, They say a man needs only six feet of earth, but surely they must mean a corpse- not a man!, perhaps to emphasize upon the futility of materialistic achievements. The (first person) narrator discusses at length what humanity actually needs in life rather than what it desires for; the empires, estates accumulated by the educated classes but eventually everyone needs just six feet of land. Man sacrifices his personal, real life, in the pretense of acquiring something that is essentially worthless, effectively he lives a meaningless and uncontended life.

A man needs more than six feet of earth and a little place in the country, he needs the whole wide world, the whole of nature, where there’s room for him to display his potential, all the manifold attributes of his free spirit.


The questions about life keep reverberating through the story, it raises the intriguing point of unspeakable poverty, overcrowding, degeneracy, drunkenness, hypocrisy, and lies as we do not get the utmost satisfaction, we quest for in our lives. The peace and quiet that seem to be prevalent in our lives are shallow and baseless since the social injustice, inherent to our society, creates an imitation of happiness for privileged people who seems to oblivious to the underprivileged ones. The vehement critic of Nikolay, his brother Ivanych preaches about the man’s inability to look for real purpose in life rather than taking refuge in so-called happiness, but we see that he himself doesn’t do anything for the same, however, he urges his friends to devise a meaningful life for themselves, reflects the irony of life.

It’s obvious that the happy man feels contented only because the unhappy ones bear their burden without saying a word: if it weren’t for their silence, happiness would be quite impossible. It’s a kind of mass hypnosis.

And I thought how many satisfied, happy people really do exist in this world! And what a powerful force they are! Just take a look at this life of ours and you will see the arrogance and idleness of the strong, the ignorance and bestiality of the weak.



link: source

The author presents a unique mix of narrative style in the story, the tale starts in a third-person narrative with a non-existent but omniscient narrator but with the onset of the 'story within in the story', it switches to first person narrative with Ivanych taking a central role in it. The language is rich and full of imagery, as you expect from Chekov, like an impressionist painting but Chekov demands his reader to play an active role in the story, Chekov’s prose has features of more like modernist literature. He deliberately evades some details of the narrative, adopting a minimalist approach (which later expounded and explored by the likes of Hemingway and Beckett) since the message, themes of a story should not be obvious to the narrator. His prose focuses upon melancholy, mood, feelings, and consciousness of the characters, around lyrical, poetic, and vivid settings. We see that the smallest, peculiar details are given importance in the story, probably to dip the senses of the reader in a tinge of wry humor. We witness an intriguing feature of Chekov’s prose that otherwise gets unnoticed, he uses lyrical repetitiveness (not like Bernhard) in a way that words may not be repeated as such but emotions or moods are repeated in the story, perhaps to pepper the reader with conflicting and unsettling notions.

My thoughts about human happiness, for some, peculiar reason, had always been tinged with a certain sadness.


The tale may across a simple story, as happens with most of the stories of Chekov, to a casual reader, but Chekov did not write for those innocuous readers, for the story has to be read more than once to understand its intended meaning. Gooseberries is a great example of the fact that why Chekov is considered among the most influential modern short stories authors, his impact is omnipresent though we may rarely find authors giving him credit, individually. He wrote to throw questions, basic questions- about life, at his readers, whose job is to actively engage themselves to search for infinite probable answers to those questions.

They were hard and sour, but as Pushkin says: “Uplifting illusion is dearer to us than a host of truths.�
91 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Gooseberries.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

May 20, 2021 – Started Reading
May 20, 2021 – Shelved
May 20, 2021 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-46 of 46 (46 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Ilse Beauteous tribute to this story which is one of my favourites by Chekhov, Gaurav.


message 2: by Lynne (new) - added it

Lynne King An excellent review Gaurav.


message 3: by Katia (new)

Katia N It is the one of my favourite stories as well. We share this with Ilse. Thank you for your great review, Gaurav. Just wanted to add that he died at 46 as far as i remember. So it is not surprising he was in prime of his creativity.


Gaurav Ilse wrote: "Beauteous tribute to this story which is one of my favourites by Chekhov, Gaurav."

Thanks a lot, Ilse, for your kind words. Glad to know that it's your favorite. I've read just two stories so I am wondering if you could suggest to me which stories of his, I should go for:)


Gaurav Lynne wrote: "An excellent review Gaurav."

Thanks a lot, Lynne for your kind words, glad that you liked it :)


message 6: by Sh (new) - rated it 4 stars

Sh Kishan Beautiful review, Gaurav. Anton Chekov is one of those authors you are still missing from my TBR. I think it would be the nice choice, any suggestions ?


message 7: by Nataliya (new)

Nataliya Wonderful review, Gaurav! Chekhov’s short stories are always so good.


message 8: by Cheri (new) - added it

Cheri Wonderful and thoughtful review, Gaurav. I need to find a copy of this one.


Gaurav Katia wrote: "It is the one of my favourite stories as well. We share this with Ilse. Thank you for your great review, Gaurav. Just wanted to add that he died at 46 as far as i remember. So it is not surprising ..."

Thanks a lot, Katia for your kind words. Glad to know that it's your favorite as well. Yeah, I am aware of the fact that he died at the age of 46, just wanted to highlight the fact that he did not lose vigor even after achieving the so-called highest point of his life, in other words, he kept improving but your point of view also raises an intriguing possibility that perhaps he would have lived longer then we could have got a fair idea of his writing proficiency- the actual high of his literary life, however, Chekhovs do not have these so-called highs and lows, they are beyond that :)


Anne Gaurav, a beautiful and thoughtful review. :))


Gaurav Sh wrote: "Beautiful review, Gaurav. Anton Chekov is one of those authors you are still missing from my TBR. I think it would be the nice choice, any suggestions ?"

Thanks a lot Sh for kind words. Wel, I read just two stories by Chekhov- The House with Mezzanine and this one so perhaps I'm not the best person to answer it, but you may go with either these or The Lady with the Little Dog, which is one of the most popular of his stories :)


Gaurav Nataliya wrote: "Wonderful review, Gaurav! Chekhov’s short stories are always so good."

Thanks a lot, Nataliya for your kind words. Yeah, his stories always have so much to ponder upon, beneath the seemingly straightforward narrative he weaves an outstandingly complex web of human emotions, which we have to discover by peeling off the layer-by-layer of the narrative. Btw, if I may ask, which is favorite story by Chekhov ?


message 13: by Sh (new) - rated it 4 stars

Sh Kishan Gaurav wrote: "Sh wrote: "Beautiful review, Gaurav. Anton Chekov is one of those authors you are still missing from my TBR. I think it would be the nice choice, any suggestions ?"

Thanks a lot Sh for kind words...."


Thank you your recommendations Gaurav. I think I start with The Lasy with The Little Dog.


Gaurav Cheri wrote: "Wonderful and thoughtful review, Gaurav. I need to find a copy of this one."

Thanks a lot, Cheri for your kind words, I think credit goes to Chekhov who always makes us ponder upon human existence in a clairvoyant manner. Would be looking to read what you make of it :)


Laysee Marvelous review, Gaurav. This reads like a story in which there is much more than meets the eye. It's been a while since I read Chekhov and I have a collection of his short stories I'm looking forward to cracking.


Gaurav Anne (On semi-hiatus) wrote: "Gaurav, a beautiful and thoughtful review. :))"

Thanks a lot, Anne for your kind words :)


message 17: by Vicky (new) - added it

Vicky "phenkos" Brilliant review, I'm going to read this! Btw, regarding happiness, the ancient Greeks thought that the pursuit of happiness is part and parcel of what it means to be human, that humans seek happiness and this cannot be taken away from them. It's like the bedrock of the human condition. Of course, this does not mean that we are happy all the time, or that unhappiness is not also a part of humanness. And of course, there are still the questions you raise about materialistic happiness...


message 18: by Carlos (new)

Carlos Wonderful review Gaurav, of one of my very favorite stories by the great Chekhov. And I agree with your last paragraph, after two, three or four readings, the story reveals itself in its whole beauty.


Kathleen It adds so much to tell us about what was going on in the world and in Chekhov's life when he wrote this. Fascinating review, Gaurav!


message 20: by Cheryl (new)

Cheryl Beautiful review, Gaurav. I love your close reading of this work. You bring up many good points that make up the underpinnings of Chekhov. The part on happiness reminds me of Ginzburg's Voices in the Evening, when a character says happiness is "like water, one only realizes it when it has run away."


message 21: by Nataliya (new)

Nataliya Gaurav wrote: "Nataliya wrote: "Btw, if I may ask, which is favorite story by Chekhov ?"

It’s hard to pick just one! “Kashtanka� reminds me of childhood. “Lady with the Dog� is very good, “On Official Duty�, and surely this one (and now I know that those particular berries are gooseberries in English!).


message 22: by Maria (new)

Maria Espadinha Hi Gaurav. I see happiness as a recognition of the self � when we recognize ourselves in what we do, we are happy. Every time we go against ourselves, we are unhappy
Great review, Gaurav 👍


Gaurav Laysee wrote: "Marvelous review, Gaurav. This reads like a story in which there is much more than meets the eye. It's been a while since I read Chekhov and I have a collection of his short stories I'm looking for..."

Thanks a lot, Laysee for your kind words. You are right it has more than what appears to casual eyes, I find it invariably with almost all stories of Chekhov as he wanted his reader not to have a passive reading experience. Glad to know that you are planning to read his collection, would be looking to read what you make out of it :)


message 24: by flo (new)

flo This splendid review goes well with one of the books I'm reading now. In fact, the meaning of the first quote can easily be found in the latter, just expressed with different words (happiness through training the mind to be more altruistic), and also the fact that happiness and sadness are a package, “two sides of the same coin.�
Always a pleasure to find thought-provoking reviews like this one, Gaurav. :) A noble thing to do, taking the time to enlighten us a little bit.


message 25: by Steven (new)

Steven Godin Great review, Gaurav.


Gaurav Vicky wrote: "Brilliant review, I'm going to read this! Btw, regarding happiness, the ancient Greeks thought that the pursuit of happiness is part and parcel of what it means to be human, that humans seek happin..."

Thanks a lot, Vicky for your kind words. I would be looking to read your opinion on it when you get to it. As for happiness, well, I think it's a complex issue, just being happy could be the meaning of humanity, as both are manifestations of the same emotions. I guess, being human means you want to do with your life and thereby living authentically which essentially means that doing things which you actually wan to, however, most of us end up doing something else, sometimes on the pretext of existence, sometimes we are afraid to take risk and it makes it quite absurd, like the myth of Sisyphus.


Gaurav Carlos wrote: "Wonderful review Gaurav, of one of my very favorite stories by the great Chekhov. And I agree with your last paragraph, after two, three or four readings, the story reveals itself in its whole beauty."

Thanks a lot, Carlos, I'm glad to know that it's your favorite story too, well it's only my second story by Chekhov so, I think, the sample is very small to say about favorite; however, I like The House with Mezazzine more, and currently I am reading 'The Lady with a Little Dog. Yeah, like many great authors, Checkhov also demands multiple and active reading from his readers :)


message 28: by Kiekiat (new)

Kiekiat Gaurav--another great review. You can't go wrong with any of Chekhov's short stories, and he showed his genius early on. I've read stories he wrote at age 26 that show a preternatural awareness of the joys and sorrows and complexity and senselessness of all human thought and action. I recommend Constance Garnett's translations, which you can buy on Kindle for a song, and as for stories, I'd recommend "The Kiss" and "The Woman with a Dog" (this title can vary according to the translation--just look for a story with lady/woman and dog). I'd recommend the story, "Rothschild's Fiddle," as well.


Gaurav Kathleen wrote: "It adds so much to tell us about what was going on in the world and in Chekhov's life when he wrote this. Fascinating review, Gaurav!"

Thanks a lot, Kathleen for your kind words. You've quite aptly mentioned that it tells us about what was happening then in and around the life of Chekhov. In fact, as I am reading The Lady with The Little Dog now I do realize the impact of his life on the story.


Gaurav Cheryl wrote: "Beautiful review, Gaurav. I love your close reading of this work. You bring up many good points that make up the underpinnings of Chekhov. The part on happiness reminds me of Ginzburg's [book:Voice..."

Thanks a lot, Cheryl for your kind words, credit goes to Chekhov to bring out the emotions. Thanks for sharing the book, and the intriguing quote that we realize happiness when it passes away, perhaps it's linked with human nature, more often than not, we acknowledge things in their aftermath. The other day, I read your nice write-up of the book you shared here, will look to try it out in the future:)


Gaurav Nataliya wrote: "Gaurav wrote: "Nataliya wrote: "Btw, if I may ask, which is favorite story by Chekhov ?"

It’s hard to pick just one! “Kashtanka� reminds me of childhood. “Lady with the Dog� is very good, “On Offi..."


Thanks a lot Nataliya for your kind suggestions, I'd definitely have a look at these stories, in fact, currently I am reading 'The Lady with The Little Dog'. Haha, gooseberries were also some knowledge to me, Indian gooseberry is similar to it (European) and they are called 'amla' in Hindi :)


Gaurav Maria wrote: "Hi Gaurav. I see happiness as a recognition of the self � when we recognize ourselves in what we do, we are happy. Every time we go against ourselves, we are unhappy
Great review, Gaurav 👍"


Thanks a lot, Maria, for your kind words. Well, I would say that when we have to do something in which we don't have heart in, voluntarily or involuntarily, we feel uncontended.


Gaurav Florencia wrote: "This splendid review goes well with one of the books I'm reading now. In fact, the meaning of the first quote can easily be found in the latter, just expressed with different words (happiness throu..."

Thanks a lot, Florencia, you've been generous as ever. You're right happiness and sadness are just two sides of a coin, perhaps what matters is our attitude, how we are living, are we living an authentic existence or not. Pleasure is all mine to have such discussions. I am curious to know which book you are referring to, in correlation with the quote, if could you please tell me?


Gaurav Steven wrote: "Great review, Gaurav."

Thanks a lot, Steven, for your kind words :)


Gaurav Sh wrote: "Gaurav wrote: "Sh wrote: "Beautiful review, Gaurav. Anton Chekov is one of those authors you are still missing from my TBR. I think it would be the nice choice, any suggestions ?"

Thanks a lot Sh ..."


Great, I hope you'd enjoy it, I've read it just a day ago. Do share your opinion on it :)


message 36: by flo (new)

flo Gaurav wrote: "Florencia wrote: "This splendid review goes well with one of the books I'm reading now. In fact, the meaning of the first quote can easily be found in the latter, just expressed with different word..."

You're welcome. :) It's The Headspace Guide to Meditation & Mindfulness (my attempt at slowing down all the racing thoughts).


Gaurav Kiekiat wrote: "Gaurav--another great review. You can't go wrong with any of Chekhov's short stories, and he showed his genius early on. I've read stories he wrote at age 26 that show a preternatural awareness of ..."

Thanks a lot, Kiekiat, for your kind words and recommendations. You are absolutely spot on about Chekhov's stories, I read three stories of him and really love those stories. As for the recommendations, I've just finished The Lady with The Little Dog, I have to look for the other stories, meanwhile, I would be looking to read your review on those, if you have written any :)


Gaurav Florencia wrote: "Gaurav wrote: "Florencia wrote: "This splendid review goes well with one of the books I'm reading now. In fact, the meaning of the first quote can easily be found in the latter, just expressed with..."

Thanks, Florencia for your reply. I'll definitely check it, meanwhile I would be waiting to read your opinion on it :)


message 39: by Sh (new) - rated it 4 stars

Sh Kishan Gaurav wrote: "Sh wrote: "Gaurav wrote: "Sh wrote: "Beautiful review, Gaurav. Anton Chekov is one of those authors you are still missing from my TBR. I think it would be the nice choice, any suggestions ?"

Thank..."


Gaurav, I am currently reading it and enjoying it.


Gaurav Something I found on Youtube-


message 41: by Junta (new)

Junta Brilliant review, Gaurav, as with Tabucchi's Requiem, I'm again coming face to face with a tinge of sadness here, this time in the form of a quote. I enjoyed one of Chekhov's collections, and was impressed by the economy of his stories, but reading your analysis here helps me connect some dots and see the whole tree of his writing, rather than the different branches! Well, if someone is happy all the time, that doesn't seem right, but of course, we'd rather be feeling happy more often than unhappy, though that's at the simplest level of things. I was discussing similar things with a friend tonight (as we were landing into a virtual online world to shoot enemies), of how the older we grow, the more time we wish we had, and how it can be difficult to see clearly what matters to us when we are younger, what we want to spend time on, not like Nikolay Ivanych, but deeper things. Well, happiness is a mysterious topic, but reading and writing and discussing books such as these is no doubt a good use of our finite time here. :-)


Gaurav Junta wrote: "Brilliant review, Gaurav, as with Tabucchi's Requiem, I'm again coming face to face with a tinge of sadness here, this time in the form of a quote. I enjoyed one of Chekhov's collections, and was i..."

Thanks a lot, Junta, for your kind words. Yeah, happiness and sadness are part-and-parcel of life, what matters is our attitude and I think, with the optimistic attitude, we may brave through vagaries of our existence. It's a natural tendency, we usually feel in aftermath of every situation that we could have done in a better way, having said that, we realize in the later phases of our lives that the things we thought to be most important in our lives, do not deserve much attention. I think it depends on our innate feeling of survival as we first strive for it at any cost and only then we think about things that may give us happiness, and it has to do with our education system and upbringing which invariably fail to think about the holistic picture, right from the start. I do agree with your point though that reading, writing are some of those distractions of life which do us do harm. Thank you for the through-provoking comment :)


Gaurav Sh wrote: "Gaurav wrote: "Sh wrote: "Gaurav wrote: "Sh wrote: "Beautiful review, Gaurav. Anton Chekov is one of those authors you are still missing from my TBR. I think it would be the nice choice, any sugges..."

I'm glad to know that it resonated with you, Happy reading!


message 44: by Lori (new)

Lori Wonderful review Gaurav, so insightful and informative.


Gaurav Lori wrote: "Wonderful review Gaurav, so insightful and informative."

Thanks a lot, Lori, for your kind words. I've recently read a few stories of Chekhov and was hugely impressed by him, planning to read more of his stories.

Hope you enjoy it as much as I did. Happy reading to you too :)


Margaret M - (having a challenging time and on GR as much as I can) Wonderful review Gaurav


back to top