ŷ

Sam Quixote's Reviews > Monsters

Monsters by Barry Windsor-Smith
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
5759543
's review

it was ok

Probably best known for his seminal 1980s Wolverine miniseries Weapon X over at Marvel, Barry Windsor-Smith is back with a new story... about the military hiring mad scientists... to secretly experiment on people� with disastrous results. Hmm. Well, I don’t want to say Barry Windsor-Smith is a one-trick pony but, from what I’ve read of him anyway, he’s 2 for 2!

Maaaaaaaan, what a project reading this was - 370 pages of densely-worded, BORING garbage! The first 120 pages is a lot of tedious military characters talking about experiments and whatever, the next 140(!) or so pages - the worst part of the book - is about a sad wife/mother getting knocked around by her abusive husband, over and over, and then, for the last 100 or so pages, we’re in the final days of WW2 where Nazi scientists try to figure out how they’re gonna explain their insane experiments to the Allies who’re hours away from rumbling them.

For such a pain-stakingly put-together work, I’m sure Windsor-Smith was trying to say something “important�, but I couldn’t tell you what it was. As far as I can see, the “monsters� the title is referring to are, 1) abusive men, 2) genetically-modified people made to look like Quasimodo, and 3) Nazi scientists (or just Nazis generally). And so� what? Don’t most people already think those three things are monsters? It’s not like Windsor-Smith is telling or showing us anything mind-blowing.

Nor do I see what the allusions to Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein did for this book. The project to transform Bobby Bailey into the monster on the cover is called Prometheus and the subtitle to Shelley’s novel is “The Modern Prometheus�. The final part of the book takes place in Schongau, which is near Ingolstadt, a prominent place in Frankenstein. Other pointlessly derivative literary allusions is having a couple of characters who essentially have the Shining in all but name.

Neither do I see the point of the experimentation. The Nazi scientists horrifically deform their test subjects - to what end? Who wants an oversized, lumbering creature with the mind of a child who can barely walk? Why would any military pour so much money into such a useless end goal?!

Windsor-Smith uses lots of dates and places to set up scenes but they add nothing to the context - who’s really going to remember that this scene is taking place three months after the one before last?

The Jan Bailey section - the battered housewife part - had far too many pages full of cursive handwriting that were a chore to slog through. Not just because of Jan’s whiny voice, or that deciphering cursive slowed down an already ploddingly-paced read, but because these pages never added anything to what we already knew. We see her husband drinking, knocking her around, being a dick, and then we read a page or two of her telling us her husband has been drinking, knocking her around, and being a dick. Ugh. This book didn’t need to be anywhere close to 370 pages long. This entire section is absurdly repetitive.

McFarland, the dude with the Shining, is less of a character and more of a plot device - so much so that you could say this character IS the plot because without him there is no book. He happens to have an extremely contrived connection to the Baileys and he just happens to recommend Bobby Bailey for the Prometheus project and he just happens to have the Shining which helps resolve the whole story that he set in motion. I just found everything about this character far too convenient.

We also never find out what drove Tom Bailey (the abusive husband/father) looney tunes. We’re told that he lost it in the war, when he was a German interpreter for the Allies, so, when we finally get to that part of the book with Tom discovering the Nazi scientists� lab and what they’ve been doing, I thought we’d see the descent into madness - but no. He’s basically crackers from the get-go. What a rubbish, anticlimactic cop-out.

I will say that I was always impressed with Barry Windsor-Smith’s black and white art. As near-comatose with boredom as I was while reading most of it, I always found something to appreciate with the artwork. I particularly loved the scene with Jan Bailey and Jack Powell in the rain - you really feel the power of the rain and to draw in black and white convincing wetness is really something. And parts of the fall of Schongau were mildly interesting - how the surviving Nazi scientist came to be the only survivor had some actually compelling moments.

Still, I can’t recommend this bland block of a book. It’s nowhere close to entertaining, has nothing to say, and the overwritten pages were always dreary to read. Barry Windsor-Smith is an incredibly talented artist but not much of a writer or storyteller - that was the case back in the �80s and he’s not gotten any better since. Monsters is a monster-sized book but also unfortunately monstrously dull.
74 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Monsters.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Started Reading
May 28, 2021 – Shelved
May 28, 2021 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-14 of 14 (14 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Drew Canole Great review Sam!


message 2: by Sam (new) - rated it 2 stars

Sam Quixote Thanks!


Soteralzobooks As usual, a very thorough and eloquent review by Sam. Although I must admit that I tend to concur with Sam on some of the points that were raised, I have to say that, read and taken in in small doses at a time, I nonetheless enjoyed reading Monsters. I loved the art throughout and also give credit to the author for the meticulously elaborated story, which to me generated a genuine mood and feel for the periods that the protagonist evolved in. A slow burn to be sure, but one that worked for me. However, again I do see what Sam meant with the observations and points raised.


message 4: by Sam (new) - rated it 2 stars

Sam Quixote Thanks man. Are you a Hulk fan?


Soteralzobooks Well, I can’t say that I dislike it since I have never read any Hulk. I am always game to take on good recommendations quality though! Feel free to send me any. You appear to have read quite a wide range of comics and graphic novels! Generally speaking, I want to think that I tend to favour non-superhero options, although I have read some favourites in the past 30-35 years (off the top of my head: Batman Year One, DKR, The Killing Joke, Arkham Asylum, Marvels, Kingdom Come, Long Halloween, Dark Victory, Superman for all seasons, Daredevil Yellow, Spider-Man Blue, Daredevil Man Without Fear and Electra by Miller, The Vision by Tom King).

By the way, you should know that because of you read/started reading Demon by Jason Shiga, Giant Days by Allison, Loneliness of a cartoonist and Killing and Dying by Tomine, and others that don’t come to mind right this minute. Thanks for those off the beaten path reccos!

Also, and I think you may already have given positive opinions on those, what do you think of: Alberto Breccia, John Porcellino, Paco Roca, Richard Sala, etc?


Soteralzobooks Ah yeah, I had forgot the that I also read the following superhero “favourites�: Harleen by Sepjic, DD Born Again, Watchmen, V for Vendetta, Ultimate Spiderman Vol. 1 by Bendis.


Soteralzobooks *** had forgotten that� (sorry, runaway auto-correct function here�)


message 8: by Sam (new) - rated it 2 stars

Sam Quixote Hulk-wise, I'd rec Mark Waid's run starting with Indestructible Hulk, Volume 1: Agent of S.H.I.E.L.D. and the one-off Marvel Knights: Hulk: Transformè as some of the best Hulk comics I've read.

Glad you found Shiga, Allison and Tomine - those guys are geniuses! Never heard of Alberto Breccia. I've tried John Porcellino but could never get through his way-too-wordy comics. Paco Roca is a fine cartoonist but his comics are so boring. Richard Sala is hit or miss but I like his overall aesthetic. Delphine and The Hidden are his best comics.


Soteralzobooks Well noted, I will look for those two Hulk titles. Thanks Sam! Were you thinking of those because some similarities with the topic of Monsters by BWS?
Thanks for your other comments about the indie authors. Unfortunately, finding copies of The Hidden and Delphine appears quite difficult. I will keep looking


Soteralzobooks Also, do you recommend any books by either Michael DeForge or Jason?


Soteralzobooks Alberto Breccia was an Argentine artist that did work with famed and censored author Oesterheld, especially during the troubled period of the 1950s-70s, such as Mort Cinder, The Eternaut, Perramus, Chtulhu Mythos, etc� I find him to be a great artist.


Soteralzobooks Do you by any chance read French? As there are a plethora of excellent comics, graphic novels and bandes-dessinées out there, mainly published in France, Belgium and Switzerland. It is a whole different expansion to the comics world. A bit like the manga world too!


Soteralzobooks One quick last question regarding Giant Days: I did purchase the first three volumes of the “Not On The Test� edition, which I find quite well done. I am a bit of a sucker for nice hardcover editions. Do you whether they will ever publish those editions to finish off the series and include the TPB vol. 7 to 14, plus the specials?


message 14: by Sam (new) - rated it 2 stars

Sam Quixote Apparently Monsters started life as a Hulk origin story back in the '80s but, over the years, I guess Marvel lost interest in BWS's book or something so he changed it to what it is today.

I haven't read any good DeForge books but I can recommend nearly all of Jason's books. Jason is so good, it's easier to list the two books of his I didn't like than to point out the ones of his I loved - I didn't think much of Jason Conquers America or Good Night, Hem. Otherwise, you can't go wrong with this guy - he's one of the best.

I don't read French but a number of French comics make it into English. Not sure about the Not on the Test editions.


back to top