ŷ

Nataliya's Reviews > Borne

Borne by Jeff VanderMeer
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
3672777
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: 2021-reads

“We all just want to be people, and none of us know what that really means.�
It’s a weird story, off-kilter and bizarre, of a world so surreal and fragile, almost like a fever dream, an unsettling hallucination precariously teetering on the edge of a nightmare and occasionally dipping into sheer insanity.
“The real reality is something we create every moment of every day, that realities spin off from our decisions in every second we've alive.�
Imagine a nightmarish ruined city which is yet so alive and full of strange biotech from the Company (nothing good can ever come out of a company named “The Company�) � a city ruled and terrorized by a monstrous colossal Godzilla-scale flying bear and its smaller bloodthirsty “proxies�, where a Magician (who mutilates feral children into mutant killers) is wrestling for control with that godlike bear, “autonomous meat� can sometimes be found hanging out in the streets, with poisonous river running through it, scavengers scouring the streets trying to survive, and local biotech fauna including medical worms, attack beetles and alcohol minnows. If you want to survive, you hide and set traps and hope you don’t get mauled.
“In the city, the line between nightmare and reality was fluid, just as the context of the words killer and death had shifted over time.�



“Come close, I could smell the brine, rising in a wave, and for a moment there was no ruined city around me, no search for food and water, no roving gangs and escaped, altered creatures of unknown origin or intent. No mutilated, burned bodies dangling from broken streetlamps.�

This is the place where Rachel, a scavenger for biotech and food, with little memory of how she got to the City, and Wick, a biotech maker and drug dealer, add a new member to their makeshift family � the titular Borne, “like a hybrid of sea anemone and squid: a sleek vase with rippling colors that strayed from purple toward deep blues and sea greens�, not quite a plant and not quite an animal and definitely not human � but certainly a person. And maybe a weapon � because persons can also be weapons, can’t they?
“That’s the problem with people who are not human. You can’t tell how badly they’re hurt, or how much they need your help, and until you ask, they don’t always know how to tell you.�
It’s a strange world, indeed.
—ĔĔ�

Strange setup aside, the story is actually pretty simple and straightforward. What makes it stand out, though, is a focus on unusual and yet deeply familiar to us humans parental bond (“I mourned the child I had known who was kind and sweet and curious, and yet could not stop killing�) as Rachel finds herself basically an interspecies adopted mother to Borne, with the love and sacrifice and heartbreak that go along with it. Borne is a person that makes Rachel see beauty in devastation and brings purpose to the world of survival. It hurts seeing a child grow up too quickly as innocence, of course, cannot last.
“I’d been teaching him the whole time, with every last little thing I did, even when I didn’t realize I was teaching him.�

And so what if living creatures sometimes disappear when Borne is around?


“That was the moment I knew I’d decided to trade my safety for something else. That was the moment. And no matter what happened next, I had crossed over into another place, and the question wasn’t who I should trust but who should trust me.�

Another theme that struck a chord with me is not just the mother-child relationship between Rachel and Borne but also a tenuous, fraught relationship between Rachel and her partner Wick. Initially it seemed like a alliance of convenience, made for resources and survival and need for companionship, but along the way it slowly developed into something a bit more, an actual partnership and a bond that survives the tumult of Borne and the City and deceit and family dysfunction.
—ĔĔ�

What makes a person is a question at the heart of this book, as well as the allures and perils of parenthood and parental bond, and it’s explored constantly � even to the point where it gets to be a little bit of a metaphorical dead-horse-beating situation. But what rescues it from the occasional veering into macabre Hallmark-ish territory is constant injections of weirdness where VanderMeer doesn’t hold back in creating the hellscape of the setting. I can’t help but feel parallels with Stephen King’s Dark Tower Mid-World with its post apocalyptic alternate-reality afterlife-like atmosphere, and Strugatsky brothers “Roadside Picnic� with the monstrous strangeness and toxicity, and a bit of Miéville’s New Crobuzon, and, of course, VanderMeer’s own “Annihilation� with all of the above. Plot to me was really secondary to the exploration of this world’s entrancing toxic strangeness.
“He knew now that he could be harmed. He knew now that he was vulnerable. No joy would be the same for Borne. No playfulness, either. Because behind it would be this certain knowledge: that he could die.�

Perfect this book certainly isn’t. There are quite a few plot threads that led nowhere, and a lot of strangeness that was hinted at but never really explored ((view spoiler)), not to mention the completely anticlimactic presence of (view spoiler). But the atmosphere made up for plot shortcomings and overall I enjoyed the weekend spent in the company of Borne and Co.
“Those are three dead skeletons on the wall, Borne.�
“Yes, Rachel. I took them from the crossroads. I thought they would look nice in here.�

4 stars.

—ĔĔĔ—�
Recommended by: Britton
140 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Borne.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

June 12, 2021 – Started Reading
June 12, 2021 – Shelved
June 12, 2021 –
15.0% "That was the moment I knew I’d decided to trade my safety for something else. That was the moment. And no matter what happened next, I had crossed over into another place, and the question wasn’t who I should trust but who should trust me."
June 13, 2021 –
29.0% "He knew now that he could be harmed. He knew now that he was vulnerable. No joy would be the same for Borne. No playfulness, either. Because behind it would be this certain knowledge: that he could die."
June 13, 2021 –
40.0% "That’s the problem with people who are not human. You can’t tell how badly they’re hurt, or how much they need your help, and until you ask, they don’t always know how to tell you."
June 13, 2021 –
52.0% "I’d been teaching him the whole time, with every last little thing I did, even when I didn’t realize I was teaching him. With every last little thing I did, not just those things I tried to teach him. Every moment I had been teaching him, and how I wanted now to take back some of those moments."
June 14, 2021 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-33 of 33 (33 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Britton Can't wait to see what you think of this. I'll get started on Roadside Picnic.


Nataliya It’s very odd, in a good way. Stranger than “Annihilation�, and has Miéville undercurrents. And the giant bear makes me think of The Waste Lands by Stephen King.

I like it so far.

My brain keeps comparing this to other books I’ve read; I assume it’s because I don’t (yet) have a good grasp of VanderMeer’s style.


message 3: by Jon (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jon Von He has a short follow up Strange Bird that I really liked the audiobook of. The sequel Dead Astronauts is great, but they get much more psychedelic and surreal, such that Borne seems almost a model of restraint in the end. Liked them a lot though. Emily Zoo Weller is a great reader.


áܻ徱 I loved this book so much! The ending broke my heart.


Nicholas Perez So glad you enjoyed this, Nataliya! It was an emotional gut punch for me.


Blue Great review! Yeah, I enjoyed Borne, too. Yet to read Strange Bird and Dead Astronauts. (Ah, good to hear EZW is reading the audiobook; I really like her as a reader, too.) I rather enjoy the meandering, not always-purposeful plot structure. I was a bit disappointed that there were no fungi/mushrooms in this one, though :) ha ha!


Nataliya Jon wrote: "He has a short follow up Strange Bird that I really liked the audiobook of. The sequel Dead Astronauts is great, but they get much more psychedelic and surreal, such that Borne seems almost a model..."

He has a sequel about Dead Astronauts? Huh. I guess that was a pretty weird tidbit from the book that’s tempting to explore.


Nataliya áܻ徱 wrote: "I loved this book so much! The ending broke my heart."

Yeah, it was definitely bittersweet.


Nataliya Nicholas wrote: "So glad you enjoyed this, Nataliya! It was an emotional gut punch for me."

I was worried about it a bit as Annihilation was the only VanderMeer I’ve read before, and although I liked it, it was still a bit of a mixed bag. This one was easier to like, although with some of the same issues � but it may be just VanderMeer’s style and approach to the weird.

I gotta say - the whole “couple fights over a new kid� setup with Borne changing the lives of Rachel and Wick was both sad and strangely funny.


Nataliya Blue wrote: "Great review! Yeah, I enjoyed Borne, too. Yet to read Strange Bird and Dead Astronauts. (Ah, good to hear EZW is reading the audiobook; I really like her as a reader, too.) I rather enjoy the meand..."

Thanks, Blue! But - mushrooms? I’m missing the connection here, although they are great on pizza :)


message 11: by Sofia (new) - added it

Sofia Wonderful review! 💛


message 12: by Reshteen (new) - added it

Reshteen Great review! It promises of lots and lots weirdness.
I still haven't gotten around to reading Hummingbird Salamander. Life!!


message 13: by Blue (new) - rated it 5 stars

Blue Nataliya wrote: "Blue wrote: "Great review! Yeah, I enjoyed Borne, too. Yet to read Strange Bird and Dead Astronauts. (Ah, good to hear EZW is reading the audiobook; I really like her as a reader, too.) I rather en..."

Oh only because I like VanderMeer's earlier work, like in City of Saints and Madmen, which have a lot to do with mushrooms/fungi, etc. (Also, I'm a yeast fan [as a genetic model organism]. I know, too nerdy...)


Vivian Ahhh, pretty sure that dangling first spoiler is explored in Dead Astronauts, so more of a teaser, actually both if I'm recalling correctly. But,yeah, I get the frustration of the open-endedness of those two.


Nataliya Sofia wrote: "Wonderful review! 💛"

Thanks, Sofia! It’s a fun book that definitely makes me want to read more VanderMeer.


Nataliya Reshteen wrote: "Great review! It promises of lots and lots weirdness.
I still haven't gotten around to reading Hummingbird Salamander. Life!!"


I haven’t read that one either. So far I’ve only read this one and Annihilation by VanderMeer, but I’m curious to explore more of his work soon. “Hummingbird Salamander� sounds like a creature that would be right at home in Borne universe.


Nataliya Blue wrote: "Oh only because I like VanderMeer's earlier work, like in City of Saints and Madmen, which have a lot to do with mushrooms/fungi, etc."

Ok, that makes sense. I was worried that I somehow missed that mushroom connection :)


Nataliya Vivian wrote: "Ahhh, pretty sure that dangling first spoiler is explored in Dead Astronauts, so more of a teaser, actually both if I'm recalling correctly. But,yeah, I get the frustration of the open-endedness of..."

Ah, good. I’m glad that the loose ends get wrapped up. Was this meant to be the beginning of a series, I wonder, or did he decide to tidy up this universe later?


Gabrielle Great review Nataliya! And interesting comparaison with the Strugatsky brothers: I have a couple of their books on my summer reading pile, now I am extra-curious!


Nataliya Gabrielle wrote: "Great review Nataliya! And interesting comparaison with the Strugatsky brothers: I have a couple of their books on my summer reading pile, now I am extra-curious!"

Thanks, Gabrielle! It’s the second time VanderMeer makes me think of Strugatsky brothers. The strongest similarities were in Annihilation � such strong vibes of Roadside Picnic, and this one made me think of that book again. I’m rereading Roadside Picnic now, as a matter of fact.


Gabrielle I have a copy of "Roadside Picinic", I'll start with that one!


Nataliya Gabrielle wrote: "I have a copy of "Roadside Picinic", I'll start with that one!"

Great choice! I’m reading in side by side in English and Russian, so it will be my first time experiencing it in translation. I hope the magic carries over into a different language.


Gabrielle Nataliya wrote: "Great choice! I’m reading in side by side in English and Russian, so it will be my first time experiencing it in t..."

It's always tricky with translations! I look forward to your thoughts on it! My edition was translated by Olena Bormashenko; hopefully, she does it justice :-)


message 24: by Nataliya (last edited Jun 16, 2021 11:00AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Nataliya Gabrielle wrote: "Nataliya wrote: "Great choice! I’m reading in side by side in English and Russian, so it will be my first time experiencing it in t..."

It's always tricky with translations! I look forward to your..."


I got that edition as well, with Bormashenko’s translation. The foreword is by Ursula K. Le Guin, which was the deciding factor for me when it came to choosing the translations (although I also have an old one by Antonina Bouis - but I think I’ll skip it unless I find something egregiously awful in Bormashenko’s translation).


message 25: by Mundy (new) - added it

Mundy Reimer Oh shoot! I came across this in a book store a few years ago and totally forgot about it while prioritizing other stuff! Wacky biology is totally my jam, and VanderMeer's Southern Reach trilogy was awesome. I love the mother-child thematic notes as it reminds me of something like the Alien franchise. I think your review has gotten me hooked once more, and I'm putting this on my list, so thanks!


Nataliya Mundy wrote: "Oh shoot! I came across this in a book store a few years ago and totally forgot about it while prioritizing other stuff! Wacky biology is totally my jam, and VanderMeer's Southern Reach trilogy was..."

Well, I’m glad I put this book back on your radar! Wacky biology is definitely abundant here (although not in a sciencey way but in a delightfully weird way nevertheless). Plus I found it to be a very easy read as well. And mother-child notes are definitely strong with this one, ranging from poignant to actually funny.

I still need to complete Southern Reach trilogy at some point. So far I stopped at Annihilation because it worked very well as a standalone, but I’m getting curious to see how it ends after my second exposure to VanderMeer ended up a success.


message 27: by Mundy (new) - added it

Mundy Reimer Yeah, thanks for putting it back on my list!

The rest of the Southern Reach books didn't give me the same level of suspense + thriller feelings as the first one, but some of the ideas were pretty interesting, especially wrt the origins of certain things mentioned in the 1st novel. If you particularly like the feeling of completeness, or just need something to read, I'd check them out!


Nataliya Mundy wrote: "Yeah, thanks for putting it back on my list!

The rest of the Southern Reach books didn't give me the same level of suspense + thriller feelings as the first one, but some of the ideas were pretty..."


I’ll keep it in mind. My inner completionist wasn’t particularly anxious about that series since the first book seemed pretty complete on its own.


message 29: by Gaurav (new) - added it

Gaurav Sagar Excellent review, Nataliya, the book looks intriguing. The question of what constitutes a man makes this book all the more enticing. Thanks for sharing, adding it :)


Nataliya Gaurav wrote: "Excellent review, Nataliya, the book looks intriguing. The question of what constitutes a man makes this book all the more enticing. Thanks for sharing, adding it :)"

Thanks, Gaurav! It’s a pretty good story, with personhood not being restricted to humanity at the heart of it. I tend to be quite partial to such stories.


message 31: by Chrissie (new)

Chrissie Whitley Wonderful review! I still have yet to pick up a VanderMeer, but I need to clearly.


Nataliya Chrissie wrote: "Wonderful review! I still have yet to pick up a VanderMeer, but I need to clearly."

Thanks, Chrissie! I’ve only read two books by VanderMeer - this one and Annihilation - and this one, from my limited experience, seems like a good one to start with.


message 33: by Chrissie (last edited Jul 17, 2021 11:57AM) (new)

Chrissie Whitley Nataliya wrote: "Chrissie wrote: "Wonderful review! I still have yet to pick up a VanderMeer, but I need to clearly."

Thanks, Chrissie! I’ve only read two books by VanderMeer - this one and [book:Annihilation|1793..."


Oh, thank you! Noted.


back to top