Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs's Reviews > Island

Island by Aldous Huxley
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
70395042
's review

liked it

When I was a kid I was mercilessly mocked by bullies, because of my introspective passivity. When I was confined to a hospital in my early twenties, the doctors wanted to lift the rocks of my dozy subconscious to uncover my own nightcrawlers.

Trouble was, my only nightcrawlers were the bullies - among whose number these physicians were simply the latest professional examples. But they had blurred their confused ethical lines - and I just liked to be left alone to dream.

Dreamers are good for the soul of humankind. But nowadays, no one shows the slightest interest in dreamers' spiritual sides. Writers, doctors and scientists only want to show you how simple it is to find your spiritual happiness WITHIN the ersatz nirvana of our utopian world.

Nice try, guys. That utopia is glaringly dystopian.

Why even bother?

Such, however is Aldous Huxley in this book. Get this - he thinks nirvana is EASY with chemicals and clinical know-how. He's bought the whole bill of goods.
***

Laura Archera Huxley, Aldous' second wife, wrote a stunningly candid biographical study of their life together amid the coolly intellectual ambience of their South California Hollywood home. It's called This Timeless Moment, and it's revelatory.

She describes in it how she interested him in the supernatural and occult.

She was a firm believer, in her new-agey way, in the afterlife. So when Aldous received a shocking diagnosis of terminal throat cancer in the early sixties, they agreed to try an experiment:

Aldous would send a message, any message, after he passed away to let her know the afterlife was a fact.

And sure enough, shortly after he died, Laura received a personal message, to whit: go to the main bookshelf, third row from bottom, and take the second book from the right. Laura followed the instructions, and came to a book entitled Eternity is Real (or that’s the general idea, as my faulty memory now dictates).

And so what? We believers already knew our "hearts will go on."
***

Now, I said previously that I’m a dreamer. Like Huxley was becoming, too, under the warming influence of his new wife. A second childhood? Except he retained all his traditional intellectual pursuits: modern science, technology and medicine.

So what happens when you combine your playful dreaming with serious intelligence? Well, you get a mishmash - an intellectual smorgasboard of irrelevant arcane trivia, pop thinking, and new age religion - LIKE THIS BOOK.

You see, we can’t take this book seriously. The plot never really progresses, the characters possess no reality, and the religion is flakey and half-baked.
***

Back in the semester of 1972/73, I belonged to my university Choral Society, though I couldn’t sight-read. I needed the credit that went with the contribution of my feeble voice.

Anyway, my fellow singers were either college professors out to unwind a bit, music majors, or intellectual flyweights with golden voices. And I was none of the above. A misfit in the larger academic world, I would take books to our rehearsals.

This was the book I lugged with me that winter.

Quite frankly, I considered it an utter dud. It just didn’t work at any level. I had read Brave New World in high school, but Huxley seemed to have lowered the bar to ankle level with this one.

And now, fifty years later, I read other people’s reviews here on GR and find my discontent verified objectively.

It’s NOT among his best.
***

Did you know Huxley died of mouth cancer the same day C. S. Lewis died of his routine surgery?

Which man, you might wonder, was the wiser of the two?. In other words, which man died within sight of his eternal home in Heaven?

I'll let you guess.

Make believe and disingenuous guys must Face the Fire First!
271 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Island.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
June 13, 2021 – Shelved

Comments Showing 1-28 of 28 (28 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Tg (new)

Tg "Philosophy is not enough Religion is not enough, nothing short of everything will really do " Island

"As luck would have it, Providence was on our side " Island

A complex difficult at times book to read, but it does have some profound thoughts

"If I ceased to behave as what I think I am, I would know who in fact I am; what in fact I am; if only the insulated Manichee that I think I am would allow me to know it: is the reconciliation of yes and No lived out in total acceptance, and the blessed experience of not-two " Island


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs Wow, Tg - you're right! Those excerpts ARE good. My only argument is with the juxtaposition of the profound with the facile: that seems an accepting nod to pop culture - the opposite to Brave New World. But you're so right insofar as Huxley had forsaken irony in order to embrace positive social and personal change!


message 3: by Misty (new)

Misty Brilliant!


message 5: by Kevin (new)

Kevin Ansbro I'm sorry to learn that you were on the receiving end of childhood bullying, Fergus. Your introspective passivity has served you well, nonetheless, my friend!


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs I think you're right, Kevin - without such introspection and a dogged determination to persevere I probably would never have found peace in my retirement. A lucky guy for sure!


message 7: by Tg (new)

Tg Thanks Fergus... Keep Soldiering on.........


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs My boots are made for walking, as Nancy Sinatra said! Thanks, Tg.


message 9: by Teresa (new)

Teresa Wonderful review as always Fergus. I learned two new words this time:) My son was bullied mercilessly in college by a guy he had gone to secondary school with and they had been friends. That guy was buried last week. They say forgive your enemies but there was no one crying in our house!!!


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs Sometimes happens that it takes years to clear away the pain! I found that when my own attitude improved noticeably wrt to a person, a prayer of thanks helped ease the residual pain.


message 11: by Tg (new)

Tg Thanks for sharing your trials and triumphs Fergus

"Real Joy believe me is a stern matter; who can contemplate the endurance of pain ? look on death with a cheerful and carefree countenance ? , and there is no cheerfulness like the resolution of a brave mind that has fortune at its feet " Seneca


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs That’s a wonderful quote, Tg - and you’re quite welcome! GR has provided me for a venue for a personal catharsis of sorts. I’ve come out of it sobered and straitened!


message 13: by Tg (new)

Tg Well done......


message 14: by Laysee (new)

Laysee I appreciate your insightful take of this book and personal sharing. Thank you, Fergus. This is a remarkable review.


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs Thanks so much, Laysee! For years I was reluctant to tell friends that this book was a non-starter, as I feared the prevailing permissiveness of the seventies would shout me down.


message 16: by Kristy (new) - added it

Kristy I was also bullied and then mostly ignored in school. I can sympathize with being bullied, though as a girl it wasn't physical, ostracizing and whispered lies. I took solace in books and excelling in academics.
I was diagnosed with a genetic disease at 14 (grade 9), and spent a lot of time in and out of hospitals, first a year of testing, and then many pneumonias throughout high school and into university. It's a very lonely existence when your best friends end up being nurses that you only see when you are extremely ill. I agree that doctors can be bullies. I've learned to deal with them. They don't like it much, ha.
I haven't read this book, but it sounds like Huxley missed out on the fun of being an outcast? I can't stand "new age" stuff. As to reaching nirvana, it must depend on which chemicals you take, and your state of mind when you take them. In my opinion anyway, I don't have much experience in this area either so it's mostly a guess. Anything taken as an antidepressant or antipsychotic isn't the way to go in my experience. Maybe painkillers if you take more than the recommended dose, but I wouldn't recommend that. Okay I've rambled enough.


message 17: by Tg (new)

Tg "Bravery is the only impregnable fortress for our mortal weakness, believe me; true Joy is a stern matter; to contemplate the endurance of pain, to view troubles calmly, we will have reached the heights once we have determined what we find Joy in, and have not placed our Happiness in control of externals and worthless things,
and there is no Cheerfulness like the Resolution of a Brave mind that has placed Fortune at its feet " Seneca Epistles


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs Tg has just let Seneca answer your question, Kristy. Life has been hell for both of us. Like Seneca says, my answer was to radically downsize my life. Think little! That's our hope for happiness. Who CARES what the World says, anyway?
Thanks so much to both of you! You put the heart back in my day.


message 19: by Tg (new)

Tg Thanks Fergus. .I appreciate your thoughtful reviews and compassionate heart.....blessings and Peace to Kristy too...


message 21: by Tg (new)

Tg To Kristy.... "We are astonished when we find children who have triumphed over their Misfortunes " Dr. Boris Cyrulink


H (no longer expecting notifications) Balikov It's good to have verification, but you knew what you knew already, Fergus


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs Even better, H: I knew what I knew back then! My doddering old memory is now porous as a sieve... Alas.


H (no longer expecting notifications) Balikov Fergus wrote: "Even better, H: I knew what I knew back then! My doddering old memory is now porous as a sieve... Alas."

Yes, the fate of all flesh


message 25: by Josephine (new)

Josephine Briggs Interesting review. If I read Huxley I've forgotten his books. But it all does seem strange about Huxley telling his wife to pick a certain book. Oh well, I don't know what to think. Your reviews are so interesting.


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs Yeah, that story flummoxed me, too! His second wife was keen on such proofs of the paranormal, though.


message 27: by Taufiq (new)

Taufiq Yves Wow, that's a really powerful personal connection you have with this book. Thank you for sharing your experiences, Fergus.


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs Oh, and you’re quite welcome! And you have made my day. As a bipolar kid, life was hard as nails, so I see easily through flimsy conclusions such as Huxley drew! The Devils of Loudon is much the better book.


back to top