Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Roman Clodia's Reviews > ³¢'鱹é²Ô±ð³¾±ð²Ô³Ù

³¢'鱹é²Ô±ð³¾±ð²Ô³Ù by Annie Ernaux
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
56111743
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: women-in-translation

... les choses me sont arrivées pour que j'en rende compte. Et le véritable but de ma vie est peut-être seulement celui-ci: que mons corps, mes sensations, et mes pensées deviennent de l'écriture.

... these things happened to me so that I might account for/realise them. And the true purpose of my life is perhaps only this: that my body, my feelings and my thoughts become writing.

Make no mistake, this is an unflinching account by Ernaux of a pivotal and horrific experience: as a twenty-three year old student in 1963 she found herself pregnant from a fleeting relationship, in a France where abortion was illegal and a criminal act. Anyone squeamish needs to be warned that Ernaux, with her usual unwavering and fearless gaze, doesn't shy away from the physical details of knitting needles, probes, induced miscarriage and the bloody results.

But none of this is either prurient or sensationalist. As the quotation above indicates, Ernaux has appointed herself the witness and creator of testimony for generations of women whose experiences have been secret, made to feel shameful, hidden and not acknowledged, perhaps sometimes, for various reasons, even by themselves.

One of the key points made here is how isolated Ernaux was during this desperate experience, forced into hiding it from her parents, with medical practitioners wary of the illegal status of her actions, and even being shouted at by a surgeon when rushed into hospital haemorrhaging.

So while this is a personal and subjective testimony, it also looks forward to Ernaux's The Years, a kind of group or generational biography that switches between the individual and the social. In some ways, Ernaux is speaking for women as a multiple, and is self-conscious of the circulation of gendered power in this story as overwhelmingly male lawmakers and physicians are gatekeepers to the experiences undergone by female bodies.

As always, Ernaux's writing is lucid and precise, and marked by its almost pellucid quality (so much so that I've switched to reading her in French). I can't put my finger on the particular alchemy of Ernaux's vision and prose but despite a significant age gap between us (she was born in 1940), she manages to hold up a mirror to women's lives and we see ourselves there.
59 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read ³¢'鱹é²Ô±ð³¾±ð²Ô³Ù.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

June 20, 2021 – Shelved
June 26, 2021 – Started Reading
June 26, 2021 –
page 0
0.0% "Je suis décendue à Barbès. Comme la dernière fois, des hommes attendaient, groupés au pied du Métro aérien."
June 26, 2021 –
37.0% "'Un lundi, je suis revenue de chez eux avec une paire d'aiguilles à tricoter que j'avais achetées, un été, pour me faire une veste, restée inachevée. De grandes aiguilles, bleu électrique. Je n'avais pas de solution. J'avais décidé d'agir seule.'"
June 27, 2021 –
53.0% "'Je ne sais pas encore quels mots me viendront. Je ne sais pas ce que l'ecriture fait arriver.'"
June 27, 2021 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-2 of 2 (2 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Paula Mota You're totally right. Although it's a personal account it's also a collective experience of women who went through it. It's brutal at places, but it's a much needed brutality to convey the angst and the suffering.


Roman Clodia Thanks, Paula - and yes, it's distressing that the right to abortion is still such a contested one and that women today may be experiencing the same things that Ernaux went through 60 years ago. One can't help thinking that if men got pregnant...


back to top