ŷ

Hanneke's Reviews > The Innocents Abroad

The Innocents Abroad by Mark Twain
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
17944903
's review

it was amazing

According to what I gathered at Wikipedia, the extensive voyage that Mark Twain, then age 32, took aboard the pleasure cruiser ‘Quaker City� took about five months. I was surprised about that relatively short time period because when reading about all those sights and extensive excursions you feel that it must have taken such a longer period of time. To me, it felt like the journey must have taken at least a year. All 65 passengers on board had never been to Europe before. In contrast, the Europeans had only seen an occasional American now and then, so the Americans themselves were considered quite a sight as well.

Mark Twain was sponsored by a local newspaper in exchange for travel newsletters which the paper then published. These travel letters were later compiled into the travelogue ‘The Innocents Abroad�.

The excursions inland all along the Mediterrean coast from Gibraltar to Egypt sometimes took Mark Twain and his small group of ship companions of about 6 people weeks away from the port where the ship was docked. I suppose it was a try-out of a new form of tourist travel where the participants stayed on the same vessel and thus were provided with accommodation aboard for the whole journey with quite a choice of optional excursions organized into the countries where the ship docked at that time. These excursions would sometimes take weeks and seemed to have been organized very professionally with train and hotel reservations to whatever the American tourists desired to see. Twain and his small group took a long trip to Paris, returned to the ship and subsequently docked again in Genoa, then took a train to Milan, on to Venice and subsequently to Florence and Rome, where they boarded their ship again to travel to the East.

I must confess that I have never read a Mark Twain novel before and I do not think I will in the future. I might consider one of his other travelogues, as I have two volumes of ‘A Tramp Abroad�. Mark Twain was a very witty writer and when the mood took him he wrote in a very beautiful style. However, I thought he was often quite unbearably grumpy and insulting and I was surprised that he felt no restriction to ventilate it in public and in writing. Granted, his insults were sometimes quite hilarious, but often quite demeaning. His likes and dislikes seemed to me to have no rational ground. Some cities he loved, like Paris, Venice and Istanbul, but lots of others he hated for no reason I could discern. And how about being always very demeaning to the local tourist guides hired, even getting so far to gang up with his little group of young men to purposely not listen to a guide who was showing them another world famous painting, thereby looking the other way and acting like they did not know who Michelangelo was. He hated most of Italy and by the time his group arrived in Rome he declared he did not want to see another Raffael or Michelangelo ever again. Hated to see the Vatican, in fact hated the whole city. Throughout Italy, he showed his loathing when seeing the poverty and destitution of the crowds in the streets, especially in Naples, and he continued to ventilate that notion on his future trips east, coming to a climax in Syria and Palestine where he remarks that the people are so degenerated that they seem to be walking skeletons and the only sound they can make is asking for bakshees. Well, the novel was written more than 150 years ago, but still I felt very uncomfortable to read his ranting remarks.

I could go into details about all the sites Twain visited, but the list is long. I am only glad and relieved to report that in the end he was smitten with Egypt, the pyramids and the Sphinx because I would have taken it very seriously against him if he had nasty remarks about those ancient sites. I feared for the worst, seeing how he had abhorred Palestine, all the so-called holy sites and was not impressed by Jerusalem.

Don’t get me wrong, I certainly enjoyed to read the reports of his excursions, as it was very interesting to hear in what condition the sites were in 1867 as I have seen most of the places he visited, except for the Crimea and Syria. This proved to be a travelogue like no other and you will surely remember having read what he told about it when seeing the places yourself in this day and age.
58 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Innocents Abroad.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

June 25, 2021 – Started Reading
June 25, 2021 – Shelved
June 25, 2021 – Shelved as: to-read
July 9, 2021 –
page 149
20.61%
July 18, 2021 –
page 210
29.05%
July 27, 2021 –
page 311
43.02%
July 27, 2021 –
page 311
43.02%
July 27, 2021 –
page 311
43.02%
July 27, 2021 –
page 311
43.02%
July 28, 2021 –
page 313
43.29% "Mr Twain is getting fed-up in Rome: “From the sanguinary sports of the Holy Inquisition; the Slaughter of the Coliseum; and the dismal tombs of the Catacombs, I naturally pass to the picturesque horrors of the Capuchin Convent. These decorations were in every instance formed of human bones: pyramids built wholly of grinning skulls, structures built of shin-bones and arm bones, flowers made of kneecaps and toenails."
August 4, 2021 –
page 386
53.39%
August 5, 2021 –
page 477
65.98%
August 8, 2021 –
page 496
68.6% "Oh dear, oh dear, Mr Twain should not have taken this desert trip through Syria:
‘Broke camp at 7 a.m. and made a ghastly trip through the Zeb Dana valley and the rough mountains - horses limping and that Arab screech-owl that does most of the singing and carries the water-skins, away a thousand miles ahead of course, and no water to drink - will he never die?"
August 10, 2021 –
page 573
79.25% "Twain is visiting the site of the Annunciation of Maria in Nazareth:
� I could sit off several thousand miles and imagine the angel appearing with shadowing wings and lustrous countenance and note the glory that streamed downwards upon the Virgin’s head while the message of the Throne of God fell upon her ears - any one can do that, beyond the ocean, but few can do it here."
August 15, 2021 –
page 629
87.0% "(Jerusalem) The strangest thing about the incident that has made Veronica’s name so famous is that when she wiped the perspiration away, the print of the Saviour’s face remained on the handkerchief, a perfect portrait, and so remains unto this day. We knew this because we saw this handkerchief in a cathedral in Paris, another in Spain and in two others in Italy. In the Milan cathedral it costs five France to see it."
August 17, 2021 –
page 382
52.84% "Twain’s reaction at seeing the Spfinx at Gizeh feels similar like my own:
‘It was looking over and beyond everything of the present and far into the past. It was gazing out over the ocean of Time - over lines of century-waves which, further and further receding, closed nearer and nearer together and blended at last into one unbroken tide, away toward the horizon of remote antiquity, of empires created and destroyed."
August 19, 2021 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-42 of 42 (42 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Jenna (new)

Jenna ❤ ❀  ❤ Excellent review, Hanneke! This sounds very interesting. It sounds funny now to think that most Europeans at that time had never seen an American!


message 2: by Hanneke (last edited Aug 19, 2021 06:59AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Hanneke Thanks, Jenna dear! I had to grin now and then that a lot of Europeans thought America was just a tiny country somewhere in an obscure region. Made Twain furious to hear it!


message 3: by Michael (last edited Aug 19, 2021 11:01AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Michael Perkins Twain is one of my favorite authors, but this is definitely not one of his best books. I don't really like it myself. His curmudgeon side is on full display which, as you say, is tiresome. Roughing It, which focuses on the America West and Hawaii, is his best travel book.

You might want to give this a try, before trying his novels.

/book/show/2...


Michael Perkins I'm currently reading Proust and loving every minute. There was a recent, big article on Proust in the New Yorker. This is a quote from the article...

"The one thing that Proust’s mature literary manner is not is mannered. It was as natural and unimpeded as Mark Twain’s."

I think this gives a sense of how Twain writes as his best. I would rank Innocents Abroad as one of his worst books.


TBV (on hiatus) Excellent review, Hanneke. I have this book and I look forward to reading it.


message 6: by Hanneke (last edited Aug 20, 2021 12:51AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Hanneke Michael, I hope you don’t feel bad about my remarks on this travelogue since you say that he is one of your favorite authors. I was not expecting all those very negative judgements of his. I can take a lot, but I feel that he was often quite cruel and heartless in what he describes and it amazed me that he seemed to have gotten away with it at that time. I have no idea, of course, if those views were considered normal then, but I think at any time lots of his remarks were quite overboard.


Hanneke TBV, thanks. I am really curious what you will think of the book. Please let me know when you read it, please!


message 8: by Ilse (new)

Ilse Sounds intriguing, to say the least, Hanneke! A good rant can be amusing (I love the letters of Flaubert), but it might be more telling on the one who is fulminating than on the ones who are subject to his grumpiness.


message 9: by Hanneke (last edited Aug 20, 2021 10:22AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Hanneke Ilse, he was downright insulting, especially to the desert people of Syria and Palestine, even going so far as as a group to fire off their guns while on horseback in the desert just to show their superiority. I just did not get where his aggression was based upon. I surely would not have appreciated his company!


Michael Perkins Americans can be very defensive about their country. I don't think Twain was an exception. He came from humble beginnings and did well, obviously. But I think his reactionary side comes out, big time, in this book.


Michael Perkins This is from the travel memoir by Anthony Trollope's mother, who went to the U.S. in the 1820's...

“A single word indicative of doubt, that any thing, or every thing, in that country is not the very best in the world, produces an effect which must be seen and felt to be understood. If the citizens of the United States were indeed the devoted patriots they call themselves, they would surely not thus encrust themselves in the hard, dry, stubborn persuasion, that they are the first and best of the human race, that nothing is to be learnt, but what they are able to teach, and that nothing is worth having, which they do not possess.�


Michael Perkins Charles Dickens encountered the same attitude when he traveled to America.


message 13: by Sketchbook (new) - added it

Sketchbook Very enjoyable review. I must get around to this one of these days....Wish you'd given some examples of his "insults." But, why not utter an insult? What's wrong with a rant or two ? Long ago I decided I would never again visit another church in Europe...much prefer theatres.


Hanneke Interesting, Michael, thanks. I am not surprised. As you read the travelogue, you probably remember that Twain now and then made a remark of comparison to situations in America, praising its cleanliness and better horses and the lack of tiresome art to look at.


message 15: by Hanneke (last edited Aug 23, 2021 06:22AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Hanneke Sketch, you know how I like insults and rants, but Twain was just being truly nasty and degrading too often, sounding like a spoiled 14 year old. The fact that he said a few times in his desert journey through Syria and Palestine that he abhorred the bedouins and would have actually liked to shoot some off if he had the chance really sounded pretty sick to me. He was not joking, you see, he considered them vermin. Perhaps you should read the book, Sketch, it is often very witty! Especially, his account of being invited by the Russian Czar and his family on holiday on the Crimea was a very strange tale. Shows you how curious people were to meet actual Americans at that time. Very enjoyable story.


Michael Perkins This same sense of American exceptionalism gets us into messes, such as Vietnam and Afghanistan. Instead of learning from history, we always think we can do better. Hubris.


message 17: by Hanneke (last edited Aug 24, 2021 07:48AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Hanneke Exactly so, Michael. It is the typical American thing that failures never really sink down. Because, indeed, what the hell were they doing in Vietnam and Iraq and Afghanistan. Worst thing was that Bush/Cheney threatened the European allies to go along with the madness. It makes people damn mad at the moment to have lost some 30 Dutch military men for nothing. Well, of course, that number is far greater in the U.S.


Michael Perkins My son was a teenager during the Bush/Cheney era and he asked: "what does the War of Terror" mean? He immediately saw it was an abstraction that could be used to justify forever wars and what turned out to be 20 years in Afghanistan.

"Oceania was at war with Eastasia. Oceania had always been at war with Eastasia.� -Orwell


message 19: by Hanneke (last edited Aug 26, 2021 04:10AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Hanneke Michael, yes, how appropriate to quote Orwell in this respect!


message 20: by Jaidee (new)

Jaidee I didn't know that Twain was an obnoxious twat Hanneke !

Very nice review. What a privilege to have the excursions he had !


message 21: by Hanneke (last edited Aug 27, 2021 12:11AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Hanneke Jaidee, I had no idea either. He could not have gotten away nowadays with lots of the obnoxious stuff he expressed.
As a European, it is not so special to have also visited Twain’s destinations. They are quite common places to have visited throughout vacation periods.


Michael Perkins I'm not sure typecasting Twain based on one of his worst books is accurate.


Hanneke Michael, you are so right to say that. I should not have done that. Nevertheless, he was quite out of order in this book in my opinion and that did not make me curious to read his other books.


message 24: by Ken (new) - rated it 3 stars

Ken Glad you liked this one. Any long trip like this would have been lightened to the extreme with Clemens as a fellow passenger. Among his travel books, I think this is second behind Roughing It (which really doesn't travel anywhere NEAR as far, but "travel" and the genre is fluid, no?).


message 25: by Hanneke (last edited Aug 28, 2021 05:00AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Hanneke Ken, thanks, I did find The Innocents Abroad actually very interesting and that’s why I gave it 5*. But that did not mean I came away with a fondness of Twain as a person and if that sounds strange and even not relevant since his travel stories were from 1867, it nevertheless gave an intimate insight in his personality.


message 26: by Ken (new) - rated it 3 stars

Ken A complex personality, the deeper you go into it!


Hanneke Ken, perhaps reading a biography of Twain would make very interesting reading. I might some day!


message 28: by Ken (new) - rated it 3 stars

Ken When the day comes, I would start with his Autobiography of Mark Twain: Volume 1, Reader's Edition, a combination of facts and "stretchers," as Twain calls lies.


Hanneke Thanks, Ken! Well, ‘stretching� he did not!


Michael Perkins Twain was a very progressive critic of U.S. imperialism as well as the British in the Boer War and invasion prompted by greed. He wrote the mocking War Prayer as a protest...




Michael Perkins He was also a severe critic of Christian hypocrisy...




message 35: by Linda (new)

Linda Interesting review!


message 37: by Hanneke (last edited Aug 29, 2021 04:29AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Hanneke Michael, thanks so much for your links. Yes, it was very clear reading the travelogue how Twain felt about anything religious. I thought it was really progressive of him to make a lot of really hilarious comments on religious outrages, especially in Italy. In fact, I quite agreed with him when he stated that the Catholic Church obviously owned Italy. Also how he made really harsh comments on what he saw in Palestine at all those so-called holy sites. Made me wonder why he took that long desert trip to see those sites at all, seeing how unreligious he was. His accounts must have scandalized people at that time, as surely they would nowadays with the American evangelicals.


Hanneke Thanks, Linda!


message 39: by Gaurav (new)

Gaurav Excellent review, Hanneke. I have not read anything by Twain but this one sounds intriguing :)


Hanneke Thank you, Gaurav. This was my one and only Twain too. Could you let me know what you think after you have read it? I often don’t notice since I don’t get any notifications anymore.


Connor I think someone should mention to you that his novels, and the voice he writes them in, are nothing like this travelogue. They're good too. I say this as your review says this book put you off wanting to try his novels. I would not draw any link between them myself.


message 42: by Hanneke (last edited Mar 14, 2022 06:28AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Hanneke Hi Connor, thanks for your comment. Well, what can I say. For the time being I think I’ll skip reading Mark Twain’s novels. I looked which ones you read and notice that you don’t rate those too high either. Please note that despite my adverse feelings towards his person, I did rate the travelogue with 5 stars.


back to top