Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Anne's Reviews > The Moonstone

The Moonstone by Wilkie Collins
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
1720620
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: audio, classics, hoopla, mystery, read-in-2021, favorites

Holy shit! This was actually funny and I was not expecting that at all.
It was a serialized story, so it tends to ramble in places and not wrap up as quickly as it probably would have otherwise. However, it didn't feel tedious or drawn out like some of those stories do. This was truly entertaining. I'd recommend this to anyone who loves locked-door mysteries because this one definitely stands the test of time.
The book is told by four different narrators who have been asked by Franklin Blake to write what they were witnesses to in regard to the crime. Franklin himself had inadvertently become deeply embroiled in the mysterious disappearance of the Moonstone and was looking to record the hijinks for posterity.

description

My favorite voice is that of Gabriel Betteredge. He's an elderly and much-beloved servant who has been in service to this family all of his life. He's loyal to a fault, and a truly humorous narrator in that grumpy but loveable old man way. The descriptions of his marriage made me laugh out loud, and his certainty that his favorite book, Robinson Crusoe, held the answers to all of life's problems was endearing.
And also made me realize that I need to read Robinson Crusoe.

description

Drusilla Clack is our second narrator. She's a hilariously accurate busybody who lives her life for the church. She spends her days handing out unwanted Bible tracts, giving unwanted advice, and drooling over Rachel's cousin (and rebuffed suitor), Godfrey Ablewhite. Godfrey is that guy. You know, the one who champions all the women's charities and basks in the worship of all the local spinsters.
Oh god. He's awful but in the absolute best way possible for a story like this.
Collins added in so many funny little extras that I wasn't expecting and they caught me off guard because so many of these older classics tend to be so dry.
For example, Miss Clack annoys one man so much that he starts cursing, then she proceeds to hand him a tract on swearing called Hush for Heaven's Sake. I loved that! Mostly because it makes you realize that people aren't really all that different now than they were back then. It's nice to know that the Drucilla Clacks of the world have always been universally...avoided.

description

Mr. Bruff is the family's solicitor, loyal champion during some hard times, and the third narrator of the tale. He's not as funny to listen to as the first two narrators, but he's a very likable guy.
You feel like you are getting the real story from him.

description

Ezra Jennings is the 4th narrator. He's Doctor Candy's foreign assistant with the dark and mysterious past and a heart of gold. This is the guy who's got the clue no one else has and his information may just crack the case wide open.

description

Each of these people tells what they know through their firsthand experiences with the events surrounding the theft of the Moonstone.
Now, underneath all of this mystery is a love story between a guy, Franklin, who is on the cusp of getting his shit together (but still has a few debts to pay off), and a girl, Rachel, who is so up her own ass with her version of morals that I kind of wanted to smack her. But they love each other and you're rooting for those two silly kids to get together and balance each other out.

description

Ok, so the gist is that Colonel Herncastle murdered some holy men in India and stole their sacred Moonstone while a battle was raging. Nobody could prove what he did, but everyone knew. And the end result was that his family turned their backs on him. So while he had the jewel, he lost all credibility and had to slink off into a dirty corner somewhere.
Fast forward toward the end of his life, and because he's a complete fucktard, he wills it to his niece in the hopes that it ruins her life as it did his, therefore taking his final revenge on his sister. <--who had had enough of his shit by the time he killed the holy men.

description

When this dude finally keels over, it kicks off an entire circus of crazy events that somehow interconnect in random ways to make for one of the best classic mysteries that I've ever read.
As I was listening to it there were so many things that seemed like one thing, but by the end of the book that part of the story was revealed to be something else entirely.

description

This? This is one of those books that I'll be recommending to my friends. A lot.
215 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read The Moonstone.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

June 30, 2021 – Started Reading
June 30, 2021 – Shelved
August 23, 2021 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 52 (52 new)


Viola The Woman in White kinda put me off from reading more by this author (bc humour: superb, pace: so slooooooow) but you convinced me to give it another try with this book :) Great review!


Anne Thanks! I am/was trying to relisten to The Woman in White but it doesn't have the same charm this one does. I agree that so far TWiW is super slow and just not...I don't know? I may give up and try it again later on in the year.


message 3: by Audrey (new) - added it

Audrey I really liked The Woman in White but haven't gotten to this one yet. I guess it does start a little slow.


Anne Audrey wrote: "I really liked The Woman in White but haven't gotten to this one yet. I guess it does start a little slow."

I remember I really liked the overall story and thought the ending was great. I'm guessing I just need to push myself to get midway through it.


message 5: by Holly (new)

Holly Oooh I've been looking for a classic that I might actually enjoy reading. Thanks!


Anne This one! This one!
But fair warning, I'm seeing a lot of people who thought it wasn't as good as I thought it was. But for the FIRST real detective story, I was just imagining this to be really bland. Plus, it's a serial, and you know how long those things are, right? I was pleasantly surprised, Holly.


Steve Chaput Read the book and listened to several audio adaptations. Enjoy how we get the different narrators throughout.


Laura Edwards Great review, Anne. Makes me want to dig out my copy and reread "The Moonstone".


Anne Steve wrote: "Read the book and listened to several audio adaptations. Enjoy how we get the different narrators throughout."

Yes! I loved that the version I listened to! Hearing how the story is told differently through all the characters is a big part of the draw for me.


message 10: by Anne (new) - rated it 5 stars

Anne Laura wrote: "Great review, Anne. Makes me want to dig out my copy and reread "The Moonstone"."

Yeah, this is one I plan to buy in hardback if I can.


Laura Edwards Wilkie Collins also wrote the book "The Woman in White" which I also enjoyed. There was a pretty good movie made of it, too, with Eleanor Parker.


message 12: by Anne (new) - rated it 5 stars

Anne I've read that one! I liked it but not as much as The Moonstone. I'm trying to relisten to the audiobook now, in fact. It's pretty slow in the beginning, so I'm hoping it picks up a bit.


Laura Edwards If I'm not mistaken, I first read "The Moonstone" in college for a class. I ended up liking it so much that I picked up "The Woman in White". Like you, I liked it, but not as much as "The Moonstone". Have you ever seen the movie? Worth watching. I watched it with my niece who was probably in high school at the time and she enjoyed it, too.


message 14: by Anne (new) - rated it 5 stars

Anne The Woman in White or The Moonstone? I've seen neither, btw.


Laura Edwards "The Woman in White".


message 16: by Audrey (new) - added it

Audrey I saw a movie of Woman in White. It had Tara Fitzgerald. I think it was a PBS production. It was more like a miniseries.


message 17: by Anne (new) - rated it 5 stars

Anne Laura wrote: ""The Woman in White"."

I want to watch that! I keep meaning to do it. Wonder where it's streaming?


message 18: by Anne (new) - rated it 5 stars

Anne Britbox. Damn!


message 19: by Anne (new) - rated it 5 stars

Anne Audrey wrote: "I saw a movie of Woman in White. It had Tara Fitzgerald. I think it was a PBS production. It was more like a miniseries."

That what I was thinking. My library might have it.


Laura Edwards The version I was referring to is from 1948 with Eleanor Parker, Agnes Morehead, Sydney Greenstreet and Alexis Smith. Black and white gives it an eerie feeling. :)


Laura Edwards Oh, and Greenstreet always puts in an excellent performance.


message 22: by Anne (new) - rated it 5 stars

Anne I can't get my hands on either the miniseries or the 1948 film. All my library has is the one with the guy from The Walking Dead - 1997, I think?


message 23: by Aneesah (new)

Aneesah haha, I just watched the series on Amazon Prime a couple weeks ago


message 24: by Audrey (new) - added it

Audrey Laura wrote: "The version I was referring to is from 1948 with Eleanor Parker, Agnes Morehead, Sydney Greenstreet and Alexis Smith. Black and white gives it an eerie feeling. :)"

Oh, I saw the beginning of that but didn't get to finish it.


message 25: by Anne (new) - rated it 5 stars

Anne Really? I have prime�


Laura Edwards For the 1948 version, you might want to keep an eye on the TCM schedule, especially if they have an Eleanor Parker day or an Agnes Morehead day, etc. :)


message 27: by Jaidee (new)

Jaidee Fab review Anne ! Are you going to read War and Peace next ? Ha !


message 28: by Anne (new) - rated it 5 stars

Anne Jaidee wrote: "Fab review Anne ! Are you going to read War and Peace next ? Ha !"

Ugggh. It's on my list, but I've not yet worked up the courage.


message 29: by Anne (new) - rated it 5 stars

Anne Laura wrote: "For the 1948 version, you might want to keep an eye on the TCM schedule, especially if they have an Eleanor Parker day or an Agnes Morehead day, etc. :)"

I don't have the TCM streaming site. :(


Laura Edwards Bummer.


message 31: by Anne (new) - rated it 5 stars

Anne Yeah. But I'll keep looking for that one. I saw the trailer on YouTube and it looked cool!


reading is my hustle love wilkie collins!


Laura Edwards Anne, "The Woman in White" is actually going to be on TCM on Thursday, Sept. 9 at 9:45 a.m. ET. I know you said you don't get this channel, but I thought I'd let you know in case you know someone who does.


reading is my hustle Anne wrote: "Thanks! I am/was trying to relisten to The Woman in White but it doesn't have the same charm this one does. I agree that so far TWiW is super slow and just not...I don't know? I may give up and try..."

i tried reading TWIW two times before settling into it. it's worth the reading fortitude!


message 35: by [deleted user] (new)

Glad to see this positive review from you Anne, as I have this on my TBR list !


message 36: by Anne (new) - rated it 5 stars

Anne I just finished it yesterday, Reading. The last 1/3 is awesome!


message 37: by Anne (new) - rated it 5 stars

Anne Michael, I hope I’m not overselling it, but it’s so relatable for a classic.


message 38: by [deleted user] (new)

No, what you're saying is the impression that I've been under, Anne. Not just from you, but from other reviews that I've read also. I'll let you know what I think of it when I do read it .


message 39: by [deleted user] (new)

Oh yeah, and I took your advice on Aquaman and got The Trench to read.... well, I actually got the Aquaman omnibus ( which has that story in it ).


message 40: by JYT (new)

JYT unreadable review. the multiple jerky gifs make the reading uncomfortable.


message 41: by Aneesah (new)

Aneesah Umm ok


message 42: by Anne (new) - rated it 5 stars

Anne Michael A Farkas wrote: "Oh yeah, and I took your advice on Aquaman and got The Trench to read.... well, I actually got the Aquaman omnibus ( which has that story in it )."

That's awesome! I love that whole run.


message 43: by Anne (new) - rated it 5 stars

Anne JYT wrote: "unreadable review. the multiple jerky gifs make the reading uncomfortable."

Aneesah wrote: "Umm ok"

Haha! Aneesah, you summed up my thoughts perfectly.


message 44: by Mika (new) - rated it 5 stars

Mika I just finished the book, and I love your review! The gifs are so accurate!! 😄


Rachael Great review! I'm reading this at the moment and enjoying it


message 46: by Anne (new) - rated it 5 stars

Anne Mika wrote: "I just finished the book, and I love your review! The gifs are so accurate!! 😄"

Thanks!


message 47: by Anne (new) - rated it 5 stars

Anne Rachael wrote: "Great review! I'm reading this at the moment and enjoying it"

It's such a good one! Glad you're enjoying it.


Christine Traficanti So funny! I found myself laughing too! Collins does such a wonderful job crafting the characters. I really liked all the perspective and the artful storytelling. Very entertaining!!


message 49: by Melissa (new) - added it

Melissa Jevnager I 100 percent agree I am still reading. However was amazed at the unique perspective here and being surprised at the humor.


MarilynLovesNature Anne, I enjoyed that book and listened to it a second time, which I rarely do. I've listened to many great books by Wilkie Collins. I think my audio (Librivox) was different than the one you listened to, which sounds good.


« previous 1
back to top