ŷ

Jayme's Reviews > One Italian Summer

One Italian Summer by Rebecca Serle
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
11345366
's review

it was ok
bookshelves: netgalley, widget-received, rom_com

When Carol dies, Katy loses more than her mother-she loses her best friend.

They were supposed to take a mother-daughter trip to Positano, Italy for Carol’s 60th birthday, but she passes away before they can make the journey, so Katy decides to make it an � Eat, Pray, Love� (Elizabeth Gilbert) trip instead-leaving behind her grieving Dad, and Eric, the husband she isn’t sure she wants to be married to anymore. She tells him this bluntly and unkindly, and she won’t even let him see her off at the airport, despite the fact that he has been nothing but supportive.

Prior to getting married, Carol had spent time in this magical town, and Katy hopes to find some of that same magic, in the solitude of the trip-something she couldn’t do if Eric had accompanied her-since Eric tends to make friends with everyone they cross paths with.

However, upon arrival, she immediately spends ALL of her time with Adam, a man nothing like her husband, and Carol, a woman who she is convinced is her mother-somehow 30 years old, vibrant and healthy.

Kind of hypocritical, if you ask me.

Was this a parallel universe? Time travel? A mental breakdown?

Each chapter proceeds to vividly describe parts of the gorgeous Amalfi Coast, the many delicious foods that Katy eats that day, and what she is wearing.

LATHER-RINSE-REPEAT

I suppose if you haven’t been to Italy, and you want to live vicariously through Katy, and enjoy the wonderful descriptions of Positano-this story may hold some appeal for you.

But, I found Katy to be a selfish woman that I couldn’t stand spending time with-not even in Italy, so, sadly, this story didn’t resonate with me at all.

And, I never FELT her grief.

I would like to thank Atria books for the gifted copy. I wish I had enjoyed this more, but I always provide a candid review!

Please read a sample of reviews, before deciding if this one might work for you. This was a buddy read with DeAnn so be sure to check out her thoughts as well!

AVAILABLE NOW!
652 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read One Italian Summer.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

November 16, 2021 – Shelved
November 16, 2021 – Shelved as: to-read
January 7, 2022 – Shelved as: netgalley
January 7, 2022 – Shelved as: widget-received
January 7, 2022 – Shelved as: rom_com
January 23, 2022 – Shelved as: to-read
January 30, 2022 – Started Reading
January 31, 2022 –
99.0%
January 31, 2022 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 114 (114 new)


message 1: by Regina (new)

Regina Did you ever watch Friends? Remember when Phoebe was convinced that a stray cat was her mom? Something about your review reminded me of that, LOL. Anyhoo, I've held off on requesting this one and am still on the fence. If anything, I'll probably get it from the library so I can try it without commitment. Excellent and helpful review, Jayme! xo


Holly  B (slower pace!) I think I enjoyed it more than you, but yes Katy! Ugh.... she annoyed me to no end. Great review Jayme!


message 3: by Peter (new)

Peter A pity this didn't resonate better with you but what a wonderful review, Jayme 💖


message 4: by Catherine (new) - added it

Catherine (alternativelytitledbooks) - in a book slump :( Well thanks to the review I am no longer frustrated about my pending review on EW or my decline on NG. Nothing worse than a selfish character you don’t like…bleh! I think I should still just try to get myself to Italy someday instead. Thanks for the great review, Jayme! 💞


Michael David (on hiatus) Great...I will be meeting Katy soon! 🤬😒🤣 Fantastic review! Glad you can move onto something better now. 💗


Jayme Regina wrote: "Did you ever watch Friends? Remember when Phoebe was convinced that a stray cat was her mom? Something about your review reminded me of that, LOL. Anyhoo, I've held off on requesting this one and a..."

Was the stray cat, smelly cat? 😂 The library is the way to go!


Jayme Holly wrote: "I think I enjoyed it more than you, but yes Katy! Ugh.... she annoyed me to no end. Great review Jayme!"

I have traveled there-so maybe that is why the descriptions weren’t enough to save this story for me?


Jayme Peter (on semi-hiatus) wrote: "A pity this didn't resonate better with you but what a wonderful review, Jayme 💖"

Thank You, Peter! 💖


Jayme Catherine wrote: "Well thanks to the review I am no longer frustrated about my pending review on EW or my decline on NG. Nothing worse than a selfish character you don’t like…bleh! I think I should still just try to..."

Definitely make it to Italy! And, include the Amalfi coast!! 💕


message 10: by Allison (new)

Allison Faught Heartbreaking you didn’t enjoy this more especially since the cover is so coaxing! Awesome review, Jayme. 💖


message 11: by JanB (new)

JanB I do have a strong bond with my daughter but this book doesn't sound like it would be for me either. Plus I hated EPL, lol. Thanks for an honest and fair review Jayme!


Jayme Michael wrote: "Great...I will be meeting Katy soon! 🤬😒🤣 Fantastic review! Glad you can move onto something better now. 💗"

Sorry 😞! Have lots of 🍷ready so you can tolerate her! 😂


Jayme Allison (Updated photo!) wrote: "Heartbreaking you didn’t enjoy this more especially since the cover is so coaxing! Awesome review, Jayme. 💖"

Thanks Allison! Hopefully the food and scenery descriptions will be enough for you, if you read it! 🤞🏻


Jayme JanB wrote: "I do have a strong bond with my daughter but this book doesn't sound like it would be for me either. Plus I hated EPL, lol. Thanks for an honest and fair review Jayme!"

Thanks Jan! It was definitely disappointing!


message 15: by Tina (new)

Tina A fair and honest review Jayme! 💝 Sorry it didn't quite work for you. 🙁


Melissa ~ Bantering Books Oh no! I think Serle has a bad habit of writing lead characters that are TOO hard to like. I loved her last book, "In Five Years," but a lot of people didn't because the lead was selfish and grating. She might need to dial it back for her next book. :)


message 17: by Kaceey (new)

Kaceey Excellent review Jayme! Eeks! This one is on my list!🤦🏻‍♀️�


Jayme Tina wrote: "A fair and honest review Jayme! 💝 Sorry it didn't quite work for you. 🙁"

Thanks Tina! 💕


Jayme Melissa wrote: "Oh no! I think Serle has a bad habit of writing lead characters that are TOO hard to like. I loved her last book, "In Five Years," but a lot of people didn't because the lead was selfish and gratin..."

Then, this one might work for you as well! I hope it does! 🤞🏻💖


Jayme Kaceey wrote: "Excellent review Jayme! Eeks! This one is on my list!🤦🏻‍♀️�"

Hope you have better luck with it, Kaceey! 🤞🏻❤️


message 21: by Fran (new)

Fran Jayme...wonderful review! Onward, my friend!�


DeAnn Thanks for the buddy read! Very fair review Jayme!


message 23: by Rosh (new) - added it

Rosh A candid review is always so much better than fake praise. Thanks for your honesty, Jayme! Wishing you a 5 star book next! �


message 24: by Ceecee (new)

Ceecee Fantastic review and an easy pass - though I do love the Amalfi coast! ❤️


Jayme Fran wrote: "Jayme...wonderful review! Onward, my friend!�"

Thanks Fran! 💖


Jayme DeAnn wrote: "Thanks for the buddy read! Very fair review Jayme!"

Thanks DeAnn! 💕


Jayme RoshReviews wrote: "A candid review is always so much better than fake praise. Thanks for your honesty, Jayme! Wishing you a 5 star book next! �"

Thanks Rosh! 💖


Jayme Ceecee wrote: "Fantastic review and an easy pass - though I do love the Amalfi coast! ❤️"

It is divine! The story though…not so much!!


message 29: by Jasmine (new)

Jasmine Great review, Jayme! I didn’t think this one was for me and your review confirmed it! Hopefully your next one is more enjoyable!


message 30: by NZLisaM (new)

NZLisaM Amazing review, Jayme. Doesn’t sound like one I’d like, but I think it would appeal to my mum, so will recommend it to her.


message 31: by Canadian Jen (new)

Canadian Jen Oh poo. Hope your next one is better!


message 32: by Yun (new) - rated it 2 stars

Yun Eeep! Sorry this didn't work for you, Jayme! I have an arc, so I'll be reading it lol. :)


Jayme Jasmine wrote: "Great review, Jayme! I didn’t think this one was for me and your review confirmed it! Hopefully your next one is more enjoyable!"

Glad to help! Thanks!


Jayme Jen wrote: "Oh poo. Hope your next one is better!"

Thanks Jen! 💕


Jayme Yun wrote: "Eeep! Sorry this didn't work for you, Jayme! I have an arc, so I'll be reading it lol. :)"

Hopefully you will enjoy it more! 🤞🏻❤️


Brandice Oh no, sorry this was a miss, Jayme! I loved In Five Years but really didn’t care for The Dinner List, curious to see what I’ll think of this if I read it. I just finished a book with a selfish character and while I don’t need to love all characters, the selfish ones can be challenging to still enjoy a story.


message 37: by Lilli (new) - added it

Lilli Too bad, Jayme! I was so looking forward to this but you're not the first to say it was a bit of a disappointment. There's nothing worse than a character you just can't empathize with. I mean, why else are we reading, you know? Hope your next read is redemptive!


Jayme NZLisaM wrote: "Amazing review, Jayme. Doesn’t sound like one I’d like, but I think it would appeal to my mum, so will recommend it to her."

Thanks Lisa! 💕


Jayme Brandice wrote: "Oh no, sorry this was a miss, Jayme! I loved In Five Years but really didn’t care for The Dinner List, curious to see what I’ll think of this if I read it. I just finished a book with a selfish cha..."

I agree! Unlikable is fine in some genres, but not in a book like this, for me! Hope you have better luck with it! 🤞🏻


Jayme Lilli wrote: "Too bad, Jayme! I was so looking forward to this but you're not the first to say it was a bit of a disappointment. There's nothing worse than a character you just can't empathize with. I mean, why ..."

Thanks Lilli! I hope you enjoy it more…if you get to it! 🤞🏻💕


message 41: by Lindsay L (new)

Lindsay L Fantastic review Jayme! I wish this would have worked out better for you. Nothing worse than a main character you don’t enjoy spending time with 😫


Jayme Lindsay - Traveling Sisters Book Reviews wrote: "Fantastic review Jayme! I wish this would have worked out better for you. Nothing worse than a main character you don’t enjoy spending time with 😫"

Thanks Lindsay! 💖


message 43: by MarilynW (new)

MarilynW Lovely review, Jayme, I'm not sure I'd like Katy 😒


Melissa (Always Behind) Bummer, sorry you didn't like this one. I have it coming up.


message 45: by Pat (new)

Pat Super review Jayme and I’m sorry the book didn’t work for you! I’ve been to a few places in Italy as well so I don’t need to see it vicariously through a horrid character’s eyes. I did enjoy Italy though 😍! 🧡🧡


Meredith (Trying to catch up!) Fantastic review, Jayme! I felt this way about her last book, and your review makes me glad I decided to not read this one, lol!


Susan  (on hiatus) Sorry that you had to go on vacation with Katie - she sounds annoying to say the least. I love your review anyway!


message 48: by Kat (new)

Kat Great review, Jayme! Katy sounds miserable to spend time with - especially in a place that should be fun and beautiful! 💗


message 49: by Lucy (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lucy I kept this one off my TBR, and best on your review I'm glad I did 😏.


Maren’s Reads Great review!! Sorry you didn’t enjoy this one. Honestly, I wasn’t a huge fan of In Five Years so I’m on the fence with this one.


« previous 1 3
back to top