ŷ

Anne's Reviews > Jane Eyre

Jane Eyre by Charlotte Brontë
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
1720620
's review

it was ok
bookshelves: classics, read-in-2009, read-with-jillybean

Whew! I finished this one this morning, and I'm glad I finally read it. I can't say, however, that I enjoyed it, would recommend it, or will ever read it again.
Not in this lifetime, anyway.

description

For starters, I didn't like Jane. Yeah, when she was a kid I felt sorry for her, but the older she got the less I liked her. Her religious convictions and the decisions she made because of them had Bertha looking like the picture of sanity by comparison. Speaking of, why in the world did she wander off in the middle of the night with no money?
What did she think would happen? Was manna supposed to drop out of heaven?
And I don't buy that an educated, sensible woman would just run off into the night without taking enough with her to make sure she could survive. An idiot would have better sense than that.
But by the end of the story, I was almost wishing she had wandered off after St John and contracted some disease. The fact that she didn't totally realize what an awful freak St John was nailed the lid on her coffin to me. Even at the very end of the book, she kept talking about all of the great works he was doing for God.

description

Seriously?
He was an ass, and I would have told him to give me my five thousand pounds back!
At least Bronte had the sense to kill him off at the end. Well, maybe he wasn't quite dead yet, but he was on his way to meet his maker. Ugh.
I also thought it was more than just a teeny bit fishy that she ended up on the doorstep of the only family she had in the entire world.
Exactly how likely is that? Not very.

description

Then there is the man himself, Mr. Rochester. He wasn't anything to write home about for sure. Let's start with the obvious, shall we? He was cold, condescending, secretive. Wow.
Oh yeah, and he was ugly to boot. Yum.

description

Can anything else be said about him to make him more of a catch? I know! Just in case, let's have him keep a drooling homicidal wife hidden away in the attic!
Personally, I think Bronte had covered all the bases at this point.
Did he honestly not see anything wrong with letting her marry him while he had that crazy bat of a wife locked upstairs? If he had just told her the situation to start with, I might have liked him a little better.
Nah. Probably not. I never actually figured out what she saw in him. My best guess ended up being low self-esteem coupled with a bad childhood.

description

The 'gothic mystery' part of the plot ended in the middle of the book, and shortly thereafter ended anything remotely interesting. Say what you will about Looney Bertha, but at least she pumped some life into the story.

description

And wasn't it just awesome that Bertha burned the house to the ground and then leaped to her death? Nice exit big girl! I gotta say, she was by far my favorite. Lest we forget, she also managed to mangle Rochester's good looks even more before she bowed out. Now Jane's man looks like a one-eyed, one-armed, flying purple people eater. Of course, she doesn't mind, because now she feels she can be of use to him.

description

Jane, I can tell we will never see eye-to-eye on things, so I'll just let it go. Our friendship was never meant to be. For some, you will forever remain the stoic heroine who finally gets her Happily Ever After. For me, you are just a ninny with bad taste in men. As Adele would say, Adieu.
Reader, this review is over.
326 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Jane Eyre.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

January 19, 2009 – Shelved
October 7, 2009 –
page 11
2.07%
October 11, 2009 –
page 49
9.21%
October 19, 2009 –
page 70
13.16%
October 21, 2009 –
page 159
29.89% "Sort of depressing so far. I think I'm getting to the good stuff now."
October 23, 2009 –
page 203
38.16% "I feel like I'm finally making some progress. It's a good book, but the lack of action is hard for me."
October 25, 2009 –
page 255
47.93%
November 2, 2009 –
page 305
57.33%
Started Reading
November 3, 2009 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 89 (89 new)


Jill I thought you had already read this. I've read it but would like to read it again. We should read it together.


Anne No, I mean I know the general storyline because it's...well, Jane Eyre! But I've never actually read it. Let me know when you want to read it!


 Danielle The Book Huntress Funny review, Anne. I loved this book, but I appreciate your review all the same.


Anne Danielle "The Book Huntress" wrote: "Funny review, Anne. I loved this book, but I appreciate your review all the same. "

Glad you saw the humor in it. I was afraid some of my friends might not think it was to funny to slam a classic. I'm pretty sure my best friend is on her way over to my house right now with a baseball bat. LOL! I can appreciate why you loved it, too. The writing really was excellent.


 Danielle The Book Huntress I love reading reviews because everyone sees things differently and that's nice to see the variety in people's thoughts about things. And a well-written review is as joyful as reading a good book to me. :)


Anne I've noticed that you like to read reviews. It's cool, because then I get to read the review that you liked, too! One of the reasons I love ŷ so much is because you can read other people's reviews. It means so much more to me to read a review written by a fellow reader than it does to read one by a book critic.


 Danielle The Book Huntress I completely agree. I even get something out of reviews that are opposite of mine on a book. It's fun and keeps me awake on the boring days at work. :)


Anne Yes, I totally understand! Sometimes the best reviews are ones that I don't agree with at all, or maybe I understand why they hated the book (Twilight is a great example), even if I personally loved the book. I agree with most of the reasons that people hated the Twilight series, but I still loved them!


 Danielle The Book Huntress I like reading reviews when you can agree with points that a person made against a book you love, but still love it.


message 10: by Anne (new) - rated it 2 stars

Anne I totally understand, Danielle. There are so many reviews that I love or think are funny, even if the reviewer and I have different opinions on whether or not the book was any good!


Erica I am not alone!
OMG, I am crying tears of joy right now.


message 12: by Anne (new) - rated it 2 stars

Anne Erica wrote: "I am not alone!
OMG, I am crying tears of joy right now."


I take it you hated this one too?
* dances around the kitchen *


Erica This is another one I've read three times (See: Wuthering Heights), twice as assigned and once because I hate myself.
Every single time, I wanted to strangle Jane.
I get that these Victorian authoresses were doing a lot for women in publishing and stuff, but I just can't appreciate the messages these tomes contain, especially as I am so far removed from the original context.
This one was especially vapid. Of course Jane turned out to be a strong, reliable, almost willful (except for when she's being flaky and subservient and holier-than-thou) woman after the childhood she endured. I mean, she's perfect. Now all she has to do is convince the never-charming Mr. Rochester of that fact and they can be married! Only, uh oh! Someone call Jerry Springer! We got an issue.
I'm getting stabby just remembering the pain this book has caused my delicate sensibilities.


message 14: by Anne (new) - rated it 2 stars

Anne Lol! Yep. Watch it, though. Fucking trolls love to knock on your door when you don't get (snort) the beloved classics. If it's old, you either love/respect it...or you're an uneducated moron.


Erica You know, it's rarely the classics I get trolled on.
My trolls show up on the trendy fads, usually the ones with pictures, the ones that are trying really hard to be Christmas gifts. I get the smackdown for not liking those.

Of course, now that I've said this out loud, as it were, they're going to swarm me for my classics-hate.


message 16: by Kristin (last edited Feb 09, 2015 03:43PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Kristin I can't believe you two. HOW CAN YOU NOT APPRECIATE SUCH A BEAUTIFUL PIECE OF WORK! Don't you know that you never ever dis a classic?! You two clearly lack taste and class. Ugh. I must go wash my eyes out with soap now.


Anna Kay I loved this review Anne! I personally like Jane Eyre (and its nutball, abusive bitchy cousin Wuthering Heights). I often think silently to myself, "Why do I like this? These people are so totally unlikeable." I literally have no reasoning, so I can appreciate your qualms. They're thoughts I've actually had myself and yet I still somehow like these books! I think I'm a bit crazy...not wife-in-the-attic-house-on-fire crazy, but still a headcase! LOL



Just had to add that in to my comment. :p


message 18: by Anne (new) - rated it 2 stars

Anne Bwahaha! Love it, Kristin! Nice try with the trolling. You gotta misspell words, though. Shelby taught me that one...or maybe it wad Kelly? Regardless! It won't work till you sound deranged.
Anna, you get a free pass to like Jane, sine you threw in the awesome GIF.


Erica Yeah, Kristin, you are not nearly angry enough. NEED MOAR RAGE!
Also, I hear Lifebouy soap is good for eyewashing.

Anna, that meme made me roll my eyes so hard, they got stuck on my brain. I may or may not have smirked, as well.


Kristin Drat! I thought I might've fooled ya since I had just changed my pic. Must be more crafty next time.


message 21: by Jess ❈Harbinger of Blood-Soaked Rainbows� (last edited Feb 09, 2015 04:43PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jess ❈Harbinger of Blood-Soaked Rainbows❈ Haha!!! I love being all stalkery with comment sections. You guys crack me up. I was going to troll this but Kristin beat me to it!


message 22: by Anne (new) - rated it 2 stars

Anne No trolling my review!!! I AM VENGEANCE!


Erica Anne wrote: "No trolling my review!!! I AM VENGEANCE!"

Oh, geez, that's YOU?
I totally thought it was the Red Skull.
Oops!



Kristin Bwhahahaha yes, totally Red Skull


message 26: by Anna Kay (last edited Feb 09, 2015 05:56PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Anna Kay Erica wrote: "Yeah, Kristin, you are not nearly angry enough. NEED MOAR RAGE!
Also, I hear Lifebouy soap is good for eyewashing.

Anna, that meme made me roll my eyes so hard, they got stuck on my brain. I may o..."


I know, I have a very popsicle-stick joke sense of humor! It runs in my family and I can't fight genetics - so I do my best to drag down the people around me too. LOL And thanks for the free pass Anne! Any time that Michael Fassbender needs some Eyre (or just plain 'air') I am totally available.


message 27: by Anne (last edited Feb 10, 2015 01:28AM) (new) - rated it 2 stars

Anne Respect Red Skull! Also, I look a bit like him in the mornings.
Tadiana...ha! I'll have to take the time to clean up this review tomorrow, you know, now that she's judging me! This was a rant written years ago. Not meant for the eyes of judgy gifs!


Tadiana ✩Night Owl☽ I'll be rereading Jane this summer with some GR buddies. You could join us and maybe we'll change your mind! Or maybe I'll end up agreeing with you this time around. One never knows!


Erica Anna (Yoda Is My Spirit Animal) wrote: "I know, I have a very popsicle-stick joke sense of humor! It runs in my family and I can't fight genetics - so I do my best to drag down the people around me too."

Hahaha! I love popsicle stick jokes! They are the absolute worst!


message 30: by Mark (new) - rated it 4 stars

Mark I actually really liked this book. It was dark and very... different. I liked it in the way that I liked "Wuthering Heights"


message 31: by Anne (new) - rated it 2 stars

Anne I've never read WH..shhh! Please don't tell on me! I've got friends who will try to make me read it.
*slinks away quickly*


Trish Muhahahaha. Great review!
I have to say that I, too, prefer Fassbender's Mr. Rochester over the one from the book. I men, at least Fassbender is eye-candy! ;)


message 33: by Anne (new) - rated it 2 stars

Anne Yes. Eye candy is what I was expecting when my BFF was telling me to read this!
Ooooh! I just love Mr Rochester!
Barring a hot guy, I would have loved one who wasn't a douche. That's all! Just...not a douche!


message 34: by Rea (new) - rated it 1 star

Rea K Anne wrote: "I've never read WH..shhh! Please don't tell on me! I've got friends who will try to make me read it.
*slinks away quickly*"

I tried reading Wuthering Heights once (it was a recommendation). I don't think I've ever been so happy to have my three weeks from the library run out. And then I found a copy at home. Ew.


message 35: by Trish (last edited Sep 22, 2015 12:20PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Trish This was my first Bronte book ever and although I did get the label "classic", I think I'm just not into the sisters (the Brontes that is). I HATED Wuthering Heights.
I prefer my men Jane Austen-ish.


FoodxHugs Oh my god, I'm snorting with laughter. Excellent review. :'D


Rachel Aranda Your review is so amusing! I admit I can't really say I love it would reread this book again. It's not what I was expecting so I was disappointed. Quite a few of your points I agree with especially the running out into the street with no belongings or money. She then magically shows up at the only family she has left right before they all leave!? It's very fairy tale in a Grimm's sort of way but not as good. Thank you for your review!


abhishek  Chakraborty Agreed. Damn overrated book


Cyndi Excellent! I thought I was the only person who didn't like this book... in history! Lol! Great review, and so accurate! Haha!


message 40: by Anne (new) - rated it 2 stars

Anne Judging by all the comments I missed, Cyndi, we aren't alone at all!


message 41: by Tara (new)

Tara Brilliant review, you absolutely nailed it! :D


message 42: by Anne (new) - rated it 2 stars

Anne Tara wrote: "Brilliant review, you absolutely nailed it! :D"

Shhh! Don't let them know you didn't love it, Tara! ;)


message 43: by Josh (new) - rated it 5 stars

Josh T OH WOW!!! It's a rare thing to read a bad review of Jane Eyre. It happens to be one of my favorite all time literary novels personally. IN FACT, I'm such a fan of the Bronte sisters, that I took a high level course for my honors English degree with Russel Perkins at Saint Mary's University that was entirely dedicated to the Bronte sisters' novels. The one I didn't make it through was Villette by Charlotte Bronte. I must give it another shot... but at the time I bitched about how it seemed like it was meant for too cultured a person (someone who knows a bit of french and such forth, among other things)...


message 44: by Josh (new) - rated it 5 stars

Josh T The most "accessible" of the Bronte novels in my opinion was The Tenant of Wildfell Hall by Anne Bronte, the "lesser" sister, as people sometimes claim. It's much faster paced, and seemed more of a page turner in contrast to Wuthering Heights by Emily, and Jane Eyre by Charlotte. Shame Anne died before writing more novels than just that and Agnes Grey.


Psientist I liked this review and also have the perception of Jane as a "ninny with bad taste in men".

As some recompense for having put in the graft of reading Bronte: have you tried Cold Comfort Farm?


message 46: by Anne (new) - rated it 2 stars

Anne I haven't. The name rings a bell, but unless it has pictures...? lol


Psientist Anne wrote: "I haven't. The name rings a bell, but unless it has pictures...? lol"
Unfortunately no pictures, but there is a movie (not as good as the book by a long stretch). It's a satire with many references to Bronte and others.


message 48: by Anne (new) - rated it 2 stars

Anne I just added it to my list, Psientist! Thanks for the rec. I'm always on the lookout for a classic I can tolerate. ;)


Annie ⚜️ Only you could rip apart one of my all time favorites and make it awesome! 😂 You have a gift.


message 50: by Britton (new)

Britton 50th comment, I couldn't deal with 49 anymore. Hehe


« previous 1
back to top