ŷ

Morgan 's Reviews > The Magnolia Palace

The Magnolia Palace by Fiona  Davis
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
77835475
's review

it was ok

2-1/2 /5

There are aspects of this book that are just too implausible.

NYC � 1919 � Lillian Carter aka Angelica, artist model falls on hard times. Work is drying up and Lillian has trouble paying the rent and then finds herself a suspect in the death of her landlord’s wife. On the run with aspirations of getting to Hollywood to become an actress she lands up, purely by accident at the door of the Frick mansion where they are expecting an applicant for the job of private Secretary to the imperious Helen Frick. Lillian is mistaken for that person and allows herself to be taken in for an interview whereupon she gets the job having no experience whatsoever. Within a few weeks she becomes almost indispensable to the family.

NYC � 1966 � Veronica Weber, British model is part of a photo shoot at the former Frick Mansion. She gets into a tiff with the photographer and is left behind by the company. She is alone in the mansion during a snow storm and a total blackout but is able to find her way around this massive cavern of a house with the aid of a candle (which she miraculously finds a match to light it). Shortly thereafter she finds she is not alone � Joshua � a part time employee joins her and they spend the time in the mansion finding clues that have been hidden for many years. All during a total blackout.

I mostly enjoyed learning about the Frick Museum and the Art Library.

The personal relationships, not so much.

The tie up at the end is just too neat and happy.

This is not this author’s finest moment.

31 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Magnolia Palace.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

December 28, 2021 – Shelved
December 28, 2021 – Shelved as: to-read
February 10, 2022 – Started Reading
February 12, 2022 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-15 of 15 (15 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Barry who enjoys well-written thrillers, mysteries , & espionage & loathes romance, horror & supernat The Frick Museum was one of my favorite spots when I lived in NYC. I especially liked the Turners and the furniture although the building itself was nothing short of magnificent. In fact, I took the woman who I would later marry there on our first date.


Morgan Barry wrote: "The Frick Museum was one of my favorite spots when I lived in NYC. I especially liked the Turners and the furniture although the building itself was nothing short of magnificent. In fact, I took th..."

What a great first date. I would have married you too.😉 I was looking at pictures of the Frick on the Internet...impressive for sure. Even though I didn't much care for the book -If not for the book I would never have known about it.


Barry who enjoys well-written thrillers, mysteries , & espionage & loathes romance, horror & supernat Actually, on that day, we went to the Guggenheim to see a Paul Klee exhibition, then to the Frick, to Chinatown for dinner, and a few blocks over to Little Italy for dessert. It was quite an experience and to think it was in 1977 is absolutely amazing to me. Life passes quickly but it can be a spectacular ride!


Morgan Barry wrote: "Actually, on that day, we went to the Guggenheim to see a Paul Klee exhibition, then to the Frick, to Chinatown for dinner, and a few blocks over to Little Italy for dessert. It was quite an experi..."

I would have married you on the spot! What did you have for dessert?


Barry who enjoys well-written thrillers, mysteries , & espionage & loathes romance, horror & supernat Can’t remember. It was too long ago. Hell, I can’t remember what I had for dessert yesterday!


Morgan Barry wrote: "Can’t remember. It was too long ago. Hell, I can’t remember what I had for dessert yesterday!"

It must have been something yummy 😀


Shaana Niessen Awww Barry what a great first date!! Morgan, completely agree with your review although I too have a new found interest in the Frick history.


Morgan Shaana wrote: "Awww Barry what a great first date!! Morgan, completely agree with your review although I too have a new found interest in the Frick history."

Thanks so much. The Frick history is interesting to say the least.


Barry who enjoys well-written thrillers, mysteries , & espionage & loathes romance, horror & supernat Shaana wrote: "Awww Barry what a great first date!! Morgan, completely agree with your review although I too have a new found interest in the Frick history."

Ain’t nothing like Fricking history!


message 10: by Lisa (new) - rated it 1 star

Lisa Davis I should have read more of the negative reviews before buying this book. Sounded so interesting but my comments are like yours. Totally far fetched, totally silly. I couldn't even finish it..BLECH.


message 11: by Annette (new)

Annette Great review Morgan. I think I just tried one book by this author previously. Would you say she brings strong historical background or it's more on a lighter side?


Morgan Annette wrote: "Great review Morgan. I think I just tried one book by this author previously. Would you say she brings strong historical background or it's more on a lighter side?"

Thanks Annette. I've read all (or most) of her books and have given them varying reviews but always found them an enjoyable read - I think this was my least favourite.


message 13: by Annette (new)

Annette Thank you Morgan :)


message 14: by Joe (new)

Joe Krakovsky I enjoyed the way you explained the implausible. :-)


Morgan Joe wrote: "I enjoyed the way you explained the implausible. :-)"

Thanks Joe, it's wasn't hard to do 😏


back to top