Tatiana's Reviews > Ishmael: An Adventure of the Mind and Spirit
Ishmael: An Adventure of the Mind and Spirit (Ishmael, #1)
by
by

I haven't finished this book yet but I probably won't because it sucks. First of all, it's supposed to be a novel but it's entirely didactic. The author has simply substituted this gorilla to preach at us in the author's voice. The viewpoint character is simple minded and vacuous to the point of not existing. In fact, he's just there as the foil or receptacle for the gorilla's teachings. The central thesis of the gorilla's thoughts, which he presents as unassailable fact, is the supposition that human population will ALWAYS increase to use all available food supply, something that simply isn't true in any of the developed countries. If it weren't for immigration, of course, the U.S. and most of Western Europe would have falling populations. The author dismisses this massive flaw in his edifice of cards by saying someone somewhere will eat the food or else people would stop growing it. Okay, so he then doesn't notice that if people stop growing food because there's nobody to eat it, then the population is limiting itself and the human species is not doing its job of multiplying, engulfing, and devouring as he claims it always must.
It's the same old stuff the Club of Rome said in the 70s and so on and so on from Malthus to the present. It comes about because people don't realize that trends do change in response to changing situations. Women empowered with birth control to choose their family size have less children. Fishers who realize fish stocks are depleted do change their methods and either enact laws limiting catch sizes, or turn to farming, or become conservationists of wild species.
The human species has lived off mother earth's bounty for all its childhood and adolescence, but it IS growing up, and will eventually nurture all the world's resources in a realistic way leading to complete sustainability. There's nothing improbable about that.
Some of the things the author doesn't realize follow.
In space the resources are truly unlimited. We're not in a closed petri dish. We just have to reach out and develop what's there.
We make new resources all the time with advances in technology. Worthless sand becomes useful glass, then even more useful microchips. Black sludge becomes a fuel or a plastic container. The more we know the more we see worthless things around us turn into jewels under our hands.
Before human stewardship, life on earth was far from safe and cozy. Asteroid impacts destroyed nearly all living things on several different occasions (Cambrian, Permian, Cretaceous, etc.) and could do so again, even more completely, if humans aren't technologically advanced enough to prevent it. The history of life is riddled with catastrophes that weren't caused by humans.
There's so much more, I could write a novel. But you get the picture. Please save your efforts for some book that will entertain you or teach you something true. This one is useless for either.
It's the same old stuff the Club of Rome said in the 70s and so on and so on from Malthus to the present. It comes about because people don't realize that trends do change in response to changing situations. Women empowered with birth control to choose their family size have less children. Fishers who realize fish stocks are depleted do change their methods and either enact laws limiting catch sizes, or turn to farming, or become conservationists of wild species.
The human species has lived off mother earth's bounty for all its childhood and adolescence, but it IS growing up, and will eventually nurture all the world's resources in a realistic way leading to complete sustainability. There's nothing improbable about that.
Some of the things the author doesn't realize follow.
In space the resources are truly unlimited. We're not in a closed petri dish. We just have to reach out and develop what's there.
We make new resources all the time with advances in technology. Worthless sand becomes useful glass, then even more useful microchips. Black sludge becomes a fuel or a plastic container. The more we know the more we see worthless things around us turn into jewels under our hands.
Before human stewardship, life on earth was far from safe and cozy. Asteroid impacts destroyed nearly all living things on several different occasions (Cambrian, Permian, Cretaceous, etc.) and could do so again, even more completely, if humans aren't technologically advanced enough to prevent it. The history of life is riddled with catastrophes that weren't caused by humans.
There's so much more, I could write a novel. But you get the picture. Please save your efforts for some book that will entertain you or teach you something true. This one is useless for either.
Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read
Ishmael.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
January 24, 2009
– Shelved
Started Reading
January 26, 2009
–
Finished Reading
December 3, 2009
– Shelved as:
fantasy
November 21, 2012
– Shelved as:
mostwretchedofalltime
Comments Showing 1-21 of 21 (21 new)
date
newest »








So not all of us "haters" are the intended audience of this book. Some of us are just people that don't like poorly written books.



Also I don't think the historical inaccuracies, or the degree of license in interpretations of biblical and religious history is very important. One can appreciate the book even knowing it is not encyclopedic. But it is true one must appreciate it in a different sort of way than one would a traditional novel. If is not about complex character development and complex and quotidian life experiences, like other social novels these days have come to be, it is just a philosophical essay in an unusual ( once usual) form.




But after re-reading the book description and some of the reviews, I may leave it on my to-read list, just because I'm very interested in the topics covered and it will probably be of value to read and respond critically to the book, even if the arguments are flawed.
Thanks again for a well articulated review.
i especially agree about the viewpoint character. i felt degraded and insulted that as reader i was forced to experience the "story" from the perspective of such a empty-headed dolt. "nom, nom, nom, mmm this tripe is delicious!"
you're the best. :)