ŷ

Emily M's Reviews > Ghosts

Ghosts by Edith Wharton
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
31387283
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: ghosts-and-hauntings, usa, nyrb

3.5 stars

I have been reading this sporadically since Christmas, but Halloween was impetus to push ahead and read the last several stories in a couple of days. And I think the accelerated speed helped me appreciate them more.

Wharton's collection of ghost stories is one part intriguingly psychological, and one part old-fashioned. She seems to foresee this herself, commenting in the introduction that

[taste for ghosts] is being gradually atrophied by these two world-wide enemies of the imagination, the wireless and the cinema.

The cinema hasn't done away with ghost stories of course, far from it, but it has changed what we expect from them. Wharton's are quiet affairs, ghosts are often absences, or they ring bells or leave footprints, but they resolutely never jump out at you. This took a bit of getting used to... I expected the stories to have twists, as they would now, or to up the ante in some way, but many of them seem content to present the likelihood of a ghost as interest enough to the reader.

And generally, in Wharton's hands, it is. Because she is dealing with the human, regardless of the supernatural trappings. Where there are dark and rambling houses, they are backgrounds to stories of unhappy marriages, or ill-gotten fortunes, or illness or madness. Elsewhere there are slight departures from the ghost story mould -- a rural Gothic piece set among snowed-in farmers, a desert idyll of peaceful horizons and lingering stenches, an old lady left alone who realises that all her mod-cons won't save her from a final solitude.

Excellent writing and pacing. Plots are a bit uneven, but there are some standouts. I really enjoyed "The Pomegranate Seed" and particularly "All Soul's" which I reread, appropriately enough, as Halloween bled into All Souls Day.
21 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Ghosts.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

January 5, 2022 – Started Reading
January 5, 2022 – Shelved
May 11, 2022 –
page 150
52.08%
November 1, 2022 – Shelved as: ghosts-and-hauntings
November 1, 2022 – Finished Reading
March 24, 2024 – Shelved as: usa
April 2, 2024 – Shelved as: nyrb

Comments Showing 1-7 of 7 (7 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Lee (new)

Lee Backlisted did a fun episode on this book a few years back.


message 2: by Alwynne (last edited Nov 01, 2022 03:30PM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Alwynne I thought 'All Souls' and 'Pomegranate Seeds' were definitely the strongest entries too, particularly 'All Souls' the scenes in the deserted house were incredibly tense and convincing. Still not sure what to make of stories like 'The Eyes' though. I was fascinated by her representation of servants in the earlier stories often loyal and devoted but increasingly duplicitous or regarded with suspicion in the later ones. Felt like an oblique commentary on the growing 'servant problem' experienced by women like Wharton as other avenues opened up for young working-class people.


Emily M Alwynne wrote: "I thought 'All Souls' and 'Pomegranate Seeds' were definitely the strongest entries too, particularly 'All Souls' the scenes in the deserted house were incredibly tense and convincing. Still not su..."

Yes the empty house in All Souls was really a masterclass in tension, and that was one I didn't feel petered out at the end (as quite a few others did). Interestingly, I was doing a little background reading and Wharton's servant problems seem to have been particular, and related to mortality rather than opportunities... two of her old faithfulls died in her last year or so (one with what appears to have been dementia), and a third was so distraught she left. It sounds like these were the people she had lived with after the death of her partner a decade earlier... an interesting reminder of some of the relationships that defined people's lives but weren't much written about and that largely no longer exist.


Alwynne Emily wrote: "Alwynne wrote: "I thought 'All Souls' and 'Pomegranate Seeds' were definitely the strongest entries too, particularly 'All Souls' the scenes in the deserted house were incredibly tense and convinci..."

I didn't know that, thanks! I've been contemplating reading a biography but haven't gotten round to it. I just liked the way she established the uneasy intimacy between employers and servants. I thought it was quite unusual.


message 5: by Katia (new)

Katia N Thank you for this review, Emily. I will fetch those two short stories you liked. I’ve read only “The house of Mirth� by her and liked it enough but not search for more of her writing. But she was quite a character it seems.


Emily M Lee wrote: "Backlisted did a fun episode on this book a few years back."

I don't know Backlisted. Is that shocking? But I was wondering why so many people had this book on their shelves.


Emily M Katia wrote: "Thank you for this review, Emily. I will fetch those two short stories you liked. I’ve read only “The house of Mirth� by her and liked it enough but not search for more of her writing. But she was ..."

I know what you mean. I read The Age of Innocence and enjoyed it but felt no need to look for more. This was a Christmas present. By and large a good read. All Souls is a particularly interesting story.


back to top