ŷ

Mark Porton's Reviews > Pnin

Pnin by Vladimir Nabokov
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
18643650
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: 5-stars, classics, funny, nabokov, russian-authors

Pnin by Vladimir Nabokov is a little gem I will come back to again. Reasons being (a) it is so good and (b) I love the character Professor Timofey Pnin. I did get lost in a couple of passages. I think this is due to the writing of Nabokov as it’s a bit too clever in parts for me, but I will make a point of understanding the whole thing one day. But I got 90% of it � I think.

Pnin must have been a sight to behold, he had a bronzed bald dome, was clean-shaven and his absence of eyebrows were partially concealed by tortoise-shell glasses. He had a thick neck and a solid apish torso � but his legs were disappointingly thin, and his feet were almost feminine.

Pnin is a hapless academic at the fictional Waindell College in America, he’s an éé, having to leave his homeland due to the Russian Revolution. We catch up with him, mostly, when he is in his fifties � but Nabokov does move the reader around chronologically, these changes in timelines were sometimes difficult to spot for this reader � hence, my confusion at times.

He was essentially homeless. He spent his entire career renting rooms from various faculty members. My favourite ‘room-lords� were the Clements family. The father being a scholar offering a course on The Philosophy of Gesture, this family maintained a warm, understanding affection for Pnin throughout this story. His reasons for changing his lodgings so frequently (about every semester) were mainly sonic. Ha � I love that! He was also quite a particular man. For example, every lunchtime he washed his hands and head. I also loved the way he extolled the virtues of having all his teeth removed, to anyone who’d listen, and the author’s description of his meaty tongue exploring his now cavernous fleshy mouth.

Like so many ageing college people, Pnin had long ceased to notice the existence of students on campus

This story has a persistent ribbon of sadness running between the laughs. Poor Timofey Pnin seems to maintain his love for his ex-wife, Liza. In fact, she asked Pnin to look after the son of her second marriage (to the guy she left Pnin for) while she galivanted around � no doubt seeking a new suitor. Yes, she did marry a third time, but Pnin sobbed uncontrollably when he realised, she didn’t want to return to him. How sad. The son, Victor, did seem to be a nice lad though � small blessings.

�.in a heated exchange between Professor Bolotov, who taught the History of Philosophy, and Professor Chateau, who taught the Philosophy of history: “Reality is Duration�, Bolotov’s voice would boom. “It is not� the other would cry. “A soap bubble is as real as a fossil tooth�

You know when you read a passage in a book and it sends you into hysterics? Well the following was one for me, I LAUGHED OUT LOUD: re-read it and LAUGHED EVEN HARDER.

�..the housekeeper was married to a gloomy and stolid old Cossack whose main passion in life was amateur bookbinding. A self-taught pathological process

I’m still chuckling.

Be careful though, as we are presented with some stark reminders of the grim times of the Russian Revolution, their Civil War and WWII. Such as the time Pnin reminisces about Mira, a Jewish girl he loved when he was young. Poor Mira ended up dying in one of Hitler’s concentration camps, soon after she disembarked from a cattle truck. This made me put the book down and think, and ponder and imagine this horror happening not once, but over six million times. How can one not feel despair?

“Pnin-ian English� was always amusing. Such as his persistent interpretation of Mrs Thayer as “Mrs Fire�. There are many examples throughout to saviour. Pnin finally found a house he wanted to buy; a small affair full of all sorts of “Pnin-isms�. Anyway, he held a house-warming party. Many people he invited found reasons not to attend, but the small gathering who did were all people who liked Timofey Pnin. There was a certain warmth about this gathering which I felt in my chest. I was happy for Pnin, and he did have a nice time.

I found myself liking the characters who liked Pnin and despising the ones who didn’t. I was certainly on Team Pnin and I don’t think I could be friends with “Anti-Pninists�. I think they would have a very mean soul to say the least.

The housewarming gathering occurs towards the end of this book, there is an interesting conclusion to the story � I won’t say if it’s happy or sad, for those of you who haven’t read this work. The narrator stays anonymous throughout but more information regarding this phantom player are revealed in the last chapter, which to this reader, was an interesting reveal.

What an absolute delight. I am so glad to have met Timofey Pavlovich Pnin , he will stay with me for a long time.

5-stars

Now to savour the reviews of others and check out some professional analyses. The fun on this one has just commenced.
110 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Pnin.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

February 3, 2022 – Started Reading
February 3, 2022 – Shelved
February 3, 2022 –
page 50
29.59% "What a gem already 😍"
February 4, 2022 –
page 110
65.09%
February 5, 2022 – Shelved as: 5-stars
February 5, 2022 – Shelved as: classics
February 5, 2022 – Shelved as: funny
February 5, 2022 – Shelved as: nabokov
February 5, 2022 – Shelved as: russian-authors
February 5, 2022 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 56 (56 new)


message 1: by Nataliya (new)

Nataliya Wonderful review, Mark! This book is on my to-read list for this year, and I’m excited to see that you really loved it.


message 2: by Candi (new) - added it

Candi Sounds like you struck it rich with Nabokov once again, Mark! I have quite the picture of Pnin in my mind now :) I'm glad this brought so much pleasure. I hope it does the same for me. Excellent review!


message 3: by Lori (new)

Lori  Keeton Timofey Pnin - what a mouthful - HA! But he sounds like such an interesting character on the inside and out. I can't imagine having all of my teeth removed and then flaunting it - how does one speak with no teeth?!?! Well, wonderful that you found a fabulous 5 star read, Mark! I really need to take on a Nabokov someday.


Nick Grammos Glad to hear you got to read this, Mark, one of my favourites. I'm due another read soon. Yes, you're either a Pninist or not. And who wants to know a non-Pninist!


Mark  Porton Nataliya wrote: "Wonderful review, Mark! This book is on my to-read list for this year, and I’m excited to see that you really loved it."

I'm a bit excited you're going to read this little book Nataliya - make sure I don't miss your review!! Yes, I really did love this one.


Mark  Porton Candi wrote: "Sounds like you struck it rich with Nabokov once again, Mark! I have quite the picture of Pnin in my mind now :) I'm glad this brought so much pleasure. I hope it does the same for me. Excellent re..."

Oh I am sure you'll love it Candi, - please read it this year (gentle nudge), you'll love him I know!


Mark  Porton Lori wrote: "Timofey Pnin - what a mouthful - HA! But he sounds like such an interesting character on the inside and out. I can't imagine having all of my teeth removed and then flaunting it - how does one spea..."

This could be a great one to start with Lori, mine was Lolita and I loved that work - but it's not for everyone. I believe Pnin is pronounced "Pineeen" - I think. I hope you get to meet Timofey one day!


Mark  Porton Nick wrote: "Glad to hear you got to read this, Mark, one of my favourites. I'm due another read soon. Yes, you're either a Pninist or not. And who wants to know a non-Pninist!"

Yes Nick, if I was at a dinner party - stay with me here - and one of the guests said "I hate Pnin!!". I would quietly dab my sauce ridden mouth and beard with my napkin, get up and leave.

I'm not surprised you threw 5-stars at this one too mate. It's great :))


message 9: by Nick (last edited Feb 05, 2022 06:29PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Nick Grammos Mark wrote: "Nick wrote: "Glad to hear you got to read this, Mark, one of my favourites. I'm due another read soon. Yes, you're either a Pninist or not. And who wants to know a non-Pninist!"

Yes Nick, if I was..."


I'm with you all the way on the dinner party. Beware, there are Philistines everywhere, you have to be prepared.


message 10: by Nataliya (new)

Nataliya Mark wrote: "Lori wrote: "Timofey Pnin - what a mouthful - HA! But he sounds like such an interesting character on the inside and out. I can't imagine having all of my teeth removed and then flaunting it - how ..."

“Pnin� is simple � it’s pronounced exactly how it’s spelled - Pnin, or I suppose, “Pneen�. No extra sound between “p� and “n�.


Mark  Porton Gotya Nataliya, cheers for that 😊


message 12: by Nick (new) - rated it 5 stars

Nick Grammos Keen on Pneen


message 13: by Judith (new) - added it

Judith E What a character analysis by both you and Nabokov. I’m going to read this one!


Violeta This story has a persistent ribbon of sadness running between the laughs.

What a beautiful sentence - Nabokov is affecting you in all the right ways, Mark!! You did a terrific reconstruction of this book and I really enjoyed the trip back to Timofey Pavlovich Pnin's world. I assure you that now that you've made his acquaintance he's going to live with (or in) you for a long time. You are right: the fun with Nabokov's books goes on long after the last page has been turned ;-)


message 15: by Beata (new)

Beata Definitely want to join Pnin-ists, Mark! :)) A delightful review!


message 16: by Bianca (new)

Bianca Beautiful review. Thanks for bringing this title to my attention. I don't recall ever coming across it. I do need to read more Nabokov.


message 17: by Mike (new) - rated it 4 stars

Mike R.W. I totally agree, Mark! Great review - I loved Pnin and the Pnin'ian world he lived in. Very Pnin to the last page - a truly great novel.


message 18: by Anne (new) - added it

Anne Mark, I really enjoyed reading your review. I now feel like I know Pnin (which, of course, I don't). I meant to read this book last year. Somehow that didn't happen. Btw, I don't get the humor/joke re: the passage you quoted which made you laugh so hard. Twice.


Left Coast Justin Always adds to the fun when you know there's a lot of good reviews out there to peek at. Nicely done, Mark.


Charles Pnin-isms are the best. Great review, Mark. Never expected something so cartoony when I read this, myself.


Mark  Porton Judith wrote: "What a character analysis by both you and Nabokov. I’m going to read this one!"

Great stuff Judith, I really hope you enjoy it and him!!


Mark  Porton Violeta wrote: "This story has a persistent ribbon of sadness running between the laughs.

What a beautiful sentence - Nabokov is affecting you in all the right ways, Mark!! You did a terrific reconstruction of t..."


Indeed it does Violeta and thanks heaps for your kind comment - Nabokov is such a good writer isn't he? BTW there is already a 'bit of Pnin' in me - e.g. I always have trouble getting out of my car without dropping my phone, or lunch or I leave the house without forgetting something, losing keys etc. There's probably a bit of Timofey in a few of us! I enjoyed your review too :))


Mark  Porton Beata wrote: "Definitely want to join Pnin-ists, Mark! :)) A delightful review!"

Well come on ever Beata - you know you want to!! Thanks heaps :)


message 24: by Ned (new)

Ned Moving it up on my TBR mountain- superb review!!


Mark  Porton Bianca wrote: "Beautiful review. Thanks for bringing this title to my attention. I don't recall ever coming across it. I do need to read more Nabokov."

Have you read Lolita Bianca? Anyway, this one is a beauty - I'm sure you'd like it!


Mark  Porton Mike wrote: "I totally agree, Mark! Great review - I loved Pnin and the Pnin'ian world he lived in. Very Pnin to the last page - a truly great novel."

Hahaha - I love your Pnin'ian comment about my review Mike - thanks mate!


Margaret M - (having a challenging time and on GR as much as I can) Sounds terrific as does your review Mark


Mark  Porton Anne (On semi-hiatus) wrote: "Mark, I really enjoyed reading your review. I now feel like I know Pnin (which, of course, I don't). I meant to read this book last year. Somehow that didn't happen. Btw, I don't get the humor/joke..."

I hope you read it in 2022 (soon) Annie!! You must it's great. Thanks so much for your nice comments.

"�..the housekeeper was married to a gloomy and stolid old Cossack whose main passion in life was amateur bookbinding. A self-taught pathological process"

What did I find funny about the passage above? - I'm glad you asked, there's so many things - the following words "Gloomy" "Stoic" and he's also "Old" and a COSSACK!!!! NO LESS!! 😂......but the killer for me, and the thing that sent me over the edge and my pup running for the door was his passion for "Amateur Bookbinding"....of all things, and not only that he was "SELF-TAUGHT" - yes took the time to learn.

I find that whole gloomy, serious, obsessive devotion to what is a very unusual hobby/past-time (even for an amateur) HILARIOUS. Yes, what I found funny about that was pretty much everything :)) 😂😂😂😂


Mark  Porton Left Coast Justin wrote: "Always adds to the fun when you know there's a lot of good reviews out there to peek at. Nicely done, Mark."

Thanks Justin and a lot of fun it is - in a quiet way, apart from the laugh out loud moments, they weren't so quiet. Thanks again mate!


Mark  Porton Ned wrote: "Moving it up on my TBR mountain- superb review!!"

Brilliant stuff Ned - enjoy!!


Mark  Porton Margaret wrote: "Sounds terrific as does your review Mark"

Thanks so much Margaret!!


Laysee Fab review, Mark. I love Pnin. I have a soft spot for him for those reasons you cited. (I was a stingy reviewer in earlier days when I rated this book. Please ignore my rating.) This is a book I wish to re-read some day and I'm so pleased you loved it.


message 33: by Ilse (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ilse Glad to find you in team Pnin, Mark! It was a joy to revive this delightful novel through your delectable review.


message 34: by Julie (new)

Julie G What a delightful review, Mark. I feel a little giddy at the rich language you've used here, and your obvious appreciation for the text.
P.S. I'm a sucker for a "bronzed bald dome!"


Mark  Porton Laysee wrote: "Fab review, Mark. I love Pnin. I have a soft spot for him for those reasons you cited. (I was a stingy reviewer in earlier days when I rated this book. Please ignore my rating.) This is a book I wi..."

Thanks so much Laysee, yes I enjoyed your review and you're right - it does read more like a 4-star review. Either way he's a terrific character isn't he? Definitely worth a re-read!


Mark  Porton Ilse (on semi-hiatus) wrote: "Glad to find you in team Pnin, Mark! It was a joy to revive this delightful novel through your delectable review."

Thanks for that feedback IIse, I really appreciate it - oh yes, I am firmly embedded in Team Pnin now, a bit late to the party I know!


Mark  Porton Julie wrote: "What a delightful review, Mark. I feel a little giddy at the rich language you've used here, and your obvious appreciation for the text.
P.S. I'm a sucker for a "bronzed bald dome!""


I loved your "Giddy" comment Julie and I almost swallowed my curried egg & lettuce roll (it's lunch time here) on your P.S. - that is GOLD!


message 38: by Julie (new)

Julie G


Mark  Porton Julie wrote: ""

CGI 😉


message 40: by Julie (new)

Julie G A great demonstration, though, of a bronzed bald dome!


message 41: by Praveen (new)

Praveen Glad to see your thoughts on the book. Very interesting take Mark! thanks for sharing.


message 42: by Antoinette (new) - added it

Antoinette What a marvellous review, Mark. I can almost visualize Pnin. Haven’t made his acquaintance yet, but hope to do so one day:)


Mark  Porton Praveen wrote: "Glad to see your thoughts on the book. Very interesting take Mark! thanks for sharing."

My pleasure Praveen and thanks for checking in!!


Mark  Porton Antoinette wrote: "What a marvellous review, Mark. I can almost visualize Pnin. Haven’t made his acquaintance yet, but hope to do so one day:)"

Oh please do Antoinette - we need you to join "Team Pnin" - he is a gem!


message 45: by Pedro (new)

Pedro Great review, Mark.

Nabokov nearly killed me (in a good way) with Lolita and I’m sure he’s going to impress me with this one too.

I’m on team President Porton, by the way. :D


Mark  Porton Hey Pedro, I can guarantee you'll drop Prezzy Porton like a hot rock when you get to know the Wonderful Comrade Pnin. Thanks again mate - PP 😉


message 47: by Yun (new)

Yun Great review, Mark! This sounds like it has it all! So glad you loved it! :)


Mark  Porton Thanks again Yun, if you like nerdy dudes with a good heart, you'll love Prof Pnin 😊


message 49: by Lori (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lori Marvelous review, Mark, your excerpts have me laughing with joy 😂 Definitely his most accessible work and the most broadly humorous: slapstick, snark, snide, a carnival of a book. :)


Mark  Porton Lori wrote: "Marvelous review, Mark, your excerpts have me laughing with joy 😂 Definitely his most accessible work and the most broadly humorous: slapstick, snark, snide, a carnival of a book. :)"

Thanks so much Lori, Nabokov certainly had a wicked wit didn't he? Poor old Pnin - how about his washing his hands and head (head for heavens sake!!!) every lunchtime, and also him spreading the word about how good it was to have no teeth!!! Bahahaha. I mean who thinks up this stuff - brilliant. I am so glad you gave it a smashing 5 stars too Lori - nice one!!!!


« previous 1
back to top