Ε·±¦ΣιΐΦ

Fran 's Reviews > Elsewhere

Elsewhere by Alexis Schaitkin
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
12653120
's review

it was amazing

"We believe our affliction began with [a blurred, smudged photograph, a girl doubled]. She became a wife who became a mother who became the first of us to go...When our affliction came for a mother...one minute she was here, as solid and real as any of us, the next her body faded, faded until she vanished into the clouds."

Vera, our narrator, described her isolated village, located in "the narrow aperture between mountains [where] everyday at dusk the clouds appeared, gathering out of nothing and thickening..." A village set apart. Anywhere else was elsewhere. Schoolgirl Vera, was in a hand-holding "threesome" with Di and Marie. It was expected that when they became "uppers" in school, marriage and motherhood would soon follow. Being a mother was a slippery slope, a new identity subject to the scrutiny and the judgement of others, gossip included.

"When a mother went...we sensed it...the clouds that took her touched us all...we felt her vanishing...". A full town ceremony ensued, the mother's existence erased. Why was this mother chosen? What was "out of balance in the nature of her love for her children that set her apart?" Did the mother love too intensely? Was she indifferent toward her children? "...it was impossible to predict what motherhood would bring out of a woman, what it would show her about herself..." How was Vera's mothering of her five year old daughter Iris being perceived? Her concern was heightened because her own mother had been disappeared.

A stranger named Ruth came to town. "[Ruth] couldn't see what we saw...we didn't demand answers from our affliction...we submitted to it. We bore it, carried it..." Vera experienced a transformation. In a attempt to save herself, Vera chose to disappear from her husband and daughter and escape the certainty of the affliction. She left the cozy, fiercely protective town and headed into the unknown.

"Elsewhere" by Alexis Schaitkin is a work of speculative fiction about motherhood, identity and how mothers judged themselves and were judged by others. Perhaps one needed to walk a mile in another's shoes to discover the many faces and emotions of motherhood and a mother's love. An excellent read I highly recommend.

Thank you Celadon Books for the print ARC in exchange for an honest review.
130 likes ·  βˆ� flag

Sign into Ε·±¦ΣιΐΦ to see if any of your friends have read Elsewhere.
Sign In Β»

Reading Progress

January 27, 2022 – Shelved (Audio CD Edition)
January 27, 2022 – Shelved as: to-read (Audio CD Edition)
February 15, 2022 – Started Reading
February 15, 2022 – Shelved
February 17, 2022 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 53 (53 new)


message 1: by Michael (new)

Michael David (on hiatus) Fantastic review, Fran! Glad you loved it!


message 2: by Fran (new) - added it

Fran Michael...you are the best. Most appreciated! ✨πŸ’�


message 3: by Kaceey (new)

Kaceey Excellent review Fran!πŸ’ž


message 4: by Fran (new) - added it

Fran Kaceey wrote: "Excellent review Fran!πŸ’ž"

Kaceey... thank you so much, sweetie! ❀️ 🧑 πŸ’›


MarilynW Wonderful review, Fran πŸ€—


message 6: by Fran (new) - added it

Fran MarilynW wrote: "Wonderful review, Fran πŸ€—"

Marilyn...thank you so much! πŸ’–πŸŒΉπŸ˜


message 7: by Yun (new)

Yun Great review, Fran! So glad you thoroughly enjoyed it! :)


Jayme Terrific review! πŸ’•


message 9: by Libby (new)

Libby Fran, I'm keeping a tbr list offline and I've added this book to it. Sounds very intriguing. Superb review :-)


Margaret M - (having a challenging time and on GR as much as I can) Excellent review Fran πŸ’–


message 11: by Fran (new) - added it

Fran Thank you Yun, Jayme, Libby & Margaret! Your kindness is greatly appreciated!
❀️ 🧑 πŸ’›


message 12: by Misty Marie (new)

Misty Marie Harms Fantastic review Fran!


message 13: by Fran (new) - added it

Fran Rambling Redhead wrote: "Fantastic review Fran!"

Thank you so much, RR! ❀️ 🧑 πŸ’›


message 14: by Tina (new)

Tina Another terrific 5 star review Fran! I'm so glad you enjoyed it!


message 15: by Fran (new) - added it

Fran Tina wrote: "Another terrific 5 star review Fran! I'm so glad you enjoyed it!"

Tina...thank you for your terrific comment! πŸŒΉπŸ’–πŸ˜


message 16: by Ceecee (new)

Ceecee Fantastic review Fran! ❀️


message 17: by Fran (new) - added it

Fran Ceecee wrote: "Fantastic review Fran! ❀️"

Thank you so much, Ceecee! πŸ˜πŸ’–πŸŒΉ


message 18: by Holly (new)

Holly  B (slower pace!) Fabulous review Fran!


message 19: by Fran (new) - added it

Fran Holly wrote: "Fabulous review Fran!"

Holly...thank you so much!πŸŒΉπŸ’–πŸ˜


message 20: by Kimber (new)

Kimber Silver What a lovely review, Fran! :-)


Meredith (Trying to catch up!) Wonderful review, Fran!


message 22: by Ellie (new)

Ellie Spencer (catching up from hiatus) Ohh this sounds so good! Fantastic review Fran 😊


message 23: by Christi (new)

Christi M What an intriguing premise. Wonderful review Fran! I'm glad you enjoyed it.


message 24: by Fran (new) - added it

Fran Thank you so much Kimber, Meredith, Ellie & Christi! You gals are most kind! πŸ₯°πŸ“š


message 25: by Mary Beth (new)

Mary Beth Fab review! πŸ’œ


message 26: by Fran (new) - added it

Fran Mary Beth wrote: "Fab review! πŸ’œ"

Thank you, Mary Beth! πŸ˜πŸ’–πŸŒΉ


message 27: by Paromjit (new)

Paromjit Your reviews are always excellent, dearest Fran! ❀️😘⭐️


message 28: by Fran (new) - added it

Fran Paromjit wrote: "Your reviews are always excellent, dearest Fran! ❀️😘⭐️"

Paromjit...your comments are always gracious! Thank you! ✨✨�


message 29: by Rae (new)

Rae Wow! Fabulous review, Fran! Sounds very intriguing indeed.


message 30: by Fran (new) - added it

Fran Rae wrote: "Wow! Fabulous review, Fran! Sounds very intriguing indeed."

Rae...thank you so much!😍✨�


message 31: by Karen (new)

Karen Wonderful review Fran!


message 32: by Fran (new) - added it

Fran Karen wrote: "Wonderful review Fran!"

Karen...thanks a bunch! πŸ’–πŸ˜πŸŒΉ


message 33: by Lea (new)

Lea What an interesting book, Fran! And I adore the cover.


message 34: by Fran (new) - added it

Fran Lea wrote: "What an interesting book, Fran! And I adore the cover."

Thank you so much, Lea! πŸŒΉπŸ˜πŸ’–


message 35: by Sue (new)

Sue Gerhardt Griffiths Fabulous review, Fran! πŸ’—


message 36: by Fran (new) - added it

Fran Sue wrote: "Fabulous review, Fran! πŸ’—"

Sue...much appreciated! 😁😊✨😊�


message 37: by Karine (new)

Karine Beautiful review, nicely done.


message 38: by Fran (new) - added it

Fran Karine wrote: "Beautiful review, nicely done."

Karine...Thank you so much!πŸ’–πŸŒΉπŸ˜


message 39: by Julie (new)

Julie Stellar review, Fran! πŸ’–


message 40: by Fran (new) - added it

Fran Julie wrote: "Stellar review, Fran! πŸ’–"

Julie...thank you very much!πŸ˜πŸŒΉπŸ’–


message 41: by Marialyce (new)

Marialyce Outstanding review, Fran!


message 42: by Fran (new) - added it

Fran Marialyce (absltmom, yaya) wrote: "Outstanding review, Fran!"

Thank you , my outstanding friend! πŸ’–πŸŒΉπŸ˜


message 43: by Kat (new)

Kat Beautiful review, Fran! It's definitely a compelling and thought-provoking subject!


message 44: by Fran (new) - added it

Fran Kat (on hiatus ... kinda) wrote: "Beautiful review, Fran! It's definitely a compelling and thought-provoking subject!"

Your comments are much appreciated, dear Kat! Thank you, thank you! πŸ’–βœ¨πŸ˜�



message 45: by Cheri (new) - added it

Cheri Fabulous review, Fran! I hadn't even seen this one before, but you've convinced me!


message 46: by Fran (new) - added it

Fran Cheri wrote: "Fabulous review, Fran! I hadn't even seen this one before, but you've convinced me!"

Cheri...I'm glad. I would love to read your thoughts if you go for it! 😍✨�


message 47: by Kay (new)

Kay Glad you loved it! Wonderful review Fran.πŸ’•


message 48: by Fran (new) - added it

Fran KaY wrote: "Glad you loved it! Wonderful review Fran.πŸ’•"

Thank you, my wonderful friend!πŸ˜πŸ’–πŸŒΉ


message 49: by Cheri (new) - added it

Cheri Fran - just letting you know that I did request this one, but it's still pending.


message 50: by Greta (new) - added it

Greta Samuelson This sounds like a book for me!

Great review


Β« previous 1
back to top