ŷ

MarilynW's Reviews > Elsewhere

Elsewhere by Alexis Schaitkin
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
49815208
's review

liked it
bookshelves: pub-prov

Elsewhere by Alexis Schaitkin

There is an isolated town where the people live their entire lives, isolated from Elsewhere, their only outside contact being the man who delivers their supplies and takes their goods to sell Elsewhere. This place is high up, damp, has a strange fog, it's very cultish (is it a cult?), and at more or less regular intervals, a mother will disappear forever. This is the way is was, the way it is, the way it will always be. This disappearing is called an affliction or is it due to an affliction? To explain this thing that they don't understand, the women left behind must find fault with the woman taken so that they can have some kind of false hope that it won't be them next time. But they are always afraid it will be them.

Vera is the centerpiece of this story and we see everything through her eyes. I don't understand the story and never fell into the rhythm of it, The men seem to have passively faded back in this world or maybe it's that they are safe, don't have to worry about the affliction happening to them, can know that they get to go on, no matter what happens to the women. The girls and women seem to have a built in cruelty to them, a constant suspicion about who will be next, what they did to be next, will it be them next. They seem to be their own worst enemy to me. But then, if things will never change, what can they do but over think this thing?

I encourage you to read other reviews for viewpoints from those who understood and enjoyed this story more than I did. I was able to read this story with DeAnn, Jayme, and Susan and I appreciate their thoughts on the story, because discussing it was what made reading the book more enjoyable for me. I love getting answers in books I read but this one provides very few answers.

Pub: June 28th

Thank you to Celadon Books for the print copy of this ARC.
230 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Elsewhere.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

June 14, 2022 – Started Reading
June 16, 2022 – Finished Reading
June 17, 2022 – Shelved

Comments Showing 1-50 of 64 (64 new)


message 1: by Kerrin (new)

Kerrin Fair review, Marilyn. This sounds a little like the movie "The Village". A little to weird for me.


MarilynW Kerrin wrote: "Fair review, Marilyn. This sounds a little like the movie "The Village". A little to weird for me."

Thank you, Kerrin, very weird and I would have enjoyed it more if there were explanations for things that happened. 😊


message 3: by Liz (new) - rated it 1 star

Liz You liked it more than I did. Well expressed review.


MarilynW Liz wrote: "You liked it more than I did. Well expressed review."

Thank you, Liz, it's more the discussion that did it for me, otherwise I was lost at sea with this one. 🤨


Susan  (on hiatus) Wonderful review Marilyn, I felt lost too - and as a group, no one could decipher it. It was interesting to discuss though!


message 6: by Ceecee (new)

Ceecee Great review Marilyn- sorry you didn’t connect with it. ❤️


MarilynW Susan - on semi hiatus wrote: "Wonderful review Marilyn, I felt lost too - and as a group, no one could decipher it. It was interesting to discuss though!"

Thank you, Susan, it left me feeling so sad but it was fun discussing it. 💗


MarilynW Ceecee wrote: "Great review Marilyn- sorry you didn’t connect with it. ❤️"

Thank you, Ceecee, it was a weird book. 🥰


Catherine (alternativelytitledbooks) - in a book slump :( This sounds like I’m either going to love or hate it…not my most anticipated ARC for sure, but I’m hopeful I’ll enjoy it. Glad you had a great buddy read, excellent review Marilyn! 💕


MarilynW Catherine wrote: "This sounds like I’m either going to love or hate it…not my most anticipated ARC for sure, but I’m hopeful I’ll enjoy it. Glad you had a great buddy read, excellent review Marilyn! 💕"

Thank you, Catherine, it is a love or hate thing, maybe it helps if the reader is a mother 😕


Jayme Even though you didn’t enjoy it-your review is fantastic! 💕


MarilynW Jayme wrote: "Even though you didn’t enjoy it-your review is fantastic! 💕"

Thank you so much, Jayme 🤗


Melissa (Always Behind) I have this one coming up, it sounds very...unique. Great review!


message 14: by Fran (new) - added it

Fran Marilyn...sorry this read did not meet expectations for you! Awesome review, nonetheless! 🌹


message 15: by Rosh (new)

Rosh Wonderful, honest review, Marilyn! 💕


message 16: by JanB (new)

JanB Sorry is was a bit disappointing but glad your discussions saved it. Great review Marilyn!


MarilynW Melissa (Extremely Behind) wrote: "I have this one coming up, it sounds very...unique. Great review!"

Thank you and I look forward to your review, Melissa, it's fun reading all the reviews, I'm looking for answers 😂


MarilynW Fran wrote: "Marilyn...sorry this read did not meet expectations for you! Awesome review, nonetheless! 🌹"

Thank you, Fran, it was fun discussing it though 🌸


MarilynW RoshReviews wrote: "Wonderful, honest review, Marilyn! 💕"

Thank you, Rosh! 💗


MarilynW JanB wrote: "Sorry is was a bit disappointing but glad your discussions saved it. Great review Marilyn!"

Thank you, Jan, I wonder what you would think of it? 😊


DeAnn Great review Marilyn. Maybe you are on outlier island with me.


MarilynW DeAnn wrote: "Great review Marilyn. Maybe you are on outlier island with me."

Yes, DeAnn, I'm on outlier island with you 🤗


message 23: by NZLisaM (new)

NZLisaM The plot does sound a bit weak, Marilyn. Fantastic review.


MarilynW NZLisaM wrote: "The plot does sound a bit weak, Marilyn. Fantastic review."

Yes, thank you, Lisa!


message 25: by Mary Beth (new)

Mary Beth Great review! Hope you love your next one. ❤️


MarilynW Mary Beth wrote: "Great review! Hope you love your next one. ❤️"

Thank you, Mary Beth! 💕


Meredith (Trying to catch up!) Fabulous review, Marilyn! I am going to lower my expectations for this one.


MarilynW Meredith wrote: "Fabulous review, Marilyn! I am going to lower my expectations for this one."

Thank you, Meredith, you might love it. I look forward to your review!


message 29: by Pat (new)

Pat Fantastic review Marilyn but it definitely doesn’t sound like one for me 🧡!


message 30: by Heidi (new)

Heidi Interesting premise� but probably not my kind of book� the unknowns would drive this bookworm bonkers. 😳🤯🤣


message 31: by Tina (new)

Tina A nice review Marilyn!


MarilynW Pat wrote: "Fantastic review Marilyn but it definitely doesn’t sound like one for me 🧡!"

Thank you, Pat, wasn't for me, either 😕


MarilynW Heidi wrote: "Interesting premise� but probably not my kind of book� the unknowns would drive this bookworm bonkers. 😳🤯🤣"

Thank you, Heidi! I don't like those unknowns, so many! 😵


MarilynW Tina wrote: "A nice review Marilyn!"

Thank you, Tina! 🥰


message 35: by Yvonne G (new)

Yvonne G Enjoyed your honest and thoughtful review! :


Kim ~ It’s All About the Thrill I think I would struggle with this one. Fantastic review Marilyn.


MarilynW Yvonne (Fiction Books) wrote: "Enjoyed your honest and thoughtful review! :"

Thank you, Yvonne! 💗


MarilynW Kim ~ It’s All About the Thrill wrote: "I think I would struggle with this one. Fantastic review Marilyn."

Thanks, Kim! My heart sank the further I got because I realized this was the way it was going to be, I'd be left wondering things...I hate to be left wondering 🤨


message 39: by Kevin (new)

Kevin Ansbro As Yvonne said, an honest and thoughtful review, Marilyn.


MarilynW Kevin wrote: "As Yvonne said, an honest and thoughtful review, Marilyn."

Thank you, Kevin!


Lindsay L Great review Marilyn! I’m reading this now.


MarilynW Lindsay - Traveling Sisters Book Reviews wrote: "Great review Marilyn! I’m reading this now."

Thank you and even though it wasn't for me, I hope you enjoy it, Lindsay.


message 43: by Freesiab (new)

Freesiab BookishReview Great review! Thank you


MarilynW Freesiab wrote: "Great review! Thank you"

And thank you, Freesiab! 💗


message 45: by Michael (new)

Michael David (on hiatus) Fantastic review, Marilyn! I have this one too, but won’t rush to get to it. 😊


message 46: by Debra (new)

Debra Great review, Marilyn!


MarilynW Michael wrote: "Fantastic review, Marilyn! I have this one too, but won’t rush to get to it. 😊"

Thank you, Michael, I look forward to knowing what you think of it! 🌞


MarilynW Debra wrote: "Great review, Marilyn!"

Thank you, Debra! 💗


message 49: by Serge (new)

Serge Great review Marilyn! Seems like an eerie story, with all those mothers disappearing in an isolated cult-like town, sorry it didn't really work for you though!


MarilynW Serge wrote: "Great review Marilyn! Seems like an eerie story, with all those mothers disappearing in an isolated cult-like town, sorry it didn't really work for you though!"

Thank you, Serge, not for me at all!


« previous 1
back to top