Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

leynes's Reviews > The Iliad

The Iliad by Homer
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
45198798
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: all-time-favorites, penguin-deluxe

The Iliad; "a poem about Ilium (Troy)" is one of two major ancient Greek epic poems attributed to Homer. As with the Odyssey, the poem is divided into 24 books and was written in dactylic hexameter. It contains 15,693 lines in its most widely accepted version. Set towards the end of the Trojan War, a ten-year siege of the city of Troy by a coalition of Mycenaean Greek states, the poem depicts significant events in the siege's final weeks. In particular, the fierce quarrel between King Agamemnon and the celebrated warrior, Achilles.

There are two human beings in the poem who are godlike, Achilles and Helen. Helen, the "cause" of the war, is a sort of human Aphrodite. She is irresistible. Every king in Greece was ready to fight for her hand in marriage, but she chose Menelaus, King of Sparta. When Paris, the Prince of Troy, came to visit, she ran off with him [or was abducted by him, depending on how one interprets the story], leaving husband and daughter, without a thought of the consequences for others. When she left with Paris she acted like a god, with no thought of anything but the fulfilment of her own desire. However, at the beginning of the Iliad, she has already recognised her flaws. She feels responsible for the human misery she sees all around her, something the gods never do. The gods feel no responsibility for the human victims of their private wars.

At the beginning of the Iliad Helen has already broken out of the prison of self-absorption, but this is the point at which Achilles enters it. The Iliad shows the origin, course and consequences of his rage, his imprisonment in a godlike, lonely, heroic fury from which all the rest of the world is excluded, and also his return to human stature. The road to this final release is long and grim, strewn with the corpses of many a Greek and Trojan, and it leads finally to his own death.

Achilles plays no part in the events described in Books 2 through 8; he sits by his ships on the shore, waiting for the fulfilment of his mother's promise. And by the end of Book 8, the supplication of Thetis and the will of Zeus have begun to produce results. The Greeks are in retreat, penned up in their hastily fortified camp at nightfall, awaiting the Trojan assault, which will come with daybreak. And Agamemnon yields to Nestor's advice to send an embassy to Achilles, urging him to return to the battle line. It is a magnificent offer, but there is one thing missing: Agamemnon offers no apology, no admission that he was in the wrong. Therefore, Achilles rejects this embassy and any other that may be sent. He vows to sail home the next day, with all his men.

Due to a string of events [mainly the death of his beloved fellow warrior Patroclus at the hands of Hector, Prince of Troy], Achilles decides to join the war after all. When he does go into battle, the Trojans turn and run for the gates; only Hector remains outside. And the two champions come face-to-face at last. The contrast between the raw, self-absorbed fury of Achilles and the civilised responsibility and restraint of Hector is maintained to the end. It is of his people, the Trojans, that Hector is thinking as he throws his spear at Achilles: “How much lighter the war would be for Trojans then / if you, their greatest scourge, were dead and gone!�

But it is Hector who dies, and as Achilles exults over his fallen enemy, his words bring home again the fact that he is fighting for himself alone; this is the satisfaction of a personal hatred. He taunts Hector with the fate of his body. And in answer to Hector's plea and offer of ransom for his corpse, he reveals the extreme inhuman hatred and fury he has reached: “Beg no more, you fawning dog � begging me by my parents! / Would to god my rage, my fury would drive me now / to hack your flesh away and eat you raw –� This is how the gods hate. His words recall those of Zeus to Hera in Book 4: “Only if you could breach / their gates and their long walls and devour Priam�.

Achilles lashes Hector's body to his chariot, and, in full view of the Trojans on the walls, drags it to his tent, where he organises a magnificent funeral for Patroclus. All through the funeral games he acts with a tact, diplomacy and generosity that seem to signal the end of his desperate isolation, his godlike self-absorption; we almost forget that Hector's corpse is still lying in the dust, tied to his chariot, and that Achilles refuses the will of Zeus, refuses to surrender Hector's body to his father Priam.

Only when Priam himself visits Achilles in his tent and kisses his hand does Achilles break out at last from the prison of self-absorbed, godlike passion. Achilles takes Priam's hands and begins to weep. But not for Priam but for his own aged father, to whose memory Priam had appealed and who will soon, like Priam, lose a son.

Achilles goes to collect the ransom, and when he orders Hector's body to be washed and anointed, he gives orders to have it done out of Priam's sight: “He feared that, overwhelmed by the sight of Hector, / wild with grief, Priam might let his anger flare / and Achilles might fly into fresh rage himself, / cut the old man down …� He knows himself. This is a new Achilles, who can feel pity for others. For the first time he shows self-knowledge and acts to prevent the calamity his violent temper might bring about. It is as near to self-criticism as he ever gets, but it marks the point at which he ceases to be godlike Achilles and becomes a human being in the full sense of the word.

The tragic course of Achilles' rage, his final recognition of human values – this is the guiding theme of the poem, and it is developed against a background of violence and death. But the grim progress of the war is interrupted by scenes which remind us that the brutality of war is not the whole of it. Except for Achilles, whose worship of violence falters only in the final moment of pity for Priam, the yearning for peace and its creative possibilities is never far below the surface of the warriors' minds. This is most poignantly expressed by the scenes that take place in Troy, especially the farewell scene between Hector and Andromache. (<3) But it is not enough. The Iliad remains a terrifying poem. Achilles, just before his death, is redeemed as a human being, but there is no consolation for the death of Hector. We are left with a sense of waste, which is not adequately balanced even by the greatness of the heroic figures and the action; the scale descends towards loss. The Iliad remains not only the greatest epic poem in literature but also the most tragic.

The death of Hector seals the fate of Troy; it will fall to the Achaeans, to become the pattern for all time of the death of a city. The images of that night assault � the blazing palaces, the blood running in the streets, old Priam butchered at the altar, Cassandra raped in the temple, Hector's baby son thrown from the battlements, his wife Andromache dragged off to slavery � all this, foreshadowed in the Iliad, will be stamped indelibly on the consciousness of the Greeks throughout their history, immortalised in lyric poetry, in tragedy, on temple pediments and painted vases, to reinforce the stern lesson of Homer's presentation of war: that no civilisation, no matter how rich, no matter how refined, can long survive once it loses the power to meet force with equal or superior force.
196 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read The Iliad.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

February 26, 2022 – Shelved
January 4, 2023 – Started Reading
January 21, 2023 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-30 of 30 (30 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Nina ( picturetalk321 ) I adore the Iliad! I prefer it to the Odyssey


Nina ( picturetalk321 ) you have a treasure to discover in that wine red sea


leynes Nina ( picturetalk321 ) wrote: "you have a treasure to discover in that wine red sea"

BESTIE WHEN I TELL YOU HOW OBSESSED I AM WITH THIS BOOK ALREADY I LOVE IT MORE THAN LIFE ITSELF


Zosia Yayyy. I loved it, I'm afraid I'll like the Odyssey less because this was so good :)


leynes Zosia wrote: "Yayyy. I loved it, I'm afraid I'll like the Odyssey less because this was so good :)"

Reading the two made me realise that while I love The Odyssey, I am absolutely OBSESSED with The Iliad. I am totally shook now!


message 6: by Law (new)

Law Wow, this sounds amazing, I might read this in the future.


leynes Law wrote: "Wow, this sounds amazing, I might read this in the future."

it's everything to me right now, it's the story of humankind, a universal story that has lived on for thousands of years and will live on for thousands more


message 8: by tanja (new)

tanja literally shaking in my seat while waiting for you to review this!!!


leynes tatjana wrote: "literally shaking in my seat while waiting for you to review this!!!"

I CANNOT WAIT TO SCREAM ABOUT THIS IN MY JANUARY WRAP UP ... also an individual review will follow. This book is one of the best things that has ever happened to me.


message 10: by Victoria (new) - added it

Victoria does homer name a lot of ships in this book? Apparently that was their favorite part in antiquity


message 11: by Danielle (new)

Danielle What edition did you read? I’ve got Fagles and Butler not sure which one flows better


message 12: by Cathrine (new)

Cathrine Hoffner All right, I’ve had this book on my shelves for some months now. Sounds like maybe I should pick it up??


leynes Cathrine wrote: "All right, I’ve had this book on my shelves for some months now. Sounds like maybe I should pick it up??"

IT'S A YES FROM ME!!!

Danielle wrote: "What edition did you read? I’ve got Fagles and Butler not sure which one flows better"

Read Fagles, but he's not known for a "lyrical" style. It reads quite prose-ish, despite being written in verse. I love his translation though because it feels rather modern and it's easy to get immersed into the story that way.

Victoria wrote: "does homer name a lot of ships in this book? Apparently that was their favorite part in antiquity"

Book 2 of The Iliad is the longest list of names (also names of ships!) you'll ever read, it's the most boring Book out of all of them :>

Matheus wrote: "you made these books seem reasonable with your commentary on it. i'm not into these milenar classics but oh gurl, it sounded fun"

it sure is fun :D


siege is tired this on my tbr for this year! looks like it’ll be worth reading sooner rather than later!

although, i am curious, what translation are you reading?


leynes solitaire during the renaissance wrote: "this on my tbr for this year! looks like it’ll be worth reading sooner rather than later!

although, i am curious, what translation are you reading?"


hope you enjoy it as much as i did! read the fagles translation and would recommend it, it's very accessible if not the most "beautiful".


message 16: by Olivia (new) - added it

Olivia Love your reviews as always! I can’t wait to read the Iliad. I’m almost done with the Odyssey and don’t want it to end. I also have the Fagles translation for both.


leynes Olivia wrote: "Love your reviews as always! I can’t wait to read the Iliad. I’m almost done with the Odyssey and don’t want it to end. I also have the Fagles translation for both."

I already loved Fagles' Odyssey but his Iliad is SO MUCH BETTER, it is simply the supreme poem!


leynes Christiane wrote: "Don't go to die before you've read War and Peace! ;-)"

Christiane, you know what, you got a point.


message 19: by Sam (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sam Just wanted to pop in and say that I am also trying to read my whole physical TBR this year which includes The Iliad and The Odyssey. Seeing you love them so much is making me less scared to get to them!


leynes Sam wrote: "Just wanted to pop in and say that I am also trying to read my whole physical TBR this year which includes The Iliad and The Odyssey. Seeing you love them so much is making me less scared to get to..."

Good luck with that goal! You're in for a treat with Homer!


message 21: by isabell (new) - added it

isabell i was always interested in this book but the edition i have is 700+ pages (introduction, etc) but this review made me go for it! i just have to finish the series I’m reading right now, then I will read it. Thank you for this review!


leynes isabell wrote: "i was always interested in this book but the edition i have is 700+ pages (introduction, etc) but this review made me go for it! i just have to finish the series I’m reading right now, then I will ..."

mine was 700+ pages as well but let me assure you, they sure fly by! hope you have splendid experience with homer's iliad!


Kayla Harder I’m so glad to see I’m not the only one who thinks Hector is *chefs kiss*


leynes Kayla wrote: "I’m so glad to see I’m not the only one who thinks Hector is *chefs kiss*"

HE IS THE IDEAL MAN!!!!!


James Thomas Hahahahahahaha I love this review. The Illiad is in my top 3 tops of all time


leynes James wrote: "Hahahahahahaha I love this review. The Illiad is in my top 3 tops of all time"

Glad you enjoyed it. :D I just love this book!


James Thomas Have you ever listened to the audio version read by George Guidell?


message 28: by Sabine (new)

Sabine What made you decide to read Homer in English? I’m struggling and can’t make up my mind which translation and language to choose.


leynes James wrote: "Have you ever listened to the audio version read by George Guidell?"

Nope, never.


leynes Sabine wrote: "What made you decide to read Homer in English? I’m struggling and can’t make up my mind which translation and language to choose."

No real reason. I wanted to have an edition with lots of notes and commentary and the "Penguin Deluxe classics" edition is a trusted one for me. Then I read up on Fagles and saw that most people recommend his translation to beginners, so it was a done deal. If you decide to read him in German you must (!) read him in the translation by Dietrich Ebener, it's the only good/faithful German one! I read the first few pages of the Ebener translation but loved it so much that upon a reread I'd definitely choose this one!


back to top