ŷ

Anna [Bran. San. Stan]'s Reviews > Tress of the Emerald Sea

Tress of the Emerald Sea by Brandon Sanderson
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
98245866
's review

it was amazing
Read 2 times. Last read September 12, 2024 to October 9, 2024.

2024: The GraphicAudio adaptation is fantastic! The same actor who is voicing Wit in Stormlight is the narrator here. He’s doing a great job and you‘ve got to love consistency like that.

2023: This was just as wonderful, delightful, and enchanting as I’d hoped; especially the humourous, whimsical tone and Hoid’s narrative voice were a joy. And the worldbuilding is just as amazing as ever: Picture a world with twelve moons, each releasing sand-like spores unto the land, creating twelve vast seas not of water but of alien dust - each a different color (the eponymous emerald being one of them). Each type of these spores explosively grows aethers (e.g. vines or crystals) when touched with water - the results of which range from “uncomfortable� to “deadly� considering “the number of wet things that leak from human bodies even if they’re healthy.� Only salt and silver render the spores inert. And they are not just a cool visual; they naturally serve to further the story.

As for the plot, the novel starts as a love story but then quickly becomes an adventure - farm boy (or rather window washing girl) leaving home to go on a hero’s journey. With our heroine, Sanderson again creates a magical character you can only love; she is proactive, competent, both brave and pragmatic, and above all relatable.

”The girl had been given the unfortunate name of Glorf upon her birth (don’t judge; it was a family name), but her wild hair earned her the name everyone knew her by: Tress.�


Tress is very much in love with the Duke’s son, Charlie, who is not very dukely at all. Charlie actually sounds a bit like Sanderson himself with his passion for story telling and words.

”[The Iriali] supposedly had golden hair. Like yours, the color of sunlight.�
“My hair is not the color of sunlight, Charlie.�
“Your hair is the color of sunlight, if sunlight were brown,� Charlie said. It might be said he had a way with words. In that his words often got away.


Charlie, however, is absent from the narrative, and Tress’s adventure lies in trying to save him from an evil sorceress. (She is, in a way, Buttercup who had gone searching for Westley.) Her journey is interwoven with a variety of characters, among them a cursed Hoid, a talking rat, a Cosmere creature, a horrible cook and also several insignificant people all referred to as Doug for simplicity’s sake.

With this “grown-up fairy tale�, Sanderson has once again created something extraordinary, something magical and enchanting and something very much unlike anything he has ever written before. And yes, Hoid’s story did feel like a “full-length version of something like 'Wandersail' or ‘The Dog and the Dragon’� - just as he intended. And even if I saw a twist at the end coming, I loved every bit of it, from the very first page.


In terms of Cosmere implications, what can you expect? (Skip if you’d rather not know. Essentially, no previous knowledge is required for you to enjoy the story; however, you will appreciate it even more if you do know your Cosmere.)

**





🔹Hoid as both a storyteller and character, though his role within the narrative is initially hilariously complicated because of a curse (some knowledge of either Warbreaker, Elantris, both Mistborn eras, White Sand and especially Stormlight is helpful)
🔹Aethers, though a different type than shown in The Lost Metal and the non-canon Aether of Night (no previous knowledge required)
🔹Kandra (Mistborn knowledge is helpful)
🔹the Nalthian magic of awakening (no previous knowledge necessary)
🔹having read Secret History is a bonus







—ĔĔĔĔĔĔĔĔ�-

March 5, 2022: The first five chapters of this (no-longer) secret project #1 are just enchanting. I loved that Hoid is telling this "slightly more fairy-tale-ish" story in his customary cheeky tone. I can just picture him telling Tress‘s story to others in the Cosmere. Did I mention I can’t wait to read this?

“She felt less a human being and more like a human who was just being.�

I’ve been beyond excited these past couple of days about Sanderson‘s announcement and these four new books! So happy to be a part of his Kickstarter campaign! (And spending waaaay too much money on it.) So much to look forward to, this year and the next...

PA: You can listen to Sanderson reading the first chapters here:
233 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Tress of the Emerald Sea.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

March 4, 2022 – Shelved as: to-read
March 4, 2022 – Shelved
January 1, 2023 – Started Reading
January 2, 2023 – Finished Reading
September 12, 2024 – Started Reading
October 9, 2024 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-41 of 41 (41 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Ifigenia I wish the actually audiobook was of him reading it 🤩


Melcat Hi Anna ! Do you recommend to finish Stormlight before reading this one ?


Anna [Bran. San. Stan] Ifigenia wrote: "I wish the actually audiobook was of him reading it 🤩"

I really enjoy listening to him reading from his books as well! He has that cheeky tone down pat. 💕 But Micheal Kramer always does a really good job too!


Anna [Bran. San. Stan] Melcat wrote: "Hi Anna ! Do you recommend to finish Stormlight before reading this one ?"

Hi, Mel! I will get back to you on that one when I've finished reading but as of now I'd say it's not necessary. Brandon has said it's only Cosmere-adjacent so you should be fine. (You will definitely miss some Easter eggs though.) BUT I also know you are big on reading order so it could be the best decision for you to wait. Hoid/Wit narrates this story so if you don't really know who that is but you want to, you should not read this first. What are your priorities? I'll try and factor that into my advice once I'm done reading. 😊

PS: The fourth secret project is far more Cosmere-heavy so it would be good to be up to speed on the Cosmere from what I've read.


Chase Sears I caught the Kandra reference, but none of the others yet. And I've read every full length cosmere novel and most novellas. I guess you're just more observant :D


MadAlys Rivers Looks like I’ll be able to get this on April 4 😊


message 7: by Anna [Bran. San. Stan] (last edited Jan 03, 2023 11:12AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Anna [Bran. San. Stan] Chase wrote: "I caught the Kandra reference, but none of the others yet. And I've read every full length cosmere novel and most novellas. I guess you're just more observant :D"

😂 Thanks but I doubt it... I usually miss a ton of references. I'll probably have to add to that list at some point.


message 8: by Anna [Bran. San. Stan] (last edited Jan 03, 2023 04:56AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Anna [Bran. San. Stan] MadAlys wrote: "Looks like I’ll be able to get this on April 4 😊"

I have some good news for you! 😊The ebook will be available on January 10 or 11! The April release date refers to the hard copies! Same for the other secret projects: available as ebook the tenth of each release month.


message 9: by Diane (new)

Diane Wallace Delightful review, Anna! and wishing you all the best for 2023! ;)


Anna [Bran. San. Stan] Diane wrote: "Delightful review, Anna! and wishing you all the best for 2023! ;)"

Thank you so much, Diane! All the best to you for the new year as well! 😊


message 11: by Warda (new)

Warda You’ve made this sound all kinds of wonderful, Anna!


message 12: by Mina (new) - added it

Mina So excited to get to this after my exam next week. Thank you for highlighting the cosmere mentions. Unfortunately, I have not yet gotten to rereading Era 2 and getting to the Lost Metal, but I am so excited for this one!


Anna [Bran. San. Stan] Warda wrote: "You’ve made this sound all kinds of wonderful, Anna!"

Thank you, Ward! Mission accomplished then. 😊 It really was all kinds of wonderful. Will probably re-read soon!


Anna [Bran. San. Stan] Mina wrote: "So excited to get to this after my exam next week. Thank you for highlighting the cosmere mentions. Unfortunately, I have not yet gotten to rereading Era 2 and getting to the Lost Metal, but I am s..."

You are right to be excited, Mina! I'm glad my review was helpful! I don't think it matters that much that you haven't read TLM yet. Something will simply sound familiar when you get to it after reading Tress, other than the other way around. Hope you'll love it as much as I do! And good luck with your exam!


Aaron Well, this book was just an absolute delight. Just finished the audiobook, and Michael Kramer’s narration was as good as ever. I can’t wait for the rest of these secret projects if this is the type of quality we can expect!


Anna [Bran. San. Stan] Aaron wrote: "Well, this book was just an absolute delight. Just finished the audiobook, and Michael Kramer’s narration was as good as ever. I can’t wait for the rest of these secret projects if this is the type..."

I'm glad you also loved TotES, Aaron! Listening to the audiobook is next on my list. I have the feeling this Year of Sanderson is going to be great! I'm especially looking forward to SP 4!


Aaron I'm interested in your POV on something here, Anna. One area in which I feel BranSan has really grown in his writing has been his ability to get in the heads and write from the perspective of his female characters. I mean, I love Vin, for example, but she wasn't even his first female protagonist and she could be pretty one-note at times, as amazing as she was. And it worked for the story he was telling! It's just that Vin didn't really...grow much, I guess, when compared with the women he's written since.

Just off the top of my head, Shallan, Jasnah, Navani, and even Lift and Syl - counting only characters who get what I'd call significant page time - have grown SO MUCH. The same can be said for Sterris and Marasi in Mistborn Era II. Spensa Nightshade in Cytonic as well? I think so.

And now we have Tress. Without spoilers, her journey was so satisfying, I don't even have words. One of my favorite aspects of Brandon's writing is how he really puts effort into improving parts of his process he feels need work. Something I always come back to is how much work he did in researching PTSD and talking with survivors to make sure he was doing Kaladin's struggle the right way; that he made it feel genuine and authentic.

I'd love to get your thoughts!


message 18: by Anna [Bran. San. Stan] (last edited Jan 06, 2023 01:43PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Anna [Bran. San. Stan] Aaron wrote: "I'm interested in your POV on something here, Anna. One area in which I feel BranSan has really grown in his writing has been his ability to get in the heads and write from the perspective of his f..."

Thank you for your message, Aaron! I love talking about Sanderson! And yes, I absolutely agree with you! I am so in awe of his ability to get into the heads of his characters and believably portray such a wide variety of personalities and opinions: Kaladin and his PTSD/depression is definitely among them, Jasnah's atheism, Shallan's multiple personality disorder, you name it. I'm also in awe of how much work he puts into getting it right.

Like you, I also feel like he has gotten better at giving more depth to his female characters. I love Vin but her arc mostly dealt with her trust issues and her figuring out her identity (to simplify things) and the characters you mentioned have many more layers than that. Honestly, Tress is probably among his best female characters. Her arc was so well done! I believe he said at some point it took a while for him to figure out the female perspective and I think it's safe to say he has long since mastered that.

I also feel like he has gotten better at writing romance. When I first read The Final Empire I was a bit surprised to see Vin and Elend become a couple and I felt I must have missed clues as to her feelings. The romance in Warbreaker also didn't feel as natural as, say, Shallan and Adolin or as Tress and Charlie. It's a bit hard to explain. Do you understand what I mean? What are your thoughts?


Aaron Oh I absolutely agree about his ability to write romance. I thought he made Elend’s feelings pretty clear in the original Mistborn trilogy, but Vin’s reciprocation of them was pretty read-between-the-lines-y. Wax and…well, that may still be considered a spoiler, Shallan and Adolin, even Navani and Dalinar are all great examples of his progression. Navani coming before Sadeas and drawing the giant glyph in rage and heartache - I believe the glyph for Justice - after his betrayal of Dalinar in Way of Kings is one of my favorite moments in the book. Showing love, not just telling. So great.

Agree with you 100%!


message 20: by Anna [Bran. San. Stan] (last edited Jan 06, 2023 01:47PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Anna [Bran. San. Stan] Aaron wrote: "Oh I absolutely agree about his ability to write romance. I thought he made Elend’s feelings pretty clear in the original Mistborn trilogy, but Vin’s reciprocation of them was pretty read-between-t..."

That really was a very powerful moment, I agree, Aaron! I also really love, in general, how supportive Adolin is of Shallan and that there's no unnecessary relationship drama. And I'm glad to hear you also felt Vin's feelings were mostly conveyed in the subtext. So yep, we are again in agreement 😊.


Shreyas Great review, Anna! TotES was such a delight read. Plenty of Cosmere easter eggs in here, especially from the Ars Arcanum of RoW and TLM.


Anna [Bran. San. Stan] Shreyas wrote: "Great review, Anna! TotES was such a delight read. Plenty of Cosmere easter eggs in here, especially from the Ars Arcanum of RoW and TLM."

Thank you, Shreyas! Happy you loved it too! The Easter eggs were so much fun! And thanks for the tip with the Ars Arcanum! It's been a while since I read it and I really need to check if I missed anything!


✧ FLINN ✧ (Semi-Hiatus) Can't wait to dive into this one! Amazing review as always!


Anna [Bran. San. Stan] � FLINN � (semi-hiatus) wrote: "Can't wait to dive into this one! Amazing review as always!"

Thank you so much, Flinn! I'm sure you'll love it!


Ifigenia Anna wrote: "Ifigenia wrote: "I wish the actually audiobook was of him reading it 🤩"

I really enjoy listening to him reading from his books as well! He has that cheeky tone down pat. 💕 But Micheal Kramer alway..."

I know that I am the minority but I really hate Kramer. He doesn't have that cheeky tone that Sanderson had when reading it. That's why I am reading this one.


Anna [Bran. San. Stan] Ifigenia wrote: "Anna wrote: "Ifigenia wrote: "I wish the actually audiobook was of him reading it 🤩"

I really enjoy listening to him reading from his books as well! He has that cheeky tone down pat. 💕 But Micheal..."


That sucks that you hate him, seeing as he narrates all of Sanderson's books! I'm so sorry. Do you least enjoy GraphicAudio?

Anyway, with Tress, I understand where you are coming from! I really would have preferred Sanderson to read this one himself. Kramer doesn't do cheeky the way he does. To be fair, I have yet to listen to Tress so we'll see...


Aaron FWIW, Michael's somewhat nasal tone he adopts when he slides into character for many of his...well...characters, kind of bugged me at first, too. But I've since grown accustomed and it's hard for me to picture anyone else but him and Kate Reading as The Voice of Brandon's books.

Part of the adjustment period was due to a prior association. I'd never heard him do one of Brandon's books, but I had heard him do the Licanius Trilogy by James Islington (well worth your time if anyone is looking for a read and hasn't come across it yet), and so had a hard time adjusting my perception of his voice to new characters.

There are really only two other audiobook narrators I think I'd want in the Sandoverse outside of Michael and Kate, and that's my personal favorite, Travis Baldree, and another great one in Nick Podehl. Travis has a way with voices unlike anything I've ever seen, and has brought Will Wight's Cradle series, so close to BranSan stuff as my favorite in all of fantasy lit, to cinematic life in my head. Moved me to tears, made me laugh, and everything in between. I've sought out books because I knew he was narrating them. He also authored a lovely bit of fantasy, a slice-of-life type book, called Legends & Lattes. Just pure relaxation and fun.

PHEW. Sorry for going off topic there, Anna! I love talking audiobook narrators almost as much as authors!


message 28: by Anna [Bran. San. Stan] (last edited Jan 20, 2023 06:24AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Anna [Bran. San. Stan] Aaron wrote: "FWIW, Michael's somewhat nasal tone he adopts when he slides into character for many of his...well...characters, kind of bugged me at first, too. But I've since grown accustomed and it's hard for m..."

I had the same issue with Kramer's nasal voices, especially recently in TLM; otherwise I really enjoy listening to him. I actually do own the audiobooks for the Licanius trilogy but just haven't gotten round to it yet! Still, for Tress, I would have loved for Sanderson to read it himself. When I listened to him on YouTube a year back, I fell in love with his kind of story-telling in connection with the whimsical tone. He sounded like Hoid to me. 😊

Btw, thank you for the Will Wight tip! You make it sound all kinds of wonderful! I'll be busy with WoT for a loooong time yet, so it's gonna have to be put on my TBR shelf 😊. I know Nick Podehl but it's honestly been a while but I'll watch out for those two narrators! And no need to apologize! In case you couldn't tell, I love talking audiobook narrators as well 🙈. I'm not sure if we've talked about GraphicAudio before?


Aaron @Anna I know I’ve listened to several GraphicAudio productions, and enjoyed them all! And I really love all the options available to readers these days. Like, I won’t ever drop paste and paper entirely, obviously for special editions and such, but I also love reading eBooks at night before bed. And I work from home in a job where I need something to keep my focus so I can keep the rest of my brain on task, if that makes sense (explaining ADHD is hard!), so I listen to a ton of audiobooks! It’s really made me appreciate what a great narrator can do for a story - especially when you pair it with great writing.

I’m jealous of you, getting a chance to read Will Wight’s stuff for the first time if you decide to go that route once the Wheel has Woven what the Wheel has Willed! He is very much a smaller author than Brandon, but the last few books in the Cradle series have made it on to the NYT Bestseller list I believe, and have made immediate splashes on Amazon and Audible.

He’s similar to Brandon in that his magic systems are so inventive, but their writing styles are very different. Will’s books are much shorter (usually in the realm of 400 pages), and they feel like Marvel movies, I guess. That’s a good description. They feel like I’m reading The Avengers or something. Thor:Ragnarok. Where it’s lighthearted and funny but the action is incredible and you cannot help but get emotionally attached to the characters - and Will isn’t shy about reminding us that there are real stakes involved for our protagonists.

So if The Stormlight Archive is, like, the new Dune movie, or Peter Jackson’s Lord of the Rings - just a sweeping epic in all ways - Cradle is the Marvel Cinematic Universe.

If any of that makes sense? I love both but for different reasons? Even though BranSan will probably always be my fav.


Shreyas I'm going to second the Cradle recommendation. I read it last year and had a blast going through all of those books. The final book is releasing this year, so this might be the right time to jump in.


Anna [Bran. San. Stan] Aaron wrote: "@Anna I know I’ve listened to several GraphicAudio productions, and enjoyed them all! And I really love all the options available to readers these days. Like, I won’t ever drop paste and paper enti..."

I just love GraphicAudio! I was surprised to find out many people loathe them (especially in the fb Cosmere group; not so much on GR). And I'm with you, as much as I love audiobooks, I will never abandon the written form - I buy ebooks because I prefer reading that way and if I loved it, I get a copy for my shelf. (My SanderShelf is coming along very nicely, with leatherbounds for example. So I definitely understand your love for special editions! ) I just miss too much when I only listen to a book. I usually read and then listen to a book I already know as my ritual before sleeping or when I'm too tired to do anything else. It sucks you have to deal with ADHD, but I'm glad you found a way to cope. I know several especially younger people who are having a hard time at school.

Will Wight definitely sounds amazing! You've absolutely convinced me. The Avengers are awesome and I'd appreciate something lighthearted after something epic. I also wouldn't mind a series with "short" books 😂. I'm only just starting book 4 (1000 pages) of Wheel of Time and I'm not sure if I want to start another series at the moment but we'll see how much WoT takes out of me.... I'm almost sad because based on your description alone, I want to start sooner than later! Thank you so much for the rec, Aaron!


Anna [Bran. San. Stan] Shreyas wrote: "I'm going to second the Cradle recommendation. I read it last year and had a blast going through all of those books. The final book is releasing this year, so this might be the right time to jump in."

That settles it, I need to read this! Just put it on my tbr. Thanks for weighing in, Shreyas! I'm a "bit" tied up with WoT for the moment but I'm already looking forward to the Cradle!


Aaron @Anna: If it’s any consolation, The Shadow Rising (Book 4 of The Wheel of Time) has one of the best ending sequences of any of the books in the series, IMO. I reeally enjoy that stretch of 4-6, and then it starts to lag a bit, until the book before Brandon takes over (again, IMO). Jordan’s last entry into the series is excellent!


Ifigenia I love graphic audio! 😍 I listened to series I wouldn't have just because they were recorded by them.


Anna [Bran. San. Stan] Aaron wrote: "@Anna: If it’s any consolation, The Shadow Rising (Book 4 of The Wheel of Time) has one of the best ending sequences of any of the books in the series, IMO. I reeally enjoy that stretch of 4-6, and..."

Yay! If the series gets even better in that 4-6 stretch, I'm even more looking forward to reading! Will just try to forget about that lagging stretch until then.


Anna [Bran. San. Stan] Ifigenia wrote: "I love graphic audio! 😍 I listened to series I wouldn't have just because they were recorded by them."

Same!! 💕 My love knows no bounds!


message 37: by Charles (new) - added it

Charles I recently discovered GraphicAudio, and I have been wanting to read this particular book for awhile, so you have convinced me to use one of my Audible credits on this story. Another wonderful review Anna thanks so much !!!


Anna [Bran. San. Stan] Charles wrote: "I recently discovered GraphicAudio, and I have been wanting to read this particular book for awhile, so you have convinced me to use one of my Audible credits on this story. Another wonderful revie..."

That's great, Charles! I hope you'll love it. 😊 Since you like GraphicAudio, you really need to listen to the Stormlight Archive, which is probably their best adaptation. Mistborn is pretty amazing as well. And thank you for the kind words! I'm looking forward to your review on Tress!


Chris Lee (away) I'm so glad it was another amazing audio experience, Anna! :D


Anna [Bran. San. Stan] Chris Lee wrote: "I'm so glad it was another amazing audio experience, Anna! :D"

Thank you, Chris! Frugal Wizard is coming out as GraphicAudio soon and I'm hoping the trend continues. 😊


Anna [Bran. San. Stan] Anna [Bran. San. Stan] wrote: "Chris Lee wrote: "I'm so glad it was another amazing audio experience, Anna! :D"

Thank you, Chris! Frugal Wizard is coming out as a GraphicAudio production soon and I'm hoping the trend continues. 😊"



back to top