欧宝娱乐

Christin's Reviews > The Black Prince

The Black Prince by Iris Murdoch
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
685153
's review

did not like it

Granted, I did not pick this book, but I did blindly and eagerly consent based on the fact that I had heard of Murdoch's work and as a result of my experience with other British/Irish women novelists being so rich and rewarding, assumed I would love it. Oh, folly! Iris Murdoch is a philosopher (and a lover of Sartre, worst offender of all, if you ask me), and I generally make it a rule never to read the novels of philosophers because they know shit about character development and even less about plot. Now, mind, as a lover of Joyce and Woolf, I can worship and venerate a plotless novel like it's my job (which it kind of is) as long as there is some lyricism and some wordplay. Not so The Black Prince . Now, all the faux editorial prefaces and postscripts would suggest that I am supposed to hate Bradley and feel that the narrative has no centre. But I hated everyone from the vacillating, talentless Baffins to whining homosexual stereotype Francis Marloe. It's 1973: take a Valium, see a therapist. As such, I resented the hell out of this novel: its endless pontificating on art and existentialism, its mangling of Shakespeare and Dante, its endless reliance on Freudian paradigms only to ridicule them ex-post-facto. I don't see how creating a cast of miserable, despondent, self-obsessed people merits a Booker Prize. I learned nothing from this book and will never read her again. It could've done with a lot more preface/postscipts and a lot less novel. Bottom line: lame.
17 likes ·  鈭� flag

Sign into 欧宝娱乐 to see if any of your friends have read The Black Prince.
Sign In 禄

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
February 10, 2009 – Shelved

Comments Showing 1-7 of 7 (7 new)

dateUp arrow    newest »

Sarah Well said. -My sentiments exactly. I am about half-way through trying to read it for a book club. Not sure I am going to make it to the end considering the amount of suffering this book has induced in me thus far...


message 2: by Pip (new) - rated it 5 stars

Pip no character development? How is it that you know these characters well enough to hate them?


Annie Williams Totally agree. Am reading it for book club and hate it. Is it supposed to be funny?


Christin I think it's meant to be mocking. I am now of the opinion that Murdoch is one of those novelists who loathes all her characters and wants the reader to feel much the same about humanity in general.


Christopher Not sure how one could see this as: 1.) a plotless novel, 2.) a winner of the Booker prize, 3.) and example of existentialism. Also, it's not that philosophers don't understand character development, in this novel especially, it's an understanding that "character development" is not true and needn't exist in a modern novel.


Mary I liked it , even though I hated all the characters . I did find it funny in parts , moving and very lyrical too. Not an easy book and not light by any means. Modern readers might find it a slog.


Russell Yours was the first negative review so I decided to add my agreement. My first Murdoch novel and I find the story unbelievable - that is, hard to believe the characters. I have 80 pages remaining but I want the worst for this Bradley narrator. Give me E.M. Forster instead.


back to top