Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

aly ☆彡's Reviews > Mr. Wrong Number

Mr. Wrong Number by Lynn Painter
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
113225804
's review

it was ok

I have had the suspicion that Lynn Painter's works are not one for me to indulge in, especially after the catastrophe from reading Better Than the Movies. But well, me with my best quality � I'll give her that benefit of the doubt. Plus, considering that this is not a YA romance, perhaps we will have something good in the house.

Regrettably, I am not a bit surprised when this novel also turned out to be another disappointment. This is even worse and I can't help but develop Olivia's annoying habit of rolling her eyes that sometimes I wonder how she still didn't get them squinted from doing it every 60 seconds.

I'll be benevolent and go with what I enjoyed with Mr. Wrong Number: the romance
There's just something so conspiring in craving the dangers of forbidden romance. The whole ordeal of falling for your brother's best friend does sound tempting and I think Lynn Painter went industriously in making sure Colin and Olivia's affair didn't go to waste as in her previous work. They bantered, helped each other out, and had a few funny scenes here there.

It was just a bit stroke of luck that Lynn Painter is being safe with the level of smuttiness. I understand if she was being considerate of her readers since her debut book was YA and she may have not attracted lots of adult readers to begin with, but I think it was clear enough if this is an adult romance, what readers should expect out of it.

People read smuts for many reasons; sometimes it's for entertainment or experience; sometimes, it's just because and I can be a bit of both or more. It’s not like I’m being demanding of what is unnecessary. As for this case, I think if there will be a bit more details than a close-door scene, it will help to flesh out both Colin and Olivia's chemistry. The romance was enjoyable but it did not hit the roof. Why is that? Now let's get to the nastiest part of my review.

“When things don't go as planned, we can either pout and behave like a reticent child, or take some time to reconsider our choices. Ruminate over what we've done in our past, and how best to move forward in our future.�


The book's main takeaway was on finding yourself and never stopping at failures. I appreciate the themes that Lynn Painter is going for. It was a good reminder and I honestly get the message she was trying to set forth. It was relatable, especially when you're struggling, had a parent who always brings you down and I guess, overall miserable.

Frankly speaking though, it was a bit hard to swallow when none of the characters are likable. Now that I've met Olivia, I believe the author just loves to write her heroines ✨quirky� and ✨different� and Olivia's entire personality is just her series of unfortunate events. She was so one-dimensional; it was either being clumsy or hypercritical. I noticed that Painters likes to make a point of her characters' traits by having them repetitively signified all the time.

I was having a hard time resonating with Olivia because she pisses me off a lot with her immaturity and scathing mind. This book utilized such a disgraceful kind of miscommunication trope and I did not dig it one bit. It makes sense when it happened to the author's YA characters because they don't suppose to have most things figured out, but when you're reaching your 30s, I'm expecting a bit of rationality on your end. Both the MCs seem to age backwards instead of their own prime.

"He's still an asshole. He looks at me like he knows he's better than me"


While I appreciate Colin's POV (because I can't remember if we had one for Wes), it was unavailing at first because it was just more of his reaction and thoughts on Olivia instead of letting readers unravel him as a person. And when you're relying on a disparaging worldview of a heroine to allow you to get to know the other characters, it didn't help your case.

I believe it was not Lynn's intention to give a lot of focus to Colin but it was only the latter that we get to know more of him than just "the love interest" or the "jerk" as claimed by the Queen of Rolling Eyes. For a good part, the author didn't give room for any lewd thoughts or objectification from Colin in feigning his attraction to Olivia. Like, he was just appreciating her as a real person and it's refreshing. He lives up to his status quo and that’s the only matchable piece of himself as a grown successful man.

Having that said, did I enjoy the book? Still NO, or maybe, if only the characters, the plot, and the romance were parallel from the beginning. The beam scale was skewed all the time for when the romance was good, the characters were there to ruin the whole course of the book or vice versa. The plot was absurd and a lot of thing just doesn’t make sense.

What's more now that my hypothesis is correct, it's best to say, it was nice to read Lynn Painters' works as this will be my last or not. Let's just hope she didn't come out with pretty covers that got me weak all the time because who judges a book by its cover? Definitely me, duh.
199 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Mr. Wrong Number.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

March 23, 2022 – Started Reading
March 26, 2022 – Finished Reading
March 27, 2022 – Shelved

Comments Showing 1-15 of 15 (15 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Yun (new)

Yun Oh no! I just picked this one up from the library! But you make good points, Aly! I'm not a fan of unlikable, quirky/cutesy characters either. I'll have to think about whether I still want to read this. 😂 Great review!


message 2: by Anna (new)

Anna Your review makes so much sense, aly! I love the brother’s best friend trope, but this sounds like it wasn’t at all satisfactory. If we can’t relate to the main characters in any level or at even like them, it’s usually not a great sign. I hope you have better luck with your next read! 💕


message 3: by aly (new) - rated it 2 stars

aly ☆彡 @Yun aw i dont get along with the characters well. its the one kind that hits the nerve and spoil the reading experience for you 😆 so i definitely support if you want to skip this, but if u have extra time and want something quirky, you can always have this one to read hehe


message 4: by aly (new) - rated it 2 stars

aly ☆彡 @Anna this book has the potential to be good but the characters are just so unlikeable 😭 and having annoying mcs are a turn off for me. thank you anna! <3


message 5: by Bibliothecat (new)

Bibliothecat This was on my maybe list but I guess I'll pass... 😂


message 6: by aly (last edited Apr 06, 2022 12:19AM) (new) - rated it 2 stars

aly ☆彡 @Lara i honestly think you wouldnt miss anything if you do. so yes plssss 😂


message 7: by mia (new) - rated it 3 stars

mia "Queen of Rolling Eyes" LMAO


message 8: by aly (new) - rated it 2 stars

aly ☆彡 @mia i lose count how many times she rolled her eyes and it makes me mad 😭


message 9: by Mina (new)

Mina ☾ I know how it is to have an author that don't matter her works are not for you. I have this same feeling with Sophie Jordan!


message 10: by aly (new) - rated it 2 stars

aly ☆彡 @Mina aw sorry about that. i remember enjoying her books but i read them like nine years ago. not sure if i still think the same but i see where ure coming from!


message 11: by Em (new) - rated it 3 stars

Em Okay I’m nervous. I got the book from bookdepo because of its glowing review, then I realised almost all of my mutuals here who read predominantly romance didn't like/rated the book low 🥲. I should have waited for a couple more months before buying hshshshssj


message 12: by aly (new) - rated it 2 stars

aly ☆彡 @ira the best now is to read this without expectation 🤩 if u love her debut book & vibe with the same kind of character as her previous, this won't probably be too bad for you!!! at least the book cover is pretty tho 😭 they can definitely sit prettily on the shelf 🤣


message 13: by mira (new)

mira ugh i hate when the characters are in their 30s and still can't communicate!!


message 14: by aly (new) - rated it 2 stars

aly ☆彡 @� mira right!!! im not asking u to solve a math question, just pls communicate when its necessary 😭


message 15: by Heather (last edited Mar 24, 2023 02:02PM) (new) - rated it 1 star

Heather I love your review! I started listening to the audiobook yesterday and finally had to STOP reading it this morning... Life is simply too short to put up with unlikable characters, excessive eyerolling, horrible communicators, and the stereotypical Bella-esque (think Twilight) accident-prone MC... UGH! What pushed me over the edge (SPOILER ALERT) was when Colin gets ticked off when he discovers that Olivia opened his sealed bottle of tequila—one that we learn was a graduation gift worth $400 from his sister that the two of them had agreed would remain unopened until he hits a certain milestone ten years later. And not only that, Olivia managed to spill half of it down the sink when she was trying to open it! Thus confronted, she remains unapologetically obnoxious, makes scathing remarks about how only idiots would spend $400 on a bottle of tequila, etc. etc. She NEVER apologizes! And when the author makes the decision to send HIM in to apologize for calling her a freeloader (among other things), she STILL doesn't apologize. When I hit that point, I decided I couldn't take it anymore! Life is too short, and I clearly wasn't vibing with this book (and probably not this author). I came here to see if I was alone, and it was great to read your review and discover that I'm not! :)


back to top