Rosh's Reviews > Surely You're Joking, Mr. Feynman!
Surely You're Joking, Mr. Feynman!
by
by

Want to read a book that is full of bragging and humblebragging? Here’s a great option that fits the bill! Reading this was like sitting across a table with an interesting person, only to realise that he finds just one topic interesting: himself. Pompous prig alert! 😬
What Richard Feynman wanted me to learn from this book:
There are many more things Richard Feynman is fabulous at but these are all I remember now.
What I didn’t find in this book:
Bonus points I learnt about Richard Feynman
The only part of the book I enjoyed without getting judgemental was when he spoke of being in a textbook evaluation committee. If you want advice on how to be better at your chosen scientific discipline, jump straight to the last chapter. That’s the only one having content bordering on advice.
I still respect Richard Feynman the physicist, but as a human being, he dropped vastly in my esteem. He must have been an outstanding scientist and teacher but hardly any glimpse of that comes out in this book, which is more of an ode to himself by himself.
Do you remember the Gaston song from ‘Beauty and the Beast�? This is how Feynman would have probably sung it:
***
Join me on the Facebook group, , for more reviews, book-related discussions and fun.
What Richard Feynman wanted me to learn from this book:
1. Richard Feynman is fabulous at physics.
2. Richard Feynman is fabulous at mathematics.
3. Richard Feynman is fabulous at biology.
4. Richard Feynman is fabulous at picking up girls. (He “loves beautiful girls.�)
5. Richard Feynman is fabulous at unlocking safes.
6. Richard Feynman is fabulous at playing musical instruments, even live on stage.
7. Richard Feynman is fabulous at learning new languages (or at least pretending to.)
8. Richard Feynman is fabulous at coding and decoding ciphers.
9. Richard Feynman is fabulous at dancing.
10. Richard Feynman is fabulous at teaching.
11. Richard Feynman is fabulous at sketching and painting. (Not surprisingly, he loved to draw nudes best.)
12. Richard Feynman is fabulous at Mayan anthropology.
There are many more things Richard Feynman is fabulous at but these are all I remember now.
What I didn’t find in this book:
1. Details about Feynman’s family except for a barebones mention of his parents and sister and a few paras on his three wives whenever they are a part of his anecdotes about how fabulous he is.
2. Details on anything Richard Feynman wasn’t fabulous at, beyond a few paragraphs.
Bonus points I learnt about Richard Feynman
1. Richard Feynman was cocky.
2. Richard Feynman loved to hear himself talk about himself.
3. Richard Feynman treated women as objects and judged them entirely on their physical merits.
4. Richard Feynman considered anyone who didn't understand physics, an idiot.
5. Richard Feynman loved playing pranks on others, whether it was funny to others or dismaying didn’t matter.
6. Richard Feynman was full of attitude and with zilch gratitude.
The only part of the book I enjoyed without getting judgemental was when he spoke of being in a textbook evaluation committee. If you want advice on how to be better at your chosen scientific discipline, jump straight to the last chapter. That’s the only one having content bordering on advice.
I still respect Richard Feynman the physicist, but as a human being, he dropped vastly in my esteem. He must have been an outstanding scientist and teacher but hardly any glimpse of that comes out in this book, which is more of an ode to himself by himself.
Do you remember the Gaston song from ‘Beauty and the Beast�? This is how Feynman would have probably sung it:
🎜 No one's slick as Feynman, No one's quick as Feynman,
No one's head is as incredibly thick as Feynman,
For there's no man in town half as manly
(Perfect, a pure paragon!)
You can ask any Tom, Dick, or Stanley
And they'll tell you whose team they prefer to be on.
Who plays darts like Feynman? Who breaks hearts like Feynman?
Who's much more than the sum of his parts like Feynman?
(As a specimen, yes, I'm intimidating!)
Who has brains like Feynman, Entertains like Feynman,
Who can make up these endless refrains like Feynman,
(I use antlers in all of my decorating!)
Who's a man among men? Who's the super success?
Don't you know? Can't you guess?
Ask his fans and his five hangers-on
There's just one guy in town who's got all of it down 🎝
And here’s where I’ll interrupt his 'Ode to Myself' and jump in for the grand outro, yelling:
🎜“Surely you’re joking, Mr. Feynmaaaaaan!!!!”�
**insert musical crescendo here!**
***
Join me on the Facebook group, , for more reviews, book-related discussions and fun.
Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read
Surely You're Joking, Mr. Feynman!.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
Comments Showing 1-50 of 52 (52 new)
message 1:
by
Canadian Jen
(new)
Apr 22, 2022 10:21AM

reply
|
flag

Good decision, Jen. I really need a 5 star book after this one! 😬

Thanks, Lori! Good call... I ground my teeth all the way through it. Gaaah! 😬




Thanks Melissa! � This was a pain!

Thanks, Pink. I was being quite diplomatic there. 😉

It is, Dorie. I still can't believe this book is so highly acclaimed. 😕

Ditto for me, Sujoya. I had such high expectations after everything I had heard. But the disaster begins right from chapter 1. You didn't miss anything. 💕

All thanks to the audio version, Chrissie. I would have thrown my book at the wall had I been reading a physical copy. He was simply disgusting in his attitude towards women.
Thank you! 💕

So true, Ushashi! I had only Einstein's treatment of his first wife as a big example of this, but now I feel Feynman is at the same level, maybe worse.

You sadist! You just keep waiting for my rants! 😛
Lucky you, I wish I hadn't ever picked this up. 😬

Good decision, Ellie. Stay far, far away from it! Thank you. �

Lucky you, I wish I hadn't ever picked this up. 😬."
🤣🤣 Darn right I am. Your rants are too good. ;P
Aww... Hugs, girl. Hope the next read is a 5-star. :*

Aww... Hugs, girl. Hope t..."
Ah well, it's been a long time since my last rant So this felt cathartic. 😛
No such luck! I think my next 5 star (rounded up) will be Kim Jiyoung.

No such luck! I think my next 5 star (rounded up) will be Kim Jiyoung."
Good to know that.
Not good to know the other one. :/
PS: The request for the clockwork queen got declined. :(


Oh! I was so sure you would get it! Barrington Stoke always comes through for me, even if late.
If it helps, the Donal Ryan book that you suggested is still in my pending requests after all these days. Random House UK is never a sureshot for me. :/

Thanks so much, Anushree! Glad I could spread some laughs. 😃
Toxic masculinity is the right word for this fellow's behaviour. I have never been so irritated with a scientist ever since I watched the depiction of Albert Einstein's life on "Genius". Wonder why so many people are ready to let his attitude go just because he was intelligent. 😒

It was, Bharath. How such a reputed scientist could gloat about such silly things as pranking a poor waitress or disclose that he chose rooms where he could peep into the opposite building that hosted women's quarters is all beyond me! He seemed almost self-congratulatory throughout. I just hated this experience.

I am sure he was fabulous at that too! He was 'so practically perfect in every way'. Surely, he wasn't joking, right? :P


Thanks, Karen! � You know I am always happy to spread a smile around. :D I shall give myself a pat on my back, on your behalf. :P


See, I do help you this way also! Now it is your turn to return the favour, Priya! 😄


Haha, thanks! 😉 But I am very much the outlier on this, Niharika. That said, if you want to read it mainly for the physics content, I'd suggest you read something else written by him.


Thanks, Hawk! I aim to please. ;)

Such people are truly annoying! I guess it comes from their inflated ego; they genuinely believe that they are fascinating even if we find their talks a snoozefest. I hope you didn't meet that friend of your uncle again. Once seems to be more than enough!

Omg, I think this is the first time I have to hard disagree with you, Rosh! *sheds a tear* :D
I found his character so endearing and down to earth after reading this! I also watched a lot of videos of his and listened to some lectures and found him to be simultaneously genius and regular larrikin!
Oh well, we can't win 'em all! :)

Omg, I think this is the first time I have to hard disagree with you, Rosh! *sheds a tear* :D
I found his character so endearing and down to earth after reading this! I also watched a lot of vid..."
*passes a tissue box!* :D
Sorry, Jonathan, but I guess we'll just have to agree to disagree on this one. :D
'Down to Earth' is the last quality that came to my mind while reading this. Some of his pranks were not endearing at all. I believe that if any joke/prank ends in someone feeling hurt, it is not funny.
Glad you enjoyed it though. Every books deserves a happy reader. :)


Thanks so much, Chantel! I doubt most modern women would appreciate his ideas of what counts as fun. It was an infuriating book.



Thank you kindly, Nika! I am truly happy you liked it better, I feel the same - I expected a lot more depth from this book.