Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Alwynne's Reviews > We Do Not Part

We Do Not Part by Han Kang
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
119953219
Han Kang’s intense, intricate narrative has the feel of a ghost story, forged from unsettling encounters with the spectres of South Korea’s turbulent past. Han opens with an eerie sequence, taken from the dreams that partly inspired her to write this. Author Kyungha � a version of Han � is living in isolation, tormented by debilitating headaches and destabilising nightmares. Recurring nightmares she attributes to the disturbing content of research undertaken for a recent book about the Gwangju uprising � similar to Han’s Human Acts. Macabre fantasies dominate Kyungha’s sleeping and, increasingly, waking thoughts. She’s unable to move freely through surrounding streets, visualising soldiers poised to swoop, intent on capturing her and inflicting searing pain. But Kyungha’s attempts to retreat from the outside world are abruptly curtailed by a summons from old friend, Inseon.

Inseon’s settled in her childhood home on Jeju Island but a serious accident’s brought her to a specialist treatment centre in Seoul. Inseon needs a favour, alone in Jeju is her small bird Ama, likely to die if Kyungha can’t reach her in time. Through blustering winds and a seemingly-incessant snowstorm, Kyungha sets out on a gruelling trek to Inseon’s house. An existential journey leading her away from the desolation of Gwangju towards the traumascape of Inseon’s Jeju. Inseon’s experiences of Jeju are shaped by her mother’s. Jeongsim, Inseon’s mother, survived what’s known as Jeju 4:3 or “Sa-Sam.� But most of her family died and her brother was disappeared.

Jeju 4:3 points to massacres that took place in April, 1948. But the killings weren’t confined to April, Jeju 4:3 encompasses atrocities that stretched back into preceding months and continued in the months ahead. A political uprising sparked by developments involving the governing of South Korea, and the policies of the US administration then overseeing it, was brutally suppressed by a grouping of soldiers, police, and right-wing militias. Ostensibly a hunt for “left-wing� guerrilla units, the underlying goal was to eradicate “leftists.� Around 30,000 people were eventually slaughtered, roughly 10% of Jeju’s population � a place considered overrun by “commie� subversives and sympathisers. During this “scorched earth� campaign whole villages were razed to the ground. No form of terror was considered too extreme, from torture to gang-rape to mass murder - victims included children and new-born babies.

The legacy of Jeju 4:3 dominates the later stages of Han’s narrative. At Inseon’s house, Kyungha’s confronted with distressing documentation compiled by Jeongsim and later added to by Inseon. And Kyungha realises the devastating scenes invading her dreams originated on Jeju. When Kyungha comes face to face with Inseon, still in Seoul yet somehow simultaneously on Jeju, the boundary between real and imagined fractures. Han interweaves surreal episodes featuring Kyungha and Inseon with extracts from the testimonies of Jeju 4:3 survivors � building on existing oral histories. Haunted individuals, they’re tortured by the knowledge that somewhere, in mass graves yet to be discovered, lie the unclaimed bodies of family members from grandfathers to grandmothers, uncles, siblings or cousins.

Although it’s fine as a standalone, Han’s narrative’s shot through with traces of earlier work. Most obviously Kyungha’s writing, and Han’s subject matter, form a bridge to Human Acts; while the symbolic use of trees and plants echoes aspects of The Vegetarian. Snow and snow-related imagery surfaces throughout � so much so it feels a little overworked at times. Han’s use of snow recalls passages from The White Book - as well as untranslated pieces set in snowy landscapes � conjuring notions of mortality and loss. But here, for Han, snow’s also intended to represent “softness and light,� tempering the “darkness� of her meditations on genocide and mass killing.

Although Han’s exploration of these topics stems from Jeju 4:3, she also references the extermination of suspected “reds� on the mainland in Busan and Daegu. But she goes beyond these too, invested in questions of what might drive humans in do barbaric things, and what distinguishes those who do from those who don’t or won’t. She’s equally interested in potential methods for addressing the past: how to heal history’s wounds: the transformation of individual mourning into a collective response possessing active political force; opportunities for solidarity and the co-creation of rituals which open up possibilities for remembrance that goes beyond gesture. Han’s comments about the novel, together with its conclusion, suggest cautious optimism. Unlike Human Acts which steered her towards despair, she found writing this cathartic.

The translation reads smoothly, although there’s not always a marked distinction between sections in Jeju dialect and those in standard Korean, the incorporation of terms of address used on Jeju offers some clues � for instance “abang� for father instead of “abeoji.� The structure and texture of the novel sometimes reminded me of Greek Lessons although it’s more collage-like. Austere, understated prose is interrupted by bursts of arresting lyricism, oneiric sequences are juxtaposed with sharply-focused, docu-style accounts. Although it wasn’t a problem for me, I think the pacing might be an issue for some. The novel took Han several years to complete. The first half initially appeared in serial form in a quarterly magazine, as a result some elements may seem slightly repetitive, excessively detailed, and/or drawn-out compared to the rest of the book. Personally, I found the rhythm of the earlier sections hypnotic. I liked Han’s willingness to experiment, even when I didn’t think it quite paid off. But overall, I found this immensely powerful and incredibly compelling. Translated by e. yaewon & Paige Aniyah Morris.

Thanks to Netgalley and publisher Hamish Hamilton for the ARC
112 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read We Do Not Part.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

May 28, 2022 – Shelved
October 2, 2024 – Started Reading
October 3, 2024 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-10 of 10 (10 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Alwynne If any librarians with time on their hands feels like removing the strident 'Booker' tag would be great!


Alwynne Thanks!


Alwynne Can't say I'm that bothered by who did/didn't win a Nobel, but if it means more of Han Kang's work in translation then that's great!


Lady Clementina ffinch-ffarowmore Sounds excellent, Alwynne. I'm yet to read Han Kang (was starting to feel reluctant because of the tag) but she seems well worth exploring. I'll look out for this one.


Alwynne Lady Clementina wrote: "Sounds excellent, Alwynne. I'm yet to read Han Kang (was starting to feel reluctant because of the tag) but she seems well worth exploring. I'll look out for this one."

This and Human Acts the ones I rate most highly, then Greek Lessons. The White Book is very powerful and quite lyrical, structured a little like a series of interconnecting prose poems. I think The Vegetarian is probably my least favourite. But I really like her sensibility in general.


The Reading Lantern just preordered from my library! I was floored by Human Acts so really looking forward to this


Alwynne Alwynne wrote: "The Reading Lantern wrote: "just preordered from my library! I was floored by Human Acts so really looking forward to this"

I really hope it works for you, it's not as immediately concrete as 'Hum..."


I really hope it works for you, it's not as immediately concrete as 'Human Acts' there's a slightly surreal flavour to the opening sections. But I think it can also be viewed as a companion piece the central themes overlap and it's also rooted in acts of repression from Korean history - and imo just as powerful. And yes, Human Acts is brilliant! Sorry I didn't reply earlier btw, my notifications wigged out for a while, so only just seen your comment.


message 9: by Jennifer (new)

Jennifer Welsh I love this review, Alwynne, thank you. I grew fascinated by Jeju from reading The Island of Sea Women, by Lisa See, and was a fan of Kang’s, The Vegetarian. I didn’t love The White Book, but own and keep meaning to read Human Acts. It sounds like this is a good companion piece to that one, and that they are your faves :)


Alwynne Jennifer wrote: "I love this review, Alwynne, thank you. I grew fascinated by Jeju from reading The Island of Sea Women, by Lisa See, and was a fan of Kang’s, The Vegetarian. I didn’t love The White Book, but own a..."

Thanks so much! I can see why I'd loved to see the women divers, did you watch 'Our Blues'? Really enjoyed the emphasis on ordinary life on the island.

I wasn't as keen on the White Book either, this and Human Acts are definitely the ones that have had the most impact.


back to top