ŷ

Luffy Sempai's Reviews > Lady Susan

Lady Susan by Jane Austen
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
7407364
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: 2022, 2rist22, classic, romance, superb-characterization, victorian

Lady Susan is a very artful book, where its artfulness lies in the author's understanding of the mechanism of Regency society. I have the feeling that the me from 5 years ago would not have appreciated the book as much as me now. The novel is almost a novella. It is rueful to realise that books with more ambition than this one have all been half forgotten by all but the most immersed of proponents.

Lady Susan, her daughter Frederica, and Reginald form a love triangle that makes us want an ending that, when it finally arrives, is excellently delivered. The bit part players in the book have more voice in it because of the nature of its epistolary structure. People who see through Lady Susan's wiles are given a stage to punctuate Lady Susan's web of lies with a running commentary that lends weight to the book.

I gave this book 4 stars because I was not half pleased with the ending. Endings like this do not hurt as much as they would in the hands of a lesser writer. But this is a book written by a young Jane Austen. She is young, but still her talent is evident. The ending is made of the stuff of Victorian commonality. I loved the book because of it. The first two thirds of the book make the third act a desirable outcome. This is because so much worse could have occurred.

I have yet to read All of Jane Austen's bibliography. I worried before reading Lady Susan. My wavering hopes tussled with my acquired pessimism and the thirst for more of Austen finally won out. I understand those who, like me, have taken a star from their ratings. Comparisons with Pride and Prejudice, are inevitable, though unfair. I have, however, no illusions as to one of Austen's books. Turns out even the most unique voice from Victorian literature is not infallible. We will have to take proof of the pudding, won't we?

I am slightly indignant by the low rating for this classic. Some may have felt cheated by all these letters and maybe they felt being robbed of witnessing the craftiness of the titular character. The skill of Austen patches up these deficiencies and even in this less ambitious form shows more than glimpses of the author's genius. I was thoroughly entertained by Lady Susan. This is the type of book that deserves to be called a classic. It is a book that has a prepossessing sketch of human nature, with the reader being delighted by the duplicitousness of one and the reactiveness of others. Lady Susan won me over, and that is reflected in my rating, and review.
64 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Lady Susan.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

August 7, 2022 – Started Reading
August 7, 2022 – Shelved
August 7, 2022 – Shelved as: 2022
August 7, 2022 – Shelved as: 2rist22
August 7, 2022 – Shelved as: classic
August 7, 2022 – Shelved as: romance
August 7, 2022 – Shelved as: superb-characterization
August 7, 2022 – Shelved as: victorian
August 7, 2022 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-16 of 16 (16 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Barbara (new)

Barbara I haven't read this one. Great review Luffy!


Luffy Sempai Barbara wrote: "I haven't read this one. Great review Luffy!"

There are better books out there. No hurry. And thanks 🤍


message 3: by Beth (new)

Beth I did a "reading project" of all of Austen's major works a couple of years ago, and I remember Lady Susan herself vividly, even if I don't remember much of anything else (my brain is not good at retaining short fiction). A unique Austen character.

Seeing this review reminded me I'll need to read Austen's letters sometime. Never got around to that. Jane Austen's Letters


Luffy Sempai Beth wrote: "I did a "reading project" of all of Austen's major works a couple of years ago, and I remember Lady Susan herself vividly, even if I don't remember much of anything else (my brain is not good at re..."

I had personally concentrated on her biographies. Will try to lay my hands on the letters. Haven't had enough of letters written by Austen. 🤍


message 5: by Ellie (new) - added it

Ellie Spencer (catching up from hiatus) Ohh I grabbed a copy of this the other day and now I am really looking forward to reading it! I absolutely adore Austen! Beautiful review Luffy! 🧡


message 6: by Michelle (new)

Michelle Great review, Luffy!


Luffy Sempai Ellie wrote: "Ohh I grabbed a copy of this the other day and now I am really looking forward to reading it! I absolutely adore Austen! Beautiful review Luffy! 🧡"

Thank you, Ellie! Austen is complex, but I am beginning to think that part of her charm lies in her acute and pertinent plotting. Heresy I know, but that is my impression. 🤍


Luffy Sempai Michelle wrote: "Great review, Luffy!"

Thank you, Michelle! 🤍


message 9: by len ❀ (new)

len ❀ beautiful review, luffy! i always find it interesting when we read books we didn’t have an interest in years ago. it really shows how much the mind changes and develops in terms of analyzing and understanding. this is actually the first time i hear about this one. it seems to be pretty underrated.


Luffy Sempai elena ❀ wrote: "beautiful review, luffy! i always find it interesting when we read books we didn’t have an interest in years ago. it really shows how much the mind changes and develops in terms of analyzing and un..."

Thank you, Elena! The book has now come at the right time. And it has impressed me. This is because I have tried to read gothic, crime, and Fantasy classics by Ann Radcliff, Fritz Lieber and Horace Walpole. These authors' works are unreadable. So I was super grateful for a good classic, and enduring book like Lady Susan.


message 11: by Kat (new)

Kat Wonderful review, Luffy! I'm not much of a classics reader, but Austen is one of the authors I'd make an exception for. Her stories are always rich and compelling!


Luffy Sempai Kat wrote: "Wonderful review, Luffy! I'm not much of a classics reader, but Austen is one of the authors I'd make an exception for. Her stories are always rich and compelling!"

Thank you, Kat! I read from several genres daily just to get my short term reading fix. No book is guaranteed to agree with my mind until I've read the last page. But when classics disappoint me, they really do a number on me. So there is that. Thank you again.


message 13: by Carol (new)

Carol A thoughtful and eloquent review, Luffy!


Luffy Sempai Carol wrote: "A thoughtful and eloquent review, Luffy!"

Glad that you found it so! Thanks for that.😀


message 15: by Fran (new)

Fran Spectacular review, Luffy!👍


Luffy Sempai Thank you so much, Fran! 😁


back to top