ŷ

Shannon M (Canada)'s Reviews > Desert Star

Desert Star by Michael    Connelly
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
65597491
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: 2022-books, 2022-favourites, top-crime-thrillers-published-2022

DESERT STAR is the 24th book starring Harry Bosch and the fifth starring Renee Ballard. (Harry has appeared in a few more books but not as the primary character.) I am not certain whether it is as good as the previous book featuring these two, “The Dark Hours�, but it kept me reading nonstop and consequently is another five-star read from Michael Connelly.

Ballard is now in charge of a resurrected Open-Unsolved Cold Cases Unit within the Robbery and Homicide Division of the LAPD. Open-Unsolved was the last unit Harry worked in before retiring from the LAPD. Ballard recruits Harry as a volunteer investigator for a team that contains several volunteer members.

There are two independent cases to solve. Ballard is most interested in solving the murder of Sarah, the 16-year-old sister of the city councilman who pushed to get the Open-Unsolved Unit reinstated—a crime that occurred almost 30 years earlier. Bosch is most interested in solving the Gallagher Family murder—a father, mother, and their two young children who were killed 10 years earlier and buried in the Mojave Desert, their bodies found by accident a year after the homicide. Bosch is almost certain he knows who the murderer was—Finbar McShane—but after slowly stealing all the money from Gallagher’s business, McShane disappeared before the bodies were discovered.

The new Open-Unsolved Unit now has many sophisticated DNA techniques at hand to help crack cases and they are able to link Sarah’s killer to another cold case, a 15-year-old murder of a 24-year-old aspiring actress. The majority of the novel focuses on identifying and then hunting down the killer of these two young women. In short sequences, Harry also pursues leads that help him discover where McShane is now living, but this is a fairly minor part of the story until the ending.

There were some things that I didn’t like about the narrative. Most of these had to do with the character development of Ballard. She appears to be turning into a bureaucrat, dealing with politics within the police hierarchy, and leaving the investigative work for others. And we receive no further information about the background circumstances that formed her personality. Compare that with Bosch, whose complex background was developed over several of the early novels in the series.

The one other element that bothered me was tying up the ending. Bosch does something (”Sometimes you do the wrong thing for the right reason.�) and there is no follow up. There should have been some repercussions from Harry’s actions—a long carry-over—but the novel just stopped.

Mostly I kept reading this novel far into the night because of Harry Bosch. His body may be deteriorating but his mind is as sharp as ever. (And I can commiserate with this because I am about ten years older than Bosch.)

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
My review for the previous book in this series:
The Dark Hours (Harry Bosch #23, Renee Ballard #4)
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
15 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Desert Star.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

September 23, 2022 – Shelved
September 23, 2022 – Shelved as: to-read
December 1, 2022 – Started Reading
December 2, 2022 – Finished Reading
December 4, 2022 – Shelved as: top-crime-thrillers-published-2022
December 4, 2022 – Shelved as: 2022-favourites
December 4, 2022 – Shelved as: 2022-books

Comments Showing 1-4 of 4 (4 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Terence M - [Quot libros, quam breve tempus!] A fine review, Shannon!
I have an incomplete review to finalise, but I certainly agree with two of your observations: a) about the development of Ballard's character, and b) the lack of repersussions with Bosch's "... wrong thing for the right reason ..." event.


Shannon M (Canada) Terence M (Somewhat indisposed) wrote: "A fine review, Shannon!
I have an incomplete review to finalise, but I certainly agree with two of your observations: a) about the development of Ballard's character, and b) the lack of repersussio..."


Thank you, Terence. I am most disturbed about the failure to provide a backstory for Ballard. I have read all the novels she has appeared in. Initially, I thought she was rather odd but that Connelly would eventually elaborate on her eccentricities. He hasn’t. And she is turning into a rather unlikable character.

As for the second bothersome incident, Connelly could always carry through with it in the next book. We’ll see.


message 3: by CarolG (new) - added it

CarolG Great review Shannon. I liked Ballard in the first few books but I'm a couple of books behind now. Glad you liked it in spite of a couple of misgivings.


Shannon M (Canada) Carol wrote: "Great review Shannon. I liked Ballard in the first few books but I'm a couple of books behind now. Glad you liked it in spite of a couple of misgivings."

Thanks Carol. I’m still staying with Bosch and Ballard despite minor misgivings. However, if Bosch goes, I don’t know if I’ll stay with just Ballard.

On the other hand, I’ve just about given up on the Prey series by John Sandford. Sandford is 78 and probably it’s time for him to retire. Connelly is only 66 and should have a few more good years in him. Of course age is not the only determining factor. Some authors will continue writing until they die—Stephen King will, I’m sure. It depends on how much perseverance they have. I’ve noticed that as I age, I have less stamina but still plenty of motivation. Inner drive. It’s just harder to translate that inner drive into productive writings—in my case, nonfiction essays (reviews) given that I never had the ability to create fictional worlds.


back to top