ŷ

Rosh's Reviews > The Tuesday Night Club

The Tuesday Night Club by Agatha Christie
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
91622714
's review

liked it
bookshelves: 3-5-stars, short-story-or-essay

A decent introduction to Miss Marple. This story is part of the The Thirteen Problems collection.

This is a short story known for having the very first print appearance of the legendary Miss Marple. I began my Marple journey with this story because I always love to see how an author introduces a staple character the very first time. In that sense, I am slightly disappointed because there’s hardly any character background provided. (Maybe this is a Christie specialty, because her first Poirot book The Mysterious Affair at Styles also revealed little beyond boring facts about the detective. Contrast this with �A Study in Scarlet� where Arthur Conan Doyle presents a perfect picture of the maverick Sherlock Holmes and makes us get inside his mind with ease.)

Anyway, back to the story. This is a very quick read, not requiring more than 15 minutes. Six people � Miss Marple, her nephew, a clergyman, an artist, a solicitor and an ex-commissioner of the Scotland Yard � have come together to form a ‘Tuesday Night Club�, whereby one of them will reveal a mystery, the answer to which is known only to that person. The remaining five try to resolve it individually. Needless to say, Miss Marple won this first round.

There is not at much of Miss Marple in this story as I would have liked but the story still is interesting. Not a very innovative mystery too because the culprit was quite predictable. The modus operandi is of greater interest than the villain. I might have enjoyed the big reveal more had I known the British term for a common baking ingredient. Because I wasn’t aware of it, the resolution seemed to come out of nowhere.

Overall, a fairly decent introduction, but the rest of the stories will determine the fate of the book. I was expecting more thrills, but there's a long way to go yet on the Marple journey.

3.5 stars



—ĔĔĔĔĔĔĔĔĔĔĔĔĔ�
Connect with me through:
| | |
41 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Tuesday Night Club.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
October 18, 2022 – Shelved
October 18, 2022 – Shelved as: 3-5-stars
October 18, 2022 – Shelved as: short-story-or-essay

Comments Showing 1-26 of 26 (26 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Feli_H (new)

Feli_H Cool review Rosh!🖐 I've heard wonders about this saga, but reading you that its protagonist is not well delineated pulls me back a bit the truth. Well, at least it's just the introduction, let's hope it doesn't disappoint in the next ones. Happy readings! 🙆‍♂️�


message 2: by SK (new)

SK Superb review Rosh! I haven't yet read this one or the collection, but it sounds decent enough.


Heather Adores Books Hope your next book is more thrilling 💚


Sujoya - theoverbookedbibliophile Hope you enjoy your experience with Miss Marple!😊 Great review!


message 5: by Holly (new)

Holly  B (slower pace!) I have a long journey to get through all the Marple novels too! Wonderful review Rosh! 😍


message 6: by Srivalli (new)

Srivalli Rekha I don't even remember the story, so can't say much. But yeah, she doesn't provide a solid intro for her detectives. They just blend into the story and do their job.


message 7: by Sheerin (new)

Sheerin Christie does not provide a solid background for her detectives. There will be snippets here and there in different books. As usual your review is balanced and quite clear. Don't remember this one though I might pick up and read it.
Reading Crooked House right now.


Bookworm (have loads of catching up to do) Great Review! All the Christie novels, I have read till date are full-length. be it Marple, Poirot or standalone (like Crooked House).
Will check out her short stories too.


Rosh Feli_H wrote: "Cool review Rosh!🖐 I've heard wonders about this saga, but reading you that its protagonist is not well delineated pulls me back a bit the truth. Well, at least it's just the introduction, let's ho..."

Hey Feli, so nice to see you after a long time. Hope the studies are going well. :)

This is just the first short story in a set of 12-13 tales, I think. So I still have my hopes high. Let's keep our fingers crossed. :D


message 10: by Rosh (new) - rated it 3 stars

Rosh SK wrote: "Superb review Rosh! I haven't yet read this one or the collection, but it sounds decent enough."

Thanks, SK! I have high hopes from the collection, and am pretty sure the stories will improve as I progress through the anthology. :)


message 11: by Rosh (new) - rated it 3 stars

Rosh Heather Adores Books wrote: "Hope your next book is more thrilling 💚"

Thanks, Heather! �


message 12: by Rosh (new) - rated it 3 stars

Rosh Sujoya wrote: "Hope you enjoy your experience with Miss Marple!😊 Great review!"

Thanks so much, Sujoya! I hope so too. �


message 13: by Rosh (new) - rated it 3 stars

Rosh Holly wrote: "I have a long journey to get through all the Marple novels too! Wonderful review Rosh! 😍"

Glad I am not the only one left, Holly! :D Thanks! �


message 14: by Rosh (new) - rated it 3 stars

Rosh Srivalli wrote: "I don't even remember the story, so can't say much. But yeah, she doesn't provide a solid intro for her detectives. They just blend into the story and do their job."

True, though I did like the background provided a little more in 'Murder at the Vicarage'. (I did have different complaints about it. Sigh.)
This story was just bland, maybe because it is quite a common trope nowadays. Might have been unique then.


message 15: by Rosh (new) - rated it 3 stars

Rosh Sheerin wrote: "Christie does not provide a solid background for her detectives. There will be snippets here and there in different books. As usual your review is balanced and quite clear. Don't remember this one ..."

True, Sheerin. I did get to know her a little more in 'Murder at the Vicarage', which I completed today. Next will be the BOTM.
Thank you. <3


message 16: by Rosh (new) - rated it 3 stars

Rosh Bookworm wrote: "Great Review! All the Christie novels, I have read till date are full-length. be it Marple, Poirot or standalone (like Crooked House).
Will check out her short stories too."


Thanks, Bookworm! I am a Christie newbie. Have hardly read any of her works. This was my first Marple story, but am planning to read a few more this month itself. :)


message 17: by Bookworm (have loads of catching up to do) (last edited Oct 19, 2022 05:40PM) (new)

Bookworm (have loads of catching up to do) Welcome! My first Christie was And Then There Were None and that drew me in to her other works. Do check it out. It's a standalone without Marple or Poirot, so it won't cause any kink in your plans if you were planning to read the books in order. :)


message 18: by Srivalli (new)

Srivalli Rekha Rosh [semi-hiatus in October] wrote: "True, though I did like the background provided a little more in 'Murder at the Vicarage'. (I did have different complaints about it. Sigh.)
This story was just bland, maybe because it is quite a common trope nowadays. Might have been unique then."


Ah! I'm curious now (though I haven't read it).
Yeah. Kinda hard to remember that she wrote them first. Hope the other one is going decent.


message 19: by Rosh (new) - rated it 3 stars

Rosh Bookworm wrote: "Welcome! My first Christie was And Then There Were None and that drew me in to her other works. Do check it out. It's a standalone without Marple or Poirot, so it won't cause any kink ..."

Thank you! That's on my agenda as well, though I didn't know it didn't have either of the two famous detectives. All this while, I've been assuming it was a Poirot title! :)


message 20: by Rosh (new) - rated it 3 stars

Rosh Srivalli wrote: "Kinda hard to remember that she wrote them first. Hope the other one is going decent.."

I tried to keep it in my mind. Problem is that as this isn't my go-to genre, I am not sure how much of her work has inspired contemporary copycats. I don't recognise tropes as easily here.

The short story collection is still stuck on story one. Tonight will be the next one.


message 21: by Feli_H (new)

Feli_H They have been! I'm already on my fourth and last one, and I'm bursting as I haven't stopped since I started (well, there was only one week between practices, but I almost didn't feel it). So it's been a killer, but I've learned a lot, and although there were bumps along the way, I'm getting closer and closer to my degree🕺.

P.D: Soon you will know what I have been reading these months, they will come almost in a row since I started several of them and I am already at the end of almost all of those 😅


message 22: by Srivalli (new)

Srivalli Rekha Rosh [semi-hiatus in October] wrote: "I tried to keep it in my mind. Problem is that as this isn't my go-to genre, I am not sure how much of her work has inspired contemporary copycats. I don't recognise tropes as easily here.
The short story collection is still stuck on story one. Tonight will be the next one."


I get it. This isn't your favorite genre. A few in cozies (which you don't read much). ;P
Take your time with it. Not urgent anyway. :)


Bookworm (have loads of catching up to do) Rosh [semi-hiatus in October] wrote: "Bookworm wrote: "Welcome! My first Christie was And Then There Were None and that drew me in to her other works. Do check it out. It's a standalone without Marple or Poirot, so it won'..."

Yeah, it's without either of the two detectives. Till date, I have read 14 of Christie's novels and that one is still my favorite.
And you might recognize the themes which have been used by modern mystery writers. Not telling much as it might be a spoiler. Happy Reading :)


Bookworm (have loads of catching up to do) Srivalli wrote: "Rosh [semi-hiatus in October] wrote: "I tried to keep it in my mind. Problem is that as this isn't my go-to genre, I am not sure how much of her work has inspired contemporary copycats. I don't rec..."

Hello Srivalli!
Just popping in to say we have similar profile picture. :D
Happy Reading! :)


message 25: by Rosh (new) - rated it 3 stars

Rosh Feli_H wrote: "They have been! I'm already on my fourth and last one, and I'm bursting as I haven't stopped since I started (well, there was only one week between practices, but I almost didn't feel it). So it's ..."

I am so glad to hear that. Good luck for whatever is left in your course! �
Looking forward to all your reviews. 😊


message 26: by Rosh (new) - rated it 3 stars

Rosh Bookworm wrote: "Yeah, it's without either of the two detectives. Till date, I have read 14 of Christie's novels and that one is still my favorite.
And you might recognize the themes which have been used by modern mystery writers. Not telling much as it might be a spoiler. Happy Reading :)"


Thank you so much. You are quite far ahead of me with 14 Christie books under your belt.

Srivalli and you have not just a similar profile pic, but you both seem to be Christie fans as well. :)


back to top