ŷ

Rosh (Off GR duty for a fortnight!)'s Reviews > Foster

Foster by Claire Keegan
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
91622714
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: 4-25-stars, netgalley

In a Nutshell: Touching and subtle. Beautiful writing, heartfelt emotions, realistic characters. You’ll want more at the end. But you’ll also realize that you have acquired far more than the 90-odd pages contain.

Story Synopsis:
The unnamed first-person protagonist, a child of unspecified age, has been sent by her parents to live with a foster family on a rural Irish farm while her mother readies herself to give birth to yet another child. She doesn’t know the people she is to stay with, and she doesn’t know when she is to return home. What she doesn’t know is that life is going to bloom for her in this foster home. But all good things come to an end, right? Or don’t they?


I loved the three main characters: the child and the two foster parents. Keegan sketches their personalities in a striking way without going into details. It is only with every subsequent scene that you begin to put a picture of what might be the backstory of the characters.

I’ve read three Claire Keegan works so far, and each time, I’ve read the respective story twice. The first time the regular way, and the second time to see what more clues I might have missed. Her writing is very intelligent, and she also respects her readers� intelligence by not spoon-feeding them every single detail. Nor does she shove the emotions into your face but causes you to feel them through simple scenes and hidden cues. I do appreciate this trait of hers, though it makes me work that much harder to glean the best of her writing as she leaves a lot unsaid. In this story though, I wish she had revealed at least a few more details. The age of the protagonist, for one. While we can gauge that the child could be anywhere between 6-10 years old, but I like knowing the age of child characters so that I can picture them and their behaviour better.

Names in all their forms have a significant role in the delivery of this novella, which is quite ironic as our narrator remains anonymous throughout the story. She is referred to variously as ‘girl� or ‘petal� or any other term, which reveals how the speaker views her. What is also interesting is her own approach to names. Her temporary foster mom, for instance, is always “the woman� in her thoughts while the foster dad is mostly “Kinsella�. There is also a significant moment connected to names at the very end, which is the most poignant moment of the story.

The writing is, as always, poetic without being over the top. Keegan maintains in her scenes the perfect balance between description and conversation, never allowing one to overpower the other. She is also true to the national identity of the characters, and retains the Irish lilt in their lines. The child’s emotions of awe and worry and fear and comfort come out well through the first person rendition. The story is medium-paced, and it would be better if you read it slower to get the exact sense of what’s happening. Keegan’s books are never to be skip-read.

The bittersweet ending left my heart longing for more. Though I know it was the only possible ending for this story, one can still wish that fiction worked better than reality and gave the girl an ending she deserved instead of an ending she was destined to have.

All in all, this isn’t a story that will leave you easily. It isn’t perfect, but it is striking in its writing and memorable in its characters. Definitely worth a read.

4.25 stars.

My thanks to Grove Atlantic and NetGalley for the DRC of “Foster�. This review is voluntary and contains my honest opinion about the book.

‘Foster� was an international bestseller on its release in 2010, and one of The Times� “Top 50 Novels Published in the 21st Century.� A variant of this story was published on the New Yorker site. This is the revised and expanded edition.



—ĔĔĔĔĔĔĔĔĔĔĔĔĔ�
Connect with me through:
| | |
140 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Foster.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

November 5, 2022 – Shelved
November 7, 2022 – Started Reading
November 7, 2022 – Shelved as: 4-25-stars
November 7, 2022 – Shelved as: netgalley
November 7, 2022 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 63 (63 new)


message 1: by Nika (last edited Nov 07, 2022 12:31PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Nika Another terrific review, Rosh! 🥰
Oh, when I root for characters, I, too, sometimes wish that fiction could work better than reality.


Kevin Ansbro Touching and subtle: two perfect descriptors.
I love how Keegan skillfully allows the reader to fill in the dots of her story without it looking as if she's missed something.

A very perceptive review, Rosh.


Rosh (Off GR duty for a fortnight!) Nika wrote: "Another terrific review, Rosh! 🥰
Oh, when I root for characters, I, too, sometimes wish that fiction could work better than reality."


Thanks, Nika! I am glad you understand. This happens more when you connect with the characters, and Claire Keegan's characters are always amazing. :)


Rosh (Off GR duty for a fortnight!) Kevin wrote: "Touching and subtle: two perfect descriptors.
I love how Keegan skillfully allows the reader to fill in the dots of her story without it looking as if she's missed something.

A very perceptive re..."


Thank you so much, Kevin. :) Completely agree - she is one of the few authors who has a knack for this. Her writing is so understated and yet so powerful!


message 5: by Carolyn (new) - added it

Carolyn Lovely review Rosh :)


message 6: by Parag (new) - added it

Parag My comment, in a nutshell, is that I'm adding this book to my TBR :-)


Srivalli Rekha Aye, aye, aye. I love how she plays with words. Love the review, Rosh (despite the 4 stars when I gave it 5; sniffle).


message 8: by Catherine (new) - added it

Catherine (alternativelytitledbooks) - in a book slump :( Any book that merits an automatic reread is special! I’m excited to try this author out soon and hopefully I can get a copy of this one. Fantastic review, Rosh! 💕


message 9: by Kaceey (new)

Kaceey Wonderful review Rosh!💖


Sujoya - theoverbookedbibliophile Wonderful review, Rosh! 🧡Claire Keegan does not disappoint! I can't wait for her next!


Margaret M - (having a challenging time and on GR as much as I can) Superb review Rosh 💖


Melissa (Semi-hiatus for Work) Excellent review Rosh, this sounds lovely.


Rosh (Off GR duty for a fortnight!) Carolyn wrote: "Lovely review Rosh :)"

Thanks, Carolyn! 💜


Rosh (Off GR duty for a fortnight!) Parag wrote: "My comment, in a nutshell, is that I'm adding this book to my TBR :-)"

I must warn you though, Parag. It is written in the present tense throughout. :D


Rosh (Off GR duty for a fortnight!) Srivalli wrote: "Aye, aye, aye. I love how she plays with words. Love the review, Rosh (despite the 4 stars when I gave it 5; sniffle)."

Arey, I debated a lot for my rating. I kept swinging between 4 and 4.5. So ended up in between. I wanted more details about the girl. :/


Rosh (Off GR duty for a fortnight!) Catherine wrote: "Any book that merits an automatic reread is special! I’m excited to try this author out soon and hopefully I can get a copy of this one. Fantastic review, Rosh! 💕"

Thanks, Catherine! I simply love the way she writes, and I hope you will too. 💜


Rosh (Off GR duty for a fortnight!) Kaceey wrote: "Wonderful review Rosh!💖"

Thanks, Kaceey! 💜


Rosh (Off GR duty for a fortnight!) Sujoya wrote: "Wonderful review, Rosh! 🧡Claire Keegan does not disappoint! I can't wait for her next!"

Thanks Sujoya! Same here! She is so good in her style, I will read anything she writes. 💜


Rosh (Off GR duty for a fortnight!) Margaret M - semi hiatus wrote: "Superb review Rosh 💖"

Thanks Margaret! 💜


Rosh (Off GR duty for a fortnight!) Melissa (LifeFullyBooked) wrote: "Excellent review Rosh, this sounds lovely."

Thanks, Melissa! 💜


message 21: by Meghhnaa (new)

Meghhnaa  (On a Review-Writing Break!) Your nutshell read like how one feels after reading your reviews- touched, gorgeous writing style, honestly heartfelt portrayal! In short, you defined your own reviews :P
Not feigning my emotions, but Rosh, thanks for working your way out and posting such awesome reviews in the middle of your busy schedule! Kudos! <3


message 22: by Federico (new)

Federico DN Have downloaded this recently. Hoping to read it next year. Fantastic review Rosh <3!


Srivalli Rekha Rosh wrote: "Arey, I debated a lot for my rating. I kept swinging between 4 and 4.5. So ended up in between. I wanted more details about the girl. :/"

Got ya. It wasn't easy to visualize the girl.


message 24: by Parag (new) - added it

Parag Ouch!
When I read your review in the past l, I thought this might be a fun book to read, but, as I read your comment in the present, I try to visualise myself reading the book that's written in a strange tense and my gut tells me, "You better avoid it buddy!" So I listen to my gut and bid the bood adeau!


Rosh (Off GR duty for a fortnight!) Meghna wrote: "Your nutshell read like how one feels after reading your reviews- touched, gorgeous writing style, honestly heartfelt portrayal! In short, you defined your own reviews :P
Not feigning my emotions, ..."


Thanks for your super-high praise, Meghna! Always so kind and generous with your words. <3


Rosh (Off GR duty for a fortnight!) Federico wrote: "Have downloaded this recently. Hoping to read it next year. Fantastic review Rosh <3!"

I hope you love it too, Federico! Thanks! <3


Rosh (Off GR duty for a fortnight!) Srivalli wrote: "It wasn't easy to visualize the girl."

True. :( I like character ages to be clear, especially for children and key characters.


Rosh (Off GR duty for a fortnight!) Parag wrote: "Ouch!
When I read your review in the past l, I thought this might be a fun book to read, but, as I read your comment in the present, I try to visualise myself reading the book that's written in a ..."


Oh my, it isn't a fun book in any sense, Parag. It is emotional but not overly so. The pathos is all underneath. But as you do not enjoy books in the present tense, you will have to miss out on this gem. :)


message 29: by Parag (new) - added it

Parag Oh! The dillemmas of reading are so taxing on my brain!

I think I'll ponder this conundrum in a cave in the Himalayas,

But, even for that, I'll have to wrestle with IRTC to get a ticket in the train.

How I wish, my problems were swept away by the rain :-)


Rosh (Off GR duty for a fortnight!) You're crazy! 😂😂


Dorie  - Cats&Books :) Sounds unique but I don't think this one is for me, it sounds like it may be a little confusing to follow? Maybe I'm reading your review wrong, at any rate great review!


message 32: by Ellie (new)

Ellie Spencer (catching up from hiatus) I do love an incredible ending, this sounds like such a wonderful read! The characters sound wonderful too! Amazing review Rosh! 🧡


Rosh (Off GR duty for a fortnight!) Dorie - Cats&Books :) wrote: "Sounds unique but I don't think this one is for me, it sounds like it may be a little confusing to follow? Maybe I'm reading your review wrong, at any rate great review!"

Not confusing as such, Dorie, but it will make you read the story with full concentration as there is much left between the lines. If you speed-read it, you won't get most of it. No problem if you skip this, but do try a Claire Keegan work some day. I have become a fan of her writing! :)


Rosh (Off GR duty for a fortnight!) Ellie wrote: "I do love an incredible ending, this sounds like such a wonderful read! The characters sound wonderful too! Amazing review Rosh! 🧡"

Absolutely, Ellie! This delivered wonderfully. Thanks! �


Lady Clementina ffinch-ffarowmore Wonderful review, Rosh. This does sound an excellent read, and I definitely must get to Keegan sooner than later. Like you I like the idea f authors who leave things t the reader to understand and interpret.


Rosh (Off GR duty for a fortnight!) Lady Clementina wrote: "Wonderful review, Rosh. This does sound an excellent read, and I definitely must get to Keegan sooner than later. Like you I like the idea f authors who leave things t the reader to understand and ..."

Thanks, Clem! You cannot miss out on Claire Keegan. Whatever I have read of her so far has been brilliant. :)


message 37: by Kay (new) - rated it 4 stars

Kay Wonderful review Rosh! 🥰


Rosh (Off GR duty for a fortnight!) Kay wrote: "Wonderful review Rosh! 🥰"

Thank you, Kay! 💕


Jennifer Welsh A review as lovely as the book, Rosh. Like you’ve done with Keegan, I’m going to return and read this more carefully, once my own experience has settled.


message 40: by Rosh (Off GR duty for a fortnight!) (last edited Dec 24, 2022 11:59PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Rosh (Off GR duty for a fortnight!) Jennifer wrote: "A review as lovely as the book, Rosh. Like you’ve done with Keegan, I’m going to return and read this more carefully, once my own experience has settled."

Thanks so much, Jennifer! Keegan's writing uncovers itself like layers. A reread always works better.
Merry Christmas to you! 💕


Darla Lovely review, Rosh!


Rosh (Off GR duty for a fortnight!) Darla wrote: "Lovely review, Rosh!"

Thank you, Darla! 💐


Cecily Lovely review of a beautifully written story. The film adaptation (in Irish, with subtitles) is excellent, though the do give the girl a name. It's called An Cailín Ciúin or The Quiet Girl.


Rosh (Off GR duty for a fortnight!) Cecily wrote: "Lovely review of a beautifully written story. The film adaptation (in Irish, with subtitles) is excellent, though the do give the girl a name. It's called An Cailín Ciúin or The Quiet Girl."

Thanks much, Cecily! I love Claire Keegan's works. :)
I wasn't aware that there's a movie adaptation as well. Will see if it is available here in India. :)


Cecily It was shortlisted for an Oscar a couple of months ago, in the international category, so you may get lucky.


message 46: by SK (new) - rated it 5 stars

SK Her writing is very intelligent, and she also respects her readers� intelligence by not spoon-feeding them every single detail. Nor does she shove the emotions into your face but causes you to feel them through simple scenes and hidden cues.

I love how you put this, Rosh, and I wholeheartedly agree with your assessment of Foster's writing. This is what I enjoy about her, too. Thank you for this review.


Rosh (Off GR duty for a fortnight!) Shelley wrote: "Her writing is very intelligent, and she also respects her readers� intelligence by not spoon-feeding them every single detail. Nor does she shove the emotions into your face but causes you to feel..."

Thanks much, Shelley. I'm glad you feel the same way. She's one of my favourite contemporary authors. :)


Terrie  Robinson Wonderful review, Rosh! I love Keegan’s beautiful writing and this story is heart-wrenching.


Rosh (Off GR duty for a fortnight!) Terrie wrote: "Wonderful review, Rosh! I love Keegan’s beautiful writing and this story is heart-wrenching."

Thank you, Terrie! I too love her writing. She is one of the best writers today. :)


message 50: by Karen (new)

Karen Wow I can't believe I have missed so many of your wonderful reviews. I'. happy for you that this was beautifully emotive with realistic characters. I apologize for getting behind on following up and enjoying your well written reviews. xx


« previous 1
back to top