ŷ

Thibault Busschots's Reviews > Night Watch

Night Watch by Terry Pratchett
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
76463472
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: discworld, favorites

Sam Vimes, the idealistic commander of the City Watch, hunts down the killer of several watchmen and follows him up to a rooftop in the middle of a magical storm. Suddenly they get struck by lightning, which catapults them both into the past. One of the first things the killer does after arrival is kill John Keel. History Monk Lu-Tze freezes time for Sam Vimes and explains to him that this is a major problem. Vimes idolized John Keel when they were in the Watch together. John Keel not only taught Vimes what it means to be a good copper, he is also responsible for Vimes� firm belief in justice. Without John Keel, there would be no Sam Vimes. And John Keel was just killed, right before he was supposed to join the Watch and meet a young Vimes. The only way to save the present, is to recreate the past as best as possible. The only way to do that, is for Sam Vimes to assume the identity of John Keel and become the mentor of his own young self.


The story basically shows us the impact one good mentor can have on the life of a person. It’s also just a very fascinating concept. As John Keel, Vimes' hero and former mentor, turns out to be Vimes himself from the future. This is so cool and also so absolutely brilliant.


The character development is incredibly good. Sam Vimes is easily one of the best characters Pratchett ever created. So exploring his past is just a really good idea. He’s the most developed and most interesting protagonist in the Discworld series. He’s also a very fascinating character. His cynicism, streets smarts and his grasp of human nature clash so hard with his pure, idealistic thoughts. But it’s his idealistic nature that makes sure he will always try to do the right thing. Because deep down, he cares. He will always try to make the world a better place, no matter how much he doesn’t like the way the world works all around him.


The Discworld series is of course known for its brilliant comedy. So it’s very interesting to note that there really isn’t much comedy to be found in this book. The serious and rather dark tone of this novel makes it stand out a lot from the other Discworld novels in all the right ways. It also makes the revolution this story revolves around feel much more grim, serious and important. It makes you pay attention. Because this story tries to send a very important message to us readers. And it’s clear Pratchett didn’t want to see his message get lost in between some good jokes.


The Discworld’s City Watch books are some of the best books ever written. This is easily one of the best books in the series.
53 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Night Watch.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

November 20, 2022 – Started Reading
November 20, 2022 – Shelved
November 20, 2022 – Shelved as: discworld
November 28, 2022 – Shelved as: favorites
November 28, 2022 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-11 of 11 (11 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Rosh (Off GR duty for a fortnight!) Nice review! Some of my friends keep recommending this series to me, but the sheer count of the books exhausts me. Are the books much interlinked, Thibault? I don't like cliffhangers in series books, so my main doubt if I can try a few of the titles and getaway with it. :/


Thibault Busschots Rosh wrote: "Nice review! Some of my friends keep recommending this series to me, but the sheer count of the books exhausts me. Are the books much interlinked, Thibault? I don't like cliffhangers in series book..."

Thanks Rosh :)

There are many different ways to read the legendary Discworld series. There are a few subseries and a few stand alone novels. Though I’d go so far as to say this is one of the only series where it’s not recommended to start with the first book. Because Pratchett grew a lot as a writer during his career and Rincewind is the least interesting protagonist. Apart from the first book, there are no cliffhangers. And most books can be actually be read as a stand alone book.

Best books to start with in my opinion:
Guards! Guards! - first of the City Watch books
Mort - first of the Death books
Wyrd Sisters � second of the Witches books
Small Gods � a stand alone book
The Amazing Maurice and His Educated Rodents � a young adult stand alone book


Rosh (Off GR duty for a fortnight!) Thibault wrote: "Rosh wrote: "Nice review! Some of my friends keep recommending this series to me, but the sheer count of the books exhausts me. Are the books much interlinked, Thibault? I don't like cliffhangers i..."

Wow! Thanks so much for taking the time out to write such a helpful reply! I will definitely take your advice and look for these books without going through the entire series. :)


Rhonda 🌒🌕🌘 🐈‍⬛ Phenomenal review Paulette! Now I want to read the series. I need giggles in my life!


Thibault Busschots Rhonda (Rowan’s version) wrote: "Phenomenal review Paulette! Now I want to read the series. I need giggles in my life!"

Guess my name is Paulette now :P

Thanks, Rhonda. It's a very entertaining series.


message 6: by Barbara (new)

Barbara I just read a review and the reviewer stated that the author was attempting to be as clever and funny as Pratchett. Now I know what that means! Thanks for all your Pratchett reviews Thibault!


Thibault Busschots Barbara wrote: "I just read a review and the reviewer stated that the author was attempting to be as clever and funny as Pratchett. Now I know what that means! Thanks for all your Pratchett reviews Thibault!"

This is like the most non-funny Pratchett book I’ve ever read :D

But yeah, I totally get that. Whenever clever comedy is done well, it's hard not to think of Pratchett. He's an absolute master in that regard.

You're welcome, Barbara. And thanks for commenting :)


message 8: by Srivalli (new)

Srivalli Rekha Interesting! The author knew his priorities. As always, a glowing review of your favorite series. ;)


Thibault Busschots Srivalli wrote: "Interesting! The author knew his priorities. As always, a glowing review of your favorite series. ;)"

Thanks, Srivalli. Hope you’ll try reading a Discworld book too someday :)


message 10: by Srivalli (new)

Srivalli Rekha Thibault wrote: "Thanks, Srivalli. Hope you’ll try reading a Discworld book too someday :)"

Some day, why not? :D


Thibault Busschots Srivalli wrote: "Thibault wrote: "Thanks, Srivalli. Hope you’ll try reading a Discworld book too someday :)"

Some day, why not? :D"


That's the spirit :)


back to top