欧宝娱乐

Emily (Books with Emily Fox on Youtube)'s Reviews > I Who Have Never Known Men

I Who Have Never Known Men by Jacqueline Harpman
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
58160628
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: favorites
Read 2 times. Last read April 7, 2023.

Do yourself a favor and read this.

The second half of this book blew my mind. Very bleak but it will haunt me forever.

Best book of 2022:

Update: Reread it in French (no idea how to add another edition here) and liked it even more.
1411 likes ·  鈭� flag

Sign into 欧宝娱乐 to see if any of your friends have read I Who Have Never Known Men.
Sign In 禄

Reading Progress

December 7, 2022 – Started Reading
December 7, 2022 – Shelved
December 8, 2022 – Finished Reading
April 7, 2023 – Started Reading
April 7, 2023 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-43 of 43 (43 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Jen K Honestly I think this is one of the best books I've ever read, not just one of the best of the year.


Painteyelash I have never heard of it until now and have added it to my tbr. I wonder if you would like Boy Parts by Eliza Clark.


Emily (Books with Emily Fox on Youtube) BucketOfEntrails wrote: "Honestly I think this is one of the best books I've ever read, not just one of the best of the year."

Agreed! I already want to reread it!

Painteyelash wrote: "I have never heard of it until now and have added it to my tbr. I wonder if you would like Boy Parts by Eliza Clark."

I've seen it going around. I think my library has it so I'll check it out!


Painteyelash Cool, I hope you like it!


message 5: by M (new) - added it

M Ok, I will. 馃檪


Vera (Estante da Vera) I'm reading because of you and loving it, but I'm ready to be devastated.


Emily (Books with Emily Fox on Youtube) Vera wrote: "I'm reading because of you and loving it, but I'm ready to be devastated."

I'm sorry in advance lol


message 8: by On (new) - rated it 5 stars

On Faery Stories I just finished that book that I've read on your recommendation, and I'm just speechless. I've also reread the very beginning which makes much more sense once you know the whole story. I'm just deeply moved and impressed by how rich Harpman's themes are through such a unique and deeply disturbing plot. One of the most thought-provoking novels I've ever read, period.


Emily (Books with Emily Fox on Youtube) The French wrote: "I just finished that book that I've read on your recommendation, and I'm just speechless. I've also reread the very beginning which makes much more sense once you know the whole story. I'm just dee..."

I'm so glad you liked it! I'm planning on mentioning it as often as possible so everyone picks it up, it's too underrated!


message 10: by Vera (new) - rated it 5 stars

Vera (Estante da Vera) I read because of your recommendation and it was magnifique!


Martina I'm currently reading this, as my first book of the year.


Janine Just finished this book as my first book of 2023 and it was bleak but a reminder of how women can be strong. Brilliant!!


Irena the book is great but I just hate the open ending I really like when author tells me everything :D


Janine Irena wrote: "the book is great but I just hate the open ending I really like when author tells me everything :D"

I agree there. What happens to them? Do they die?


Gail (Neuroknitter) This book!! I wish it had been my first book of 2023! It was phenomenal. I鈥檓 so grateful you found it and brought it to our attention. This story verges on perfection despite its sadness. I just put chased it so it can have a permanent place on my shelves! Thank you, thank you!!


Tidoublegr79 I couldn't have picked a better time in my life to read this. I can relate to the protagonist so much. I'm so glad you wouldn't stop recommending it. More people should read it.


Taylor Franson-Thiel Bleak is such the right word. But ditto to people needing to read this!


message 18: by Len (new) - rated it 5 stars

Len Currently reading and it makes me think of another book, you might like: Two Old Women: An Alaskan Legend of Betrayal, Courage and Survival by Velma Wallis


Katie I鈥檓 all for reading and throughout the whole book I was WAITING for something to happen. And then it ended. Well written but SO dumb.


Jesse @Katie did you really expect closure? There was plenty of stuff happening throughout the book.


message 21: by Jen Bowman (new)

Jen Bowman Nonfiction?


Keyla I bought this because of you and can't wait to read it!


message 23: by Len (new) - rated it 5 stars

Len Jen Bowman wrote: "Nonfiction?"

I'd say it's dystopian fiction?


message 24: by Rach (new) - rated it 5 stars

Rach Thank you for the recommendation. I absolutely agree with you that this one will stay with the reader forever.


Salem This book is a masterpiece I loved it so much.I wish I spoke French so I could read it in the original language.


Acara The French wrote: " I've also reread the very beginning which makes much more sense once you know the whole story.

I just finished and then went back to the beginning after seeing your comment. So glad I did! It clarified the narrator's point of view and actually shifted my perspective of the story. This is a fascinating book! I'm so glad I came across it.


Kaitlyn Crozier Please explain to me why this would haunt you? It鈥檚 a fantasy and completely unrealistic. I couldn鈥檛 be drawn in by how unfathomable the entire thing is


miriam_cologne It鈥榮 sold out in Germany right now. :) Might be because of you 鈥�


message 29: by Deborah (new)

Deborah Saki It鈥檚 horror


Twila Hankins There's more than a story here , yes it's disturbing at times , but the courage of the young girl , her constant ability to keep hoping for something better was something that cannot be explained , but in a way experienced by humans even when it's not understood ,why?
Especially when her life was a blank page to be filled with the limited experiences around her .
Where did she find the hope? The courage to never stop believing for something better?


message 31: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa I purchased a copy of this book because of you, and I thank you. It was as good as you promised (if not better) and I will definitely be rereading it, perhaps multiple times.


message 32: by Cala (new)

Cala Im scared to read this. It sounds very dark.


message 33: by Luke (new) - rated it 5 stars

Luke I read this book because of your review and it鈥檚 wonderful. I normally don鈥檛 read much fiction but this was such an easy and engaging read. There were passages that made me cry and I really don鈥檛 think that has ever happened before. It made me really think about exactly what it is that makes us human. How much can be stripped away before we become something else. Thank you so much.


Caladae Thanks for the recommendation. I just finished it. What a read.


message 35: by Cheng (new) - added it

Cheng Bogdani Wow, with a review like that I had to get on my library's wait-list right away!


Veros I read this because of you and I loved it but also damn, the bleakest thing I've probably ever read!


message 37: by Erin (new) - rated it 5 stars

Erin One of my all time favorite books.


Marne - Reader By the Water I just finished and am struggling to write a review. What a tiny, powerful story.


Nona the First I read this because of you! Loved every second


message 40: by Larissa (new)

Larissa SHAKHNOVICH I read this because of your review and struggle to understand what exactly blew your mind? I was waiting for the whole of the second half of my reading to have my mind blown, did I miss something? Or are you using too strong of an expression?


Zooey Glass I really didn鈥檛 get it. It started well but I found it so boring and repetitive in the second part. What did I miss? Nothing happens, no deep characters, no answers, actually you already know there鈥檚 not gonna be a surprising ending, that made it so difficult to read! It took me 4 days to read the last 20 pages 馃う馃徎鈥嶁檧锔�


Allison Ryder I read this is 2 sittings! A modern classic! Thanks for telling us we have to read it!


Amy Rouse Ho This book left me as troubled as The Road did, and both are unforgettable. It is the kind of book that you recommend but you don鈥檛 necessarily 鈥渓ike鈥�.


back to top