ŷ

Paul Bryant's Reviews > The Life-Changing Magic of Tidying Up: The Japanese Art of Decluttering and Organizing

The Life-Changing Magic of Tidying Up by Marie Kondō
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
416390
's review

bookshelves: reviews-of-books-i-didnt-read

I got hooked on watching a show from around ten years ago called Hoarders. As you may imagine from the title, this is about people who are the polar opposite of tidy. If you, dear Goodreader, exploded a bomb inside your house, the resulting vista of destruction would still be 100% more organised than these hoarders.

I realised that I myself hoard books. But very neatly. Most of them are in the loft. The first section is fiction, arranged, obviously, by author’s last name. I’ve read all these. I am thinking that Marie Kondo might possibly give me a hard time about that. She could reasonably ask why I need to keep those, since there is no possibility I could ever have the time to reread any of them, and in any case, I rated quite a few of them one or two stars, so why would I ever want to. This is where me and the hoarders are not so far apart. They keep stuff they won’t ever use, they seem to imagine vaguely that they will be able to live another hundred years and be able to get round to all these projects and sort out all these towering piles of broken furniture and rain damaged guitars and patch all those rat-gnawed doileys.

In the fiction section those names beginning with Mc give me mild anxiety � should I assume there is an A between the M and the c? If I don’t those authors will find themselves exiled from their clan members whose names begin Mac. So I assume, but trepidaciously. The short story collections come at the end of the fiction section. There is no sensible way of ordering them. Very sorry but no one remembers who edits an anthology so their names are useless. After fiction comes Memoirs, Politics, Theology and History. These have their own idiosyncrasies which I shan’t bore you with. After those comes some great shelves of graphic novels and then science fiction followed by my Shelf of Shame : true crime. I’m sure Ray Bradbury shudders to find himself within arm’s reach of John Wayne Gacy (whereas Kurt Vonnegut smiles sardonically) but I am not running Borges� Library of Babel here. So that is the loft.

Downstairs you will find bookcases dedicated to biographies (arranged alphabetically by subject name not by author name), books about books, and books about music. There are memoirs and biographies in the music book section � I know! What a contradiction! Shouldn’t the music biographies be shelved with all the other biographies? Should Joni Mitchell come between Grace Metalious and Anais Nin? How delicious!. Should Captain Beefheart interpose himself between Samuel Beckett and Saul Bellow? Perish the thought. So after much head scratching I assigned the musicians to their own ghetto. Then finally I have some shelves dedicated to those most intimidating books of all � the To Be Reads. They glower at me every day. I know what they are thinking � why haven’t you read me yet? Eight years I have been patiently waiting! Am I no longer pretty enough? Some of the older ones watch newer arrivals plucked off the tbr shelf almost immediately � I can hear their pages gnashing.

I’m almost sure Marie Kondo would tell me point blank to get rid of half of these books. So I’ll put my copy of The Life-Changing Magic of Tidying Up carefully on my tbr shelf and benignly ignore it for a few years.
112 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Life-Changing Magic of Tidying Up.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

December 9, 2022 – Shelved
December 9, 2022 – Shelved as: to-read
February 27, 2023 – Shelved as: reviews-of-books-i-didnt-read

Comments Showing 1-33 of 33 (33 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Ann (new)

Ann This sparked joy. Marie would say to keep it :)


message 2: by Renee (new)

Renee Roberts Half? No, Marie Kondo would (possibly) allow maybe 5 books: your current read, your Bible, your dishwasher manual, a dictionary, and the children's book you read every night to your toddler. No, wait, the dishwasher manual and the dictionary are available on your phone, and the children's book is memorized, so MAYBE 2 books.... This is where I closed her book and filed her system as extremist nonsense, since my house is like yours, but less organized!


message 3: by BeMandyReads (new)

BeMandyReads I loved that show! Long live Hoarders!


Paul H. I've gotten insanely merciless about selling my old books, it turns out that once you sell the 1/2-star books that you'll never reread, you don't really miss them or notice they're gone . . . at this point I've sold thousands. As a former book hoarder, I actually recommend it!


message 5: by Paul (new) - added it

Paul Bryant But don't you look at the space you save and think that space is just right for more books?


Paul H. I always end up getting more books, is the thing! So that space fills up quickly haha


message 7: by Cecily (new)

Cecily Hoarding books doesn't count, especially when they're well-organised.


message 8: by Roman (new)

Roman Stadtler The only point I agree with Kondo on is that only the things that bring you joy are worth keeping. Books bring me, and most of us, joy, so they stay (unless I didn't like them, or they're badly reviewed by multiple sources). Everything else, she's too disciplinarian.


message 9: by Carmen (new) - added it

Carmen Great review.


Laura It is my opinion that books cannot be hoards, unless you're like the couple in Season 5 who filled their entire house, floor to ceiling, with what appeared to be clearance finds that nobody was actually going to read.


message 11: by Paul (new) - added it

Paul Bryant Sounds like they were doing the world a service and removing terrible books from circulation. People should do that more.


message 12: by Paul (new) - added it

Paul Bryant Actually I had missed that episode & have now seen it. The cleanup team took 20,000 books out of their house and only cleared two rooms! Ha! Man, they were book freaks.


Laura If your house isn't like that, or it is but you've read over half of the 20,000+ books, then I say you're in the clear. 😸


message 14: by Gary (new)

Gary Brilliant review! Thanks.


message 15: by Paul (new) - added it

Paul Bryant thanks Gary....


message 16: by Alexandra (new)

Alexandra Have you read The Trauma Cleaner??


message 17: by Paul (new) - added it

Paul Bryant yes I did!

/review/show...


message 18: by Jessaka (new)

Jessaka Thanks for an enjoyable review


message 19: by calleigh (new) - added it

calleigh curran I strongly believe (like Laura) that “hoarding� books is rarely possible. Even if they only get one read, and even if they are only 1 star books, they are still books. And if books “spark joy� in you, the physical books serve as decorations, memories, and signs of intelligence. Books are wonderful, and getting rid of items that we spend so much time enjoying is just wasteful. Loved your review and completely agree!


message 20: by Gary (last edited Jun 30, 2023 02:20AM) (new)

Gary calleigh wrote: "I strongly believe (like Laura) that “hoarding� books is rarely possible. Even if they only get one read, and even if they are only 1 star books, they are still books. And if books “spark joy� in y..."

I agree, Calleigh. I have only(!) about 750 books and not enough space to put them, but I struggle to ever get rid of any of them. Recently I have given away quite a number to charity shops, but I know the day will come when I look for one and wonder where it's gone. I am proud of my 'library' because it says something about who I am. :-)


message 21: by Paul (new) - added it

Paul Bryant I have been known to re-buy books I gave away to Oxfam. This is a dangerous habit.


message 22: by Gary (new)

Gary Paul wrote: "I have been known to re-buy books I gave away to Oxfam. This is a dangerous habit."

Indeed! You have my sympathy, Paul. :-)


message 23: by Gary (new)

Gary I love that review, btw, Paul. Re: the difficulty with Mc/Mac, I think book shops handle it by listing all the Macs and then the Mcs before Ma... so they are all at the beginning, so to speak. That way they are all together, and treated almost as a separate category, rather than part of the Ms. Hope that helps.


message 24: by Nahyan Ameen (new)

Nahyan Ameen I would like to learn more about Oxfam


message 25: by Paul (new) - added it

Paul Bryant they are the second largest booksellers in the UK


message 26: by Robin Wright (new)

Robin Wright Gunn Dear Mr. Paul Bryant, I first discovered you through your brilliant ( but OH SO WRONG) review that both mocked AND panned We Have Always Lived In the Castle. And now I am reading this *review* and once again have come to the conclusion that you have turned ŷ into an art form!! BRAVO to you Mr. Paul Bryant!!! I am not worthy. ❤️❤️❤️❤️


message 27: by Robin Wright (new)

Robin Wright Gunn UPDATE: Oh my goodness I made a mistake!! Your "brilliant (but OH SO WRONG) review" was of I Capture the Castle.

I keep getting my castle books confused.


message 28: by Paul (new) - added it

Paul Bryant Not to mention The Castle of Crossed Destinies, Castle Rackrent and The Castle of Otranto....books can be very castley

thanks Robin...!


message 29: by Robin Wright (new)

Robin Wright Gunn "books can be very castley" 😂❤️🤩


message 30: by Jenbebookish (new)

Jenbebookish YES. There’s nothing I hate more than throwing away a book I’ve read. I need to keep them all and look and them and appreciate all the time spent reading them all and feel like I’m making progress on the other group of hundreds of books that I own, the UNread ones.

Ok here’s another thing I need to know, do you keep your read and unread books separate? You said u keep the read fiction books separate from the others, and organize alphabetically, so for all the other books do you throw read and unread alike together on the shelves?


message 31: by Jenbebookish (new)

Jenbebookish Or I should have said GIVE AWAY. Not THROW AWAY. I would never throw away books. Blasphemous.


message 32: by Paul (last edited Jun 01, 2024 08:53AM) (new) - added it

Paul Bryant All the unread ones are located on several shelves together, sorted only into fiction and nonfiction. All the read ones have their own sections elsewhere. I have actually thrown away a book occasionally, because it literally fell apart as i was reading it - some old paperbacks can do that. But most of them are amazingly robust.


message 33: by M_c_jay (new) - added it

M_c_jay Borges' Library of Babel should be the goal!


back to top