ŷ

Vesna's Reviews > I'm a Fan

I'm a Fan by Sheena Patel
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
59785585
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: 2022-releases, debut, fiction, uk-ireland-commonwealth, read-2022-contemporary

Raw, intense, uncompromising, what a debut! The narrator is a young (30-ish) British woman of nonwhite heritage caught in a love triangle with “the man I want to be with� and his other on-and-off girlfriend, “the woman I am obsessed with� (well, it’s a quadrangle, he is married). They are privileged, she is not. They are white, she is not. They have fans (he in the art industry, his other girlfriend as a savy influencer on Instagram), she doesn’t. So she becomes their fan-turned-stalker.

She is entangled in a cat-and-mouse relationship with him, no actual love on either side, but the game of domination between the sexes. She descends into an obsessive goal to own him, to control him, to reverse the arrow of dominance, but the pursuit of which just shows how much she lets that control her life.

At the same time, she follows his other girlfriend on Instagram, practically turning into a virtual stalker, trying to connect the dots of his and her life during the weeks and months when he avoids her, but also envying the other girlfriend's white privileged life of a famous poet’s daughter and a trend-setter of an expensive and “curated� lifestyle that brings her an army of Instagram followers and fans.

Their story is told in a nonlinear way through shorter vignettes that alternate between the narrator’s story and her thoughts (evidently, lending voice to the author) about the hypocrisies, illusions, and injustices of our contemporary society. Some vignettes read like short essays, most of which are quite powerful like “There’s no business like�, “buds�, “how does your garden grow�, and others.

Patel’s uncompromising and powerful views extend to the unequal class, racial, and gender issues of our times, as well as the optical illusions of social media which slowly penetrate into our lives.

It’s very quotable on all these issues (the lower the level of melanin in the body, the higher your place in the hierarchy �), so I’ll just sample a few about social media...

and its dehumanizing and illusory nature:
this automated time where an algorithm has to get to know you before a human being can […] You hear people you don’t know, in living rooms you’ll never be invited into, preparing meals you’ll never eat.

and its role in perpetuating the inequalities:
Aren’t these wealthy aesthetes on Instagram merely another iteration of a class elite deciding what is good and what is not good, shaping our reality the way they always have just better disguised by technology which has the optics of transparency and democracy?

and this scary aspect:
I’ve never followed anyone before and I’m surprised at how easy it is and how engrossed people are in their lives that they don’t notice someone tracking them.

My only caveats are about some repetitions that the author could have done without and the ending (view spoiler) - still can’t make up my mind if it’s a literary ingenuity or a new writer’s struggle with how to go about it. These personal caveats aside, this is a terrific debut and an author to watch.
48 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read I'm a Fan.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

December 10, 2022 – Started Reading
December 11, 2022 – Shelved
December 12, 2022 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-9 of 9 (9 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Laura (new)

Laura Yes - it was one of my criticisms of Bernadine Evaristo's book that she ignores/overlooks the fact that Asian women have been writing about racial discrimination your years and years. Most of what she covered focussing exclusive on her definition of 'black' has been covered in exactly the way Patel has done here - that emphasis on a hierarchy depending on the melanin content of your skin.
Sounds good - although the way people fall for or become obsessed with this 'Influencer/blogger/Instagram' hype is boring.


Vesna Laura wrote: "Yes - it was one of my criticisms of Bernadine Evaristo's book that she ignores/overlooks the fact that Asian women have been writing about racial discrimination your years and years. Most of what ..."

I am with you, Laura, about the social media hype in recent novels (and avoided for example Lockwood's book for that reason). Patel though treats it differently and the parts about Instagram were more about other issues such as the shallow trendsetting, virtual stalking, the illusion that the "followers" feel they are "sharing" the life with the privileged through "likes" and comments when in fact that would never happen in real life, and so on. I selected these quotes only because they were shorter. There is much more in the novel about the injustices in class, racial, and gender roles/relationships but those would be much lengthier quotations. :-)


message 3: by Fionnuala (new)

Fionnuala All very interesting, Vesna, and the quotes super well phrased. Like Laura and yourself, I wouldn't be sure I'd want to read much about people so fixated on influencers and other social media stars but Patel sounds as if she offers a very astute take on our times nonetheless. I've a funny relationship with social media. Each time a new platform comes along, I create a profile in order to understand what it has to offer but in most cases I've left the profile unvisited—with the exception of Twitter where I sometimes look at tweets from a few publishers and booksellers. I've never become a 'follower' of an individual. The word 'follower' puts me off so much that I even have the 'followers' option on my goodreads profile unticked and my profile set to private mode. Also no country of residence listed. When I get friend requests, I vet them to see if they write reviews of the kind of books I read and if what they say about them is interesting. I like having total control—or at least the maximum I can have. Obviously all our reviews end up in the community review pages but at least strangers can't click on 'My Books' and see all my activity at a glance. And I'm hoping people don't bother clicking into the comment threads on the reviews they scroll through on the community pages because we all inevitably share a bit of private stuff with close friends in comment threads. I wish goodreads didn't post the number of comments after each review in the community reviews page for each book though...


message 4: by Vesna (last edited Dec 21, 2022 10:12PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Vesna Fionnuala wrote: "All very interesting, Vesna, and the quotes super well phrased. Like Laura and yourself, I wouldn't be sure I'd want to read much about people so fixated on influencers and other social media stars..."

Thank you for stopping by, Fionnuala. My social media experience mirrors yours in that I don't like the idea of "followers" (first time I heard it, I was like "what??"), have a couple of accounts but hardly ever use them. The only reason I have Instagram account is to look up at the updates about our local semi-stray three-legged cat taken care by two neighbors in case I don't walk in that area for a few days (she already knows me and loves to be pet :-)). Facebook was a wonderful platform to reconnect with many friends from my childhood and later years, but they know that I am just not into social platforms so we now communicate privately. I can't remember when was the last time I logged on there. I am active only on GR and, like you, prefer GR friends who interact and at least occasionally post reviews

Back to Patel, she is very smart and talented. To sample her writing, her incredible essay "there's no business like" can be read on Google books. It's incredible. tinyurl[dot]com/bdfc8fwx


message 5: by Jola (last edited Jan 18, 2023 11:10PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Jola Dear Vesna, I read your spellbinding review a few days ago, got hold of the book at once and read it fervently in just two days! 🙂 I hope to write a review soon but wanted you to know that we are broadly aligned and I feel grateful for your encouragement as I might have ignored this novel. You pinpointed its strengths brilliantly!

Regarding the ending... (view spoiler)


Vesna Jola wrote: "Dear Vesna, I read your spellbinding review a few days ago, got hold of the book at once and read it fervently in just two days! 🙂 I hope to write a review soon but wanted you to know that we are b..."

My goodness, dear Jola, I never got notification for your comment and wouldn't have seen it had you not kindly referenced my review in your exceptional writeup about this book. Thank you so much for your lovely and thoughtful comment!

As for the ending, I absolutely love your take on it. Throughout the novel, she throws darts at many contradictions of our times, not sparing even her narrator from it (view spoiler)


Jola Dear Vesna, you are very welcome. Please, don't worry. I often face problems with updates also. I'm 100% sure I wouldn't have reached for this book if I hadn't read your exquisite and inspiring review! I am truly grateful. As for the narrator's feminist views, the manipulative aspect of the man she wants to be with is depicted so vividly that her infatuation is fathomable � maybe even a bit infectious 🙂 despite his repulsive personality � but annoying at the same time.


Laura Really good review that voices exactly what I liked about this book!


Vesna Laura wrote: "Really good review that voices exactly what I liked about this book!"

I'm glad we had the same reading experience, Laura. And thanks for sharing this comment.


back to top