Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Stephen P(who no longer can participate due to illness)'s Reviews > Pitch Dark

Pitch Dark by Renata Adler
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
11602286
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: favorites

"We were running flat out. The opening was dazzling. The middle was dazzling. It was like a steeplechase composed entirely of hurdles.
But that would not be a steeplechase at all. It would be more like a steep, steep climb.
They were shouting, Tell it, big momma, tell it. I mean, the child is only six years old.
Do I need to stylize it, then, or can I tell it as it was?"

Seemingly, this opening of Pitch Dark is telling and foretelling about an adult love relationship. However, Adler tucks in the child of six years old. What are we to make of it? She even seems to ask permission if she can slip past her requirements as a writer; a reporter, novelist, as though the form and act of writing distances her from reality. Is it O.K. to tell it as it was?

Speed Boat, her previous novel, which Proustitute so rightly suggests to read initially and in conjunction with Pitch Dark, utilizes her effective style of fragmentation and articulate concision to report on the hypocrisies and surface cloaked meaninglessness of her contemporaries, as well as glimpses of herself

Pitch Dark is a large moaning leap into the battleground of Renata Adler's interior strewn with blood of amputated limbs, hearts abandoned still pulsing, thoughts rushing through the crammed sentences of a frightened mortal mind. Using her fragmented and articulate style she now whispers brief compelling stories, produces repetitions, offers bits of confounding thought urging the reader on in the narrative and further on into her mind. She has eschewed writing for telling us as it was, placing us there with her as she battles her demons, discovers herself, as we are doing the same.

The style bears a taut tension for her and we the reader who no longer read but share a consciousness, a difficult consciousness straining beneath the weight of what is desired but also feared. A consciousness similar to all of ours but also imprinted in its on specialized cast.

The initial of three parts-Please read, Proustitoute's and Brian Dice's fine reviews of this book- the first person female narrator retells the history of her relationship with a married lover of a number of years, shifting us in time. She is alone but missing him, wanting him. What is love for her? Can she love? She sees that something that has been there over time may be there because it is dying, is dead. If it is dead it is not love. She spies on the huge questions now surfacing, dominating her life; the off-on again distance of her relationship with her lover has her ruminating on whether veering any closer despite her wishes and dreams might combust in a dissimulation of herself she may never recover from. Can she exist within a relationship outside all the self-delusions, and still be herself? Will she necessarily be absorbed and within that context no longer exist? Can she exist alone, a separate entity with her paralyzing conflicts and fears?

She is in Ireland, alone, driving a rental car of a circumspect nature trying to find Dublin (Home? Home of herself?) It is getting dark, Then darker, rain misting. She is lost. Has she passed the turnoff? If so she must go back. However if she has not and does go back there will be that much further to go. It is darker and few if any cars on the road. She waves down a large truck asking the driver for help. Suspicious of the look he gives her still she chooses to follow him as he offered. Driving behind him she believes she has done something wrong concerning the rental car and the authorities may be looking for her. The truck driver may well be leading her in the opposite direction of Dublin. What to do?

If on her own what she locates is piercing thorns of paranoia and helplessness. No one cares about her, or outright would like to do her harm. This is a dangerous and claustrophobic world she hurtles into as she enters the pitch dark of her wavered and wounded mind, relentless in finding means of supporting its own beliefs. In the pitch dark of herself and the world she has created she is truly frightened. She has a right to be frightened.

The final section, Home, has the reader rooting for her, if that is possible, if there is time. It is so simple to be lost in the the writing's beauty of precision, its burning and burnt passion, the profound and courageous intellect of the author. You will have to read the book to find out what happens to her, of what she may or may not make happen, what we may or may not make happen for ourselves. As in all 5 star works there is wisdom, then left with a yearning for more, a taste we do not want to relinquish. Adler has also given us a unique style honed to the sheerness of beauty, sentences to lavish in, thoughts to relish. I am so glad that I have read this book, its enjoyment and challenges and its mirror held up for all to see themselves, if they so wish. Also, the gratitude that Speedboat, Pitch Dark, was reprinted and made available. The world would be lesser without its contributions. This may mean that readers such as ourselves are being heard and if nothing else making it worth a publisher's effort to reprint great works which might otherwise slip into oblivion. A new club? Keeping Authors From Burial to complement the already so valuable GR's, Buried Authors?

PS: I just wanted to thank you. I love talking about the books that I read, and believe there is someone listening. There is no other place I can do this. Whether what I write is agreed with or other, it is the community of book-interested people, all ages, all countries, connected through literature, that is so important. Completing this review reminded me how grateful I am.






30 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Pitch Dark.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

January 30, 2013 – Shelved
June 27, 2013 – Started Reading
July 5, 2013 – Finished Reading
July 7, 2013 – Shelved as: favorites

Comments Showing 1-17 of 17 (17 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by M. (new) - added it

M. Sarki Very good review. I ordered this book today, the original, and really can't wait to read it. I have not read any of her work as yet, but I am going to read this one first even though you friends of mine suggest differently.


Stephen P(who no longer can participate due to illness) M. wrote: "Very good review. I ordered this book today, the original, and really can't wait to read it. I have not read any of her work as yet, but I am going to read this one first even though you friends of..."

Thanks M. I think this is your kind of book. Read away. I can't wait to hear what you think of it. She has such a rare grasp of the inner world and the beauty of language.


message 3: by Garima (new) - added it

Garima Aww! And we're grateful that you read and review all these wonderful books, Stephen. Your willingness to read all kind of books is really inspiring, so thanks to you. Wonderful review as always. My copies of speedboat and pitch dark are on its way..can't wait to read her now.


Brian This is such an awesome review, Stephen. And I want to thank YOU for investing the time to construct these lovely reflections on books that are beautiful and important.

I read these out of order (am half finished with Speedboat); and even though I wish I had read Pitch Dark second I am so happy I found Adler through Prou and Kris here on GR. She is my 2013 new-found author crush, for sure.


Stephen P(who no longer can participate due to illness) Garima wrote: "Aww! And we're grateful that you read and review all these wonderful books, Stephen. Your willingness to read all kind of books is really inspiring, so thanks to you. Wonderful review as always. My..."

Thanks Garima for the kind, kind words. I hope the copies of sb and pd find their way safely to your door and when the time is right you get to read them. I felt in such awe of her searching intellect. Then I was stunned that she invited me in to join her open, curious, struggling mind. She is someone who I would love to have the opportunity to spend an afternoon talking with, searching her mind, her urbanity, her humanness. And I did. It feels just that way. Reading is so remarkable isn't it.


Stephen P(who no longer can participate due to illness) Brian wrote: "This is such an awesome review, Stephen. And I want to thank YOU for investing the time to construct these lovely reflections on books that are beautiful and important.

I read these out of order ..."


Your so very kind words really move me Brian. These beautiful books are so important. Adler's rare gems have had a profound effect. I very much shared with her such intellectually and emotionally harrowing events, as one sided as it might be, I feel a bond. She laid her intellect and mind bare, courageously searching and vulnerable. Her language and perceptions are a part of my mind now What an honor. What an opportunity. I am so interested in what it will be like for you to read Speed Boat next having already read Pitch Dark. Please let me know what it is like for you.


Stephen P(who no longer can participate due to illness) Proustitute wrote: "Great review, Stephen. I'm so glad you enjoyed the Adler books!

And you're right: there is a sense to read them in order. They're loose companion books. I think one's reading of Pitch Dark require..."


Thank you so much Prou. Hopefully you understand that I would never have known about Adler and her books or have sought them out with such interest, if it weren't for you. Your reviews and comments stock my library and keep taking me on great literary adventures. Adler's two books were certainly that! I loved that she or the narrator could be at a party with famous, important people and it would mean nothing to her. She knew what was important to her and chose to live that as best she could even knowing it would in the end provide alienation. She truly fought in these books to know and be herself. A noble battle. She's my new role model. Thanks again Prou.


message 8: by Rakhi (new)

Rakhi Dalal This is just WOW, Stephen! A very profound manner and passionate rendition.And I completely agree with the note at the end :) Thanks for being around and sharing your reviews!


Stephen P(who no longer can participate due to illness) Rakhi wrote: "This is just WOW, Stephen! A very profound manner and passionate rendition.And I completely agree with the note at the end :) Thanks for being around and sharing your reviews!"

WOW is good. WOW is great! I appreciate every word Rakhi. :)


message 10: by [deleted user] (new)

Excellent review, Stephen. I just picked up Speedboat at the library this past weekend and have been reading Adler reviews to taunt myself a bit longer before dipping into her words.


message 11: by Stephen (last edited Jul 08, 2013 10:34AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Stephen P(who no longer can participate due to illness) Sean wrote: "Excellent review, Stephen. I just picked up Speedboat at the library this past weekend and have been reading Adler reviews to taunt myself a bit longer before dipping into her words."

"Taunt myself a bit longer." That's great. I think I know what you mean. Great reviews and ground-swell and hold that sweet pleasure off for just a little bit? Anyway her style may sound a bit daunting from the reviews but I fell into it quick. If you like the urbane intellectual mind questioning the world and herself this will be for you Sean. It's helpful to read them in order with Pitch Dark following. Thank you for the "Like" and taking the time to comment. Happy Reading.


message 12: by Declan (new)

Declan A terrific review Stephen. I read Speedboat when I was a teen and it made a huge, and lasting impression on me. Then I found Speedboat and loved that too. I remember, in preinternet days, trying to find out if she had written any other novels and being very disappointed to find that there weren't any. Now, according to an interview I read yesterday, http://www.guardian.co.uk/books/2013/jul/07/renata-adler-new-york-author-interview?INTCMP=SRCH she is, after so many years, writing another one! I hope she will keep to the style of those two wonderful books.


Stephen P(who no longer can participate due to illness) Declan wrote: "A terrific review Stephen. I read Speedboat when I was a teen and it made a huge, and lasting impression on me. Then I found Speedboat and loved that too. I remember, in preinternet days, trying to..."

How can I thank you. I'm going to the link immediately! Another book of hers. You have made my day. And yes, I do hope the same style. I'm glad you like it too.


message 14: by Steve (new)

Steve Excellent review, Stephen -- beautifully written and insightfully analyzed. I liked your postscript, too! Count me in that same camp.


Stephen P(who no longer can participate due to illness) Steve wrote: "Excellent review, Stephen -- beautifully written and insightfully analyzed. I liked your postscript, too! Count me in that same camp."

Your kind words mean a lot to me Steve. Thank you.


message 16: by Ian (new) - added it

Ian "Marvin" Graye Sorry it took me so long to find this wonderful review. The quality stuff is not just in the latest updates.


message 17: by Stephen (last edited May 26, 2014 08:42PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Stephen P(who no longer can participate due to illness) Ian wrote: "Sorry it took me so long to find this wonderful review. The quality stuff is not just in the latest updates."

Ian, thanks so much for your sensitive waiting and timing to read this review. It brought me back to thinking again about this complex and wondrously written book which may have unjustly been crowded out by others with the unmarked passage of time.


back to top