ŷ

s.penkevich's Reviews > Matilda

Matilda by Roald Dahl
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
6431467
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: childhood_classics

There are perhaps no days of our childhood we lived so fully as those we spent with a favorite book.
-Marcel Proust

I loved this book so much as a child that I quite literally named a child after it. Matilda by Roald Dahl is a beloved children’s classic for a reason and one that still warms the hearts of kids and adults today. Who doesn’t love a book that celebrates the empowerment of reading, that tells a story of overcoming tyrants and surviving abuse while retaining a love for the world? Wrap that all up in a story of a girl with magical powers and a will to freedom and love aided by librarians and a caring teacher and you’ve got yourself a winning story. While I noticed some problematic aspects returning to this again as an adult, I was reminded how much this story meant to me as a kid and how much it grew inside me through my whole life.

The books transported her into new worlds and introduced her to amazing people who lived exciting lives.

For the uninitiated, Matilda is the story of a young girl who �longed for a friend, someone like the kind, courageous people in her books.� Her parents neglect her and are involved in shady dealings, her principal is a nightmare who hates children and loves punishment, but she has discovered her magic powers and will right the wrongs in order to thrive. There is a fantastic film adaptation I used to watch constantly as a kid and this, coupled with movies like , was an early start to my love of libraries and books. We see how books can comfort the lonely, can inspire and empower, and there’s nothing I love more than the idea that money is not an obstacle to reading when you have a library card. Flash forward to today, I work in a library and in a bookstore and, likely thanks to Matilda, have devoted a large part of my life to getting good books to the people who need them.
So Matilda’s strong young mind continued to grow, nurtured by the voices of all those authors who had sent their books out into the world like ships on the sea. These books gave Matilda a hopeful and comforting message: You are not alone.

The idea that books remind you �you are not alone� is something that has always struck me hardest. I used to leave favorite poems all over trees for that very reason, to say ‘I was here� but also ‘you are not alone� and picked passages that might comfort or inspire. Palestinian poet Mahmoud Darwish once wrote �A poem in a difficult time / is beautiful flowers in a cemetery,� and I believe this applies to books too. A good book can help in times of need, can comfort, uplift, can be a friend when you need one. And in good times too, a book can elevate your day and be a companion in your mind, something you can’t wait to return and read more. �There is no frigate like a book / to take us lands away,� wrote Emily Dickinson, and Franz Kafka reminds us that a �book must be the axe for the frozen sea within us,� so I have always believed in the power of books. Reading and opens us to new ideas, so read widely and often and definitely read to children if you have any available.

Dahl is a complicated figure, however, and there were some aspects that raised my eyebrow while reading. You can always find discourse on Dahl all over the internet, such as the extremely frustrating fact of his , or his use of , and claims of fatphobia and misogyny abound. A big debate is often about the way he , as The Witches is hotly argued, though many consider Matilda to be a feminist work. Sure, we have Ms Honey, a single woman who is able to rise about on her own, and Matilda, a young, determined girl who can overthrow tyrants. But the depiction of Agatha Trunchbull are a bit unpleasant as it seems an anti-lesbian structuring. Called simply by her last name, Trunchbull is vaguely based on Soviet Olympian and is described as big and bulky and, well, rather masculine. It would seem, as a contrast to Ms Honey, that Dahl finds women acceptable only if they perform femininity in the “right� way. Trunchbull is pretty blatantly queer and he depicts her in a way that is very similar to accusations thrown against queer women at the time, such as wanting to destroy the nuclear family (after the children spell ‘difficulty�: �Mrs D, Mrs I, Mrs FFI, Mrs C, Mrs U, Mrs LTY,� Trunchbull is outraged and snaps �why are all these women married?�) and for not being sexually desirable the way society thinks they should be. It all seemed a bit off, and a quick internet search showed , so, as a queer person myself, that's a bit of a bummer. The book does focus on breaking the cycle of child abuse and a lot of it is very good, but this was rather awkward as an adult. Also the reading list in the book is very much white, male cannon. So take that as you will, I still find the book worth reading and enjoyable, and I have to give a hand to Pam Ferris for a knockout performance as Agatha Trunchbull in the film. Separating art from an artist is something that people will do at their own comfort level and we should give space for everyone for that.

This book looks at the mentality of �I'm right and you're wrong, I'm big and you're small, and there's nothing you can do about it,� and tells it to sit down and shut up. This is an underdog story (well, an underdog with magic) and one that celebrates reading. I loved Matilda as a child and now look at me, I’m writing about books constantly of this website hoping people might see them and be inspired, and spending my working hours getting books into people’s hands. Books, they are the coolest.

3.5/5
238 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Matilda.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
January 9, 2023 – Shelved
January 9, 2023 – Shelved as: childhood_classics

Comments Showing 1-42 of 42 (42 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Seemita (new)

Seemita Coolest indeed! Thanks for this lovely reminder, Steven. Matilda continues to be one of my favorite trysts with the book world :)


Caleb Simpson I watched Matilda the musical last night and was really impressed, it's worth watching.

Roald Dahl is one crazy cat, brilliant.


Nenia ✨ I yeet my books back and forth ✨ Campbell Great review! I love that you named a child after this book! I loved this book as a young girl (also the Pagemaster), but the Trunchbull definitely hits different through an adult's eyes.


message 4: by Rebecca (last edited Jan 09, 2023 10:29PM) (new)

Rebecca Ahhh I need to read this again, it’s been years! I picked up a Roald Dahl boxset late last year at a charity shop. I should try and read one a month.. or something 😄 sweet review Steve 👌🏻💖


s.penkevich Elyse wrote: "A very cool - wonderful review.
Matilda was a big hit in our house too - with both our daughters when they were younger."


Thank you so much! Its so good, glad your daughters enjoyed it too, as have mine. Bummer to learn about his personal opinions but this book still holds up.


s.penkevich Seemita wrote: "Coolest indeed! Thanks for this lovely reminder, Steven. Matilda continues to be one of my favorite trysts with the book world :)"

Thank you! It is certainly worth revisiting. All the magic and fun totally holds up.


s.penkevich Caleb wrote: "I watched Matilda the musical last night and was really impressed, it's worth watching.

Roald Dahl is one crazy cat, brilliant."


Ahhh thats amazing! So glad to hear it is good, I REALLY want to go see it (and take my 12 year old named after the book haha)


s.penkevich Nenia � I yeet my books back and forth � wrote: "Great review! I love that you named a child after this book! I loved this book as a young girl (also the Pagemaster), but the Trunchbull definitely hits different through an adult's eyes."


Thank you so much :) YES, the Pagemaster rules right?! I dare not watch it now as I suspect it will seem really corny but that blew my mind as a kid haha. But yeaaaaaaaa...lots of Dahl stuff is really unfortunate to learn as an adult. I try to hold space for still enjoying the book though (on a reread of the Narnia series with child Matilda a few years ago I realized that The Horse and His Boy, a favorite from youth, had some..glaring racism that was a bummer to confront). But the magic is still there. Thanks again.


Caleb Simpson Cool beans, love that you named your child Matilda.


Axl Oswaldo Superb review, Penkevich.
The movie adaptation of this book is my childhood, literally, and I love rewatching it at least one time a year. As for the book, it was also a great experience, very heartwarming and beautifully written. So glad to see you also enjoyed it. :)


message 11: by LilliSt (new)

LilliSt I loved this one as a child as well and have often wondered how it would hold up if I read it again as an adult... Great review, thanks!


s.penkevich Rebecca wrote: "Ahhh I need to read this again, it’s been years! I picked up a Roald Dahl boxset late last year at a charity shop. I should try and read one a month.. or something 😄 sweet review Steve 👌🏻💖"

It is worth it! Oooo that sounds great, I want to revisit Fantastic Mr Fox at some point as well. Another that had a great film adaptation.


s.penkevich Caleb wrote: "Cool beans, love that you named your child Matilda."

Thanks!


s.penkevich Axl Oswaldo wrote: "Superb review, Penkevich.
The movie adaptation of this book is my childhood, literally, and I love rewatching it at least one time a year. As for the book, it was also a great experience, very hear..."


It’s such a good film! I love Danny DeVito in that. And thank you, glad to see you love it as well! Really glad to have revisited it


s.penkevich LilliSt wrote: "I loved this one as a child as well and have often wondered how it would hold up if I read it again as an adult... Great review, thanks!"

Aside from a few things it really did hold up pretty well. Definitely still fun and magical, would recommend! And thank you!


message 16: by Cecily (new)

Cecily This book was too late for my childhood, and not new enough that I noticed it for my kid's, but I enjoyed your review. Re the importance of cultivating a love of reading, and the power of the right book (back to Winterson?), and the importance of librarians, have you seen A Witch’s Guide to Escape: A Practical Compendium of Portal Fantasies?


s.penkevich Cecily wrote: "This book was too late for my childhood, and not new enough that I noticed it for my kid's, but I enjoyed your review. Re the importance of cultivating a love of reading, and the power of the right..."

Ah yea, that makes sense and I feel like this is one that you sort of...have to have that built up nostalgia for to read as an adult otherwise its probablt kind of bland perhaps? The move was cute though, I love Danny DeVito in it as a shitty dad and skeezy used car salesman haha, played alongside his actual wife Rhea Perlman
as the wife.
Lighthousekeeping always makes me laugh because its like the reverse of the benevolent librarian, I love the scene where the librarian takes the book home she knows Silver is reading to read it but...also spite her? But then Winterson talking about reading the library in alphabetical order in real life is delightful.
SPEAKING OF DELIGHTFUL I really need to read that haha. Yes, all librarians should be witches.


message 18: by Nataliya (last edited Jan 10, 2023 08:03PM) (new) - added it

Nataliya Lovely review, Steven! I’m among the uninitiated when it comes to “Matilda�, but I suppose I’ll remedy that after this wonderful review of yours :)


s.penkevich Nataliya wrote: "Lovely review, Steven! I’m among the uninitiated when it comes to “Matilda�, but I suppose I’ll remedy that after this wonderful review of yours :)"

Oooo yes, I’d be curious how this reads to someone without built up nostalgia. Now I’m super curious what you think!


Paula W If I may, for those of you who listen to audiobooks in the car while driving your children around from place to place, this audiobook is read by the wonderful actress Kate Winslet. She does such a fantastic job, is very animated, and gets very emotional.


s.penkevich Paula W wrote: "If I may, for those of you who listen to audiobooks in the car while driving your children around from place to place, this audiobook is read by the wonderful actress Kate Winslet. She does such a ..."

Ooooo I will have to get that, I do enjoy Winslet and she sounds like a perfect choice. Thank you!


Paula W s.penkevich wrote: "Paula W wrote: "If I may, for those of you who listen to audiobooks in the car while driving your children around from place to place, this audiobook is read by the wonderful actress Kate Winslet. ..."

I have a thing for actors who narrate books. Another favorite is Anne Hathaway reading The Wonderful Wizard of Oz. Actors are perfect narrators because they don’t just read; they ACT. Tom Hanks led me through The Dutch House when I probably would have quit early on if I read it in print.


Andrea Cox Great review! You've got me thinking about going back and reading childhood beloved books with a new lens. I was totally in the dark about the Roald Dahl critiques! After The Phantom Tollbooth, The Witches was definitely up there in childhood favorites, and now I'm excited to read again as an adult.


s.penkevich Andrea wrote: "Great review! You've got me thinking about going back and reading childhood beloved books with a new lens. I was totally in the dark about the Roald Dahl critiques! After The Phantom Tollbooth, The..."

I’ve done a few now (mostly through reading to my own kids) and it’s always a pretty interesting experience. When I reread Narnia with my oldest I picked up on a LOT that I’d not thought of as a kid (unfortunately Horse and His Boy comes across uncomfortably as an adult with the Calormen civilization in the desert being described as dark skin savages with a false god sort of thing…not awesome) and found a new appreciation for them.
I really want to revisit Phantom Tollbooth! I loved that one. And The Witches. I don’t remember much of that one but there is a recent graphic novel adaptation id love to check out at least. A lot of the Dahl criticisms seems to focus on that book so now I’m interested. Well his depictions at least, a lot of the other criticisms surround aspects like and him bluntly admitting “I’ve become antisemetic� which is a bummer to learn.


s.penkevich William P wrote: "Mate just wanna clarify that your review is absolutely 100% true. Roald Dahl is by far one of the most best illustrator/author, mabye even the best. By far Roald Dahl is infact, a astonishingly big..."

Thanks! Gotta admit I had to look up Walliams but those seem really cool—I like the cover art, reminds me a lot of Dahl in a good way.


elon musk it is the best book i have read.


elon musk Best book ever!


s.penkevich elon musk wrote: "it is the best book i have read."

It is a good one!


s.penkevich William P wrote: "(¬_¬)(^_^)(·_·)[¿-¿]('-')[>�<]
(^<^) (¬<¬) [$<$] (�<�) [¿<¿]
( _ ) ( _ ) [ о ] ( � ) [ _ ]"


Indeed


William « №тгмё Hey guys just wondering if you could follow me. Thanks a lot!
^


William « №тгмё can anyone follow me? If so thanks a ton, also a oustanding review!


Essayharper "I loved this book so much as a child that I quite literally named a child after it." THEN WHY DID YOU ONLY GIVE IT 4 STARS


I hate Aadvik Bro I hate. This book😂


carla what a fantastic review!! i love how you included the reference to faina melnik- guess you can learn something new every day :)


Siarl I always read your reviews AFTER I’ve finished a book. I so enjoy the depth you add to my readings. It’s like being in a book club without having to go to the meetings. Also, snaps to your final line: books, they are the coolest. They really are.


s.penkevich Your Kindle wrote: "This book is good but rohald dahl is rasist so... 4/5"

Yeaaaaaa pretty not great. I remember when his estate tried to apologize on his behalf by....printing his statements and it was like OH NO why would you share those haha.


s.penkevich carla wrote: "what a fantastic review!! i love how you included the reference to faina melnik- guess you can learn something new every day :)"


Thank you so much! Ha I have to admit that was something I only learned from writing the review, but interesting to have learned for sure!


s.penkevich Siarl wrote: "I always read your reviews AFTER I’ve finished a book. I so enjoy the depth you add to my readings. It’s like being in a book club without having to go to the meetings. Also, snaps to your final li..."

Thank you so much! Haha yeaaa I should probably write them in ways that make people want to read the book but I kind of learned everything from writing papers for classes that assume the reader has also read the book so I sort of stick to that. But thank you, I do really love the idea of goodreads being like a giant bookclub that you can attend on your own time haha


Faerie What an incredible review, as always. I loved this one as a child too, one of my favourite Roald Dahl books!


message 41: by Pamela Irwin (new) - added it

Pamela Irwin i love
the book


s.penkevich Faerie wrote: "What an incredible review, as always. I loved this one as a child too, one of my favourite Roald Dahl books!"


back to top