Nataliya's Reviews > Troy
Troy
by
Ancient Greeks sure loved their sprawling soap opera dramas, didn’t they? Game of Thrones can shut up and sit in the corner quietly and take notes and learn from those epic bloody myths.
Before Stephen Fry my memories of reading The Iliad were mostly of frustrated boredom and some good quality naps. I bet Homer was a hoot back in his days, but to me watching paint dry had about the same entertainment level as his epics (I'm uncultured like that). But Stephen Fry’s reinterpretation of Greek myths made them unexpectedly fun for me before, so here we go.
And Stephen Fry is awesome. With his dry humor and charmingly common sense wry wit he not only unites a bunch of story threads and side stories into a coherent, mostly linear and very readable narrative (going way beyond the events covered in The Iliad) but also seemingly easily manages to make sense of the who’s who of the sprawling cast of characters (with handy reminders and refreshers along the way) so that you never really feel lost. Achilles, Hector, Paris, Helen, Cassandra, Priam, Odysseus, Agamemnon, Menelaus and the entire pantheon of pettily vengeful and vain Greek gods � all of them become easily familiar here, warts and all, like a quarrelsome extended family or a weird bunch of neighbors. And Fry does not shy away from pointing out not just the good bits but also all the vanity and cruelty and stupidly poor judgment that make this story a fascinating trainwreck of an entertaining mess with a tragic bloody ending.
The audio is my go-to when Stephen Fry is concerned. His narrative delivery is simply perfect. And yes, I’m eagerly waiting for his version of The Odyssey. *tapping foot impatiently*
5 stars.
—ĔĔĔĔ�
Also posted on .
by

“No, Paris was not a good boy.�
Ancient Greeks sure loved their sprawling soap opera dramas, didn’t they? Game of Thrones can shut up and sit in the corner quietly and take notes and learn from those epic bloody myths.
“How strange is our mortal zest for fame. Perhaps it is the only way humans can be gods. We achieve immortality not through ambrosia and ichor but through history and reputation.�
Before Stephen Fry my memories of reading The Iliad were mostly of frustrated boredom and some good quality naps. I bet Homer was a hoot back in his days, but to me watching paint dry had about the same entertainment level as his epics (I'm uncultured like that). But Stephen Fry’s reinterpretation of Greek myths made them unexpectedly fun for me before, so here we go.
(That damned apple that sparked the trouble. A truly dangerous fruit in mythologies.)
And Stephen Fry is awesome. With his dry humor and charmingly common sense wry wit he not only unites a bunch of story threads and side stories into a coherent, mostly linear and very readable narrative (going way beyond the events covered in The Iliad) but also seemingly easily manages to make sense of the who’s who of the sprawling cast of characters (with handy reminders and refreshers along the way) so that you never really feel lost. Achilles, Hector, Paris, Helen, Cassandra, Priam, Odysseus, Agamemnon, Menelaus and the entire pantheon of pettily vengeful and vain Greek gods � all of them become easily familiar here, warts and all, like a quarrelsome extended family or a weird bunch of neighbors. And Fry does not shy away from pointing out not just the good bits but also all the vanity and cruelty and stupidly poor judgment that make this story a fascinating trainwreck of an entertaining mess with a tragic bloody ending.
“The gods had watched in helpless horror while the scenes of violence and devastation had unfolded. Zeus had forbidden interference, but he feared he had been wrong to do so.
“What did we see last night?� he asked. “It wasn’t warfare. It was madness. Deception, savagery, dishonor, and disgrace. What have the mortals become?�
“Terrible, isn’t it? Who do they think they are—gods?�![]()
The audio is my go-to when Stephen Fry is concerned. His narrative delivery is simply perfect. And yes, I’m eagerly waiting for his version of The Odyssey. *tapping foot impatiently*
5 stars.
Zeus sighed heavily. “I wish, all those years ago, Prometheus hadn’t persuaded me to make mankind,� he said. “I knew it was a mistake.�
—ĔĔĔĔ�
Also posted on .
Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read
Troy.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
Comments Showing 1-28 of 28 (28 new)
date
newest »

message 1:
by
H (no longer expecting notifications) Balikov
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Jul 09, 2023 05:08PM

reply
|
flag

Me too, and I’m loving the narration.



Thanks, Alexandra! I adored it, and audio from now on is going to be THE way to read Fry. He is just such a skilled narrator!
I still need to finish "Mythos'; I started it but then it went back to the library and I never got it back. Must remedy that.

Thanks, Barbara! This is a lot of fun also because it follows one general story and not a bunch of myths, so it feels like a very coherent narrative. I think you'll enjoy it.

Very good review, again."
Thanks, Erika! I’m really excited to see his take on that.

Well, it’s him retelling the story in accessible manner, with adding the backstory for the characters, incorporating other legends and myths and synthesizing a coherent narrative with humorous slant and a bit of common sense often missing from these stories. He uses different sources to arrive at a more complete picture than just The Iliad, for instance.


I did the entire thing on audio and only looked at the ebook for the illustrations. Stephen Fry’s narration is just too good to not listen to it.

You are welcome, Julio! I’m definitely going to read/listen to him more. I had fun listening to him read Harry Potter before as well.


Thank you, Gaurav! It is quite a fun book.

Thanks, Sourabh! And no, I haven’t checked out his narration of Wodehouse. I’m ashamed to say I haven’t actually tried Wodehouse yet. But I listened to him narrating last Harry Potter book once and it was fun.


Thanks, Cathy! At Hector’s death you’re not far from the end. And yes � Fry’s narration definitely takes precedence over the story itself. He can read a car repair manual and I’d still listen 😅


How are you liking the e-bike?

Awesome! My brother-in-law has one and loves it.

Anyway, one hour of audio to go for Troy. The gods really are a nasty bunch� have you ever read Ilium? Interesting take on the story.

I’m glad you’re already getting good use out of it, and for fun, too!
Yes, Greek gods were one nasty and vengeful bunch. Seems to have been better spending a life beneath their notice. And no, I haven’t read “Ilium� but I’ve suffered through “The Iliad� at some point.