Catherine (alternativelytitledbooks) - in a book slump :('s Reviews > Yours for the Taking
Yours for the Taking
by
by

Catherine (alternativelytitledbooks) - in a book slump :('s review
bookshelves: smp-influencer, widget-received, netgalley
Dec 08, 2023
bookshelves: smp-influencer, widget-received, netgalley
**Many thanks to NetGalley, St. Martin's Press, and Gabrielle Korn for an ARC of this book! Now available as of 12.5!**
Ava and Orchid believe their love is strong enough to transcend anything: space, time...and even a rapidly eroding climate. But in 2050, the third factor in this list has started to overtake all else, as their homebase of Brooklyn has passed dangerous and is quickly becoming uninhabitable. Billionaire and self-proclaimed visionary Jacqueline Millender has the possible answer to their problems: The Inside Project. In it, women (and only women, we soon come to find out) will live under a dome of sorts, protected from the unsafe air and the ugly ramifications of a world decimated by men...but just how HONORABLE are Jacqueline's intentions?
Shelby can hardly believe when Jacqueline reaches 0ut to HER to be her personal assistant, and jumps at the chance to be second in command to one of the world's most powerful and influential women. Olympia works on the medical side of the house, and she too is honored to work for Jacqueline at first...until Jacqueline's visions for her own personal progeny come to light, and Olympia begins to wonder exactly WHAT she has signed up for...and if it's too late to escape. As the three perspectives converge, all of the women in Jacqueline's 'orbit' come to one terrifying conclusion...but with the world literally crumbling around them, can they band together to work against the climate crisis? Is their little slice of paradise on the "Inside" really a paradise? Or are they simply cogs in a devastating machine, with wheels TOO far in motion to be stopped now?
This book is marketed as queer and dystopian, and in many respects, these descriptors are accurate. The MCs ARE entrenched in a lesbian relationship from the very beginning, but the book quickly becomes less of a true love story and more of a semi-thesis on the pros and cons of a man-free society, with a disjointed and at times eye-roll worthy plot that tried to tread a LOT of ground...and ended up simply dancing around ideas instead. We bounce from the climate issues, to the pros and cons of 'traditional' feminism, queer relationships, men and the patriarchy and more...but Korn never gives ANY of these ideas full credence and room to breathe...and subsequently, the book suffers because of it.
This is also supposedly adult fiction...but it reads INCREDIBLY YA to the point where I actually stopped and looked it up at one point to confirm that this wasn't the case. The "women" in the book read more like teenage girls, with bubbling insecurities, wanton lust, and a lack of focus and determination you'd expect from much younger people. This became especially difficult when some of the characters had children of their own...and once said women hit their teens/twenties, it became even harder to tell them apart from their parents, who were theoretically FAR older (at least, I hope so 😬).
Which brings me to another one of the book's issues...a timeline that never seemed to end. By the end of the book, some of the characters are literally OLD WOMEN and they certainly did not start off with their AARP cards in hand. With characters who gave me such minimal emotional investment, especially, I did not need to see their lives progress over such a LONG period of time, and it made a plot that already felt slow become interminable. I also am not a fan of timeline jumps in general unless they a) make sense and b) are easy to follow, and in this case? I'm sad to say BOTH boxes were marked.
To cap it off, one of the most distracting and odd things about this book was the dialogue. It felt cheesy, unnatural, and often felt like an info dump about different characters and their motivations. Over and over again we were told WHAT to think about characters rather than being inspired to feel something about them and form a unique opinion as a reader having an individual reading experience. One character in particular is SO one dimensional that by the end, I started to roll my eyes each time they popped up in the narrative: in the words of Radiohead, there were No Surprises here.
Nevertheless, there ARE some interesting concepts and theses buried under a subpar plot and overshadowed by lackluster characters here. If you want to go down the rabbit hole of your own thoughts and speculation about the dystopian picture Korn paints, and the pitfalls of a women-only society...this is your book. For me, however, the only thing that felt like it was MINE for the taking was a generous helping of disappointment.
3 stars, rounded up from 2.5
Ava and Orchid believe their love is strong enough to transcend anything: space, time...and even a rapidly eroding climate. But in 2050, the third factor in this list has started to overtake all else, as their homebase of Brooklyn has passed dangerous and is quickly becoming uninhabitable. Billionaire and self-proclaimed visionary Jacqueline Millender has the possible answer to their problems: The Inside Project. In it, women (and only women, we soon come to find out) will live under a dome of sorts, protected from the unsafe air and the ugly ramifications of a world decimated by men...but just how HONORABLE are Jacqueline's intentions?
Shelby can hardly believe when Jacqueline reaches 0ut to HER to be her personal assistant, and jumps at the chance to be second in command to one of the world's most powerful and influential women. Olympia works on the medical side of the house, and she too is honored to work for Jacqueline at first...until Jacqueline's visions for her own personal progeny come to light, and Olympia begins to wonder exactly WHAT she has signed up for...and if it's too late to escape. As the three perspectives converge, all of the women in Jacqueline's 'orbit' come to one terrifying conclusion...but with the world literally crumbling around them, can they band together to work against the climate crisis? Is their little slice of paradise on the "Inside" really a paradise? Or are they simply cogs in a devastating machine, with wheels TOO far in motion to be stopped now?
This book is marketed as queer and dystopian, and in many respects, these descriptors are accurate. The MCs ARE entrenched in a lesbian relationship from the very beginning, but the book quickly becomes less of a true love story and more of a semi-thesis on the pros and cons of a man-free society, with a disjointed and at times eye-roll worthy plot that tried to tread a LOT of ground...and ended up simply dancing around ideas instead. We bounce from the climate issues, to the pros and cons of 'traditional' feminism, queer relationships, men and the patriarchy and more...but Korn never gives ANY of these ideas full credence and room to breathe...and subsequently, the book suffers because of it.
This is also supposedly adult fiction...but it reads INCREDIBLY YA to the point where I actually stopped and looked it up at one point to confirm that this wasn't the case. The "women" in the book read more like teenage girls, with bubbling insecurities, wanton lust, and a lack of focus and determination you'd expect from much younger people. This became especially difficult when some of the characters had children of their own...and once said women hit their teens/twenties, it became even harder to tell them apart from their parents, who were theoretically FAR older (at least, I hope so 😬).
Which brings me to another one of the book's issues...a timeline that never seemed to end. By the end of the book, some of the characters are literally OLD WOMEN and they certainly did not start off with their AARP cards in hand. With characters who gave me such minimal emotional investment, especially, I did not need to see their lives progress over such a LONG period of time, and it made a plot that already felt slow become interminable. I also am not a fan of timeline jumps in general unless they a) make sense and b) are easy to follow, and in this case? I'm sad to say BOTH boxes were marked.
To cap it off, one of the most distracting and odd things about this book was the dialogue. It felt cheesy, unnatural, and often felt like an info dump about different characters and their motivations. Over and over again we were told WHAT to think about characters rather than being inspired to feel something about them and form a unique opinion as a reader having an individual reading experience. One character in particular is SO one dimensional that by the end, I started to roll my eyes each time they popped up in the narrative: in the words of Radiohead, there were No Surprises here.
Nevertheless, there ARE some interesting concepts and theses buried under a subpar plot and overshadowed by lackluster characters here. If you want to go down the rabbit hole of your own thoughts and speculation about the dystopian picture Korn paints, and the pitfalls of a women-only society...this is your book. For me, however, the only thing that felt like it was MINE for the taking was a generous helping of disappointment.
3 stars, rounded up from 2.5
Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read
Yours for the Taking.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
March 31, 2023
– Shelved
March 31, 2023
– Shelved as:
to-read
May 17, 2023
– Shelved as:
smp-influencer
May 17, 2023
– Shelved as:
widget-received
July 26, 2023
– Shelved as:
netgalley
November 28, 2023
–
Started Reading
December 3, 2023
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-35 of 35 (35 new)
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Barbara
(new)
Dec 08, 2023 06:43PM

reply
|
flag




Well thank you Barbara, I tried to make lemonade out of lemons, that’s for sure! 🤣 🍋 I had so many issues with it that it made it hard for me to enjoy without connecting to the characters etc. Better luck is hopefully on the way, I’ve been in a bit of a slump! 🤞🏻 💕

I think it was because it was a debut, or maybe I was just impressed by her lofty goals in the subject matter? Who knows…but I’ve also been slumping so hard lately that I’ve read worse! 🙈 thank you, Jayme!! 💗

Oh me too Dutchie, my last 5 star is starting to feel far away! 😭 thanks so much!! 🥰

Ugh tell me about it! I should not be allowed to slump this hard going into Christmas! 😫 hope it turns around soon, thanks very much Kay! 💖

I hate to say it, but between feeling all over the place, like YA but not good YA, and the love story sort of being shoehorned weirdly into the plot at certain points, it just didn’t come together for me. I would consider another read by this author though, if it sounded good and the reviews were promising…so you never know! Thanks so much, Rosh!! 💚

Me too, especially when I feel like it COULD have worked as YA if a lot of changes were made. I just had a hard time believing any of these women aged throughout the book…and that’s a bad sign! 😣😣 thank you, Heather!! 💞

It was among so many other issues, unfortunately! Thank you, Sheyla!! 💙

Thanks very much, Sujoya! 💗 this was a tough one for me to get through but sadly my next was worse so in retrospect I’ve just blocked this one out! 😣

Thank you Srivalli! I’m sorry it wasn’t either, the concept sounded promising but it just didn’t live up to its potential, I don’t think! 😔

Thank you very much, Kaceey!! 💕 on to the next one!! 🤞🏻

I still don't understand why she didn't actually write this as YA, but it sure read that way! 🤷♀� Dystopian is so hit or miss for me, but I was taking a chance on this one...sadly, it didn't pay off, but there's always next time! I think this would be a wise one for you to skip though, Jayne. Thanks for your kind words!!

I have to admit I actually started a small list in my phone's notes of all the things that just didn't work after I finished this one..😣 it's one of those times I was determined to explain WHY rather than let my disappointment get the better of me! I'm sad I've been book slumping so hard lately, but hope things will turn around soon. Thanks so much, Kat! 💞

Thank you much, Mica! 💚 I was impressed by her lofty ambitions more than the finished product, but since it was a debut, maybe her next book will be better! 🤞

Thank you so much, Carol!! 💓 I’m always bummed when I read a premise that makes me think the book will go one way and it goes in an entirely different direction…so frustrating! Still trying to break out of my book slump…thanks for the good vibes!! 🫶

Debut and an intriguing premise…I think that’s what tipped the scales! (I also never one star so two is the bottom of the barrel 😵�) my Friday was indeed cozy, hope yours was too!! ☕️ 🛌

I can understand that Tina! 💜 it’s hit or miss for me these days too…especially with the dystopian subject matter (another hit or miss category! LOL)

I do think some readers will love it (and from the 5 star reviews out there, some have!) but not a good fit for me this time. Thank you much, Jen! :)


That is for sure, Terrie!! 💖 this was nothing like what I expected…and it was already a gamble trying it out since dystopian is already hit or miss for me on a good day…I’m so sorry we both felt like so much was to be desired, but I’m heading over to read your review now…thanks for your kind words, my friend! 🤗