ŷ

Cheryl's Reviews > A Woman in Berlin

A Woman in Berlin by Marta Hillers
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
11255849
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: global-intrigue, diaries-journals, non-fiction, europe, mesmerizing, women-and-books, war-stories

"Poor words, you do not suffice," this is what she wrote in her diary.

“The truth lay in the mass of closely observed detail,� says this book's editor. “The anonymous diarist possessed an eye so consistent and authentic that even the most imaginative forger would never have been able to reproduce her vision of events.� Indeed, you sense the authenticity in these words--even if the book really was authenticated. Being alongside the author during her private moments of journaling creates spaces of intimacy that are so informative because they are so closely observed by her. This is a human experience laid bare, an experience that you read about and find difficult to forget:
The day breaks gray and pink. The cold blows through the empty window sockets, filling our mouths with the taste of smoke. Once again the roosters. I have this early hour all to myself. I wipe everything down, sweep away cigarette butts, bread crumbs, fish bones, rub the brandy rings from the tabletop. Then a frugal wash in the tub, with two cups of water. This is my happiest time, between five and seven in the morning, while the widow and Herr Pauli are still asleep—if happy is the right word. It’s a relative happiness. I do some mending and then soap up my extra shirt. We know from experience that no Russians come at this early hour.


I don't want to have you afraid of reading such heavy stuff written with lyrical grace but these words will slice through the page and come at you. It is a necessary read. One that the women's issues woman in me had to tackle. It is not that there is sensationalized or harsh detailing here, for this is beautiful prose written effectively with introspective reasoning. Pity is not grasped for, partly because the author does not even allow herself more than a couple short moments of self-pity. It is fact and experience blending harmoniously and when you think about it, it is so nice to know that such art was being produced during war. The close of war, I should say, because the timeframe here is during the period of Germany’s collapse, when Hitler commits suicide and the Russian army gains control of Berlin.

“It began with silence, ”she writes. I read this line and try to imagine how the noisome brutality that this thirty-four-year-old German and Russian-speaking journalist had to endure, could possibly be accompanied by a silent night and silent morning: “Outside, a bright blue, cloudless sky.� Yet I’m only left with a few seconds to brood because later, the noise of Russian antiaircraft equipment pierced the German early morning quiet. Jeeps, then boots. Motorcycles. Laughter on once-deserted streets. And then the cracking of windows as Russian soldiers climbed into homes and businesses, demanding what were their spoils of war. Or so they thought.

Poor words, you do not suffice.

Women and pubescent girls, used and abused (the best estimates say more than 100,000 women). But I won't detail these heartrending moments. I will tell you this: “German women were not supposed to talk about the reality of rape; and German men preferred not to be seen as impotent onlookers when the Russians claimed their spoils of war.� No wonder it took more than five years to find a German publisher for this book that was “quickly relegated to obscurity.�

Yet there is so much more written here. It is about survival and "herd instinct." It is a memoir set apart from others of that era, one that you read and remember. One that you should read, especially since it was practically banned, since the author was chided for even writing about her experience of being subjected to numerous assaults, since she told a friend she didn't want another publisher until after her death.

Poor words, you do not suffice.

A stranger’s hands expertly pulling apart my jaws. Eye to eye. Then with great deliberation he drops a gob of gathered spit into my mouth. I’m numb. Not with disgust, only cold. My spine is frozen: icy, dizzy shivers around the back of my head. I feel myself gliding and falling, down, down, through the pillows and the floorboards. So that’s what it means to sink into the ground.

Once more eye to eye. The stranger’s lips open, yellow teeth, one in front half broken off. The corners of the mouth lift, tiny wrinkles radiate from the corners of his eyes. The man is smiling.


40 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read A Woman in Berlin.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

March 2, 2013 – Shelved
March 17, 2014 – Started Reading
March 23, 2014 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-22 of 22 (22 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Julia (new)

Julia oh wow, this looks amazing.


Cheryl Very much so, Julia. Very much so. You will like it if you can stomach it--but you've read some memoirs with heavy stuff, so I think you can;)

I may post a review later, not sure yet. But that quote was from her and I just thought it described the book perfectly.


Cheryl Ok Julia, I changed my mind and did one anyway :)


message 4: by Deb (new)

Deb Wow! Wonderful review. I will keep this in mind when I'm in the mood for something deep.


Cheryl Thanks, Debbie! It's deep AND beautiful. I agree, you need a certain "space" to really appreciate it for what it is.


message 6: by Amanda (new) - added it

Amanda Great review--glad you brought this to my attention!


message 7: by Garima (new) - added it

Garima Excellent review, Cheryl. This surely sounds like a must read, both for the writing and the time it depicted. Thank you for bringing this book to my notice.


message 8: by · (new)

· Chilling. I was almost reluctant to hit the like button at the end. For your review, yes, but oh oh oh.


Cheryl Amanda wrote: "Great review--glad you brought this to my attention!"

Thanks, Amanda. I can't wait to see your thoughts on this.


Cheryl Garima wrote: "Excellent review, Cheryl. This surely sounds like a must read, both for the writing and the time it depicted. Thank you for bringing this book to my notice."

Thanks, Garima. Yes, the timeframe was what caught my attention in the first place. I hope you enjoy it and as always, I would love to read your response.


Cheryl ·· wrote: "Chilling. I was almost reluctant to hit the like button at the end. For your review, yes, but oh oh oh."

Karen, I kid you not, I wrestled with whether to even write a review for this. Then I thought, why not? This is the premise for this after all, the whole notion of silence. So I couldn't keep silent about it either. Especially not when I will always remember this one. But yes, as you say, it does make you go oh oh oh.


Cheryl Judy wrote: "Wow! Sounds like an eye-opening book, Cheryl."

Judy, knowing what you read, I think you will like this one--if you can get through the gut wrenching moments, but I think you can:)


message 13: by Nidhi (new) - added it

Nidhi Singh Wonderful review Cheryl!


Cheryl Thanks, Nidhi. I'm so glad you have this on your list to read. It's a worthy read, even with the melancholy.


message 15: by Connie (new)

Connie  G Great review, Cheryl. The book sounds heartbreaking.


message 16: by Deanna (new)

Deanna Love your review Cheryl :)


Cheryl Connie wrote: "Great review, Cheryl. The book sounds heartbreaking."

Thanks, Connie. The mood of the book is melancholic for sure, but as I said, the prose is lyrical, so it helps.


Cheryl Deanna wrote: "Love your review Cheryl :)"

Thanks for stopping by to read it, Deanna.


message 19: by Dolors (new)

Dolors I have unburied this text thanks to Agna's recent review and I just got the extra confirmation I needed to add it to my shelves. What a terrifying prospect, that of being the victim of repeated abuse to atone for the sins of committed by others in the context of barbarous warfare. Thanks for this heart-wrenching chronicle, Cheryl. I need to read this one.


Cheryl Dolors wrote: "I have unburied this text thanks to Agna's recent review and I just got the extra confirmation I needed to add it to my shelves. What a terrifying prospect, that of being the victim of repeated abu..."

Thanks, Dolors :-) I'm glad you've dusted off hopes of reading this book. It is one I cherish, when it comes to war literature that covers the depths of survivorship, especially as relates to this fear faced by women of war.


message 21: by Dhanaraj (new)

Dhanaraj Rajan Seems to be a Must Read.


Elena Nailed it 10000000%....


back to top