Jenn(ifer)'s Reviews > The Razor's Edge
The Razor's Edge
by
"One of Maugham's three major novels ..." TIME. That's high praise coming from TIME magazine. This MUST be good.
I’m sure some of you are familiar with a little American television drama series that aired on HBO from 2002-2008 called The Wire. I was way late to the party, but over the past 6 months or so, I’ve managed to watch all 5 glorious seasons back to back to back. Well, glorious to a point. But what the hell happened in season 5? I kept waiting for it to get good, kept waiting for something to happen. Waiting for the outlaw Omar Little to come along, whistling ‘The Farmer in the Dell,� and take that bitch Marlo down. Man. Talk about anticlimactic. How you gonna do Omar like that, huh?
I had a similar experience with this book. I was really digging it for about 200 pages. Then an unfortunate thing happened�
I forgive the weirdness of Maugham interjecting himself as a minor character in the story and the weirdness of him being the narrator. I forgive the implausibility of every character just happening to feel the need to unburden themselves in his presence, whether they really knew him or not. What I cannot forgive is this:
I feel it right to warn the reader that he can very well skip this chapter without losing the thread of such story as I have to tell, since for the most part it is nothing more than the account of a conversation that I had with Larry. I should add, however, that except for this conversation I should perhaps not have thought it worth while to write this book.
What? What the What??? Well of course I have to read it now that you’ve said �(blah blah blah) except for this conversation I should perhaps not have thought it worth while to write this book.� But good God man, I wish I hadn’t. That was just awful. All that bullshit Eastern philosophy seemed so contrived. I think Maugham got confused for a moment there and thought he was Hermann Hesse. He is not Hermann Hesse. No one wants him to be Herman Hesse.
I loved that the main character (Larry Darrell) was going through his own ‘Eat, Pray, Love� spiritual journey type thing, travelling from country to country trying to find his own version of Truth. I loved him, and I loved the way he eschewed all of the so called social norms and expectations and did his own thing. But that whole conversation was just plain hackneyed and I wish I had never read it. Minus that chapter, this is definitely a 4 star book. But quite honestly, I was sitting in a park reading the chapter that INSPIRED THE BOOK and I almost threw it in the garbage can unfinished.
I’m just bitterly trying to pretend that chapter never happened. If I could do it all again, I’d be like that annoying little kid who doesn’t want to listen to his mother, with his fingers in his ears going “la la la laaaa.. I can’t hear you." The end.
by

"One of Maugham's three major novels ..." TIME. That's high praise coming from TIME magazine. This MUST be good.
I’m sure some of you are familiar with a little American television drama series that aired on HBO from 2002-2008 called The Wire. I was way late to the party, but over the past 6 months or so, I’ve managed to watch all 5 glorious seasons back to back to back. Well, glorious to a point. But what the hell happened in season 5? I kept waiting for it to get good, kept waiting for something to happen. Waiting for the outlaw Omar Little to come along, whistling ‘The Farmer in the Dell,� and take that bitch Marlo down. Man. Talk about anticlimactic. How you gonna do Omar like that, huh?
I had a similar experience with this book. I was really digging it for about 200 pages. Then an unfortunate thing happened�
I forgive the weirdness of Maugham interjecting himself as a minor character in the story and the weirdness of him being the narrator. I forgive the implausibility of every character just happening to feel the need to unburden themselves in his presence, whether they really knew him or not. What I cannot forgive is this:
I feel it right to warn the reader that he can very well skip this chapter without losing the thread of such story as I have to tell, since for the most part it is nothing more than the account of a conversation that I had with Larry. I should add, however, that except for this conversation I should perhaps not have thought it worth while to write this book.
What? What the What??? Well of course I have to read it now that you’ve said �(blah blah blah) except for this conversation I should perhaps not have thought it worth while to write this book.� But good God man, I wish I hadn’t. That was just awful. All that bullshit Eastern philosophy seemed so contrived. I think Maugham got confused for a moment there and thought he was Hermann Hesse. He is not Hermann Hesse. No one wants him to be Herman Hesse.
I loved that the main character (Larry Darrell) was going through his own ‘Eat, Pray, Love� spiritual journey type thing, travelling from country to country trying to find his own version of Truth. I loved him, and I loved the way he eschewed all of the so called social norms and expectations and did his own thing. But that whole conversation was just plain hackneyed and I wish I had never read it. Minus that chapter, this is definitely a 4 star book. But quite honestly, I was sitting in a park reading the chapter that INSPIRED THE BOOK and I almost threw it in the garbage can unfinished.
I’m just bitterly trying to pretend that chapter never happened. If I could do it all again, I’d be like that annoying little kid who doesn’t want to listen to his mother, with his fingers in his ears going “la la la laaaa.. I can’t hear you." The end.
Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read
The Razor's Edge.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
March 12, 2013
–
Started Reading
March 12, 2013
– Shelved
March 13, 2013
–
10.14%
""One of Maugham's three major novels ..." - TIME. Really Time? That's all you've got for me? Is that the best press they could think to put on the jacket cover?"
page
30
March 14, 2013
–
20.95%
"I wish I could take a couple of years off and "loaf" around Paris, spending 8 hours a day reading..."
page
62
March 15, 2013
–
34.46%
"It was spring all right, but it seemed to come shyly in that grim and sordid landscape as though unsure of a welcome. It was like a flower, a daffodil or a lily, growing in a pot on the window sill of a slum dwelling and you wondered what it did there."
page
102
March 15, 2013
–
50.68%
"Don't you know? Because American women expect to find in their husbands a perfection that English women only hope to find in their butlers."
page
150
March 19, 2013
–
90.88%
"Perhaps I should have listened to Mr. Maugham's advice and skipped this chapter."
page
269
March 20, 2013
–
100.0%
"apparently Nicki is stuck in traffic, so I guess I'll have to review this one myself"
page
296
March 20, 2013
– Shelved as:
read-in-2013
March 20, 2013
– Shelved as:
brits
March 20, 2013
– Shelved as:
own
March 20, 2013
– Shelved as:
self-discovery
March 20, 2013
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-50 of 102 (102 new)
message 1:
by
Jenn(ifer)
(last edited Mar 12, 2013 05:52PM)
(new)
-
rated it 3 stars
Mar 12, 2013 05:25PM

reply
|
flag

“Nothing short of an invasion could add much to Casablanca.�- Time Magazine, November 30, 1942"
The screenplay for Casablanca won the three scriptwriters an Academy Award and some people think it is the best script ever written. I thought one of the scriptwriters, Julius Epstein, had said it was a "crock of shit", because they were writing it right up to the time Bogart, etc acted it, but I can't find the quote online.
It might be apocryphal.
However, Epstein did say, Casablanca contained "a great deal of corn, more corn than in the states of Kansas and Iowa combined. But when corn works, there's nothing better."


I actually read Of Human Bondage years ago but never reviewed it.... I was just playing around with the Manaj critique.

What was the crazy conversation about? Now I have to know?! I guess I should just read it.... Just a typical philosophy discussion purported to be mind blowing (like Matrix 2? haha), that really can ruin a good book though. Great review by the way. Or, as Tony the Tiger would say Grrrrrr-eat!
Also, Ian, love the Epstein quote. Hilarious.

I actually read Of Human Bondage years ago but never reviewed it.... I was just playing ar..."
Oh yeah, I should have remembered, because I believe you told me once that is a must read. Memory is going with age I fear haha. I dug the Manaj critique though, someone should make a American Idol profile and do a series of reviews bantering back and forth as the hosts. Who are the current hosts actually? Is it still Aerosmith plus Manaj? All I know of Manaj was her cameo in that awesome SNL song:


You'd think the guy composed a chapter of nothing but 'X's...

I actually read Of Human Bondage years ago but never reviewed it.... I ..."
It's a pretty sad little judging quad -- Keith Urban (who generally has nothing to say except 'I loved it baby) and Randy Jackson (this girl is in it to win it!) and Mariah Carey, who, in her critique, in front of millions of viewers said "all I have to say is hashtag POW!" That would be funny - I love a good American Idol parody.
I'll have to check out the video when I get home. Manaj is a funny little bunny.

Ah, yeah, that does seem very Hessey. That hussy! I know what you mean though, that type of thing is either brilliant or groan worthy (like the joke a second ago). Like Life of Pi, that either really works for people or causes groans as well.

Maybe he was playing homage to Hesse? Poorly. :D

I actually read Of Human Bondage years ago but neve..."
It also has John Waters!
Ha, Keith Urban. That guy is just Sawyer from LOST but with more hair care, every time I see him on a magazine cover I get excited, but then very disappointed.
Hashtag POW, classic hahaha

I actually read Of Human Bondage..."
I don't mind looking at Keith Urban, he just should be allowed to talk is all, baby.

Hashtag POW should become the catch phrase for some new superhero: Twittergirl or Internetboy or something like that. I'd laugh along with that comicbook.

Hashtag POW should become the catch phrase for some new superhero: Twittergirl or Internetboy or something like that. I'd laugh along with that comicbook."
Ha! I'd rather see Sawyer, too. Mariah Carey is a twit. Er....


Strange.
Yeah, never liked Mariah Carey much. And just when you think she disappeared - BAM american idol

I worked with a guy at ye ole factory that looks just like him there, but plus beergut. I do dig the cassete tape belt buckle though haha.
Sounds like I need to check this guy's books out. Nicely done. And the Wire is glorious. I actually thought the last season was a perfect ending to the show.


I do not think you and I can be friends anymore.

It was just 'okay' for me. I really wanted Omar to come out on top. And another thing. Brother was one of my favorite characters; they should have done more with him.

But considering this show is based so heavily in criminal realism, don't you think having a script written where Omar Little comes out on top might be kind of disingenuous? To me, it seemed a perfect ending to the extent that such a show can have an ending. It's very cyclical, showing the same streets getting taken over by new players as they fill the vacuum left by the dead ones.
I think Omar had to die. Because that's how he lived. There were no other options, really.
Jenn(ifer) wrote: "Anthony wrote: I actually thought the last season was a perfect ending to the show."
I do not think you and I can be friends anymore."
I was afraid it would one day come to this, Jenn(ifer). Well, everyone must part ways eventually. Shall we at least end this with a bender to do McNulty proud?
I do not think you and I can be friends anymore."
I was afraid it would one day come to this, Jenn(ifer). Well, everyone must part ways eventually. Shall we at least end this with a bender to do McNulty proud?

Apparently it is the movie Stay Cool:
And for ifer, a much cooler Sawyer:


But considering this show is based so heavily in criminal realism, don't you think having a script written where Omar Little comes out..."
All good points, Jason. But still. OMAR!

I do not think you and I can be friends anymore."
I was afraid it would one day come to thi..."
I was glad to see McNulty return to form. That whole sober guy, livin a regular life bit was BORING.

OOOOOOOO, Anthony, you is a baaaaaad boy. 8)

Only two television shows have ever ended perfectly. "The Sopranos" and ABC's 1986-1988 satirical police sitcom "Sledge Hammer!" which I mainly know of through indirect references from my older brother, BUT (via Wikipedia, which we all can agree has replaced OUR HEAVEN as the ETERNAL DESTINY OF ALL EPHEMERAL THINGS):
"Because ABC intended to cancel the series, the last episode of the first season ends with Hammer accidentally destroying the city when he attempts to disarm a stolen nuclear warhead; just before the explosion Hammer embarks on his infamous catchphrase "Trust Me.....". The last scene shows the "Beneath the Planet of the Apes"-style ruins of the city with Trunk's voice screaming "HAMMMMMMMER!", and a graphic flashed: "To Be Continued... Next Season?""
Oh wait, but then I kept reading THE SCROLLS OF WIKIPEDIA (aka St. Peter's Book of the Saved), and it appears that was not the ending to the series but only the first season, the second season acting as a prequel starring Bill Bixby of Incredible Hulk fame. One thing that intrigues me is that apparently throughout the second season references to contemporary events made it clear that the action was occurring AFTER the apocalyptic explosion that ended season one (which WOULD have been the perfect ending to a television series) so that "one explanation that has been suggested is that the nuclear warhead which detonated at the end of the first season was an experimental model that was designed to only destroy buildings and not humans."... which is lazy plotting at best. ANYWAY notice Anthony Vacca that I did not mention THE WIRE in this analysis of television shows and their perfect endings; while the ending of THE WIRE was satisfactory, it was not perfect, but not an utter failure of endings of shows like the last, I dunno, 4 entire seasons of LOST or the last half of the last season of BATTLESTAR GALACTICA which really just shouldn't have been made. Angels? They were angels? Gimmee a break. Late spoiler alert. Apologies.
Jenn(ifer) wrote: "Anthony wrote: "Jenn(ifer) wrote: "Anthony wrote: I actually thought the last season was a perfect ending to the show."
I do not think you and I can be friends anymore."
I was afraid it would one..."
Omar was my favorite character and it would have been magnificent to see him burn Marlo's empire to the ground. But the whole feel of the show was to avoid playing out events in obvious melodramatic ways. Plus Omar was an almost folktale like hero, an ideal in a sense, and one big theme in the show was the failure of idealism in all aspects of government, education, journalism (what is truth), etc.. The way the show ended was also completely circular. Most of the characters, who started out raging against their ineffectual superiors, have ended up becoming exactly that. And let me be clear that I not trying to say you are wrong or anything (I think differing opinions are still legal), I'm just trying to show you where I'm coming from, knowwhatimsayin?
I do not think you and I can be friends anymore."
I was afraid it would one..."
Omar was my favorite character and it would have been magnificent to see him burn Marlo's empire to the ground. But the whole feel of the show was to avoid playing out events in obvious melodramatic ways. Plus Omar was an almost folktale like hero, an ideal in a sense, and one big theme in the show was the failure of idealism in all aspects of government, education, journalism (what is truth), etc.. The way the show ended was also completely circular. Most of the characters, who started out raging against their ineffectual superiors, have ended up becoming exactly that. And let me be clear that I not trying to say you are wrong or anything (I think differing opinions are still legal), I'm just trying to show you where I'm coming from, knowwhatimsayin?
Geoff wrote: "Anthony wrote: "I actually thought the last season was a perfect ending to the show."
Only two television shows have ever ended perfectly. "The Sopranos" and ABC's 1986-1988 satirical police sitc..."
I don't, I mean, won't stop believin' The Wire is a perfect show.
Only two television shows have ever ended perfectly. "The Sopranos" and ABC's 1986-1988 satirical police sitc..."
I don't, I mean, won't stop believin' The Wire is a perfect show.

Only two television shows have ever ended perfectly. "The Sopranos" and ABC's 1986-1988 satiric..."
But I would wager a guess you've never seen "Sledge Hammer!". I mean, I don't even know if I have, and I was making all these arguments for it, so that's gotta mean it's something powerful, right?
Geoff wrote: "Anthony wrote: "Geoff wrote: "Anthony wrote: "I actually thought the last season was a perfect ending to the show."
Only two television shows have ever ended perfectly. "The Sopranos" and ABC's 1..."
No, I haven't but that would have been amazing if that was how SH ended, but also without the yelling of hammer. Just nuclear explosion and then silence and fade to black.
And I am not offenders by spoilers for either Lost or BG. I kind of hated what I saw of either of those shows.
Only two television shows have ever ended perfectly. "The Sopranos" and ABC's 1..."
No, I haven't but that would have been amazing if that was how SH ended, but also without the yelling of hammer. Just nuclear explosion and then silence and fade to black.
And I am not offenders by spoilers for either Lost or BG. I kind of hated what I saw of either of those shows.

No no no. The screaming of HAAAAMMMMMEEERRRR and the fade to "To Be Continued... Next Season?" are why it's the best ending ever. I don't think you're getting it.
Oh, I get it. But in my warped sense of humor, the ultimate expression of comedy would be for a sitcom to end on a deadly serious and hopeless note. The ultimate "fuck you viewer! Are you laughing, now?" The ending they went with still has that wink wink nudge nudge feel to it.

I disagree, I think it's a much bleaker conclusion than your preferred ending. You thought that was supposed to be funny? I was shivering just thinking about it.

Yes it would have. I had a feeling things would go down the way they did, but it would have been nice to be surprised.
Well, I haven't seen it, so it wouldn't be fair for me to say. But yeah, I'd say that it was supposed to be funny. It still is still a dark and absurd ending.Besides, I don't think I can say I am a particularly funny person, so they probably did it right. Now that I think about it, I think Dr. Strangelove already covered my idea of an ending.


sheer badassery indeed! hobbling around with his little broomstick crutch. oh I miss him already!
Jenn(ifer) wrote: "matt wrote: "I just watched the last three seasons of The Wire in the past few months, too. Finished the whole shebang a couple of nights ago, in fact. I'm with you on the anticlimactic side of th..."
When Marlo says something like, "That is some spiderman shit, right there." Pure lulz.
When Marlo says something like, "That is some spiderman shit, right there." Pure lulz.